Alvin Matlock was a 21-year-old Army veteran who went missing from his cabin outside the city of Spokane, Washington, in 1951. Rumors circulated after he disappeared, and the police came to believe he was met with foul play, but they had few le

The LaSalle Street Murders

Jan 22nd, 2024 1h 18m

On December 1st, 1971, three Indianapolis businessmen were found dead inside a house on LaSalle Street. The three victims were bound, and their throats were cut. The police had multiple theories and two main suspects, but the case remains unsol

The Axeman of New Orleans Part 2

Jan 15th, 2024 1h 4m

Over a century later, the Axeman of New Orleans remains unidentified. Writers and historians sometimes disagree on which cases should be grouped together and whether or not the early cases from 1910-1911 should be included.Join Mike and Gibby

The Axeman of New Orleans Part 1

Jan 8th, 2024 1h 3m

The Axeman of New Orleans was an unidentified serial killer who attacked approximately a dozen people in the early 20th century. Several people, including a young child, were murdered. Join Mike and Gibby for episode 1 of 2 on the Axeman of N

Karlie Gusé

Oct 16th, 2023 1h 13m

On the evening of October 12th, 2018, Karlie Gusé called her stepmom and asked for a ride home. She admitted that she had gone to a party and smoked marijuana. Karlie had an adverse reaction to the marijuana and was paranoid and anxious all nig

Max DeVries

Oct 9th, 2023 1h 21m

14-year-old Max DeVries went missing on a family vacation to Aruba in May 2004. Officials declared that Max was “lost at sea,” but his family believes there was foul play. A 56-year-old man named David Stacey Sr. took Max out on wave runners af

Brandon Swanson

Oct 2nd, 2023 1h 6m

Brandon Swanson went missing after he crashed his car into a ditch on his way home from a party. He called his parents for help, but the phone call ended suddenly when something seemed to surprise or frighten Brandon. Join Mike and Gibby as t

Elizabeth Ann Gill

Sep 25th, 2023 34m 29s

Two-year-old Elizabeth Ann Gill went missing from her front yard on June 13th, 1965. Decades later, her disappearance remains unsolved, but Elizabeth’s family believes she could still be alive. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappea

Beverly Jaye Potter-Mintz

Sep 18th, 2023 1h 1m

In February 1987, a young mother named Beverly Jaye Potter-Mintz was brutally murdered inside her home. Her two-year-old son witnessed the murder, but he could only say that a man came inside and hurt his mother. Join Mike and Gibby as they d

Ryan Shtuka

Sep 11th, 2023 1h 9m

20-year-old Ryan Shtuka went missing in 2018 after leaving a party at a ski resort in British Columbia, Canada. Five years later, no physical evidence pinpointing his location has been found, and several unconfirmed theories about what happened

Kyron Horman

Feb 7th, 2022 1h 20m

In June 2010, 7-year-old Kyron Horman disappeared from Portland, Oregon. Kyron was last seen by his stepmother after she walked him inside the school to drop off a project for the school science fair. But Kyron never made it to his first class.

The Bishop Family Murders

1 Aug 24th, 2020 1h 1m

In 1976, five members of the Bishop family were found burnt in a small town in North Carolina. Authorities in North Carolina were quick to figure out the family was from Bethesda, Maryland. Meanwhile, authorities in Maryland searched the Bishop

Ep145 - Suzanne Lyall

Jan 6th, 2020 58m 21s

Suzanne Lyall was a college student in New York who went missing in 1998. Suzanne worked very hard at everything she did. She was a good student, held down two jobs, and had great relationships with her friends and family. On the night of March

Ep96 - Cindy James

1 Jan 14th, 2019 1h 6m

After separating from her husband in 1982, Cindy James began filing police complaints that someone was stalking, harassing, and even physically assaulting her. This went on for seven years and she filed close to 100 complaints. At a certain poi

Ep95 - Trudy Appleby

1 Jan 7th, 2019 55m 46s

Trudy Appleby, a vivacious and outgoing 11-year-old, vanished from outside her home in Moline, Illinois in 1996. Police had early suspects but no arrests were made. Years later, police came out and named at least one person who they believe had

Ep94 - Brookelyn Farthing

1 Dec 24th, 2018 1h 1m

In June of 2013, 18-year-old Brookelyn Farthing disappeared without a trace. She lived with her family in Berea Kentucky and was out partying with family and friends into the early morning hours. Witnesses said she got a ride with two men, one

Ep29 - Greg and Bernadette Ohlemacher

Aug 6th, 2017 1h 14m

Early on the morning of August 2nd, 2005, Greg and Bernadette Ohlemacher were shot and killed in their Albuquerque, NM home. Their 20 year old daughter was in the house that morning when the murder took place. She would call 911 to report that

Ep28 - Claudia Lawrence

Jul 30th, 2017 1h 1m

Claudia Elizabeth Lawrence was a 35 year old chef when she suddenly disappeared from her hometown of Malton in North Yorkshire England in 2009. Over the years there have been a number of men arrested on suspicion of the murder of Claudia. Joi

Ep27 - Seymour and Arlene Tankleff

Jul 24th, 2017 1h 3m

Seymour and Arlene Tankleff were murdered in 1988. Their 17 year old son Marty was charged and convicted of the murders. Marty was exonerated after serving 17 years in prison leaving his parents murders unsolved.Join Mike and Gibby as they di

Ep26 - Jaclyn Dowaliby

Jul 16th, 2017 1h 3m

The family of 7 year old Jaclyn Dowaliby woke up one morning in 1988 to find that Jaclyn was missing. Someone had come into their home near Chicago, Illinois in the middle of the night and had taken her. The evidence initially pointed to someon

Ep25 - The Disappearance of Melinda McGhee

Jul 10th, 2017 46m 25s

Melinda McGhee returned home on the morning of March 24th, 2003 after working third shift at her job. She made a few phone calls and then was never heard from or seen again. Join Mike and Gibby as they talk through the facts of Melinda's disapp

Crystallyn Girard

1 Feb 24th, 2020 1h 5m

In 1993, 13-year-old Crystallyn Girard was found dead in her bedroom by her mother Lynn Dejac. The police found Lynn to be a neglectful mother and pinned the murder on her. She was ultimately convicted and sent off to prison. Lynn contended tha

Martha Moxley

1 Feb 10th, 2020 1h 13m

In 1975, 15-year-old Martha Moxley was murdered in the wealthy town of Greenwich, Connecticut. This case drew national attention due to the fact that the Moxley's lived across the street from the Skakel family who had ties to the Kennedy clan.

Mary Badaracco

3 days ago 1h 9m

Mary Badaracco has been missing since August 1984. Initially, investigators believed she was fleeing her marriage to businessman Dominic Badaracco, but as time passed, they became suspicious that there was more to Dominic’s story. Join Mike a

Tera Smith

10 days ago 1h 7m

Tera Smith was a 16-year-old girl living in Redding, California. On August 22nd, 1998, Tera told her sister she was going out for a jog and would return in 20 minutes. Tera went missing and has never been found. Although he was never declared a