Popular Reviews of Where the Stars Fell

Funny, witty, wonderfully bittersweet. The two leads' antagonism is almost as charming as their moments of vulnerability. Strong performances bring the unique residents of this mysterious town to life, and I'm excited to follow their story.

I love Ed's voice and I was hooked from episode one. I'm a sucker for "antagonistic roomates to friends," so this is good stuff.

I wanted to like this show but the fighting between the protagonists got to be exhausting. I found them both very quick to fly off the handle at any perceived insult and that by season’s end, that hadn’t really improved. Also, when one of them says at the end of the season, the clues were all there, you could have figured it out, I vehemently disagreed that those clues were in any way fair for what the revelation was.

I love the dynamic between the two protagonists, especially their rare moments of friendship and tenderness. I hope their relationship continues to develop as the story progresses. I can't wait to hear more about the mysteries in Jerusalem, and where it takes Ed next.

Story follows two women, a cryptozoologist and an author, as their relationship develops and mysteries regarding the small town they live in are uncovered. Character-driven, with slice-of-life elements. The protagonists' dynamic is belligerent sexual tension and though they start to work as a team later on and learn to care for each other, some of their excuses for antagonism wear a bit thin as the story progresses. Looking forward to seeing more soft romantic moments with the two of them. Disability (the main character is dyslexic and has a personality disorder, while the deuteragonist is autistic and uses a cane) plays a significant role in characterization in a way I haven't seen explored in a lot of media in this genre. Story follows two prideful women, a cryptozoologist and an author, as their relationship develops and mysteries regarding the small town they live in are uncovered. Character-driven, with slice-of-life elements. The protagonists' dynamic is belligerent sexual tension and though they start to work as a team later on and learn to care for each other, some of their excuses for antagonism wear a bit thin as the story progresses. Looking forward to seeing more soft romantic moments with the two of them. Disability plays a significant role in characterization in a way I haven't seen explored in a lot of media in this genre. I enjoy and appreciate the addition of a Jewish deuteragonist and Jewish mythology, but unfortunately for my personal desire/quest to find a non Christian-centric story, important elements of the story (Antichrist, Jesus, arguably the rapture) are still completely Christian additions. The folk music added in the second season is lovely, both lyrically and vocally, and I've added it to some of my playlists.

I love how Ed and Lucy are their own little puzzles that reveal themselves over time.

Awesome podcast!! Brilliant sound design and I love the plot! I cannot wait for the next season!

I never know what to expect from this podcast and that’s my favorite part. The story of WTSF has evolved and expanded its strange roots in unexpected ways due to some carefully and brilliantly planted seeds.

Finally - a supernatural story that’s character driven and not spooky-spooky driven. Love this show, love the relationship between Edison and Lucille - love all the small town charm - and yes love the spooky-spooky too. Newton Schottelkotte fucking gets it so right.

It is a truly amazing podcast, it has rep and the humour is immaculate. Overall extremely fun to listen to.

The core cast of characters is so strong and well drawn that you would enjoy listening to them do just about anything. Place an engaging, supernatural mystery on top of that and it's hard to go wrong with Where the Stars Fell.

I normally hate angel stuff and tend to dip when angels show up in a fantasy setting, but I'm glad I stuck this series out. The two leads have fantastic chemistry, the sound design is really cozy, and I love the dry comedy.

A great plot that gives you just the right amount of curiosity to leave you wanting more. While the voice acting is insanely good I have to admit I sometimes found both the main characters slightly insufferable. But I think that's intentional as they both develop quite nicely throughout the season, coming together multiple times to settle their differences and solve problems as a team. I have great hopes in the upcoming season and can't wait to hear more about the strange town called Jerusalem!

Soooooo excited for season two!!!!

Where the Stars Fell is a lovely, character-driven show that slides between romcom and supernatural thriller. The sound design is truly LUSH (and that isn't a word I use often), and the witty dialogue between the two main characters is ever-entertaining. The show holds a little tightly to its secrets at the beginning, but I understand the need to build character first. If you like weird small towns, odd-couple dynamics, and cryptid hijinks, this is the show for you!

The enemies to lovers of it all! This show is brilliant, and the witty writing combined with the rustic charm of the setting makes this one of my top shows at the moment. Ed and Lucy's chemistry was a major appeal to me from the start, but after... certain reveals in season two, I can say with confidence that No One is doing it like them. I can't wait to see more of this hilarious and touching show!