Podchaser Logo
Home
Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Released Saturday, 30th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Putin’s pawns in the high-stakes game of hostage diplomacy

Saturday, 30th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Hi, this is Andy Katz, host of March

0:02

Madness 365, presented by Grammarly. This

0:05

week on the podcast, tune in as

0:07

we discuss March Madness players, upsets, matchups,

0:09

and bracket busters. Listen to March

0:11

Madness 365 with Andy Katz, presented by

0:13

Grammarly, wherever you get your podcasts. Grammarly

0:16

is a secure AI writing partner that gives your

0:18

team an instant first draft in a few clicks,

0:20

not a few hours. Companies that use

0:22

Grammarly save an average of 19 days per

0:24

employee per year. Grammarly works

0:26

seamlessly across 500,000 apps and websites. Get

0:30

personalized on-brand writing help everywhere your team

0:32

works. Learn what better writing can do

0:34

for your company at grammarly.com. Grammarly,

0:38

easier said, done. Hello

0:48

everyone and welcome to the Almond poor hour. Here's

0:50

where we're headed this week. Here's

0:52

a dictator and a usurper. This time the

0:54

free world finally said so. Putin's

0:57

pawns, the wife of Russia's most

0:59

high-profile political prisoner, reacts to

1:01

the year-long detention of Wall Street

1:04

Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich. Journalism

1:06

being equated with espionage, seriously?

1:10

That is a hostage situation.

1:13

Then why this State Department staffer

1:16

quit over the humanitarian crisis in

1:18

Gaza. People are shocked and appalled

1:20

by what the US government is doing. The

1:22

relative of an Israeli hostage who was

1:25

arrested at an anti-government

1:27

protest accuses Netanyahu of

1:29

deliberately slow-walking ceasefire talks. The

1:31

Israeli public is being pumped with,

1:34

together we will win, together we

1:36

will win, and we're not winning.

1:39

Also this hour, how did Elon

1:41

Musk's satellite internet system fall

1:43

into Russian hands? And

1:45

from my archive, the legendary feminist

1:48

Gloria Steinem turns 90. Welcome

1:55

to the programme everyone. I'm Christiana

1:57

Manpour in London. And we begin

1:59

this hour with Putin. Putin's political

2:01

pawns, and the dangerous hostage diplomacy

2:03

at play in the Kremlin. It's now

2:05

one year since Wall Street Journal

2:08

reporter Evan Gershkovich became the

2:10

first American journalist detained on

2:12

espionage charges since the Cold War.

2:15

He was on assignment with press credentials given

2:17

to him by the Russian Foreign Ministry.

2:20

There's zero evidence to support their charges.

2:22

And Evan, his family, and the Journal,

2:25

and the US government deny all the

2:27

allegations against him. In a

2:29

moment, I'll introduce you to Evgenia Karamorza.

2:31

Her husband Vladimir, who's a

2:33

British Russian citizen, is one

2:35

of roughly 700 political prisoners

2:39

in Russia. He's survived two

2:41

poisonings that nearly killed him, and he's

2:43

now serving 25 years for

2:46

treason after criticizing Putin's illegal

2:48

invasion of Ukraine. But first,

2:51

CNN's Fred Pleitkin explains how

2:53

we got here. No

2:56

media allowed at Evan Gershkovich's most recent

2:58

court hearing in Moscow, just this short

3:01

clip by the court's press service. Despite

3:04

a year in a Russian jail, a

3:06

defiant smile from the Wall Street Journal

3:08

reporter, no surprise, his detention

3:10

was extended yet again through June

3:12

30th. The

3:14

US ambassador to Russia ripping into the

3:17

verdict. The accusations against Evan

3:19

are categorically untrue. They are

3:21

not a different interpretation of

3:23

circumstances. They are fiction.

3:26

Evan Gershkovich was arrested and charged

3:29

with espionage a year ago while

3:31

on assignment in Yekaterinburg, central Russia.

3:35

I do not know if there are any

3:37

other cases, but the allegations made by our

3:39

intelligence services today were not related to his

3:41

journalism. The

3:46

Wall Street Journal and Gershkovich's family

3:48

strongly deny the allegations. Paulina

3:51

Ivanova of the Financial Times is

3:53

one of Evan's best friends and

3:55

still keeps in regular contact with

3:57

him writing letters. Well,

4:00

he's absolutely staying strong. He's not

4:03

allowing himself to wallow,

4:05

to get too upset by everything. In fact,

4:07

he spends most of his time in letters

4:10

to us trying to make us feel better. Gershkovich

4:13

faces a jail sentence of up to 20

4:15

years of convicted. But CNN

4:17

has reported that Gershkovich and former

4:19

U.S. Marine Paul Whelan were part

4:22

of a proposed prisoner swap with

4:24

a now-dead opposition leader Alexei Navalny.

