Not only did country superstar Carrie Underwood perform live at Sunday night’s ACM Awards, she shared a photo of her face for the first time since November! While stories about country award shows and celebrities posting selfies wouldn’t typically lead Dirt Bag, this one’s a little different. Primarily because until last night, this whole “what happened to her face” was the strangest celebrity mystery of 2018—in some ways, even weirder than The Bite.