Creepy Caffeine

A weekly True Crime and Comedy podcast featuring and
 7 people rated this podcast

Reviews of Creepy Caffeine

Search Reviews...
I absolutely LOVE this podcast, definitely my favorite by far. Dani and Whitney are hilarious - I've found myself driving and listening and coming damn near close to needing to pull over. I love their range of topics and how every episode is different in their own way. The "list" episodes never fail to entertain me while their serious true crime always leaves me pondering on their thoughts of the cases. The biggest issue I have when it comes to true crime podcasts is it sometimes feels as though the hosts don't always speak on the subject with the respect I think they should, Creepy Caffeine is absolutely not one of those. They have a massive amount of respect for the victims and the crime but can still create an interesting atmosphere while bringing awareness to the cases. These ladies really know how to connect with their audience and make you feel like you're listening to your friends chit chat. I love this podcast so much that I've probably heard every episode at least four times. This is my go-to podcast no matter what. I drive for a living so I generally have a lot of free listening time and they are always my first choice, even when I only have old episodes to listen to. I seriously cannot recommend this podcast highly enough and if you're interested in listening, I strongly recommend episode 66 "Krampus - And Other Creepy Christmas Traditions" to get a feel for their banter and comedy, episode 44 "Men in Black" for their paranormal stories, and episode 100 "Edmund Kemper: The Co-Ed Killer" for a more serious true crime. Those are my favorites and I think they're great ones to start with because you get an awesome feel of who they are. I never listen to podcasts from the first episode until I get a feel for it but that's obviously up to you. Really, listen to this internet stranger and listen!!
I have been listening for a long time and I love them! They can make me laugh or cry. They value the victims is true crime and always give accurate stories. I love when they tell stories on haunted places!
I'm 55+ episodes in and I'm positively addicted. Whitney and Dani go to extraordinary lengths to find and present the most interesting creepy cases while preserving the dignity of those affected or bereaved. The variety within this pod leaves you thoroughly entranced and eager for the next episode, and the dialogue between the two of them about the cases will give you deep things to ponder or will very nearly make you pee your pants. These ladies are the best. Go! Binge them now and you'll see!
I love love love this podcast, the moment I started watching it I was hooked. These two are an addicted duo leaving you laughing one second, and intrigued the next!
I tuned in at episode 54 and liked it so much that I went back and listened to every episode. I'm addicted. Dani and Whitney have hilarious banter but tell the story all of the way through, as opposed to some podcasts that banter during the story and make it hard to follow.
Hilarious. And the stories are presented respectfully and well researched. A little true crime, a but paranormal. And all around good time.
add a review
Rate Podcast

Share This Podcast

Recommendation sent



Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Podcast Details

Created by
Whitney & Dani
Podcast Status
Oct 7th, 2018
Latest Episode
Apr 12th, 2021
Release Period
Avg. Episode Length
About 1 hour

Podcast Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
Are we missing an episode or update?
Use this to check the RSS feed immediately.