4:28

The Russian president taunted on his

4:30

re-election day that he approved a

4:32

swap on the condition he'd get

4:34

back a high-profile Russian intelligence officer

4:36

in prison for murder in Germany,

4:38

Vadim Krossikov. The person who spoke

4:40

to me had not finished his sentence yet.

4:43

I said I agree, but unfortunately,

4:45

what happened happened. For

4:47

those close to Evan, that means

4:50

the waiting continues outcome uncertain. When

4:52

you see Putin talk about it, and in

4:54

very clear terms that this is what they

4:56

want to see happen, that they are looking

4:58

for a deal, it just

5:00

gives you hope that at some point that he will be home.

5:04

He needs to be home. He needs to be back with

5:06

his family, with his friends. From

5:08

Plakken, CNN, Berlin. As

5:10

the war in Ukraine enters its

5:12

third year, Putin gets ever stronger in

5:15

punishing any dissent at home. People

5:18

like Vladimir Karamorza remain in

5:20

jail. So now to my conversation

5:22

with his wife, Evgenia Karamorza, who

5:25

is central in the increasingly

5:27

female-led fight for human rights

5:29

and democracy in Russia. Evgenia

5:32

Karamorza, welcome to the program.

5:35

Hello, Christian. Thank you very much for inviting me.

5:38

I'd like to ask you, in light

5:40

of your husband's persistent imprisonment in

5:42

Moscow, in Russia, and also

5:44

being a one-year anniversary since

5:46

the journalist Evan Gershkowitz was

5:49

taken, his

5:51

family tries to reach him. I know you try

5:53

to reach your husband and your kids,

5:55

you try to get them to talk to him. How

5:58

do you do it? When was the

6:00

last time you managed and how long can you

6:02

talk for? The

6:06

last time I talked to my husband was last

6:09

summer, in summer 2020. My

6:12

kids were allowed a 15-minute

6:14

phone call with their dad at

6:16

the end of December of last year. And

6:19

since we have three kids, it

6:23

meant that each of them got five minutes

6:25

on the phone with their dad. And

6:28

that was the first call in over half a year.

6:31

And I obviously had to

6:35

measure those minutes with a timer because

6:37

I could not allow one of

6:40

our kids to speak to their father for

6:42

longer than five minutes. So in

6:46

the conditions in which Vladimir is being kept

6:48

now, and that is a punishment cell

6:51

in a so-called special regime prison

6:53

colony in western Siberia,

6:55

he's not allowed any visits by family

6:57

members. He's not allowed any calls. And

7:01

only under exceptional circumstances.

7:04

So in mid-February, we

7:06

celebrated our 20th anniversary and Vladimir requested

7:08

a phone call with me and

7:11

was denied the Russian, the

7:14

prison authorities told him that this was

7:16

not an exceptional circumstance, as

7:18

was not our oldest daughter's 80th

7:21

birthday. So

7:24

they told him that this would

7:27

be an exceptional

7:29

circumstance. Other than that, he's

7:31

not allowed any phone calls with him. Wow.

7:34

That is just so hard to hear. It's

7:36

really hard to hear. What must

7:38

be going through your mind every

7:41

day since Alexei Navalny died? I

7:43

don't know whether you also believe that he was killed in

7:46

prison. I do believe that this

7:48

was a murder and that the

7:50

responsibility lies with Vladimir Putin.

7:53

As to my family's situation, well,

7:56

you know what? I have been

7:58

leading with this fear. Fifteen.

8:01

One man had and survived the first.

8:03

Attack on head the first and then

8:06

no smoking. So. Than survive yet

8:08

not a one in two thousand. And. Seventeen. And

8:10

then he threw. An an independent

8:12

investigation by banning certain inside as

8:14

we know that the same team

8:16

that were implicated in the fourth

8:19

nobody says vomit had been following

8:21

my husband before first attack. So

8:23

now that he's been how of

8:25

Madison people who try to to

8:27

twice of. Course I am extremely

8:29

worried about his life and I I've

8:31

I've been. Living with his fear for many

8:34

years already. And I can see the

8:36

strain. Obviously in your in your face

8:38

and in your words your husband

8:40

is a domestic and other was

8:42

a Russian critique inside Russia of

8:44

fruits. And or Evan Gosh

8:47

coverage was arrested and jailed.

