Household gods, musical sacrifices, and the worst little sister ever... Oh lawd, it's about to get pretty dark! In this episode, these '90s kids theorize about the origins of the infamous AYAOTD basement creature while also unpacking the emotional trauma and toxic masculinity hiding within one of the Midnight Society’s most popular tales.

Have a frightfully nostalgic memory to share or a pretty dark topic you'd like us to cover? Email us at [email protected]

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook @thatsprettydarkpodcast