Flagstaff, Arizona yields new and tragic insights to the story of Dennis Kaye; re-examining a moment from a previous episode brings host Scott Gordon closer than ever to discovering the truth about Jethro Spivey.

S1 E8 Disgusting American Dreams

May 25th, 2018 21m 52s

What about Al? This episode focuses on answering the lingering questions about Al Russo in the wake of the abrupt exodus of Dennis in 1980. Russo’s unlikely benefactor finally surfaces to tell his tale.

S1 E7 I Pulled His Card

May 18th, 2018 15m 7s

The line between Dennis Kaye and Jethro Spivey begins to blur as colorful characters from his past share illuminating and violent stories, putting some of the missing puzzle pieces of Spivey’s true identity into place.

S1 E6 Joined At The Hip

May 11th, 2018 19m 4s

Host Scott Gordon enlists some unlikely help in his search for Dennis Kaye, whose path leads back to Louisiana. An anonymous tipster shares the details of a pivotal relationship from Kaye’s past.

S1 E5 A Real-Life Ghost

May 4th, 2018 16m 43s

Experts dissect the contents of Jethro Spivey’s poetry, host Scott Gordon reveals a personal connection to the investigation, and a former roommate relates some revealing details.

S1 E4 Don't Let The History Books Fool You

Apr 27th, 2018 21m 43s

A little barhopping is required when host Scott Gordon attempts to chase down details about the mysterious figure “Dennis.” Things might get a little sloppy.

S1 E3 Disco Days

Apr 20th, 2018 18m 56s

The trail of the mysterious Al Russo leads to Union City, New Jersey, where tales of drugs, disco, and bloodthirsty goons abound.

S1 E2 Strange Times in Baton Rouge Town

Apr 13th, 2018 15m 57s

A Louisiana man claims to have been a classmate of Jethro Spivey's in the 1970's, sending host Scott Gordon on a bizarre tangent into the sordid and at times unbelievable past of one Baton Rouge high school.

S1 E1 Jethro Spivey Was Here

Apr 6th, 2018 16m 53s

Jethro Spivey was a prolific playwright and poet from 1979 through 2003, after which he vanished from the literary world and society in general. As host Scott Gordon begins his search for this elusive and enigmatic character, he learns that loc

Rate