8:49

On what the Americans called from

8:51

top espionage charges The first time

8:54

a journalist ah American journalists since

8:56

the Cold was. What is

8:58

foods his aim in? I

9:00

know the difference. But what's

9:02

the aim of holding these

9:04

pawns, whether domestically or international.

9:07

Because. Ah

9:09

well, the early imprisonment or

9:11

by Evan Deskovic shower An

9:14

absolutely ridiculous grounds. And

9:16

in journalism Been acquainted with Athena

9:18

Us. Seriously. Ah,

9:20

but that is. That

9:23

it's it's would. Be

9:25

pushing and it's hostages. To

9:27

than get the ad persons of

9:30

interest to him. To

9:32

Russia in exchange for. A

9:34

delight to be through stages. The

9:37

kind of the to five o'clock in.

9:40

A tweet to the sand. In. The

9:42

country. Of

9:45

criminals, sky traders and foreign agent.

9:47

you spoke as the you when

9:49

in fact this last week and

9:51

you laid into President Putin. I'm

9:53

gonna play a little bit of

9:55

what you said. Vladimir. Putin

9:57

is not a legitimately elected president.

10:00

He is it better and a usurper. It's time.

10:02

The Free World Final the said. So. Famously.

10:05

President Biden said that you know putting

10:07

would pay for the death of novel

10:09

Nice I'm you have met your husband

10:11

was a jewel Uk. Citizens with the

10:14

bar minutes the here and and

10:16

others. What must the world do

10:18

you think? Ah

10:20

well with regard. To on Britain

10:22

biden promise I'm afraid with

10:24

so we keep it as

10:27

devastating consequences. Not had

10:29

been promised. Ah. I.

10:32

That you know I'd join my

10:35

husband in his call the Tsunami

10:37

Coin Stay the same and I

10:39

believe adopt the World. Has

10:42

to Finally. Called. That

10:44

and it's which Is that What he

10:46

is a criminal wanted by the I

10:48

C see four feet not be of

10:50

Ukrainian kids and for movie other. Crimes.

10:53

that his and he himself and

10:56

his regime has been making over

10:58

the years of his teachers. Not

11:00

be seen and recognized as a

11:02

legitimate partner who the international stage.

11:04

I want to ask you. Whether

11:06

furthermore, the terror attack that took

11:08

place of Isis claimed last week's

11:11

that kills you know, nearly one

11:13

hundred and forty people you saw

11:15

that Putin finally admitted that it

11:17

was a Be Isis. The said that

11:20

Ukraine must have had something to do with it.

11:22

Move my. I'm still struggling. You know

11:25

that the crime was committed by radical

11:27

Islamic. Whose. Ideology: The Islamic

11:29

World itself has been fighting for centuries.

11:31

It is also necessary to answer the

11:33

question why the terrorists tried to go

11:36

to Ukraine after committing a crime. Who.

11:38

Was waiting for them there. We

11:40

know that lot of it was in has

11:43

been on the scene for almost a quarter

11:45

of the century, making very similar crimes to

11:47

the ones that have been committed now

11:49

in Ukraine and in the past. And.

11:53

The. Regime used every terrorist

11:55

attack eve the country.

11:58

To. It's own. That. Were

12:03

frequent repression in the country

12:05

and to launch across. Each

12:08

other than to enter. Third and fourth

12:10

harry attack nord off and

12:12

fetch lands were used. To

12:15

start the Second Chechen War.

12:17

By and like, the bombing of

12:19

Ninety Ninety Nine are all these

12:21

the terrorist attack in the past

12:23

we use to start at a

12:25

second Chechen war. And to

12:27

justify this aggression against such,

12:30

yeah, And I

12:32

believe that line to push and

12:34

would use these terrorist attack. For.

12:36

The same. Purpose: Thank you so

12:38

much Evgeny A caramel sauce and we

12:40

wish you and your family well. Thank.

12:43

You very much Christian. Coming.

12:46

Up next to my exit interview with

12:48

a state. Farm and Stauffer who

12:50

quit over the crisis in Gaza.

12:53

Why She believes the Biden Administration

12:55

is helping enable the atrocities in

12:57

her words and then the relative

12:59

and of Israeli. Hostages tells me

13:01

wife he. Believes in his and Yahoo

13:03

government. Is deliberately

13:06

stalling Ceasefire

13:08

Thoughts: Are

13:13

the City Council Submerge Metaphysics Bar presented

13:15

by Grammarly this week. On the part,

13:17

as soon as we discussed March Madness

13:20

players upsets match ups and brought Fosters

13:22

listener. March Madness Three Sixty Five with

13:24

any Chance Presented by Grammarly where we

13:27

get your projects. Grammarly. As

13:29

a secure a are writing partner the gives your

13:31

team in an instead first drafted a few clicks,

13:33

not a few hours. Companies that use grammarly save

13:35

an average of nineteen days per employee per year.

