We Discuss: Phantom Zone confusion J’onn being a jerk Alex and J’onn’s feels Lena and Brainy’s murder plans Lex and Lena great story Kara bringing hope Nyxly being suss Post Crisis stress Editor: David Schaub Host Trish Matson with David S

Supergirl S6E02 Review: "A Few Good Women" (TeeVee 706)

Apr 21st, 2021 31m 57s

We Discuss: The Trial of The Century Lex being Lex Lena being clever Lillian being complicated Brainy training Nia poorly Andrea failing at journalism Alex and J’onn character assassination Silas being great The Phantom Zone being messy and K

Supergirl S6E01 Review: "Rebirth" (TeeVee 704)

Apr 11th, 2021 36m 33s

We Discuss: Whether this is a finale or premier. So much plot. All the personal moments. Lex being his own worst enemy. The ephemeral nature of comic book deaths. Our hopes and dreams for the final season. Editor: David Schaub Host Trish Ma

Superman & Lois S1E1 Review: "Pilot" (TeeVee 694)

Mar 2nd, 2021 28m 42s

During Supergirl’s hiatus, the Supergirl Supercast takes a small dip into the “Pilot” of Superman & Lois! We Discuss: how this show does/doesn’t fit into the CW; how little Lois has to do; the CW Drama; speculating about all the big baddies,

Supergirl S5E19 Review: "Immortal Kombat" (TeeVee 653)

Jun 5th, 2020 30m 43s

We Discuss: Lena!!! Brainy needing a win. Dreamer paying attention. Kara’s ONE mistake and her inability to hold a grudge. Believing in great editing. Alex’s “disguise”. The power of imagination. Heat vision surgery super-science. Lex saving

Supergirl S5E18 Review: "The Missing Link" (TeeVee 651)

May 20th, 2020 34m 7s

We Discuss: Lena’s response to failure Lex’s EXTRA vindictiveness Nia’s dream interpretation failures M’Gann and J’onn’s great heroism Brainy’s life hitting bottom Librarian Samwise’s wisdom Kelly and William’s Flailing Alex’s future costume

Supergirl S5E17 Review: "Deus Lex Machina" (TeeVee 650)

May 14th, 2020 43m 30s

We Discuss: This great little kinda-clip episode; How EVERYTHING is Lex’s fault; Earth-Prime’s impressive Lillian; Chekhov’s pysanka? Disappointment with Lena’s characterization; Unexplained mice; Lex’s tipping point and future fall; Eve crue

Supergirl S5E16 Review: "Alex in Wonderland" (TeeVee 635)

Mar 29th, 2020 29m 26s

We Discuss: The good guys having no idea who the bad guys are; VR being dangerous; Insane bug management, which is getting worse? Alex failing to cope, and forgetting the last episode; Alex strange unhealthy fantasy choices; William not doing

Supergirl S5E15 Review: "Reality Bytes (TeeVee 629)

Mar 22nd, 2020 37m 14s

We Discuss: How shockingly dangerous Obsidian Platinum is (thanks Leviathan); Alex fighting her magic martian weapon; J’onn & Alex PIs on the case; The nice parallel real and VR investigation; Kelly being shocked by Obsidian Platinum sucking;

Supergirl S5E14 Review: "The Bodyguard" (TeeVee 627)

Mar 18th, 2020 33m 29s

We Discuss: Alex coping with not having a gun, or powers, or an army; Lex being helpful, and failing to kill anyone; Lex and Brainy’s plan being surprising, and overly complicated; Lena making progress, and not understanding why her mind alte

Supergirl S5E13 Review: "It's a Super Life" (TeeVee 624)

Mar 3rd, 2020 23m 19s

We Discuss: Mxy’s rules; Why it should have been pre-crisis; Kara’s apologies to us for being horrible to Lena; Fun re-creations of previous seasons’ scenes; Choose your own adventures where all the endings sucks; Revealing secret identities

Supergirl S5E12 Review: "Back From the Future, Part Two" (TeeVee 622)

Feb 27th, 2020 25m 2s

We Discuss: Kara learning that lying is bad; William and Kara almost starting to date; Technology is SCARY; Wonderful complex manipulations between Lena, Lex, and Leviathan; Obisidian Platinum is so high tech… it’s magic; ghost in the machine

Supergirl S5E11 Review: "Back From the Future, Part One" (TeeVee 616)

