Well, it's been a hot minute, but we're back! Life got pretty crazy and hectic for the last 6 months and we had to take a longer break than anticipated. From broken collarbones to moving, to weddings and jobs changes, we didn't get nearly all t

50 - The Murder of Mary Olenchuk

Apr 11th, 2021 1h 2m

Welcome back for our season finale! Anastasia is covering our final episode before we take some time off to work on Season Two, merch ideas, and more! We want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has made our first year such a success- we'r

49: Scary Stories #5

Apr 4th, 2021 1h 10m

It's that time of the month again! As the new month is here, we're starting things off right with the scariest stories we can find. Leave the lights on and grab a blanket and your beverage of choice... Aunties Anastasia and Loren are going to r

48: Oleg Sokolov

Mar 28th, 2021 42m 37s

Welcome back for another week of horror! Anastasia's going to be glad she's sitting this one out while she moves...Loren's guest feature is Rory- back again for another story that will horrify and enthrall. This week's feature? Oleg Sokolov, th

47- The Dullahan of Ireland

Mar 21st, 2021 44m 10s

Welcome back!This Sunday, we're back with a myths and lore episode! Anastasia is up and sharing the popular folklore of the Dullahan. A type of Fae from Irish lore, this being appears as a person riding upon a black horse with no head on thei

46 - Susan Smith

Mar 14th, 2021 54m 31s

Bonus background puppy jingles.Welcome back creeper peepers! Loren is up this week with a truly horrifying story. On October 25, 1994, Susan Smith reported that she was carjacked in South Carolina by an unknown man at a traffic stop. He took

45 - They Came Through The Mirrors

Mar 7th, 2021 57m 29s

Have you ever felt an unexplained cold draft in your home? The answer may be something innocent, or it could be a scenario straight from our nightmares....Join us this week as Anastasia tells us the sad story of Ruthie Mae McCoy- the woman wh

44 - Scary Stories #4

Feb 28th, 2021 57m

It's that time of the month again! As the new month starts, we're starting things off right with the scariest stories we can find. Remember, if you see 9ft tall, shadowy, humanoid figures with wide grinning mouths...Run and don't look back. Lea

43 - FBI Most Wanted Women Series #4: Ruth Eisemann-Schier

Feb 21st, 2021 45m 40s

DO NOT BE ALARMED. YOU ARE SAFE.These were the haunting words that began the survival instructions left for Barbara Mackle. But we're getting ahead of ourselves...Today, we end back at the very beginning of it all, with the first woman added

42 - Who Killed Cindy James?

Feb 14th, 2021 58m 39s

Trigger warning@ 41:45 phone messageBreak-ins, threatening phone calls, arson, and physical assaults. Moving and changing names didn't help. Physical security measures failed. For nearly 7 years, Cindy James was stalked, harassed, and assault

41 - Scary Stories #3

Feb 7th, 2021 1h 10m

We think you all know how much we love a good spooky story, so it's that time again! We're sharing some of our favorite spine tingling stories this week. We knew there was a reason we weren't a fan of lake houses and closing shifts....Leave th

40 - FBI Most Wanted Women Series #3: 1970’s Power, Saxe, & Davis

Jan 31st, 2021 55m 6s

Join us as Loren continues her FBI's Most Wanted Women Series this week- guest starring Rory!This week features Katherine Power, Susan Saxe, and Angela Davis.Katherine Power- Fugitive #315. Born January 25, 1949 as the third of seven childr

39 - The Exorcism At Earling

Jan 24th, 2021 56m 6s

Welcome back, spooksters!This week, Anastasia is bringing you the hair raising tale of one of the best documented cases of exorcism on US soil. Exorcism is something that has long fascinated people the world over and the mystery of the unknow

38 - FBI Most Wanted Women Series #2: Shauntay Henderson

Jan 17th, 2021 57m 43s

Join us as Loren continues her FBI's Most Wanted Women Series this week!This week features Shauntay Henderson- Fugitive #486.Shauntay was arrested on March 31, 2007 after being on the FBI's list for less than 24 hours. On September 2, 2006,

37 - The Ghosts of Pluckley

Jan 10th, 2021 50m

Are you brave enough to spend some time in a town that laid claim to the title "The Most Haunted Village In Britain" in the Guinness Book Of World Records?Boasting a roster of anywhere between twelve to fifteen ghosts, if not more, the village

36 - FBI Most Wanted Women Series #1: Brenda Delgado

Jan 3rd, 2021 1h

Join us as we start 2021 with a series by Loren! Grab a chair and get comfy because for the next few months, Loren will be covering some dangerously fascinating women.Of this lengthy list, there is a rather surprisingly small number of women.

35 - The Texarkana Moonlight Murders

Dec 27th, 2020 1h 21m

We're back to our normal horror filled schedule this week and Blake is joining Anastasia as a guest for this one! In Texas, there's a little town that hugs the line between Texas and Arkansas. Nicknamed "The Town That Dreaded Sundown" for a str

34 - Merry Cryptid Christmas (and other holidays!)

Dec 20th, 2020 1h 8m

It's one of our favorite times of the year- the holidays! We wish you all a very happy holiday season, whatever you may celebrate, and hope that everyone finds some joy to brighten this pandemic filled year. We are pulling on our boots and gett

33 - Winchester Mystery House

Dec 13th, 2020 34m 44s

*Warning: We are super space cadets in this one and we're sorry. Our brains are stressed and tired, and we're doing our best, buuuuut we're having some special brain moments right now. We'll be back to normal shortly. We appreciate you all for

32 - The Brown Lady of Raynham Hall

Dec 6th, 2020 39m 10s

Join us this week as we head to Norfolk, England with Anastasia! We're spending the night in the famous Raynham Hall. For over 400 years this regal estate has been the seat of the Townshend family. And, like many centuries old buildings, it has

31 - Scary Stories #2

Nov 29th, 2020 1h 4m

30 - The Survival of Mary Vincent

Nov 22nd, 2020 41m 39s

We are thrilled to bring you a horrifying, but happy ending filled story for once! A true story of grit and determination--- with a solid dose of badassery that we haven't seen before--- Loren is bringing us the survival story of Mary Vincent.

29 - Alexander Bean: The Legendary Cannibal of Scotland

Nov 15th, 2020 46m 37s

There's something something romantic about the shores of Scotland that we can't seem to escape from! This week, we're heading back to Scotland, but there's no romance in store... Well, not entirely, but it's not a good romance in the traditiona

28 - Michael Malloy and the Murder Trust

Nov 8th, 2020 45m 26s

The best laid plans are made over a round of drinks, right? A plot was conceived around a round of drinks in Tony Marino's speakeasy in 1932. Tony Marino, Francis Pasqua, and Daniel Kriesberg- all part of "The Murder Trust"- concocted what the

27 - Alice Kyteler

Nov 1st, 2020 48m 22s

We've extended our stay across the water and bringing you a story from Ireland this week! Join us as Anastasia takes us on a bit of a history lesson and tells us the tale of Alice Kyteler, aka "The Merry Widow" or "The Witch of Kilkenny."Polit