13:38

Grammarly. Works seamlessly across five hundred

13:40

thousand and apps and websites get

13:42

personalized on brand writing. Help everywhere

13:44

your team works, learn were bitter.

13:46

Writing can do for your company.

13:48

grammarly.com. Grammarly. Easier

13:51

said. Don. Welcome.

13:57

Back to the program. it's another significant.

14:00

Kind of growing descent inside

14:02

the Biden camps. Over his

14:04

handling of the crisis in Gaza,

14:06

State Department's Darfur. And now sea

14:08

lions resigned in protest this week,

14:10

I decided. To go public after

14:13

colleagues convince her to speak out

14:15

on their behalf. Rising. In an

14:17

office for she said that her

14:19

job to advocate. For Human Rights

14:22

was impossible while blank check

14:24

support for Israel quote enables

14:26

atrocities in Gaza. In her

14:28

first television interviews, I asked

14:30

her why now. I

14:33

think as it became clear what

14:35

Us policy was going to be

14:38

as far as enabling them the

14:40

ongoing military operations in Gaza as

14:42

well as they intentionally ease of

14:45

starvation as a weapon am I

14:47

initially hoped to make a difference

14:49

inside the State Department the through

14:51

than their descent cables through internal

14:54

forum I'm speaking the supervisors. And

14:57

then. Eventually became clear that from

14:59

my position inside state there was really

15:01

very little that I could do Know

15:04

is initially just going to resign quietly.

15:06

Ah my just didn't want to be

15:08

part of this government anymore. But as

15:11

I started to let colleagues know. Of

15:14

my intention they said please speak for

15:16

us, please use your voice. You know

15:18

many of these are individuals who feel

15:21

they they cannot resign, all who are

15:23

still doing very important work inside the

15:25

State Department arm. And so I decided

15:27

that I would go ahead and and

15:29

go public. With it

15:32

painful to did you would risks

15:34

did you feel you were taking?

15:36

What consequences for your life. For

15:39

your taught you have a one year old

15:41

child I believe a mortgage. Yes,

15:46

The those are all on concerns

15:48

I do think I'm I'm privileged

15:50

to know I I'd only been

15:52

at the State Department for a

15:54

year. I have an academic background

15:56

on. i had a phd

15:59

in and political science, I had previously

16:01

been in the think-tank sector, whereas I think

16:03

for a lot of my colleagues who have

16:05

spent their whole careers inside government or inside

16:07

the State Department, it

16:10

is much more challenging

16:13

to think about trying to leave, although plenty

16:15

of colleagues have said that it is something

16:17

that they're considering, that they see what the

16:19

U.S. government is doing in

16:22

such direct contravention to the mission that they

16:24

believe they're trying to uphold by working for

16:26

the U.S. Department of State and

16:29

in contravention of American values

16:31

more broadly. You just talked about using

16:33

starvation as a weapon of war. Yes,

16:36

the EU has said that. Yes, the

16:38

UN. Yes, other international organizations, but

16:40

not the United States. Let

16:43

me play this from the

16:45

briefing on Monday by the

16:47

State Department about whether

16:49

the U.S.

16:51

believe, the department that you just left

16:54

believes that that is happening. Take a

16:56

listen. We have not made

16:58

an assessment or drawn the conclusion that

17:00

they are in violation of international humanitarian

17:02

law when it comes to the provision

17:04

of humanitarian assistance in the government. They

17:06

said we do believe there is very

17:08

much more that they can do to

17:10

let humanitarian assistance go in. So

17:13

you can hear the U.S. saying that over and over

17:15

again now, I mean, really for a long time.

17:18

So they're trying to thread a needle and

17:21

they are dropping aid. They

17:24

are complaining and demanding that

17:26

more aid goes in. Tell

17:28

me what you're noticing about

17:31

maybe a shift in the

17:33

public posture of the administration.

17:38

I think it's encouraging that we have started

17:40

to see some degree of a shift, but

17:42

at present it has made almost no difference

17:44

to the lives of people starving

17:47

and being bombed inside Gaza.

17:51

I think to the extent that even

17:53

things like the U.S. being willing to

17:55

abstain at the UN Security Council is

17:58

significant, but then the administration came out

18:00

and immediately said that that was non-binding.

