Podchaser Logo
Episode from the podcastThe Right Shoe

The Pine Hill Massacre

Released Thursday, 20th May 2021
Good episode? Give it some love!
When William "Bill" and Catherine "Cass" Stuart get shot in their own house along with their 3 year old daughter, Sandy, who was also shot in the head. This happened in Pine Hill NJ April 1982, back then, Pine Hill was just about the country, who would have done such a thing and why? Everyone was squeaky clean. The investigators could find nothing on the couple that would have made someone shoot them.

And whoever came in and shot them didn't realize that there was a witness. When the "Tall, long stringy haired, white male" came into the house they didn't realize when they looked into the bedroom that there was not one little girl there who came running to protect her parents, there was another 6 year old little girl, named Miriam who stayed behind until the bad man left What happened in Pine Hill NJ that day is nothing short of a nightmare.