On July 31, 1986 the body of Keith Warren would be found hanging from a tree in Silver Spring MD. The woman who called 911 originally said the body was in her boyfriend's basement. The clothes Keith was wearing were too large and not his own. A manilla envelope would show up at his mother Mary's home. Inside were copies of police photos from the case and a note warning her that Keith's friend Mark would be next.
 Mark contacts Mary, he wants to unburden themself and the two make plans to meet. Unfortunately that would never happen. Mark. then mysteriously dies in an accident on his bike. Mary and the family decide to have an autopsy, and the case gets even stranger and less likely to be suicide the more they look at it.