The gang discusses the origins of creepypasta, arguing whether goosebumps were creepypasta before they were cool.

Media Mentioned: It, The Babadook, Portlandia, Scary Stories to tell in the dark, Baroness von Sketch, Robot Chicken, Dreamcatcher, Urban Legends, Blair Witch, As Above So Below, The Descent, Session 9, The Haunting Hour

Creepypasta: Cropsy, Smile Dog, Jeff the Killer, John's Spelunking Site, Stairs to Nowhere, No End House (Channel Zero), Russian Sleep Experiment, Slenderman, Candle Cove, The Killer in the Backseat, SEP Files, How to Kill a Monster.

Goosebumps: The Scarecrow walks at Midnight, The Blob that ate Everything, The Haunted Mask, Calling All Creeps!, Say Cheese and Die!, The Night of the Living Dummy, Attack of the Mutant.

Shoutouts: Contrapoints, Jenny Nicolson, Shaun, Believer/Skeptic Podcast, Occultae Veritatis, NoSleep Podcast