The group talks about how the production pulled out all the stops on this final episode. Chris reveals that Germany will make two new episodes of Beyond Belief for the twentieth anniversary of the original. This is also the last chance for Chri

#44 Frakes and geeks [S4E12 with Samm Levine]

Jan 8th, 2019 1h 8m

Kyle is sitting out but we have guest-host actor and podcaster Samm Levine. Samm has watched the show before, and also had a neighbor who bragged about acting in an episode of Beyond Belief. Samm is a hardline skeptic of all things supernatural

#43 A good first draft [S4E11 with Jonathan Kite]

Jan 1st, 2019 55m 26s

Kyle is out, but joining us is the comedian, actor, and writer Jonathan Kite. Who has a new movie out – All The Creatures Are Stirring. Jonathan is familiar with the show, but hasn’t seen it until now. Jonathan talks about Nightmare on Elm Stre

#42 Futzing with the wrong drivers [S4E10]

Dec 25th, 2018 58m 52s

Jesse pitches his Beyond Beliefe App which would randomize BB stories from all four seasons. This way you would get a fresh mix bag of stories each time. This leads to a discussion of each host’s voting strategy and meta-game. Story 1: Moonstru

#41 Into the spider closet [S4E9 with Will Hines]

Dec 18th, 2018 1h 2m

Kyle is out this episode, but in his place we have guest host Will Hines! Will Hines is a comedian who performs at UCB LA and co-hosted the podcast “Don’t Get Me Started.” Will hasn’t seen the original show before and is a hardline skeptic. Sto

#B06 Our original unaired pilot

Dec 13th, 2018 1h 9m

This week we’re bringing you a special bonus episode: our original unaired pilot. No one outside of the five of us has ever heard this before. And in fact, we hadn’t even listened to it in over a year. So, we gathered around the campfire (livin

#40 Leafing the witness [S4E8]

Dec 11th, 2018 49m 7s

We’ve returned with the back half of our fourth and final season. And if something feels oddly familiar about this week’s batch of stories… it’s because we watched this episode in the past and recorded an unreleased episode as a test pilot. And

#B05 Chris, Claire, & Max watch the scariest Beyond Belief story

Dec 5th, 2018 15m 18s

Chris has gone rogue and started his own podcast: Highbrow Reviews. With some pretty spectacular co-hosts, I might add: Claire Berger and Max La Bella, both previous Beyond Beyond Belief guests. In this new podcast, Chris and his co-hosts get

#39 Car trouble [S4E7]

Oct 23rd, 2018 59m 2s

This is the season 4 mid-season break…and Jesse has karaoke voice. Story 1: The Wreath – A detective investigating a hit and run case gets a break when another accident mysteriously occurs. It’s very believable that city officials could get con

#38 Black belt ghost [S4E6 with Jamie Gaul & Joe Dolce]

Oct 16th, 2018 54m 30s

This episode we welcome two guest hosts: comedian Jamie Gaul from Upright Citizens Brigade and friend-of-the-podcast Joe Dolce. Regarding the world of supernatural, Joe is a skeptic while Jamie is a “boo-liever.” That’s not actually said in the

#B04 Uncut interview with modern sage, Ian Sneed

Oct 11th, 2018 31m 38s

On this week’s episode, we interviewed modern sage Ian Sneed and asked: what are some tips and tricks for conducting a Oujia board night? Those of you who listened to the interview were probably as shocked to discover as we were that Ian believ

#37 Critical hit [S4E5]

Oct 9th, 2018 55m 17s

The group compares Don Lafontaine and Campbell Lane’s voice over work on the show. Story 1: House Of Shadows – A house sitter finds a strange video on the TV that seems to be coming from inside the house. Everyone agrees this one was really cre

#36 Pickle [S4E4]

Oct 2nd, 2018 53m 25s

The group discusses how great the all-female episode was. Tiffany realizes how hard it is to host the podcast (but is it really? Try doing these show-notes every week). Story 1: Second Sight – A blind woman who received a corneal transplant can

