Podchaser Logo
Home
IRC chief David Miliband

IRC chief David Miliband

Released Wednesday, 20th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
IRC chief David Miliband

IRC chief David Miliband

IRC chief David Miliband

IRC chief David Miliband

Wednesday, 20th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Car a lot about who we are. It

0:02

represents freedom for a lot of people. This

0:04

season on Drive I'm going to talk

0:07

to all sorts of different people. I

0:09

looked at current aims. yeah and yeah,

0:11

I found all the car names that

0:14

have science or astronomically agree. I agree

0:16

that have you get it? Yes, I

0:18

happen to be Ceo Ford Motor Company.

0:20

For me, it's all about cars, movement

0:23

and our mutual passion for things to

0:25

get us around. This is Drive and

0:27

I'm Jim Farley. Hello

0:35

everyone and welcome to Amanpour. Here's what's

0:37

coming up. 100%

0:40

of the population in Gaza is

0:42

at severe levels of acute

0:45

food insecurity. The International

0:47

Rescue Committee calls famine in

0:49

Gaza a profound failure of

0:51

humanity, blaming it on

0:53

Israel's blockade and bombardment. I

0:56

speak with IRC President David

0:58

Miliband. Meanwhile, Israeli settlers set

1:01

their sights on Gaza, correspondent

1:03

Clarissa Ward reports. A

1:05

call to return to the settlements of

1:07

Gaza. And the outspoken

1:09

Israeli lawmaker with a different view. And

1:12

the vast majority don't want to know about it.

1:15

It's because it's very hard to see a villain when

1:17

you look at the mirror. Michelle

1:19

Martin speaks with Knesset member

1:21

Ofa Kasey. Plus... You're

1:24

pregnant by gay guy? No. You're

1:26

not my gay sister? I'm still gay,

1:29

I just happen to get pregnant. The award-winning

1:31

comedy that's funny because it's true. We

1:33

look at the Persian version. The sweet

1:36

and salty breakout hit of the Sundance

1:38

Film Festival. Welcome

1:59

to the programme, everyone. I'm Christiane Amanpour in

2:01

London. Israeli military action

2:03

continues to devastate the civilian

2:05

population in Gaza. A three-day

2:08

siege at Al-Shifa Hospital is

2:10

ongoing, though thousands are sheltering there.

2:12

The IDF claims the site is being

2:14

used by Sidi-Yahama terrorists and says it's

2:16

killed 90 of them. The

2:19

bombardment is pushing Gaza towards

2:21

a devastating humanitarian crisis. A

2:23

UN-backed organization reports that half

2:25

of Gaza, which is more than

2:28

a million people, are on the brink of

2:30

catastrophic hunger. The British Foreign

2:32

Secretary David Cameron says the status

2:34

quo is unsustainable, and earlier this

2:36

week the U.S. National Security Advisor

2:38

Jake Sullivan had even harsher words.

2:41

Set a pause to reevaluate

2:43

with insanity and hate and what adjustments

2:45

are needed to which you want to

2:48

success. To stand a focus

2:50

on legalizing the area of Gaza and

2:52

Israel's clear-set and Hamas and Hamas

2:54

generally, and retake territory that

2:57

Israel has already cleared. The

2:59

Israeli government is now talking about watching

3:01

the immediate military escalation. More

3:04

than a million people have taken refuge

3:06

in Gaza. They went from

3:09

Gaza City to communist and then to

3:11

Gaza, and they have nowhere else to go.

3:15

So the clear frustration of the Biden administration

3:17

and the Israeli Prime Minister

3:19

Netanyahu is scheduled to talk

3:21

behind closed doors with Republicans

3:24

in Congress. Now the International Rescue

3:26

Committee calls the imminent famine in

3:28

Gaza, quote, a profound failure of

3:31

humanity and entirely preventable. David Miliband

3:33

is president and CEO of the

3:35

IRC. He's a former

3:38

British Foreign Secretary, and he himself is

3:40

a child of Holocaust refugees. David

3:42

Miliband, welcome back to our program. Thank

3:44

you, Christian. So the

3:47

WHO, you all, everybody is really

3:49

trying to sound the alarm of

3:51

what is, we can see by

3:53

the pictures, this impending famine. Who

3:56

do you blame for this? Well, first of all,

3:58

let's just be absolutely clear. that the

4:00

threat of imminent famine described by the

4:02

United Nations is not someone, an official

4:05

in New York writing a press release.

4:07

The international phase classification system

4:09

is a detailed, technocratic, quite

4:12

small, conservative look at the

4:14

facts on the ground. They

4:17

describe, as Secretary Blinken said, a

4:19

million people at level five, that

4:21

is famine level. The

4:23

rest of the population, level four

4:25

is considered an emergency, level three,

4:28

a crisis. So

4:30

2.2 million people don't know where their next

4:32

meal is coming from. And

4:34

the million who are at risk of famine, imminent

4:37

risk of famine, in

4:39

level five represent the

4:41

fastest degradation, the fastest

4:44

acceleration of a hunger crisis that's ever been

4:46

seen. Now how do you explain that to

4:48

get you to your question? This is about

4:51

very straightforward decisions that

4:54

are being made on the ground about the

4:56

number of crossing points, about the

4:59

number of trucks that are allowed to go through

5:01

crossing points, about what aid, above all

5:03

food aid, is allowed to go on the trucks

5:05

that go across the crossing points, about

5:08

the transit of trucks once

5:10

they are inside Gaza, because you'll

5:12

know a World Food Programme convoy was

5:14

turned back in the middle of the

5:16

night inside Gaza last week.

5:18

So you've got a series

5:20

of impediments, blockages, restrictions being

5:22

put in place on lorries

5:24

carrying the most basic humanitarian

5:27

aid. And it's not getting through to

5:29

the people who need it. That's why

5:31

you're ending up in the situation where

5:33

what are frankly fourth and fifth best

5:35

alternatives dropping aid from the sky, building

5:38

a pier that's going to be online in another six

5:40

weeks, that won't help

5:42

the people at imminent risk of famine

5:44

now. What they need is different decisions

5:46

about crossing points, about truck numbers, about

5:49

what goes in the trucks. So

5:51

those decisions are in the hands of

5:53

the Israeli government and the IDF. The

5:55

UN says it has enough food sitting

5:57

in those trucks that you're talking about to the

6:00

2 million people plus inside Gaza. What

6:04

possible reason could a

6:06

democracy at war have for

6:09

denying the basic elements

6:11

of survival? Well, no good reason has been

6:13

given. There's one part of the argument which

6:15

I think is important to get clear, which

6:17

is that some of the trucks are being

6:20

turned back because of allegations that some of

6:22

the items on a truck might be quote-unquote

6:24

dual use. In other words, they might have

6:26

civilian use as well as military use. Let's

6:29

be clear what kind of items we're talking about.

