[TRUE CRIME: Erin Caffey & Jasmine Richardson] The cousins chat about two eerily similar cases that have them both even more afraid of having kids. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDIT

36 | Villisca Axe Murder House

Aug 3rd, 2021 37m 45s

[HAUNTINGS: THE VILLISCA AXE MURDER HOUSE] This week you get a little true crime with your hauntings as Caroline covers the Villisca Axe Murders. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDITAR

35 | La Bête

Jul 20th, 2021 23m 58s

[MONSTERS: LA BETE] This shorter episode is a one-story legend that caused mass hysteria in 1700’s France. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected]. And don't forget to fol

34 | Yule & Anthropromorphic

Jul 6th, 2021 33m 8s

[MONSTERS: CHRISTMAS MONSTERS] It's Hereditary returns with a little Christmas in July! Hear all about some sinister yuletide monsters..we're halfway to Christmas! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email

33 | Scuba & Speculation

Apr 21st, 2020 59m 40s

[TRUE CRIME: MAURA MURRAY & THE LONERGANS] The girls transport you from quarantine to the snowy highways of New England and crystal clear waters of the Great Barrier Reef in their episode on unsolved missing cases. Want to share the stories tha

32 | Pirates & Spookeasies

Apr 7th, 2020 34m 36s

[HAUNTINGS: JEAN LAFITTE'S BLACKSMITH SHOP & MURIEL'S] Wash your hands and crack open a cold on, it's day 267 of quarantine and the girls are talking about haunted bars! Happy birthday Blake! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (

31 | Mortar & Fey

Mar 24th, 2020 45m 57s

[MONSTERS: BABA YAGA & MORGAN LE FAY] Time to get a little witchy! The girls go medieval in their discussion of witches, all done from a safe social distances away. Oh, and WASH YOUR HANDS! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (an

30 | Raging Ripper

Mar 10th, 2020 57m 37s

[TRUE CRIME: JACK THE RIPPER] It's the big 3-0! Haley writes the script. Caroline tries to keep up. It's a wild ride through Whitechapel. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDITARYPOD@GMA

29 | Tortures & Theatres

Feb 25th, 2020 41m 42s

[HAUNTINGS: LE PETIT THEATRE & THE LALAURIE MANSION] The girls are sending out a little Mardi Gras madness! We're circling back to haunted New Orleans in honor of Fat Tuesday! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do tod

28 | Vile Valentines

Feb 14th, 2020 41m 56s

[FOLKLORE: VALENTINE'S DAY] The girls are back in action, kicking it off with some lonely hearts stories. It's 2020 baby! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected]. And don'

27 | Clowns & Sprees

Dec 18th, 2019 1h 7m

[TRUE CRIME: JOHN WAYNE GACY & RICHARD SPECK] As the girls say, better late than dead (or pregnant). It's our final episode of the year and we finish out with two big ones! Serial killers that is... Want to share the stories that scared you as

26 | Walls & Rocks

Dec 10th, 2019 52m 54s

[HAUNTINGS: MISSOURI STATE PENITENTIARY & ALCATRAZ] The girls are SUPER apologetic for missing last week, but don't worry, Caroline discovers her new worst nightmare in our episode on haunted prisons. Want to share the stories that scared you a

25 | Gorgons & Goldilocks

Nov 26th, 2019 36m 31s

[MONSTERS: MEDUSA & PROCRUSTES] The nerds are on high alert in a short episode jam packed with a lot of -euses. It's time for some Greek Mythology! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDIT

24 | Letters & Gangsters

Nov 19th, 2019 1h 24m

[TRUE CRIME: THE LONELY HEARTS KILLERS & BONNIE AND CLYDE] True love is all about finding someone with the same passions as you...unless those passions include murder and mayhem. Or at least that's what the girls will try to convince you of...W

23 | Myrtles & Magnolias

Nov 12th, 2019 42m 33s

[HAUNTINGS: MYRTLE PLANTATION & MAGNOLIA PLANTATION] Apparently all the haunted plantations are in Louisiana and Caroline is thoroughly freaked out. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDI

22 | Icy & Emaciated

Nov 5th, 2019 42m 33s

[MONSTERS: CHENOO & WENDIGO] Looking for some good reasons to stay out of the cold? The girls have got them for you this episode. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected].

21 | Happy Halloween

Oct 29th, 2019 1h

[TRUE CRIME: "Halloween" & Halloween Crime] We wrap our spooky season celebration with a viewing of the classic film and discussion of crime on Halloween! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITS

20 | Horror House

Oct 22nd, 2019 49m 42s

[HAUNTINGS: "The Amityville Horror" & The Amityville House] Caroline isn't happy about this one. It's a little short and a lot of spooky. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at ITSHEREDITARYPOD@GMA

19 | Lasting Legends

Oct 15th, 2019 1h 9m

[MONSTERS: "Urban Legend" & All The Urban Legends] It's a power-packed episode with ALL the urban legends! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected]. And don't forget to fol

18 | Screamin' Students

Oct 8th, 2019 1h 11m

[TRUE CRIME: "Scream" & The Gainesville Ripper] Our Halloween movie marathon continues! In an effort to preserve the podcast (and their relationship) the girls agree that "Scream" is one of the best horror/slashers ever made, and the Gainesvill

17 | Poppin' Poltergeist

Oct 1st, 2019 1h 21m

[HAUNTINGS: "Poltergeist" & The Hermann Family Haunting] This. Is. HALLOWEEN! We're kicking off spooky season with a viewing of "Poltergeist" and a look at the events that inspired the PG-RATED blockbuster. Want to share the stories that scared

16 | Slippers & Pipers & Giggles

Sep 24th, 2019 59m 23s

[MONSTERS: CINDERELLA & THE PIED PIPER] Once upon a time, Haley lived in a blissful, only child existence...until Caroline and our guest host came along. It's three times the girl power in our episode on dark and twisted fairytales! Want to sha

15 | Underworlds & Arsenic

Sep 17th, 2019 53m 2s

[TRUE CRIME: THE AFFAIR OF THE POISONS & JUDY BUENOANO] Watch what you drink. Watch what you eat. It's our episode on poisonings! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected].

14 | Red & White

Sep 10th, 2019 40m 40s

[HAUNTINGS: KUCHISAKE-ONNA & LA LLORONA] Where the ladies in the house? It's short, sweet, spooky and all about the ladies in white. Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (and still do today?), email us at [email protected]

13 | Baths & Dinners & Defenestrations

Sep 3rd, 2019 1h 2m

[MONSTERS: ELIZABETH BATHORY, GLENCOE MASSACRE & BLACK DINNER] The girls know they'll never be royals, and after this episode, they're both okay with that. It's our episode on bloody royals! Want to share the stories that scared you as a kid (a