18:03

So in general, I just

18:05

find that the way the administration

18:07

is trying to do this, I think

18:10

they made a political calculation that

18:12

they thought that it made the

18:14

most sense politically to maintain this

18:16

extreme support for Israel, regardless

18:19

of the illegal behaviors that Israel

18:21

engages in. And now very, very

18:23

quickly, I wonder, because you

18:25

are the second to actually resign, can you

18:28

give us a sense from what you know

18:30

inside the State Department of how

18:32

much the support is? People

18:34

are shocked and appalled by what the U.S. government is

18:36

doing. Many people continue to

18:38

do the very important work inside the

18:41

State Department and continue to feel that

18:43

their efforts are making a difference on

18:45

the many, many issues that the State Department is involved

18:47

in. But on

18:50

the other hand, I do know people who

18:52

may be

18:54

considering resigning. And you can

18:56

watch the rest of our conversation online at

18:59

amunpour.com, along with all my other interviews. Up

19:01

next on the show, the relative of an

19:04

Israeli hostage on the frustrating fight

19:06

to reunite his family and

19:08

the drastic measures he took

19:10

to get the government's attention. We're

19:13

not winning. We're not winning at all. So

19:16

this charade should

19:18

stop. Welcome

19:27

back. Famine in Gaza has

19:29

brought civilians to the depths of despair.

19:32

But Israeli families continued their own

19:34

struggle to bring back the 130 remaining hostages. On

19:39

Tuesday, protesters in Tel Aviv

19:41

took to the streets, demanding the return

19:43

of those still held captive, while

19:45

symbolically locking themselves in

19:47

cages. Four of them

19:50

were detained briefly for blocking a public

19:52

road. The hero Shahamur was

19:54

one of them. His cousin

19:56

was murdered and his house was torched

19:58

by Hamas on October 7. His

20:01

uncle, aunt and cousin together with

20:03

her nine-year-old son were taken

20:05

hostage. But while the women and

20:07

children were released late November, Abraham

20:10

is still in Hamas captivity.

20:12

And his nephew, Zahiro, is

20:14

joining me now from Jerusalem. Welcome

20:17

to the program. How are you holding up?

20:20

Not so well. It's almost six

20:22

months now. And

20:25

every day you have cycles of

20:27

despair and hope and hope and

20:29

despair. What is your

20:31

honest, genuine feeling about

20:33

whether you will get your

20:35

uncle back? He was

20:38

alive according to others who've been

20:40

released subsequent, but he was

20:42

injured. Last we heard was

20:45

from, as you said, one of

20:47

the released hostages, who was a L.A.D.

20:50

medical nurse in Soroka Medical Center. And

20:52

she took care of him. Apparently, he

20:54

was taken to Gaza on the backseat

20:56

of a motorcycle, and he fell on

20:58

the way. I remind you, this is

21:00

a 79-year-old man. So

21:03

apparently he fell and he got some superficial scratches

21:05

and wounds. And

21:09

she took care of him. And she said that his

21:11

wounds are getting better. But

21:13

since then, and this was like almost

21:15

three months ago, we know nothing.

21:18

We just know that he's been moved,

21:20

and now he's probably deeper

21:23

inside some tunnel. And

21:26

we know from people that got released,

21:28

we know that the humidity there is

21:31

terrible and that the sanitary conditions are

21:34

nonexistent. And I want

21:36

to ask you about the protests you and

21:38

others are now undergoing

21:41

regularly in Israel against

21:44

the government and its inability to

21:46

bring back more of these hostages,

21:48

including your uncle. So we

21:51

said and we showed you and

21:53

others in cages, symbolic cages,

21:55

on a street in Tel

21:57

Aviv. Why do you think you were

21:59

arrested? and detained? For

22:03

the obvious reason, you know,

22:06

for police force arriving, we

22:08

are not family members or

22:12

we are people disturbing

22:14

the traffic. Yeah,

22:18

we got released real fast last Tuesday.

22:20

We spent like 134

22:25

minutes, symbolically, in

22:27

this prison cell. It's nothing

22:29

compared to what I call it

22:33

going through, of course. So the

22:35

Israeli government has, from the beginning,

22:37

said that it has two objectives, defeating

22:39

Hamas and returning the

22:41

hostages. Do you believe

22:44

that that second objective is

22:46

actually, you

22:48

know, happening? The military

22:51

maneuver going on

22:53

in Gaza is not helping

22:55

the hostages in any way. This

22:57

was, from day one, we

23:01

understood that there can't

23:03

be two prime objectives,

23:06

and they try to convince us that these two objectives will

23:09

go hand in hand, and neither

23:11

of them is

23:14

accomplished. And the Israeli administration is just

23:16

not committed enough, and it's

23:19

busy doing all kinds of political

23:21

games for political

23:24

survival. And the

23:26

hostages are wasting away

23:28

in some rat hole inside Gaza.

