Episode #45: Nash & special guest Phil cover the unbelievable story of that time some people in America lost their ever-loving minds & had themselves a vampire-related meltdown. (New England Vampire Panic, American Vampire Panic) . | Show N

Pools And Pits (Part Two)

Aug 1st, 2021 58m 43s

Episode #44: Join Nash & Tiff as they continue to talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural (the Centralia Pennsylvania fires).| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog || Tum

Pools And Pits (Part One)

Jul 18th, 2021 58m 31s

Episode #43: Join Nash & Tiff as they talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural. (Boston's Great Molasses Flood). | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youto

Randompalooza

Jul 4th, 2021 1h 17m

Episode #42: Nash & Tiff collected some bonus content for their faithful listeners - outtakes, sidebars, and stuff that wouldn't fit in the regular episodes. There's also rants, complaints, and general wittiness. (PS: If you're new, start somew

Bonus

Spooky Snack 14: Unsolicited Meat

May 30th, 2021 35m 59s

Mini-Episode #14 - Tiff tells Nash a true story about a time meat fell from the sky. No, really. (Hosts' Choice: the Kentucky meat shower) . Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or

Something Suddenly Came Up

May 16th, 2021 1h 10m

Episode #41: Nash & Tiff once asked you to join them as they talked about what could be hiding in the snow. Now they ask you to come along as they revisit one of those stories, because as you'll see, they just can't let it go. That was a bad jo

The Second Anniversary Special

May 2nd, 2021 32m 32s

Episode #40: Nash & Tiff are celebrating the second anniversary of You Totally Made That Up with a special “best of” episode full of their favorite moments from the past year!. | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtot

Where To Stick Your Rod

Apr 18th, 2021 1h 23m

Episode #39: Come along as Nash & Tiff examine two medical marvels - one has a stomach seemingly made of steel & the other has a brain that doesn't give up. (Tarrare, Phineas Gage) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr

Bonus

Spooky Snack 13: Into The Middle Distance

Feb 21st, 2021 28m 52s

Mini-Episode #13 - Nash surprises Tiff with a story related to the Zodiac Killer that involves bunnies, an ice cream freezer, a motorcycle, urinal faux pas, and getting a guy fired. (Hosts' Choice: "The Zodiac Killer" movie) . Spooky Snacks

Wassables

Dec 24th, 2020 1h 5m

Episode #38: It's a surprise episode for the Ho-Ho-Ho-holiday, in which Nash & Tiff talk about times when Christmas was *actually* cancelled. There's also fancy nuts. And those pesky wassables. And soooo many tables. (Christmas is cancelled, Ch

Clyde And Jodie (Part Two)

Dec 20th, 2020 1h 31m

Episode #37: Nash & Tiff continue their discussion of famous "cursed" houses & the people whose lives were impacted by them - plus some bonus true crime content! (the Amityville Horror, DeFeo family murders) . | Show Notes, Credits, and mor

Clyde And Jodie (Part One)

Dec 6th, 2020 51m 47s

Episode #36: This time, Nash & Tiff talk about famous "cursed" houses & the people whose lives were impacted by them. (the Winchester Mystery House, Sarah Winchester) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymade

Americana Idols

Nov 22nd, 2020 1h 16m

Episode #35: This Thanksgiving, join Nash & Tiff as they discuss some American folktales that actually have some truths behind them. (Johnny Appleseed, Davy Crockett) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadeth

How To Make A Monster (Part Two)

Nov 5th, 2020 1h 8m

Episode #34: You knew it was coming - here's part 2 of the Halloween episode, where Nash & Tiff continue their discussion of two of the world's most famous monsters... and their creators... and bad accents, somehow. (Bram Stoker, Dracula, Vlad

How To Make A Monster (Part One)

Oct 30th, 2020 1h 19m

Episode #33: To celebrate Halloween, Nash & Tiff discuss two of the world's most famous monsters... and their creators. (Mary Shelley, Frankenstein). | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitte

Team Bubba

Oct 15th, 2020 2h 11m

Episode #32: Nash & Tiff are taking a deep dive to talk about the true stories behind some legit sea monsters. And it's a MEGA EPISODE for our return from hiatus! (the 1916 Jersey Shore shark attacks, the sinking of The Essex) . | Show Notes

Big Peaches And Grey Cats (Part Two)

Jul 2nd, 2020 1h 3m

Episode #31: Come along as Nash & Tiff continue taking a peek into the inner workings of some very nutty cults. (Benjamin Franklin, Francis Dashwood, the Hellfire Club) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallyma

Big Peaches And Grey Cats (Part One)

Jun 19th, 2020 1h 12m

Episode #30: Get ready for a wild ride, because this time Nash & Tiff are taking a peek into the inner workings of some very nutty cults. (Edmund Creffield, the Holy Rollers) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtot

Bonus

Spooky Snack 12: Dolphin Bacon

May 28th, 2020 34m 58s

Mini-Episode #12 : In which Nash & Tiff share the tales of a haunted castle with a wild history & a very unique English cryptid who lives in a tree. (Listener Suggestions: Franklin Castle, the Highclere Grampus) . Spooky Snacks are bite-sized

Bonus

An Important Message For Our Listeners

May 27th, 2020 1m 3s

Special Quickie Message: Shall we just spoil it here in the description? Here in a bit, the podcast has to take a mini-hiatus due to some upcoming stuff IRL, but no worries, we've got some eps stockpiled for you. Listen for more detail. Or chec

Treacherous Pronunciations

May 14th, 2020 1h 11m

Episode #29: Come along as Nash & Tiff discuss a few famous locations where strange things have happened & wonder: are the events that took place really as mysterious as they seem? (the lost colony of Roanoke, the Bermuda Triangle) . | Show

Extreme Makeover

Apr 30th, 2020 58m 20s

Episode #28: This time Nash & Tiff examine a collection of fairy tales & ask - could there be any truths behind them? Spoiler: yes! (Snow White, Margaretha von Waldeck, Maria Sophia von Erthal, Hansel & Gretel, Hans Traxler, Katharina Schraderi

The First Anniversary Special

Apr 16th, 2020 57m 45s

Episode #27: Nash & Tiff are celebrating the first anniversary of You Totally Made That Up with a special "best of" episode full of their favorite moments from the past year!. | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtot

Spooky Snack 11: Trash Rabbit

Apr 9th, 2020 38m 19s

Mini-Episode #11: In honor of Easter, Nash & Tiff tackle some unruly cryptid bunnies & tell you about the origins of the big bunny itself - plus some stuff about the history of the holiday, and what's up with the eggs, because hey why not? (Hos

Teddy's Bubblegum

Apr 2nd, 2020 1h 14m

Episode #26: This time Nash & Tiff dish up some servings of super-creepy dolls, with a side of murder. (Robert the Doll, Arthur's Seat Dolls, Burke and Hare) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |