TheShadowThatKnows reviewed this podcast on Feb 3rd, 2019
"Podcast form of the greatest live play stream there is. Love these guys."
PaceofSpades reviewed this podcast on Dec 4th, 2018
"I really enjoy Critical role and learnt so much from it as a dm and as a player. However if you listen to this as purely a podcast the live episodes and what you can miss without visual cues always being explained does bring it down a notch imo. However if you wanna hear some amazing voice actors play d&d with a pretty awesome story you will enjoy this."
michaelrtm reviewed this podcast on May 18th, 2018
"Critical Role is story telling at it's finest. Matthew Mercer's style as a DM is captivating, and inspiring. Long episodes as it is unedited D&D, but worth the listen."