6:32

A pair of scissors for

6:34

use in a health center. My

6:36

own organization has doctors, orthopedic surgeons

6:38

working in one of the hospitals,

6:40

not the Al-Shifa hospital, but another

6:42

hospital in Gaza. But they lack

6:45

the most basic, the

6:47

saline drips, the saline at all, the

6:49

most basic implements with which to do

6:52

their work. And when a

6:54

pair of scissors gets found on a truck,

6:56

the whole truck gets turned back. So

6:59

we're talking about a really serious

7:01

set of very localized decisions, but

7:03

also bigger decisions about the number

7:05

of crossing points and how they're

7:07

used. I want to

7:09

say just so that our viewers and you

7:11

also really hear from at

7:14

least one person there of the desperate

7:16

hunger that they face. What

7:19

has this child done to suffer from hunger? I

7:24

cannot find him milk for five shekels or

7:27

a packet of milk from the agency. There,

7:30

the normal milk is for 150. There

7:32

is no work. There is no food,

7:34

no drinks. We are

7:36

eating plants. We started eating pigeon

7:38

food, donkey food. We are

7:40

like the animals. I saw you

7:43

shaking your head. I mean, this reference to

7:45

them eating animal food is shocking

7:47

still every time we hear it.

7:51

Yeah. And remember the International

7:53

Phase Classification Report that came out

7:56

the day before yesterday, 25

7:58

children have died of starvation. Whoa. This

8:01

is not about rhetoric. This is

8:04

not actually about politics. this is

8:06

about human survival And that's why

8:08

it's a failure of humanity. You

8:11

cannot get away from the idea

8:13

as many people are saying including

8:15

the top. Representative for Foreign Affairs

8:18

of the You Joseph Morales

8:20

that. It is deliberate. His.

8:22

What He said. To. Some

8:24

in is not the

8:26

natural disaster. Not

8:29

a small does not the his

8:32

place is entirely man made hundreds

8:34

of to add, sort of waiting

8:36

to enter. An

8:39

is absolutely imperative to make

8:41

crossing bonds war to effectively

8:43

an open edition or crossing

8:46

point. and it's just a

8:48

matter of political will. See

8:51

who else has to do it. Starvation

8:53

is uses a weapon of war. Yes,

8:55

as database shouldn't is use as a

8:57

weapon of war. And

9:00

me that from assets you know

9:02

I just keep thinking Somalia, Ethiopia,

9:04

All these famines that we've covered,

9:07

all these food deliveries, all these

9:09

urgent interventions by the Us and

9:11

others to to save civilians. Is

9:14

this one. Different ways this one

9:16

allowed to happen. Well we've got a

9:18

lot of experience of the way in

9:20

which conflicts on the climate crisis a

9:23

creating with those a man made but

9:25

their long term. Loan.

9:27

Some factors that are driving. Enormous.

9:30

Humanitarian need around the world We

9:32

published are emergency list was actually

9:34

had saddam as the numbers on

9:36

humanitarian crisis, twenty five million people

9:39

and humanitarian need. I visit some

9:41

of them in South Sudan recently

9:43

but this is a different. I'm

9:45

because of the speed of the. Onset

9:48

of the spam and because of

9:50

the virulence of the attack. Some I

9:52

say that. Plural. because remember

9:54

there are one hundred hostages as more than

9:56

one hundred alleges as well as more than

9:58

two two million palestinians civilians in Gaza

10:01

at the moment. This

10:03

is the depth of this urgency, but also we know the depth

10:05

of this political crisis, because

10:12

every humanitarian emergency is also

10:14

a political emergency. This is

10:16

a political emergency of really

10:20

global significance. And it's one where

10:22

our role as humanitarians is to

10:24

be the expert witness of

10:26

what's actually happening on the ground, because

10:29

the testimony that you've managed to

10:31

play of the Palestinian woman from

10:33

Gaza mirrors what our staff are

10:35

seeing on the ground in Gaza.

10:37

Both our own medical staff who

10:39

are working with medical aid for the Palestinians, who are

10:41

our partner

10:44

for our orthopedic surgeons group, our

10:46

emergency medical teams, but also local

10:49

NGOs. And these are

10:51

people, it's their community, they're

10:53

seeing life being lost, livelihood

10:55

being lost, in front of their eyes in

10:57

the most dramatic fashion. And they're appealing, as

11:00

I'm appealing, for action

11:02

to be taken. What action, though, because

11:04

we keep hearing that all the people of

11:06

goodwill around the world are saying action needs

11:08

to be taken, a ceasefire needs to happen

11:11

for humanitarian aid, for the release of

11:13

these hostages. Clearly, the Israeli people,

11:15

that's their number one priority, the

11:17

release of their hostages. It requires a

11:19

ceasefire. It's not happening. Al-Shifa

11:22

Hospital is again being raided. It's in process

11:24

right now. So then again, the question as

11:26

Jay Sullivan put it, and you're a former

11:28

foreign minister, so it's a real

11:31

life test case here. It means

11:34

that they are clearing and maybe not

11:36

holding if Al-Shifa is

11:38

again being raided. So this

11:41

could be endless. Well, that's the

11:43

fear. Endless

11:45

but imminent in its threat. I just want

11:47

to make two points. One, we're

11:50

absolutely clear in the National Rescue

11:52

Committee as a humanitarian organization that

11:55

the dual humanitarian imperative, a legal

11:57

and moral humanitarian imperative, of protection

11:59

protecting civilians from fighting and

12:03

of delivering aid to civilians. They

12:05

can only be met by an

12:08

immediately enduring ceasefire. However, secondly,

12:11

we cannot be in a position where

12:13

the complicated search for a ceasefire precludes

12:15

other action in the interim. And that's

12:17

why I went through the detail for

12:19

you of the truckloads, of

12:21

the limitations, of the turning back, of

12:24

the dual use, of the passage of

12:26

trucks inside Gaza. But it's not just

12:28

how many go across the border. It's

12:30

their ability to get to people and

12:32

then people to get to the food

12:35

that's needed. Remember, this is a legal, as

12:37

well as a moral imperative and a legal

12:39

right that these people have not

12:41

just to life and limb, to survival,

12:44

but to aid delivery. And here's

12:46

the most shocking thing. The

12:48

fighting has already claimed at least 30,000 lives,

12:52

the majority of them women and kids. And

12:54

I was saying 31,000. 31,000

12:57

lives. The peril that

12:59

Gazans face is that if the

13:01

fighting doesn't get them, the

13:05

famine or the public health emergency,

13:07

which is lurking underneath this public

13:09

health emergency of not having clean

13:11

water, that is going to stalk

13:14

them too. And that's why the urgency

13:16

for the UN Security Council is not

13:18

just to work on the ceasefire. It's

13:20

got to work on these very practical,

13:23

very localized decisions. Because here's the thing,

13:25

the amount of aid that went in in February,

13:28

according to David Cameron reporting to the House of

13:30

Commons, was half that that went in in January.

13:33

We're going in the wrong direction. We've got to

13:35

turn around and go in the right direction. So

13:37

you clearly paint a picture and so do all

13:39

the humanitarians of how aid can be

13:41

delivered and most importantly distributed, because it

13:43

needs to be distributed properly. We saw

13:46

when the Israelis tried to do it

13:48

themselves, it was a complete disaster.

