Welcome back to I Am Gotham, the show that explores Bat-family history from 1939 to the present. In this episode, Martin sits down to address some of the controversies cropping up around the Batman books. First up, a discussion about the petiti

Batman #6 (1941)

Jan 16th, 2018 12m 51s

I Am Gotham returns with a brand new episode as Martin dives deep into Batman #6 from 1941! Will we read another gangster story? You bet! Will there be weirdo villains? Maybe! Can we expect some moral lessons? Of course! Is the issue any good?

The #Batman Challenge

Dec 25th, 2017 22m 51s

In a special Christmas episode of I Am Gotham, Martin is joined by his Nerdy Legion cohost, Nick Wetmore, to talk about his recent experience rereading the first six issues of Batman: Rebirth and whether he still feels as strongly about the boo

Batman Vs. Two-Face Animated Film Discussion

Dec 11th, 2017 1h 2m

Welcome to a special episode of the I Am Gotham podcast. For this episode, Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast, and Ronnie Barron from the Absolute DC podcast join Martin to discuss "Batman Vs. Two-Face", the latest DC animated film wh

Batman: The Animated Series, "The Last Laugh"

Dec 7th, 2017 20m 11s

Jay Loving returns to I Am Gotham to discuss another Batman: The Animated Series episode with Martin. This time, it's episode 4, "The Last Laugh" which is an all out insane story feature the Joker and his crew. How will the boys feel about this

World's Finest Comics #3

Dec 4th, 2017 15m 22s

Welcome to another episode of I Am Gotham, as we take a step away from our usual Detective Comics and Batman discussion to talk about World's Finest Comics #3, the first appearance of the Scarecrow from 1941! Martin read the book in preparation

Batman: The Animated Series, "Nothing To Fear"

Dec 1st, 2017 29m 21s

Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast returns to I Am Gotham this week to discuss Batman: The Animated Series episode 3, "Nothing To Fear", the introduction of the Scarecrow into the animated universe. Jay and Martin have a great time di

Detective Comics #51 and #52

Nov 27th, 2017 21m 6s

Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, as we return to our Golden Age Batman discussion with a look at Detective Comics #51, "The Case of the Mystery Carnival", and Detective Comics #52, "The Secret of the Jade Box". We hope you enjoy

Listener Questions

Nov 24th, 2017 26m 25s

I Am Gotham returns to your ears with a listener question episode! In this episode, Martin tackles some corrections, Batman: White Knight, Elseworlds stories, a few thoughts on Justice League, favorite Bat stories, his creative dream team and m

Gotham By Gaslight

Oct 30th, 2017 51m 25s

Welcome back Gothamites! On this episode, Paul Tesseneer from the Valiant Central Podcast joins Martin to have an in-depth discussion at what is considered the first Elseworlds story, Gotham By Gaslight. This episode was originally published as

Gotham By Gaslight

Oct 30th, 2017 51m 25s

Ep 16: Christmas With The Joker

Oct 17th, 2017 38m 26s

Welcome back Gothamites, to another episode of I Am Gotham. In this episode, Jay Loving joins Martin once again to dive deep into Batman: The Animated Series episode 2, "Christmas with the Joker".

Batman: The Animated Series, "Christmas With The Joker"

Oct 17th, 2017 38m 28s

Welcome back Gothamites, to another episode of I Am Gotham. In this episode, Jay Loving joins Martin once again to dive deep into Batman: The Animated Series episode 2, "Christmas with the Joker".You can support this show by visiting our merch

Batman/Harley Quinn

Sep 22nd, 2017 51m 15s

Welcome to a special bonus episode of I Am Gotham! For this episode, Martin is joined by Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast, and Aaron Bell and Ronnie Barron from the Absolute DC Podcast (formerly Rebirthically) to discuss the latest

Batman/Harley Quinn

Sep 22nd, 2017 51m 15s

Detective Comics #49 and #50

Sep 18th, 2017 20m 32s

Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show where we explore Batman family history from 1939 to the present and beyond. In this episode, Martin discusses Detective Comics #49, Clayface Walks Again, and Detective Comics #50, The Cas

Detective Comics #49 and #50

Sep 18th, 2017 20m 32s

Batman #5

Sep 11th, 2017 24m 4s

Welcome back, Gothamites! It's time to dive back into another fun Golden Age Batman story as Martin discusses Batman #5! This issue includes "The Riddle of the Missing Card", "Book of Enchantment", "The Case of the Honest Crook", and Linda Page

Batman The Animated Series, "On Leather Wings"

Sep 8th, 2017 39m 43s

Hello fellow Gothamites! This episode of I Am Gotham is a little different. Martin recently had the itch to start watching the Batman: The Animated Series again so as a result, we'll be having a recurring discussion of every episode in the seri

Detective Comics #47/Detective Comics #48

Sep 5th, 2017 26m 43s

Welcome to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show that explores Batman family history through the ages. In this episode, Martin goes in depth on Detective Comics #47 and #48 from January and February 1941. Before that though, Martin goes in a

The Case of the Joker's Crime Circus

Aug 29th, 2017 34m 31s

Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show that explores Batman history and dives into what makes Batman so great. In this episode, Martin talks about Batman #4 from Winter of 1940 with four new stories, THe Case of the Joker's Cr

The More Things Change, The More They Stay The Same

Aug 21st, 2017 16m 27s

A new week means a brand new episode of I Am Gotham, an exploration of Bat-family history! In this episode, Martin wraps up Batman stories from 1940 by discussing Detective Comics #43-46: "The Case of the City of Terror", "The Land Behind The L

Nobody's Puppet

Aug 18th, 2017 23m 34s

Gather 'round Gothamites, it's time for a few episode of I Am Gotham, a podcast exploring Bat family history from 1939 to the present and beyond! In this episode, Martin discusses Batman #3 from the fall of 1940. Enjoy the show!You can support

Return of the Joker

Aug 14th, 2017 25m 28s

Welcome back to an all new episode of I Am Gotham, an exploration of Bat family history. In this episode, Martin talks about Batman #2 from the summer of 1940. This issue contains four stories: "The Joker Meets Catwoman", "Wolf, The Crime Maste

Return To Gotham

Jul 17th, 2017 32m 16s

After a long hiatus, I Am Gotham is back to explore Batman history! In this episode, Martin discusses Detective Comics #39-42 from 1940 in an episode dubbed "Return To Gotham'! Are you reading along? Let us know! We'll be back in a few days to