#B03 Guest stories: Close Call & Midnight Dog

Sep 27th, 2018 4m 51s

Misty Stinnett and Kelly Perron share their own beyond belief stories from our all-female panel of guests from Tuesday’s episode. These stories were fantastic and we didn’t want to edit them down, so we decided to release them as a bonus episod

#35 Girls just wanna have puns [S4E3 with Misty Monroe, Claire Berger, Misty Stinnett, & Kelly Perron]

Sep 25th, 2018 1h 4m

Prepare for an all-female takeover of Beyond Beyond Belief! Along with Tiffany, our guest hosts this week are: Misty Monroe, Claire Berger, Misty Stinnett, and Kelly Perron. The hosts dive into their relationship with the show and the supernatu

#34 Uncomplicated playtime [S4E2]

Sep 18th, 2018 52m 10s

The group discusses Frake’s use of illusions in the intro. Does he come up with them himself? They reminisce about Fox’s Breaking The Magician’s Code. And discover it was Valentino all along! Story 1: Writer’s Agent—a slimy literature agent is

#33 The journey of the ouija [S4E1]

Sep 11th, 2018 51m 51s

This is the season 4 premiere! And apparently it’s already Chris’s favorite season… Kyle’s loving it too. The stories this season look like they’re shot with more cinematic direction. The group misses Don Lafontaine’s opening voiceover. There’

#B02 Drunk Q&A

Sep 4th, 2018 39m 16s

We recently solicited phone numbers from our listeners. Then we started drinking and dialing. Our callers could ask us anything or share a story of their own that was Beyond Belief… and the results were fantastic!

#32 The anomaly [S3E13]

Aug 7th, 2018 52m 50s

This is the season 3 finale! Will Mark win season three as he has with the previous two seasons? Will Chris get all five stories correct, as he’s never done in the history of this show? Story 1: The Dealer—a shady blackjack dealer discovers the

#31 Why would you say no to the guac? [S3E12 with James Mastraieni]

Jul 31st, 2018 55m 58s

This week comedian James Mastraieni joins us in the studio. He performs regularly at The Upright Citizens Brigade and has a podcast called I’m Too Effing High. He’s not really a believer in the supernatural but shares a story about a maybe haun

#30 Don’t Wake Deadbeat Daddy [S3E11]

Jul 24th, 2018 49m 14s

The group reminisces about the game Don’t Wake Daddy. Story 1: Deadbeat Dad—a cheating gambler who wants nothing to do with his ex-wife and son, sees his run luck out caused by a mysterious woman. Jesse points out the loop group/background nois

#29 Dr. Seuss’s trash can [S3E10 with an 11-year-old]

Jul 17th, 2018 55m 49s

Tiffany is out, but we have a special guest-host, 11-year-old Wolfe Yanovich! We hope he can bring a unique child’s perspective to the stories of Beyond Belief. So far he just thinks the acting is bad. Like, 90’s bad. And he’s like, right. Stor

#28 Don’t let your ghost cat on the counter [S3E9]

Jul 10th, 2018 47m 41s

The group talks about how great it would be to interview Jonathan Frakes and James Brolin for the show. Would Frakes play along and would his predictions be correct? Did he record all of his material in a single day? Would Josh Brolin be a good

#27 The Help Me Help Me Ghost [S3E8]

Jul 3rd, 2018 54m 12s

Chris talks about his recent psychic reading with Marla Frees, where she explained that there are frequencies all around us that she can tap into to download info from beyond. Story 1: Creepy Comics—after a publisher verbally abuses his comic b

#26 You had me at haunted barbecue [S3E7]

May 15th, 2018 47m 38s

Tiffany is back from her vacation to India. She didn’t see any ghosts though. Also she may have an infectious rash on her hand or just a henna tattoo. Story 1: Connie—a dead woman’s spirit or essence lives on in her husband’s new wives. Jesse