13:50

There was shooting. There were 118 people dead. There

13:53

was a stampede, all of this. So it was a

13:56

disaster. What

13:58

does this ongoing humanitarian crisis look like? this

14:00

potential imminent famine, do

14:03

for Israel, not just its standing

14:05

and its morality, but its eventual

14:08

security? Well, obviously, the great

14:10

fear is that

14:12

the longer the fighting goes

14:14

on, the longer the desperate

14:17

struggle for survival of the civilians,

14:19

the longer the Palestinian civilians,

14:21

the longer the hostages are held,

14:24

for every day more of humanitarian crisis, you

14:27

put off by three days the eventual

14:30

sustainable resolution of

14:32

this core crisis.

14:35

And that leaves the whole of the

14:37

region less safe rather than more safe.

14:39

That is the fundamental fear. We have

14:42

operations in Lebanon. We have operations in

14:44

Syria. We have operations in Iraq. We

14:46

have operations in Jordan, humanitarian operations. And

14:50

I was in Jordan recently. I mean,

14:52

obviously, the whole region is roiled by

14:54

this. And so the humanitarian

14:56

imperative is not just a moral one.

14:59

We know from our experience around

15:02

the world, untended humanitarian crisis leads

15:04

to further political instability. That's

15:06

the message too. David

15:09

Miliband, president of IOC. Thank

15:11

you very much. Thank you very

15:13

much. We all do

15:16

things our own way. And since the way that each of

15:18

us sleeps is unique, you need a bed that fits you

15:20

just the right way. Sleep Number Smart

15:22

Beds make your sleep experience as individual

15:24

as you are. And cutting edge technology

15:27

to give you effortless, high quality sleep

15:29

every night. J.D. Power ranks Sleep Number

15:31

number one in customer satisfaction with mattresses

15:34

purchased in store. And now during Sleep

15:36

Number's Presidents Day sale, save 50% on

15:38

the Sleep Number limited edition smart bed

15:40

plus special financing for a limited time.

15:43

For J.D. Power 2023 award information, visit

15:45

jdpower.com slash awards. Only at Sleep

15:47

Number stores or sleepnumber.com. See store

15:49

for details. I'm

15:52

Dr. Sanjay Gupta, CNN's chief medical

15:54

correspondent. This week on Chasing

15:56

Life, it was 13 years ago when a

15:58

Seattle based writer by the The name of

16:00

Lindy West published an essay that took

16:03

the internet by storm. It was called

16:05

simply hello, I'm fat. That was

16:07

scary too. kind of in a certain

16:09

way announce. I'm throwing in the towel

16:11

of trying to be this other thing lindy

16:14

and are going to discuss how the way

16:16

we talk about weed has changed. Listen to

16:18

Tasting Like River, You get your podcasts. Cells

16:23

Throughout this war, many extreme

16:25

Israelis. Including members of this

16:27

and Yahoos coalition ah assessing

16:29

their sights on resettling Gaza.

16:32

Which is why these comments by

16:34

Jared clustered old from Son in

16:36

Law or sparking controversy. And

16:39

golfers waterfront property. You could be a very

16:41

valuable to thought if people would focus on

16:43

kind of building up your life with us.

16:45

You think all the money that's gotten into

16:47

this tunnel network and at all the munitions

16:49

of that would have gone into education or

16:52

innovations. What could have been done? And so

16:54

I think that it's a little bit of

16:56

an unfortunate situation. Their blessing from Israel's perspective.

16:58

I would do my best to move the

17:00

people out and then clean it up. Move

17:02

the people out, clean it up, The

17:05

occupied West Bank gets much less

17:07

attention, but Israeli settlements their continued

17:10

to expand against international. Law Correspondents

17:12

or his award reports from

17:14

that troubled West Bank. High

17:18

in the hills of the

17:20

occupied West Bank, flag flies

17:22

in the face of a

17:24

Palestinian village.is King it says.

17:27

Too young settlers guard this

17:29

illegal outposts. Construction hasn't even

17:32

been. That we are

17:34

not welcome. They're

17:37

asking us to we don't want

17:39

to talk to us. Isn't there

17:42

for about. Just

17:47

crossed the last Or

17:49

fight. To assert his really

17:51

control over Palestinian land, the

17:54

Arabic names and signposts crudely.

17:56

Erased. Under international

17:58

law to date. Hardware settlement

18:00

is illegal but last February

18:02

so the Israeli government officially

18:05

recognize it along with eight

18:07

other. Movie Us

18:09

strongly oppose. Roma

18:11

buffalo bulkier were a mere because god

18:13

your honor of our land as real

18:15

Alberta car to tell them. Now

18:18

the settlers have set their sights on

18:21

a new prize. One. That

18:23

seemed utterly impossible before

18:25

October seventh. Returning

18:28

so dire that they cheer. That

18:30

is the goal of Zion Settler

18:32

Organization a heloc. One of more

18:35

than a dozen groups now advocating

18:37

for the reestablishment of Israeli settlements

18:39

in Gaza Southern Up know the

18:41

A com a refund promotional video

18:44

even both had gone the will

18:46

become the next Riviera. Donkeys on.

18:48

His. Last Movie or a Madman. And

18:52

Yellow Line is the God mother

18:54

of the movement and from already

18:56

started recruiting from the seven hundred

18:58

thousand strong settler community As Israel

19:00

were just arriving now at a

19:02

settlement in the West Bank and

19:04

we're heading towards Hawks, the Danielle

19:07

or Weiss is given to a

19:09

group of people who are potentially

19:11

interested in resettling Gaza or not

19:13

move as as a society we're

19:15

for the land of Israel and

19:17

banged his ears says about twenty

19:19

people gather in the legislative. Assembly

19:22

see him home with my wife.

19:24

knows that for many and it's

19:26

community there is deep nostalgia for

19:28

Goose is he's a block of

19:30

twenty one Israeli settlement of the

19:32

were forcibly evacuated. Eighty eighty I had

19:35

to love in the eyes in Israel,

19:37

less the Gaza Strip. Nine. Of

19:40

is this is the vision of

19:42

Gaza She says see all the

19:44

nucleus groups. A

19:46

map has already been thrown out of

19:48

the season. Six groups laying claim to

19:51

different parts of the enclave they've just

19:53

been having out the a little fuck

19:55

was that. Save people with Israel to

19:57

return home. And as underneath. called

20:00

to return to the settlement of Gaza.

20:04

One of the organizers tells the group

20:06

they have a representative flying to Florida

20:09

to raise money. Snaphala

20:11

gets support from a number of

20:13

groups in the US, including Aafsi,

20:16

Americans for a Safe Israel, which

20:18

co-sponsored a recent webinar on the

20:20

return to Gush Katif, even as

20:22

the Biden administration has cracked down

20:25

on settlements in the West Bank.

20:27

There is a very strong support

20:30

from very prominent, from very,

20:33

I would say, wealthy people,

20:36

wealthy Jews in the US. Can

20:39

you name any names? No. I

20:42

cannot. No. Back

20:44

at her home in Kedunim settlement,

20:46

Weiss tells us she's already enrolled

20:48

500 families. I

20:52

even have on my cell

20:54

phone names of people who say, enlist

20:56

me, enroll me. I want to join. I

20:59

want to join the groups that are going to settle

21:01

Gaza. I have to ask you, though, because we're sitting

21:03

here talking, and we're listening to the calls of prayer.

