Y'all need to be listening to Chillhaven High!
The Keeper does an excellent job of building the fiction through deeply evocative descriptions and collaborative worldbuilding with the players. The monsters are unique and truly terrifying, with a definite science fiction bent that's underrepresented in most Monster of the Week actual plays. The cast and characters are hilarious and engaging, with great queer representation throughout.
What really makes this show special though is the production value. The editing is stellar, the music is all-original and absolutely slaps, and the sound effects are perfectly balanced to immerse you in the narrative without being overdone or distracting. On multiple occasions I've been legitimately startled while listening, thinking that a snarling blankanthrope, sentient robo-insectoid, or rogue science gadget is right behind me. What more could you ask for?!
Go give this show a listen!