23:31

And we don't have time. They don't have time. Every

23:34

day that goes by. You

23:36

told us before we started the

23:38

interview that some hostage

23:40

families are hesitant to

23:43

actually go out and protest. Why

23:45

is that? There is a

23:47

very strong notion of, please

23:50

don't make too much

23:53

noise, otherwise your family

23:55

member, your hostage, could

23:58

be more move to

24:00

a lower place once a

24:03

list will be composed.

24:08

There's a lot of pressure

24:10

coming from the Cabinet ministers

24:14

stating these thoughts, okay,

24:16

be quiet, be quiet,

24:18

play along, come with us

24:20

to the delegations and

24:23

then meet with the UN

24:25

and put pressure on outside

24:27

players, but don't say

24:29

anything to contradict the official

24:32

governmental line. And the

24:35

Israeli Republic is being pumped

24:37

with, together we will win,

24:39

together we will win, and

24:41

we're not winning, not winning at

24:43

all. So this

24:46

charade should stop. We

24:49

need some international intervention because

24:51

the way things are going in

24:54

Israel now, we're jumping

24:58

straight head down to their base.

25:01

And it is really horrible to hear you

25:03

describe that, and we obviously wish you all

25:06

the best. Zihiro Shaham or thank you very

25:08

much for joining us. Thank

25:10

you for hearing my voice. In

25:13

response to that interview, a statement from

25:15

the Israeli government reads in

25:17

part, Destroying Hamas

25:20

and freeing the hostages are not

25:22

mutually exclusive goals. On the contrary,

25:24

these missions complement one another. Israel

25:27

will continue to do what is needed

25:30

to reach all its just war objectives.

25:32

Destroy Hamas, free our hostages and ensure

25:34

that Gaza does not pose a threat

25:37

to Israel and the civilized world in

25:39

the future. And up next,

25:42

why is Elon Musk's satellite internet

25:44

system getting into Russian hands? And

25:46

how does that impact drone warfare

25:48

in Ukraine? A CNN

25:51

investigation when we come back. Welcome

26:03

back to the program. Elon Musk's

26:05

Starlink internet satellite system has

26:07

been crucial to Ukrainian troops

26:10

on the battlefield, especially its

26:12

drone pilots, but now it's being

26:14

used against them by Russian soldiers who

26:16

aren't supposed to have access to it

26:18

in the first place. This

26:21

week's investigation by correspondent Nick

26:23

Peyton-Walsh shows how Russia appears

26:25

to be bypassing US sanctions

26:27

to exploit this vital modern

26:30

warfare technology. Ukraine's

26:34

newest target is something they've long cherished

26:36

themselves. Small

26:38

white rectangular satellite internet

26:40

terminals from Elon Musk's

26:42

Starlink, apparently in Russian

26:44

hands, and hit by

26:46

Ukrainian drones. They're not

26:49

supposed to be there at all, according to

26:51

Musk and US sanctions. Here,

26:56

a Russian soldier explains frontline

26:58

damage to one of their

27:00

Starlink units, connecting attack drones

27:02

and command centres. While

27:07

Russia has officially denied their

27:09

use, their army of crowdfunders

27:11

openly flaunt Starlink purchases in

27:13

third countries. There

27:16

is one key supplier showing off

27:18

store-bought drones and five Starlinks, too.

27:26

The look on their faces does not

27:28

suggest they're too confident in coming home. She

27:36

has posted other images of Starlinks

27:39

and drones bought. Across

27:43

the east and south of the frontline,

27:46

said Russia, has near copied their system

27:48

of attack drones, using

27:50

Starlink's internet signal to control

27:52

dozens of single-use first-person view

27:55

devices to swarm Ukrainian positions.

28:00

An intercepted signal one unit told us

28:02

they had hacked from a Russian drone.