21:05

Yeah, I'm listening. I hope you

21:07

are listening to it. Which is a reminder, I think,

21:09

of the people who live

21:12

here, but also the people who live in Gaza. What

21:14

happens to them in this vision

21:16

of this new settlement with Jewish

21:19

settlers, even in Gaza City? What I

21:21

think about Gaza, the Arabs of Gaza,

21:24

lost the right to be

21:26

in Gaza on the

21:28

7th of October. Yes, I do

21:31

hear the mosque. I do hear

21:33

that the prayer things were different

21:35

until the 7th of October. No

21:38

Arab, I'm speaking about more than two million

21:41

Arabs, they will not stay there.

21:43

We Jews will be in Gaza.

21:46

That sounds like ethnic cleansing. The

21:49

Arabs want to annihilate the state

21:51

of Israel. So you

21:53

can call them monsters. You

21:57

can call them cleansing.

22:00

Joseph. We are not

22:02

doing to them, they are

22:04

doing to us. I

22:06

couldn't make it clearer when I

22:08

said that the myself as a

22:10

person who is be with settling

22:13

the land and feel the seventh.

22:15

Of October I didn't have the

22:17

flames of returning to Gaza. It's.

22:20

Clear I'm not interested in clean.

22:23

What is? Clear is that voices

22:25

views traditionally seen as extreme in

22:28

Israel. Had become more popular

22:30

since October. Hobble the

22:32

late January June cause

22:34

heartburn on Purim Harvard.

22:37

Or from her home front on

22:40

for the settlement or harbor or

22:42

poll that month from the Jewish

22:44

People Policy Institute found the twenty

22:47

six percent of Israelis advocate the

22:49

reconstruction of the Bush Qatif settlements

22:52

after the war is over. Mom.

22:54

Supporters of Prime Minister Benjamin

22:57

Netanyahu's right wing coalition government.

22:59

That number jumps to fifty

23:01

one. Percent government has

23:03

a conference Looting far

23:05

right heritage minister I'm

23:08

high on yahoo. In

23:12

a rare interview with Western media,

23:14

he tells us his political decisions

23:16

are guided by the torah were

23:18

brutal. it's or anything about good

23:20

to teeth. And. Here are. Good.

23:23

But as of December. Settlements

23:25

in Gaza aren't enough to

23:27

prevent another October seventh. Of

23:29

the fossil record co moved from the language of

23:31

the Lambs from that wherever there is a Jerusalem

23:33

and there will be more security. The.

23:35

Remainder will be off of security or

23:37

there will be more security. Why

23:40

would you advocate for something that many

23:42

would throw? Is illegal. Immoral.

23:46

Or not supported by the

23:48

majority of Israelis and is

23:50

also very harmful to Israel

23:52

in terms of it's international

23:54

standing Market Research on fully

23:56

why do you think it's

23:59

immoral to. They do. I am

24:01

from someone who wants to kill me. Elaborate

24:03

on why is it immoral to take my

24:05

land which my ancestors lived there was as

24:07

even given up someone's slaughters, rapes and murders

24:10

made me sit. For what is more moral

24:12

than that? Netanyahu

24:14

has called me settling down and

24:16

of. Course

24:23

my Gf soldiers fighting

24:25

Thera video. Calling

24:28

from time to discuss it's easy.

24:31

For. Many supporters of the settler

24:34

movement, what was once a

24:36

disincentive is now a further

24:38

three. And

24:42

the Us Administration. Also has

24:44

strongly rejected this vocal but

24:46

still minority View Cell Service

24:48

award that. In a moment Michelle

24:51

Moss in he a very. Different,

24:53

equally outspoken view. From

24:55

the Israeli Knesset member overcast seats. he's

24:57

an opponent of the Settler movement and

24:59

also the Nes and Young governments. But

25:01

first with entities tried to the

25:03

person versus. An Iranian American family

25:06

comedies that was a breakout hit at

25:08

last year's Sundance Festivals has been out

25:10

in the United States is now opening.

25:13

In Europe's the semi autobiographical

25:15

film from director Mariam Cash.

25:17

Out as bring serious energies. To

25:20

her own migrant experience. Here's a clip

25:22

from the trailer. This

25:25

is a family said in a self capone.

25:27

The Problem: A courtesy junior month queen class

25:29

to bring that the guy had been three

25:32

her mmm for sexual. And these. Attacks

25:35

mean for the anonymous

25:38

francis. Fell

25:40

in the movies the family All Gather

25:42

as their father played by Be Jeans.

25:45

On this manned undergoes a heart transplants

25:47

Persian version opens instead. As as I

25:49

said across year of this Fridays and

25:51

on Netflix in the U P's and

25:53

on spent on Mariam Kiss of As

25:55

Join Me Now welcome both of you

25:58

to the program! So Merriam This. Essentially

26:00

a semi autobiographical. Stories you

26:02

have is he wrote it directed at.

26:05

What? About your life is

26:07

is represented there. Oh my God

26:10

I said to myself I. Honestly,

26:13

I just wanted to do something. I grew up

26:15

in New York City as born in New York

26:17

by Selma, came from Iran and the sixties. I

26:19

just grew up. Never seen any images of people

26:22

like our family. And I have it when Trump

26:24

took office I wanted to show the the reality

26:26

of our community and the levity and someone someone

26:28

should dig into your own family. Oh lordy, there's

26:30

so much to begin to. I grew up with

26:32

seven brothers and one bathroom. a New York City

26:35

so there's plenty of drop. In reality, reality

26:37

in the movie, to in the movies.

26:39

Eight. In reality of seven and you

26:41

know I just dug deep to kind

26:43

of look at family secrets as a

26:45

way to analyze that immigrant experience to

26:47

the movies. Oh unusual. It's a safe

26:49

place half and Iran and has cinema

26:51

and the people and not used to

26:53

seeing. An Iranian Rom com Or an Iranian

26:55

American. A Rom. A Nice having father

26:57

were such fun p Miles you know

26:59

they are ivory. So

27:02

is is. it starts in the you

27:04

while doesn't stop. But there is a

27:06

real major sort of opening sequence where

27:08

you're all gathered, the family around you

27:10

as the father, bees and you play

27:12

the father who is now over father,

27:14

older father. Yes, Who's. Now

27:16

enduring a you know life

27:19

threatening illness writing. And

27:21

that brings. This whole

27:23

story to light what made

27:25

you. Enjoy playing this part have you

27:27

do do a lot of of I've seen

27:29

in. In Britain and America

27:32

are awesome things and yourself who.

27:35

British and American productions either in

27:37

the you to. Europe.

27:39

Or North Africa sometimes. I'm.

27:42

What was very attractive about this for surgery

27:44

was it's a social film and is hop.

27:46

He got some. I'm. So sad

27:48

moments. On

27:51

I enjoy playing. In the

27:53

movies which are of social. Families.

27:56

Disputes. Workings

28:00

if you like and I was honored

28:02

to play her father and and nervous

28:04

as well because I wanted for feedback

28:07

as to what your father really? You,

28:09

you know and I did. He really

28:11

was. And I have to say it,

28:13

It is really interesting that because it's

28:15

so she is based around the very

28:17

fractious relationship you have used. Your mother.

