My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

 121 people rated this podcast

Reviews of My Favorite Murder

Search Reviews...
I used to listen to this show, which I enjoyed greatly, but as I returned to following many podcasts including My Favorite Murder ( To my Horror, I found that I missed approximately 150+ episodes , Brilliant 🤨🤯🤯) but the sparkle has faded, what made the them special/unique before was not there as we have a plethora of podcasts that deal with True Crime recently, all of which strive for excellence. My Favorite Murder is not unique any more and frankly, so much time is wasted on the hosts talking about unnecessary things that don’t add anything other than to draw some laughs. Overrated!
Had a few laughs but had to check what episode I was listening to know I was listening to the right one, goes off topic too much for too long. Listened to 3 episodes 20min in and it’s scattered different subjects.
I absolutely love you all!! I have been addicted since the first time I happened upon your podcast. I will never look at Swiss cheese the same 😂
My warm blanked podcast. Listening to Karen and Georgia feels like cuddling up with a blanket and talking with old friends, plus super interesting cases!
Love these gals! Not the most in depth true crime reporting you'll ever see, but they have a fun conversation every week. Came for the true crime, stayed for the positive attitude!
One of the best true crime comedy duos out there. They reel you in not just for the true crime storytelling, but also stories about their lives and the importance of mental health, which I never imagined would be something I'd be interested to hear in a true crime comedy podcast. Also very impressed by their professionalism and sensitivity to each other in the way they host.
There was a definite point where the episodes became unlistenable which was extremely disappointing because the initial episodes were so fantastic. Suddenly the episodes weren't about murder, they were mostly fan submitted stories which seemed to be mostly fake. As well as I have never experienced a podcast with more aggravating live episodes. The pandering to the audience makes it completely unenjoyable. The podcast now is more like My Favorite Non-Murder Crimes LIVE.
Extremely funny but was starting to give me anxieties about getting murdered I didn't have before I started listening. Had to stop true crime all together.
I like a good crime story and this podcast tells it like it is. Fun and the girls are oh so funny. I may be a little old but I'm a fan! 🤣
My favorite Podcast duo of all time. Though the main topic is said to be Murder I love that Karen and Georgia sidetrack each other. Their personal talks perfectly undercuts the otherwise serious topic in an awesome way. Instead of deep digging journalism the two share stories in a way that only friends that did extensive internet searches can do.
I LOVE this show! Georgia and Karen are hilarious. This is the perfect show to listen to while drinking a glass of wine and painting or coloring. Of course, if I listen to too many, I canNOT sleep. Sometimes I lie awake at night, and all I can think about is that barrel! That said, the minisodes usually tone down the creepiness enough that I can listen to those with only minor paranoia as a result. Stay sexy and don't get murdered.
One of my favorite podcasts. Karen and Georgia often feel more like friends than hosts, and they're always a joy to listen to. Love the true crime content, as well as the way it's approached. SSDGM, everybody!
Not bad to listen to when I have nothing else to listen to but it is kind of hard to follow sometimes as they are all over the place with random conversations. I prefer to listen to podcasts that stay on track and are easier to follow when listening.
The crew has gotten me through some very long days and nights. The compassion, the humor, the snarkiness and the whole bag is my true crime fix and good for the spirit as well.
My co-host and I became friends because we’re both Murderinos. Our podcast wouldn’t exist if not for MFM. SSDGM4EVA!!
Highly addictive and one of my favorites!
Heartwarming look at true crime
Definitely my #1 favorite podcast!
This is the first podcast I ever listened to and I'm truly a Murderino! Karen and Georgia's banter and ease of chatting with each other before each story of true crime inspired me to start my own podcast, although I'm definitely not as funny! Thanks for the inspiration and for teaching me the details of murders in history during my morning commute.
add a review
Rate Podcast
Get episode alerts
Subscribe to receive notifications by email whenever this podcast releases new episodes.

Subscribe to receive notifications by email whenever this podcast releases new episodes.

Recommend This Podcast

Recommendation sent



Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Podcast Details

Jan 14th, 2016
Latest Episode
Apr 23rd, 2020
Release Period
No. of Episodes
Avg. Episode Length
About 1 hour
Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
Are we missing an episode or update?
Use this to check the RSS feed immediately.