The siren call of the fable “goaty” has summoned seven combatants to The Rumble Pack arena to compare Top 5 lists and reflect on the year in gaming that was 2016. Buckle up for an extremely long episode!

Tom:5. Rhythm Heaven Megamix4. Pokemon Sun/Moon3. Enter the Gungeon2. Inside1. FuriMcFadden:5. Slayaway Camp4. Owlboy3. Firewatch2. Crashlands1. OxenfreeTony:5. Oxenfree4. Overwatch3. DOOM2. Stardew Valley1. SuperhotKaz:5. DOOM4. Obduction3. Forza Horizon 32. Inside1. Stardew ValleyJustin:5. Overcooked4. Dragon Quest Builders3. Pokemon Go2. The Last Guardian1. OverwatchNeil:5. No Man’s Sky4. Firewatch3. Overwatch2. Inside1. OxenfreeAccordino:5. Firewatch4. Street Fighter V3. Uncharted 42. Furi1. OverwatchWeighted Rankings Combined:1. Overwatch – 15
2. Inside – 123. Oxenfree – 114. Stardew Valley – 95. Furi – 96. Firewatch – 67. Superhot – 58. Crashlands – 49. DOOM – 410. The Last Guardian – 411. Enter the Gungeon – 312. Forza Horizon III – 313. Pokemon Go – 314. Uncharted 4 – 315. Pokemon Sun/Moon – 216. Owlboy – 217. Obduction – 218. Dragon Quest Builders – 219. Street Fighter V – 220. Rhythm Heaven Megamix – 121. Slayaway Camp – 122. Overcooked – 123. No Man’s Sky – 1