28:20

And you figure out a family

28:22

secret. Through your grandmother when you

28:24

left behind with her while the rest

28:26

of the family is it the father's

28:29

bedside. Exactly. It's a really based on to start

28:31

my dad had a heart transplant and my grandmother

28:33

came from Shiraz and suit only want to stay

28:35

with me. I had had a falling out with

28:37

my mom she was a tough lady growing up

28:39

as the.com and take care of your grandmother and

28:41

my grandmother's and sooner or your parents came to

28:43

America nineteen sixty seven and I thought I knew

28:45

the stories that came because there were enough doctors.

28:47

they're all in Vietnam as as I said such

28:50

a cute story. I'm in the what are the

28:52

to be as I say as the want to

28:54

know the Truth Eight You know the came because

28:56

of scandal and it's it was a fun thing

28:58

to do because we think. Of our parents are

29:00

so different than us, but actually the movies

29:02

showing the relationship between mother and daughter are

29:04

different decades and that's the reason that we

29:06

have so many issues my mother and I

29:08

that were so much alike on the not

29:10

to me and discounted is real. the send

29:13

A story are the sorts of the story

29:15

essentially that I'd also add. So you're full

29:17

of nausea. He doesn't bad things like

29:19

been was younger a concert you because

29:21

in the story of the good well

29:24

it is it means he does have

29:26

He adds another family kind of see

29:28

how to behave. Fab. See

29:30

when he was younger he wasn't a bad

29:33

manners Guzman you love this family placebo makes

29:35

the bambee so yes but. The your

29:37

mother in real life. Was. Bit

29:39

rose to a man. more than ten years

29:41

says or her than hard as he was only

29:43

a teenager exactly and i was really sick hard

29:45

for thing for me to do it's like my

29:47

mom got married a thirteen i've heard the story

29:49

thirty seven or eight and a cast affair last

29:51

year old girl to play my mother i knew

29:53

the store i've heard in a million times rights

29:56

but when you bring an actor to play your

29:58

mother your really emphasize is that this girl one

30:00

year older than my own daughter, and she

30:02

was playing my mother, to have someone breathe

30:04

your parents' story. And also my

30:06

father. He became a man at 11. His

30:08

own father died, and he had to become

30:10

the patriarch of eight sisters. So

30:13

for me, I learned so much about

30:15

my parents, about being empathetic. The

30:18

film for me was a

30:20

challenge, because I had to think of my

30:22

parents, not as my parents, but as individuals,

30:25

teenagers, 20-something year olds who

30:27

make mistakes and are afraid.

30:30

And Bijan, it also says

30:32

a lot about Iran. It says a

30:34

lot about how things were back then.

30:37

Yes. Yeah, which not many people

30:39

in the West really know. And

30:41

even Iranians born post-revolution

30:43

don't know much, particularly

30:46

the ones which are born outside of

30:48

Iran. Yeah. Yeah, and I think,

30:50

you know, my mom struggled in the 60s. We

30:52

think, I mean, of course, before the revolution,

30:54

there was a lot of freedom in terms of

30:57

dress and all these different things. But still,

30:59

I think women's struggles are a continuous one, even

31:01

pre-revolution. My mom. And the post-glows

31:03

going on now. And now, of course, is a

31:05

continuum. People say, you know, the fight for women's

31:07

rights is an ongoing one. My mom wanted to

31:09

just finish school. That was a revolutionary idea then.

31:12

And now that's kind of why she's so open to

31:14

having her story told. Because it's time after

31:17

how many 50-plus years, 60-plus years,

31:19

that we take the reins. This is a

31:21

mother who my whole life said, we should

31:23

not talk about the past. We should not

31:25

talk about our stories. And here she is,

31:27

she's saying, it's time for us. She

31:30

likes this film. She wanted me to tell this. I would never

31:32

do it without permission. It would raise her awards and all. And

31:34

that's the thing. People like me in the film,

31:37

I'm portrayed as Leila. The

31:39

mother, because we see all of what she went

31:41

through and how she became a strong immigrant and

31:43

everything she did for her family and redefined herself

31:46

and became the writer of her own destiny. They're

31:48

like, you're cool, but your mom is a hundred

31:50

times more interesting. And I say, you know what,

31:52

she really is because I learned so much making

31:54

a film about her. And Bijan, I mean, the

31:57

film is obviously a great

31:59

tribute. to the women, to the women

32:01

of Iran as well. The sub-todd is the sub-todd. I

32:03

mean, my own mother was a strong

32:05

person in my family. I relate to

32:07

that as well. And

32:10

it's so much- The father figure was an

32:13

interesting man. He had his dogmatic,

32:16

strict set of principles the way he lived. He didn't

32:18

want to sell his house for

32:20

a profit, for example. In America, my dad

32:22

was a very unique person. I think I'm very

32:24

much a mix of both of my parents. My

32:26

dad was so idealistic. They don't make him like

32:28

him anymore. He was a doctor that

32:31

when people didn't have money, they would just bring him a pie

32:33

or like a knit sweater. And that was

32:35

fine. And in the film again, it

32:38

merges to, well, as you go back

32:40

and forth, America, childhood, Iran, you know-

32:43

And my smuggling days of smuggling. I want to ask

32:45

you about that. This

32:47

play, just the clip that we have, it's sort of

32:49

kind of magical realism part of the play.

32:53

So- Shia Muslims are really

32:55

into this magic real stuff. In

32:57

our family, there's always someone who comes to save

32:59

the day. His name is-

33:02

Ammon Ammon. He's this amazing thing.

33:04

When he disappeared a few hundred years ago, like

33:07

literally disappeared in a dinner one day, he

33:10

was a busy guy. A true believer says

33:12

his name, and he appears in times of need. And

33:15

he can appear in human or

33:17

animal terms. Oh, you're stuck, uh-huh.

33:20

Well, I thought of him too. Disclosed

33:22

to getting what she wants. Of

33:24

course she pulled a favor from the big guy. My

33:27

mom only believes in this stuff. I'm not

33:29

sure I do. If she's old world, I'm

33:32

new world. This is my mom and

33:34

I's relationship in a nutshell. It's

33:38

great to be able to stop time in a movie, isn't it? As

33:41

we said, it won the audience favorite at

33:43

Sundance. Were you surprised,

33:45

I mean, by the reaction? I really, you never

33:47

know when you make a movie. It's so bearing

33:50

your family there. But

33:53

it was a very weird Sundance. I

33:55

finished the film two days before the premiere, and we showed it.

33:57

I was more terrified because my family was in the audience. the

34:00

end people got up and danced and

34:03

the head of Sony was like we've had many

34:05

films at the festival for 20-something years we've never

34:07

had audience stand up and dance

34:09

and that was kind of my agenda in

34:11

some ways for you to go through the

34:13

roller coaster of this family but at the

34:15

end want to celebrate and I think that's

34:17

kind of a radical concept I think in

34:19

our part of the world. In our part

34:21

of the world you're absolutely right about that. I want to

34:23

ask you a slightly different question you know

34:25

you've all you've talked about

34:27

being concerned with repetition, difference and disruption.

34:30

My art. Yes, your art. Yes. So

34:32

tell me about that because you're also

34:34

an artist I've seen your beautiful paintings.

