Grab a warm mug of the blackest brew and settle in for our most unbalanced episode yet! Mike ruins everyone's day with the unsolved mystery of an Australian boogeyman that has haunted him for years. Priscilla brings it home with the story of a

Episode 7: Van der Sloot Drools/ The Giggling Granny

Dec 15th, 2018 1h 58m

Sit down and settle in for a warm cup of MURDER!First, Priscilla tells Mike the story of a serial surf-centric suspect.Then, Mike tells Priscilla the story of a giggle geriatric whose longest relationship was with MURDER. Intro Theme: Convicti

Episode 6: The Town That Didn't See Shit/Get Shorty

Dec 4th, 2018 2h 5m

Snuggle up with something furry and a steamy cup of coffee for two tales of intrigue, minecarts, and murder! First, Mike tells Priscilla the tragic tale of the unjust murder of a perfectly fine Chevy Silvarado. Then, Priscilla tells Mike about

Episode 5: The Mother of All Cannibals/The Lady Of Silence

Nov 10th, 2018 1h 2m

Brew a warm pot of beautiful black gold and settle in for story time! Priscilla tells Mike the tale of a killer cultist with bad taste. Mike tells Priscilla the story of a lethal loca lucha and her murder spree of over 40 little old ladies.Int

Episode 4: Hate Crimes

Nov 3rd, 2018 57m 44s

Brew a pot of sweet sweet black gold and settle in as Mike and Priscilla tell each other stories of two men consumed by hate. Mike tells Priscilla the groundbreaking story of a trans teen and a Latin King. Priscilla tells Mike the story of a ma

Episode 3: Celebrity Stalkers

Oct 26th, 2018 1h 8m

Thanks to listener Angie for this week's recommendation! Sit back, grab a mug, and settle in as we dive into two stories of when obsession goes too far.Priscilla tells Mike the tale of a love sick bomber. Mike tells Priscilla a story of the sys

Episode 2: Crimes That Started It All

Oct 19th, 2018 1h 52m

Brew a pot and settle in as Mike tells Priscilla about the notorious child murderer that started his criminal obsession. Priscilla tells Mike the story of hundreds of unsolved murders that hit too close to home.Intro Theme: Conviction - Litt

Episode 1: The Cases of Kenneka Jenkins and Elizabeth "Bipsy" Amirian

Oct 11th, 2018 1h 33m

Priscilla drags Mike down the rabbit hole of Youtube and Facebook conspiracies surrounding the tragic death of Kenneka Jenkins. Mike tells Priscilla the story of what happens when someone is consumed by rage, religious zealotry, and love.Intro

Rate