28:05

You can see it maneuvering into a

28:07

Ukrainian target. Near

28:09

the heavily contested village of Robotina, down

28:11

in the bunkers where the drone wars

28:14

are fought, this change is huge and

28:16

has come with an apparent complication for

28:18

the Ukrainians too. Their

28:21

starlink speeds have been getting slower,

28:23

said this commander. I

28:25

am happy by the aim of putting

28:27

what I am being given an offensive

28:29

flag in this state. My

28:34

most so-called information is that

28:37

Russian people are given the time, taking

28:39

the long trip and considering theming

28:42

of the frightening striking, the probations

28:44

are very different. Another

28:47

operator in the same area reported problems

28:49

in the last month. Some Where I

28:51

would say texting The

29:17

Craft Most thinking is one of these things While

29:20

Ukrainian officials went public with their

29:23

concerns six weeks ago, they've since

29:25

gone silent, they're perhaps quietly pressuring

29:27

Musk, who experts think can vet

29:29

who uses terminals, even if that's

29:31

trickier in contested areas. It's

29:34

possible SpaceX can't appoint each

29:36

terminal and they know who

29:38

is who, but the

29:40

problem is to identify extra owner

29:42

of the account. Musk is

29:45

a big child, so it's important

29:48

to talk to him and don't

29:51

offend him, because he

29:53

might do some quick decisions

29:55

that might be not very

29:58

good for everyone. SpaceX

30:00

and Starlink did not respond to requests

30:02

for comment. They said previously they do

30:04

no business with the Russian state or

30:06

military, and if a sanctioned party uses

30:09

Starlink, we investigate the claim and take

30:11

action to deactivate the terminal if confirmed.

30:14

But as Ukraine's other lifelines wobble or

30:17

dry up, space-based

30:19

internet is one they can't afford to

30:21

see slow, lose to the Russians,

30:23

or lose at all. Nick

30:26

Peyton-Walsh, CNN, London. And

30:29

far from the battlefield in Ukraine, a

30:32

different kind of struggle. The fight for

30:34

women's rights and the icon

30:36

at its center. Gloria Steinem, the fiercest

30:39

feminist of them all, turns 90. Welcome

30:51

back to the program. From Russia's war in

30:53

Ukraine to Israel's war against Hamas,

30:55

it is women who often suffer

30:57

the most. According to the United

30:59

Nations, the world is failing, girls

31:01

and women, and the fight for

31:03

equality and justice is far from

31:06

over. That has been Gloria Steinem's

31:08

life's work, the world's most

31:10

famous feminist activist, a trailblazer

31:12

of the women's rights movement.

31:15

Steinem's tireless advocacy and undercover

31:17

journalism reshaped norms and turned

31:19

her into a global

31:22

icon for women. This week,

31:24

fittingly, during Women's History Month,

31:26

Steinem turned 90. And

31:28

from my archive, one of my interviews with

31:31

her almost 10 years ago, right after

31:33

she wrote her memoir. When

31:37

you look back and you write this book,

31:39

which is really instructive and entertaining at the

31:41

same time, we've been

31:43

through several waves of feminism. Where

31:46

are we now? Because some people think the fight

31:49

is over, is it? The

31:51

people who say the fight is over, the same

31:53

people who used to say to me, it's impossible. It's

31:56

against nature. And now their

31:58

current form of obstructionism... is it's

32:00

over. No, no, no, we've just barely

32:02

begun. And obstructionism, you

32:05

choose that word, obviously, with consideration.

32:07

I mean, you still feel that

32:10

the women we are being obstructed.

32:13

Well, you know, we're all born into

32:15

this very patriarchal culture.

32:17

It takes different forms around

32:19

the world. But the

32:21

basis of it is that reproduction

32:24

must be controlled by men, and

32:26

that means controlling women's bodies.

32:28

It may take different forms,

32:31

religious forms, political

32:33

forms, but that is the

32:35

basic impulse. And so, you

32:37

know, it's quite radical to say we

32:39

are seizing control of reproduction, which we

32:41

are. And it makes perfect sense because

32:43

these are our bodies. And

32:45

this was also the form of governance

32:48

for millennia before

32:50

patriarchy came along. Again,

32:52

going back to India, you were there,

32:55

you observed the female prime

32:57

minister, Indira Gandhi, being the

32:59

first, controversially, to enact

33:01

a family planning program.

33:04

But you also know that there is

33:06

infanticide there, and obviously girls are the

33:08

ones who get aborted. We

33:13

talked also to an activist

33:15

recently about the continuing abomination

33:17

of female genital mutilation. And she

33:19

put it in these terms

33:21

that you're talking about. Just listen and we'll talk about

33:23

it. I

33:27

understand one of the priorities for you was to

33:29

have a cabinet that was gendered balanced.