34:37

Yeah I make paintings and various

34:40

works of art. Repetition is very

34:42

interesting for me I just believe the whole

34:44

universe is a series of repetitive actions we

34:47

all repetitions I mean it's like

34:49

snowflakes like sperms but

34:51

there's always a difference and my

34:54

latest work of art in terms

34:56

of paintings I've been painting damavans

34:59

and I've made over a classic iconic

35:01

the highest mountain the mountain in Iran

35:03

and it's a symbol of fighting the

35:05

oppressor it's very symbolic it's in our

35:07

poetry and I've made all

35:09

these paintings they're identical yet they're

35:12

all different yes and just quickly

35:14

before I ask you the last question playing

35:16

you played in the diplomat which was a

35:18

very popular series about a

35:20

US ambassador here in Britain yes what

35:23

was that like playing in a Netflix series it was

35:25

good because for once there I mean Iran

35:27

has got up to many bad things but

35:29

they're not always doing the bad things and

35:31

in this particular TV show we were

35:34

not actually the people who had

35:36

you weren't the baddie you were in the baddie you've

35:41

been banned and your films have been banned

35:43

in Iran you've done other other films about

35:45

the country so in the last 30 seconds that

35:48

we have how is this being seen there and

35:50

surely people have seen it it has

35:53

a great reception I mean it's been pirated obviously

35:55

and they watch it there and it's it's kind

35:57

of the first one that takes place half between

36:00

Iran and half between America. So it's their

36:02

story and our story. And I think people

36:04

are really responding to the humor and the

36:07

playfulness and the magic realism aspects. And one

36:09

of the things that was very funny

36:11

is as a kid, you used to

36:13

travel back. I was a smuggler. I smuggled

36:15

Michael Jackson, Cindy Lauper, Madonna,

36:18

because back in the days there was no digital downloads. The

36:20

only way to get music from America was for me to

36:22

put them into my underwear. And

36:24

I was a smuggler. On the next scene,

36:26

the airport scene in the film. Yeah, it's very

36:28

good. It's very good. It's a very

36:31

uplifting and fun film. It really is

36:33

a great story. Thanks for having

36:35

me. I'm Maryam Kishawaz, Bijan Dhanishpand. Thank you

36:37

both very much. And as we said, this

36:40

will premiere here in the UK

36:42

on Friday. As

36:49

we reported earlier, there are loud and

36:51

differing voices within Israel on the

36:53

so-called day after the war. We

36:55

heard the extreme settle of you earlier

36:58

and left-wing lawmaker Ofer Kassif

37:00

is just as passionate about

37:02

opposing that and opposing Netanyahu's

37:04

handling of the war, stressing

37:06

the need for a political

37:08

solution. And he joins Michel Martin

37:10

now to explain why and

37:12

how he survived the recent effort to impeach

37:14

him. Thanks,

37:17

Christiane. Can I say, member, thank

37:19

you so much for speaking with us. Thank

37:21

you for having me. My pleasure and honor. Before

37:24

we get into recent events, I wanted

37:26

to go back a little bit

37:29

to last month. You've

37:31

been very critical of the Netanyahu government.

37:34

You have argued and you have

37:36

made no secret of the fact that

37:38

you think that this government has been

37:40

engaging in many

37:43

sort of anti-democratic efforts, trying

37:45

to silence dissent, silence

37:48

any criticism, cracking

37:50

down on public demonstrations that

37:53

would be customary in a democracy. How

37:56

did you find out that, and I understand that

37:58

this is your fellow Knesset. Members Who would

38:00

move to impeach you. But how did you

38:03

find out that they were moving to impeach

38:05

you? Were laid. there is a

38:07

lawyer you got to do. It's an

38:09

active be made two thousand and sixteen

38:11

but the longer majority of ninety and

38:14

windows of exist without a one hundred

38:16

twenty two Mph and other member of

38:18

the lists. If if one is a

38:20

a a fuse the an idea of

38:22

being a supporting racism or supporting an

38:25

armed struggle against Do It. Now.

38:27

Way after a sign this petition

38:29

which I guess we will discuss

38:32

later about a i realized that

38:34

say one member of the knesset

38:36

this highlights member of business and

38:39

a he gave be done. In.

38:41

A dizzying signatures from other

38:43

members of the cliffs of

38:45

the an older to begin

38:47

emotion to a beach with

38:50

so.sawaya a new about it

38:52

and do it as he

38:54

saw his swim. Honest. The

38:56

specific action that you were

38:58

accused of. Is in relation

39:00

to your decision to support the

39:02

petition to the International Criminal Court

39:05

that would have investigated Israel and

39:07

relation to it's. Absence in

39:09

Gaza in South Africa has

39:11

asked for. Israel to be investigated

39:14

and you said that new feel that

39:16

this is an appropriate thing to do

39:18

is briefly as you can. Why did

39:20

you feel that that was important? To

39:22

do. With. The to Maine seems

39:24

that the first of all you know

39:26

a i do not enough Png government

39:29

to investigate it says. He. The

39:31

it's not as seventy only the

39:33

Israeli government. that any government I

39:35

think the basis of democracy is

39:38

tough to anyone to cast doubts

39:40

on one's own Gabi Macys. like

39:42

in forty nine days it'll feel

39:45

that he said. She.

39:47

Wants to get conventional genocide

39:49

it's and actually recognize his

39:51

belt. So easy of the

39:53

I Cj investigating. Geek

39:56

such accusations so for me

39:58

towards very clear. That.

40:00

Day The I Cj is the

40:03

authority to investigate the ongoing seen

40:05

It in Gaza and know the

40:07

Israeli government itself. That was one

40:10

See the appeal is that in

40:12

bay appeal of South Africa as

40:14

well as the the petition. That

40:17

I joined and eventually by the

40:19

way they were almost one thousand

40:21

Israeli citizens who signed is pretty

40:23

simple ones are very clear call

40:26

to stop below. We all know

40:28

the the death toll of Palestinians

40:30

in Gaza. Is eg,

40:32

some always been mean the thirty

40:34

thousand. And. Day the Out

40:37

also have you learned soldiers and

40:39

hostages. We. Want everyone.

40:42

Who to it's to leave? We

40:44

got one symptoms anymore so it

40:46

was very clear. will be. A

40:48

good the government reason is not say

40:50

interested in the lives of anyone. Nigel

40:53

the is a little on the Palestinians.

40:56

So. Highly of fight song by

40:58

Sample Blinds. To. Appeal to

41:00

an international body such of I see take.

41:02

The. Effort to impeach you failed. At a

41:04

time to receive. A. Significant

41:07

number of us, but not enough to press

41:09

to obviously move forward with the impeachments. You

41:11

clearly have not been cowed by this. I

41:13

mean, this weekend gave a speech on the

41:15

floor of the Knesset in support of the

41:17

by the administration's sanctions against settlers in the

41:19

West Bank. Why do you believe that that

41:22

is the right course of action? Why do

41:24

you believe that it is appropriate for the

41:26

administration to play sanctions on the settlers? Because

41:28

as you know that it's very controversial? Pro:

41:30

A number of reasons many people think it's

41:32

sort of minimalist. Some people think it's the

41:34

wrong people, Some people think it's. A.