Feb 6th, 2020 22m 31s

We Discuss: Convoluted Lex plots; Brainy’s big feels; New secrets; Wynn not helping Nia, Some weak pep-talks; Nia reduced to punchy-punchy; What’s up with Acrata; Q-waves being beaches from the future; Our search for continuity; A new tower;

Supergirl S5E10 Review: "The Bottle Episode" (TeeVee 614)

Jan 29th, 2020 35m 25s

We Discuss: post crisis multi-verse and memories strangeness new backstories so many unknowns chess games hopes Lena’s choices some good, some bad arguments economy of Brainys more lies and a bit about post-crisis Black Lightning Host Trish

Supergirl Supercast: "Crisis on Infinite Earths, Parts 4-5" (TeeVee 611)

Jan 22nd, 2020 37m 26s

We Discuss: This wonderful hot-mess of a cross-over; Strange backstories; All the big fight setups; Viewer surrogate Ryan gets all the great lines; The need to save hell-scape Freeland; The soft-reboot consequences; Filler plots digressions t

Supergirl S5E09 Review: "Crisis on Infinite Earths, Parts 1-3" (TeeVee 605)

Jan 4th, 2020 57m 42s

We Discuss: the multi-verse of multi-verses; the amazing cameos & references; the ridiculous plot machinations; the needs of the few winning; the Earth as the centre of the universe; the Black Lightning cross-over episode; the differences fro

Supergirl S5E08 Review: "The Wrath of Rama Khan" (TeeVee 600)

Dec 14th, 2019 34m

We discuss: Everyone being the hero of this episode Rama Khan being weak Kara arguing well, but not going far enough Lena trying to be good so much she’s bad Brainy being competent J’onn and Malefic doing great things Alex making the hard cal

Supergirl S5E07 Review: "Tremors" (TeeVee 597)

Nov 26th, 2019 36m 58s

We Discuss: Kelly trying to breakup with Alex, but they talk successfully; J’onn and Vision Myr’nn successfully talking; J’onn and Malefic failing to talk, but maybe telepathy is working; After Lena’s reveal, Lena and Kara talk, but are entir

Supergirl S5E06 Review: "Confidence Women" (TeeVee 594)

Nov 18th, 2019 39m 22s

We discuss: Andrea & Lena’s childhood bonding. Lena’s screwed up family. Andrea’s poor choices when supporting her father. Andrea’s betrayal, kinda mirroring Kara’s. Shadow-walking killer Acrata’s reveal. Leviathan’s incredible capabilities a

Supergirl S5E05 Review: "Dangerous Liaisons" (TeeVee 590)

Nov 13th, 2019 18m 1s

We discuss: this episode only having half an episode of content; Andrea’s VR product being a bad Second Life clone; Kara’s bizarre secret keeping; Rip Roar’s plot and character being equally boring; water effects eating the episode’s budget;

Supergirl S5E04 Review: "In Plain Sight" (TeeVee 587)

Nov 6th, 2019 39m 20s

We discuss: Malefic’s complicated hunt; J’onn’s blame game; Nia & Kara’s investigations; William’s toxic jerk status; baddie-of-the-week’s 45 second plot; Kelly & James’ super corrupt hometown; Nia & Brainy’s further communication; James’ fut

Supergirl S5E03 Review: "Blurred Lines" (TeeVee 586)

Oct 31st, 2019 41m 39s

We discuss: Nia dealing with Brainy being too-much; Lena doing evil to stop evil, but needing Lex’s help; Kara & Kelly both failing to say NO to their needy friends; Malefic getting more powerful and being pissed off about the wrong things; J

Supergirl S5E02 Review: "Stranger Beside Me" (TeeVee 584)

Oct 23rd, 2019 33m 45s

We discuss: Alex & Kelly almost killing each other, but not really; Brainy & Nia failing to communicate, and not being funny; Eve & Lena & Hope failing to “Do No Harm”; J’onn & Malefic stopping the pain by remembering; Lena & Andrea turning o

Supergirl S5E01 Review: "Event Horizon" (TeeVee 581)

Oct 13th, 2019 45m 31s

Our all-listener panel is back with Supergirl Season 5! We discuss: Lena & Kara drama Nia being the grown-up with Brainy The boring baddie of the week The future AR dystopia Unethical Journalism Bizarre corporate contracts Antimatter Super S

Supergirl S4E22 Review: "The Quest for Peace" (TeeVee 572)

May 28th, 2019 46m 59s

We discuss: Strange flashbacks Various gambits Luthor family tea The future of Harun-El Big Fights Lena and Kara competing to be the biggest dummy Nia being too understanding George being awesome The entire season and our hopes and fears for