33:36

Because it's 2015. All

33:43

right, that's the right soundbite at the wrong moment, but let's

33:45

just talk about that then. We'll get back to that. That

33:47

was good news. That was really good

33:49

news, exactly. That's the recent prime minister

33:52

of Canada saying it's 2015 and

33:54

we need gender balance in

33:57

the cabinet. That

34:00

must have sounded great to you, right? I mean, that went

34:02

viral. Yes, absolutely. It makes perfect

34:04

sense. And we have made progress in a

34:06

lot of ways, but we

34:08

still discuss, say, foreign policy

34:11

and terrorism and all the disasters

34:14

that you report as

34:16

if it was separate from

34:18

the women's movement. The women's movement is

34:20

a silo over here. Foreign policy

34:22

is a silo over there. And never the

34:25

twain shall meet. How do you think the

34:27

twain meets? The twain meets because

34:29

the single biggest predictor of

34:31

violence in a culture has always

34:34

been the polarization of

34:36

roles, hypermasculinity on one

34:38

side, hyperfemininity in women

34:41

and reproduction control on the other side. And

34:44

if we simply looked

34:47

at that as an indicator, we would

34:49

not, for instance, have supported, say,

34:51

the Mujahideen in Afghanistan who

34:53

turned into the Taliban because

34:56

they were way more hostile

34:59

and way more violent towards

35:01

females than the regime we

35:03

helped them overthrow. Let

35:05

me play that other sound bite because it goes to the heart

35:08

of what we're talking about. This is

35:10

about female genital mutilation. There's

35:13

a reason why our

35:15

genitals were specifically targeted. Women

35:19

are not supposed to have sexual pleasure.

35:21

They're not supposed to experiment with their

35:23

sexuality. So we need to

35:25

ask ourselves why is there

35:27

such a focus on women's sexuality?

35:29

Yes. I

35:32

mean, it's taking away women's

35:34

sexual will, women's sexual pleasure,

35:36

and turning them into nothing but

35:39

a controlled means of reproduction.

35:43

That's an extreme form of it. But

35:45

it is in gradated forms in

35:47

many cultures. reproductive

36:00

rights movement since Roe versus

36:02

Wade was overturned. Now, when

36:05

we come back, a Palestinian poet's

36:07

terrifying escape from the wreckage of

36:09

Gaza and his moving tribute to

36:12

the home who left behind. Welcome

36:23

back. After seeing his family's

36:26

home destroyed in Gaza and fleeing

36:28

one bombing after another, Palestinian

36:31

poet Mossab Abu Tohar eventually

36:33

found refuge in Egypt with his

36:36

wife and three children. He

36:38

was only allowed to cross the border on

36:40

account of his youngest son being born in

36:42

America. Mossab has been writing

36:44

about the terrifying journey they made. As

36:47

part of our longer conversation airing next

36:49

week, I asked Mossab to read a

36:51

poem inspired by his life in Gaza

36:54

and the home he and his

36:56

family left behind. What

36:59

is home? It is

37:01

the shade of trees on my way to

37:03

school before they were uprooted. It

37:05

is my grandparents black and white within

37:08

photo before the walls crumble. It

37:11

is my uncle's prayer rug where dozens

37:13

of ants slept on wintery nights before

37:15

it was looted and put in a

37:17

museum. It is

37:20

the oven my mother used to bake bread

37:22

and roast chicken before a bomb

37:24

reduced our house to ashes. It

37:27

is the cafe where I watched football

37:29

matches and played. My

37:31

child stops me. Can

37:33

a four-letter word hold all of these?

37:37

All the elements of a home gone by.

37:40

And you can watch that full conversation

37:42

along with all my interviews online at

37:44

amanpour.com. And don't forget

37:47

you can find all our shows online at podcast.com

37:49

and on all other major platforms.

37:53

I'm Cristiana Manpour in London. Thank you for watching and

37:55

see you again next week. Hi,

38:05

this is Andy Katz, host of March Madness

38:07

365, presented by Grammarly. This week

38:10

on the podcast tune-in we discuss March

38:12

Madness players, upsets, matchups, and bracket busters.

38:15

Listen to March Madness 365 with

38:17

Andy Katz, presented by Grammarly, wherever

38:19

you get your podcasts. Grammarly is a

38:21

secure AI writing partner that gives your team an

38:23

instant first draft in a few clicks, not a

38:25

few hours. Grammarly's that use Grammarly save an

38:27

average of 19 days per employee per

38:29

year. Grammarly works seamlessly across 500,000

38:32

apps and websites. Get

38:34

personalized on-brand writing help everywhere your

38:36

team works. Learn what

38:38

better writing can do for your company at

38:41

grammarly.com. Grammarly, easier said,

38:43

done. CNN

38:45

presents the untold story of the Space

38:48

Shuttle Columbia disaster. Columbia, Houston, com check.

38:50

We hear nothing. The CNN original series,

38:52

Space Shuttle Columbia the final flight, premieres

38:54

Sunday, April 7th at 9 on CNN.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features