41:37

Bandaid. It doesn't really address the situation that

41:39

many opinions, but why do you think it

41:42

was an appropriate course of action? I

41:44

may upset or I may have set

41:46

or of the things you said. Smith

41:49

still doesn't rule out to some say

41:51

I read the main made it a

41:53

mainly you know buddy the to be

41:56

sanctioned in these people and government big

41:58

obvious for discs the government. The

42:00

responsible for the ongoing problems dust

42:02

settles, else carry out against Palestinians

42:04

in the West Bank. Look, I

42:07

want to be very very blunt

42:09

and very many leah. You.

42:11

View: the ethnic cleansing going on in

42:13

the air in the West bank been

42:16

slow the massacre of them and may

42:18

have of doorbell I mean. Literally

42:20

sleep for days before the massacre of the

42:22

Total Massacre the Game. In the Us it's.

42:25

Not. So much committed in which I does

42:27

on as your some friends three three

42:30

voted to say that they would totally

42:32

convinced because they get some people believe

42:34

that the fight against the wall and

42:36

against occupation that means that they support

42:38

the crimes of com us absolutely not

42:40

so I want to be medically about

42:42

that he had a to so. Sweet

42:45

or four days before domestic economy That

42:47

myself as I visited. And

42:49

Jordan Valley some fast. So you

42:51

know communities of Palestinian lands in

42:53

the West Bank. Finity. In

42:55

and been. That's all it is.

42:57

So communities were totally eliminated. speakers

43:00

to sleep because of the ongoing

43:02

daily boggles committed might set them

43:04

as as of the auspices of

43:06

the occupation forces. we are talking

43:09

about his size and then it's

43:11

only covered under siege. you'll still

43:13

be. And evidence

43:15

and since October seventh. He

43:19

devised into Palestinian communities a

43:21

little early thirties. Build.

43:23

An ongoing to explain saying you're saying

43:25

the in the West Bank we're not

43:27

talking about dogs and now we sent

43:29

him packing Bambee when you will manifest

43:32

Settlers are and making an effort to

43:34

drive Palestinians out. That would force. Accessible

43:37

to thoughts, smoke and twenty

43:39

communities Palestinian communities skyn sense.

43:41

Shepherds won't be good if

43:43

I visited. I know many

43:45

of them for so many.

43:48

Good people. Have nothing to

43:50

do is you know where violence

43:53

or whatever gets out. Assaulted

43:55

only continuous basis, a

43:57

daily basis for more.

44:00

At least actually, He's

44:02

been more the exactly want you. Since

44:05

I first set the live up. To

44:08

you are gonna be a you first

44:10

meet it's they will physically then i

44:12

said in butler of the middle of

44:14

the best sites that to eat doubtful

44:16

phones going on. By.

44:19

Settlers against the Palestinians in the

44:21

West Bank. Please stop leads us

44:23

to stop it first because it's

44:25

criminal. And

44:28

secondly, because it's going to blow up

44:30

with the old adage if. Everybody's

44:32

going to pay. The price is going

44:34

to be. And bloodshed that we've

44:37

never experienced. I said that, say slit

44:39

several months before the most secure

44:41

hawthorne assume it. Isn't. I

44:43

ever since I said. Okay,

44:45

Ice I just another thing. Lessons of

44:48

the same kinds. Of things

44:50

however got even one little i don't

44:52

have minister walid like. The you

44:54

think the Israeli. Public.

44:56

Sees what you see, In.

44:59

Gaza and the West Bank with know.

45:02

Be.the Bee media you bush did meet

45:04

the media and use that have been

45:06

entirely by the way. it's not you

45:08

know, way. A

45:12

it's not please. It's not something that

45:14

the government has been doing before. sink

45:16

in the media to books the maybe

45:18

I thought some really you. A

45:21

Totally sides. Or

45:24

ignores from the ongoing in God's

45:27

ask any the West Bank, Nobody

45:29

actually knows about it, and the

45:31

vast majority don't want to know

45:33

about it. Is. Because

45:35

is very hard to see a villain when you

45:37

look at the middle. The

45:39

polls and Israel so. High

45:42

support. For Israel's war in

45:44

Gaza in January there was a group

45:46

of Israel Democracy Institute which. i think

45:48

as a respected research institute said

45:51

it's fifty six percent i was

45:53

really pulled and january said continuing

45:55

the military offensive was the best

45:57

way to recover the hostages yet

46:00

The prime minister, Netanyahu, is not popular.

46:02

That same poll found that only 15

46:04

percent want Netanyahu to be prime minister

46:07

once the war is over. How do

46:09

you understand that? Well, many people

46:11

in Israel could blame at least

46:14

some of the responsibility for the

46:16

massacre of October 7 on

46:18

Netanyahu. And just be

46:20

so. He is responsible. He is

46:23

responsible for his long-going policy. He

46:25

said explicitly in 2019, and

46:28

I quote him almost all by

46:30

word, he said, those

46:32

who oppose a Palestinian state

46:35

like he does

46:38

must weaken the Palestinian Authority

46:40

and strengthen Hamas. He

46:42

said so. He said so. Even

46:45

Smotrich in 2015 said,

46:47

and I quote, the

46:50

Palestinian Authority is a burden. Hamas

46:53

is an asset. He said so.

46:55

They wanted Hamas to be strong

46:58

as part of the classic colonialist

47:00

divide and rule. And

47:02

they want the biggest of Hamas to

47:04

be stronger in order to find an

47:06

excuse and say that there's no one

47:08

to talk to. They

47:11

wanted it. They passed Netanyahu

47:13

himself for more than 10 years,

47:16

allowed millions of dollars to get

47:18

to the pockets of Hamas from

47:20

Qatar. It's not

47:22

a secret. Everybody knows that. He

47:24

is responsible because of that many

47:26

Israelis don't want him as a

47:28

prime minister. And just be so. They

47:30

say you are responsible. You are guilty. Some

47:33

even say you are guilty at

47:36

the same time. Many

47:38

of them think that the war must go on. Of

47:41

course, I'm not there. I am my

47:43

own criticism. But we do not agree about

47:45

the war, the assault. There

47:48

are many that do agree with me, especially

47:51

among the families of the hostages, not

47:53

all of them. Many

47:55

of the families of the hostages

47:57

and the victims were butchered by

47:59

Hamas. Understand

48:02

that this assault on Gaza will

48:04

not deliver neither security

48:06

for the Israeli sorry,

48:11

nor, let alone release of

48:13

the auspices. More and more

48:15

people begin to understand that, and I believe

48:18

that the atmosphere is shifting

48:21

slowly, gradually, but

48:23

it is shifting because of this situation.

48:26

So, let us turn

48:28

now to the U.S. rule here. First,

48:30

there was the Senate Majority Leader, Chuck

48:33

Schumer, a senator from New York. I

48:37

would say the sort of highest-ranking, most

48:39

prominent Jewish elected official in the United

48:41

States said that the Netanyahu government should

48:43

go, that the prime minister is not

48:45

serving the interests of the people. This

48:48

caused a huge reaction. And then, according

48:50

to the White House, President Joe Biden

48:52

called Prime Minister Netanyahu just this week

48:55

to warn against this

48:57

planned military operation that we are told

49:00

is coming in Rafa, saying that

49:02

a major ground operation there would be a mistake.

49:06

What do you make of these developments, particularly

49:08

the White House? Do you think that this

49:10

is consequential? Look, I must

49:13

say I'm very critical of the White

49:15

House and then of Biden's administration because

49:17

actually without their consent, the

49:19

assault on Gaza and this terrible death toll

49:22

would have never occurred. I

49:24

mean, there is a kind of,

49:27

you know, if you allow me

49:29

to use some concepts from psychology,

49:32

there is a kind of dissonance cognitive

49:35

because, you know, dissonance cognitive

49:37

is when one consciously

49:41

clinging to two contradictory

49:43

or more contradictory moments.

49:46

And that's what I see in the behavior of

49:49

President Biden, because on the one hand,

49:52

he speaks about the dire

49:55

situation, the grave situation of

49:57

the Palestinians in Gaza. starving

50:00

them. So it

50:02

is starvation caused by

50:04

Israel. And of course, no

50:07

medicine or street destruction, death toll,

50:09

etc. etc. That could

50:11

not happen without the support of the

50:14

United States. Why do you say that? Because

50:17

I give you two examples, which for me

50:19

are the main ones. First of

50:21

all, every time there's a

50:24

motion in criticism

50:26

of Israel in the Security Council

50:28

of the United Nations, the

50:32

United States vetoes

50:34

the decision. That's the support, which

50:37

I do not accept. I want

50:39

to be very clear. It's not

50:41

the support for Israel and the

50:43

Israelis. It's the support of the

50:45

Israeli government, which is against the

50:47

Israelis. I am in opposition.

50:49

I am committed

50:52

to the Israeli public and

50:55

I'm trying to do my job. And

50:57

part of my job is to stand

51:00

still against the government if the

51:02

government is wrong, let alone

51:04

things. And the

51:06

indigenous administration in supporting the

51:09

government of Israel is

51:11

acting against justice, against the Palestinians,

51:13

but also against the Israelis. Except

51:15

that public opinion, as we've discussed,

51:17

does not support this government per

51:19

se, but it does support what

51:21

the government is doing. Can I

51:23

say, remember, your views are

51:26

not in the majority. First

51:28

of all, you may be right. That

51:31

doesn't undermine my obligation to

51:35

raise my voice and to represent

51:37

the thousands and hundreds and

51:40

hundreds of thousands of

51:42

Israelis who do support my

51:44

view and the lateral people

51:46

out of Israel. But I

51:48

guess that we both would

51:51

agree that polls are

51:54

mainly for statistics, but not for

51:56

political decisions. So the White House

51:59

has said that Mr. Biden

52:01

asked Prime Minister Netanyahu to

52:04

send a delegation of

52:06

intelligence and military officials to

52:08

Washington to hear firsthand

52:11

the White House's views, particularly about this

52:13

planned incursion into Rafa. We are told

52:15

that the government, the Netanyahu government, has

52:17

agreed to send such a delegation. Does

52:20

that offer any hope to you? I

52:22

don't know if you heard how

52:24

Netanyahu explained sending the delegation. He

52:27

said that he's been doing

52:30

that for, and I quote,

52:32

for respect, because

52:35

he respects Biden, Mr. Biden.

52:38

Not because he wants to

52:40

achieve something or he's ready

52:42

to restrain from operating in

52:48

Rafa. I think

52:50

that to say that invading

52:53

to Rafa is wrong,

52:55

it's an understatement. It's

52:57

going to be a carnage. It's

53:00

the death toll that's going to be there,

53:02

the bloodshed that's going to be there, is

53:06

going to be even more disastrous than

53:08

what has been going thus far. Before

53:13

we let you go, clearly

53:15

you remain as

53:17

outspoken as ever. Do you feel

53:19

that you are opening up more

53:21

democratic space, more space

53:25

for public criticism or to

53:27

sort of maintain

53:30

these democratic traditions of sort of

53:32

public dissent? You

53:35

probably know this story that

53:37

just after the American

53:40

United States invaded Vietnam, there

53:43

was one person who used to demonstrate in

53:45

front of the White House. Every time he

53:47

was asked, what are you doing here alone?

53:49

You know that you're all alone. Everybody supports

53:52

the invasion of the assault of

53:54

Vietnam. And he used to answer,

53:56

according to the story, Per

53:59

AR. He was told by

54:01

a man he does. He was not

54:03

going to change society so used to

54:05

say perhaps I'm not going to change

54:08

society but they're sending in order to

54:10

make sure that society doesn't change me.

54:12

But eventually going back to the story

54:14

we know that this guy probably did

54:16

say society. Because we know what

54:19

happened later. So

54:21

answer your question. By.

54:23

Using the story. I. Do

54:25

believe. Not only me but

54:27

thousands of people that we could. We

54:29

went to demonstrate informed of the American

54:32

Embassy. As you know, I

54:34

got away or physical in calling

54:36

for the United States to recognize

54:38

a Palestinian state. So

54:41

it's not only be. It's pretty

54:43

intimate. It will be very it

54:45

was censored to say to me

54:47

that the people like to be

54:49

A or A and me together

54:51

we are the old. So both

54:53

peoples of these lands including the

54:55

Israeli. Knesset Member of

54:58

Focusing Thank you so much for sitting with us!

55:00

My. Pleasure think you have a nice day. And

55:04

Israeli government has consistently. Denied any

55:07

attempt to strengthen Hamas. And finally,

55:09

tonight, spring has begun in the

55:11

Northern Hemisphere. Mocking for many in

55:13

the world's not just the promise

55:15

of warmer weather, but also the

55:17

beginning of the ancient festival. Of

55:19

know who's. The celebration of

55:21

the person You yes some three

55:24

hundred million people are taking part

55:26

in ritual said symbolize rebirth and

55:28

reflections from Iran to Afghanistan, Central

55:31

Asia and the cause. Like these

55:33

performers. Donning traditional costumes, In

55:35

Bisbee Stag Kyrgyzstan in Tehran

55:37

with people are jumping over

55:39

fire to cleanser skirts and

55:41

even in the International. Space

55:44

Station where one Iranian, American,

55:46

Astronauts has prepared. A customary

55:48

have seen so happy know ruse

55:50

to old who celebrate. A the

55:52

some. I'm aware that that's it for now.

55:54

Thank you for watching and goodbye. for months We

56:06

all do things our own way, and since

56:08

the way that each of us sleeps is

56:11

unique, you need a bed that fits you

56:13

just the right way. Sleep Number SmartBeds make

56:15

your sleep experience as individual as you are,

56:18

using cutting-edge technology to give you effortless, high-quality

56:20

sleep every night. J.D. Power ranks Sleep Number

56:22

number one in customer satisfaction with mattresses purchased

56:24

in-store. Now, the Queen Sleep Number C4 SmartBed

56:27

is only $15.99. Save $300,

56:29

only for a limited time. For

56:31

J.D. Power 2023 award information,

56:34

visit jdpower.com/awards, only at a

56:36

Sleep Number store or sleepnumber.com.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features