Podchaser Logo
Home
‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

Released Friday, 9th February 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

‘An Elderly Man with Poor Memory’: Biden’s Age Old Problem

Friday, 9th February 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This is the BBC. The

0:30

story of Hollywood's greatest leading man, Cary

0:33

Grant. Unbox BritBox and escape to the

0:35

best of British TV. Stream

0:38

with a free trial at britbox.com. Ryan

0:41

Reynolds, hear from It Mobile! I'm proud to offer

0:43

premium wireless for just fifteen dollars a month.

0:45

And I'm proud that we have thousands of five

0:47

star reviews from customers like Dan De in

0:49

New York who writes i am satisfied customer how

0:51

can this only be fifteen bucks? He wrote it

0:54

in all caps. I need you to feel like

0:56

he feels it. I hope I do that just

0:58

as yeah. And I hope that you try

1:00

Mint to at Mint mobile.com. Slash switch from

1:02

payment of forty five dollars for three months

1:04

required new subscribers. Only thing you for twelve

1:06

months to like in additional taxes. Even restrictions

1:09

apply. The Mint Mobile. Dot Com. Being

1:30

Elderly Man with a Poor Memory. devastating

2:00

for Joe Biden because the decision is

2:03

not to prosecute him because

2:06

of that phrase, because he is

2:08

a well-meaning elderly man with a

2:11

poor memory. That, the

2:13

lawyers say, is how he would come across

2:15

to a jury so there is

2:17

no point in prosecuting him. And

2:19

that, of course, raises in the minds,

2:22

not just of his opponents, but of

2:24

many, many Democrats already shaking about

2:26

whether or not this man should be

2:28

reelected in the autumn and should be

2:31

standing in the autumn. The ramifications of

2:33

all of this, which seem for Joe

2:35

Biden to be pretty gloomy and seem

2:37

for American politics to be pretty

2:40

huge, are coming up in

2:42

this emergency edition of America. America.

2:46

America from BBC News. Let me

2:48

start off with two words. May

2:52

in America. I'm not running for santa here.

2:54

I'm running for president. I did everything right

2:56

and they indicted me. I can chew and

2:58

walk on at the same time. There

3:01

is no indication of aliens

3:03

or extraterrestrial activity. We will fight

3:05

the woke in education. We will fight

3:07

the woke in the businesses. We will

3:10

never ever surrender to the woke mob.

3:12

Nobody should have to go to jail for smoking weed.

3:15

Ryan. Aren't you guys tired

3:17

of having this? So,

3:25

hello and welcome to this emergency edition

3:27

of America's Anthony is on

3:29

the line and will join us in just

3:31

a second. First this

3:33

Sarah Baxter joins us, who is old

3:35

friend of mine used to be the

3:37

Sunday Times's Washington correspondent back

3:39

in the day. Sarah's really nice to talk to

3:41

you. What do you do these days? Hi, Justin.

3:45

Well, these days I'm director of the Marie

3:47

Colvin Center for International Reporting and that's in

3:49

New York. But I obviously keep

3:51

a weather eye on all

3:54

things Washington and political. Right.

3:56

And although you sound English, you are

3:58

as well, aren't you an American? American citizen. I

4:01

am indeed. My mother is from Ohio. Brilliant.

4:03

Okay. Well, that gives

4:06

you plenty of qualifications, both journalistic

4:08

and otherwise, to talk to us

4:10

tonight as it is for me

4:12

here in Britain, because the news

4:14

for Joe Biden, which frankly has

4:16

been pretty grim for

4:18

some time, hasn't it, when it comes

4:21

to what Americans think and what Democrats

4:23

think of his cognitive abilities

4:25

and of his ability to

4:27

stand again for the presidency,

4:29

it's received quite a blow

4:31

in the form of

4:33

a kind of, I mean, it's

4:36

kind of shockingly dismissive,

4:39

almost, this set

4:41

of lines from lawyers about whether or

4:43

not he should be prosecuted. So number

4:45

one, they decide that he shouldn't be

4:47

prosecuted or taking classified documents

4:49

home when he was vice president, when

4:51

he finished being vice president, which on

4:54

the whole, you'd think, oh, hang on

4:56

a second. That's quite good news. But

4:58

my goodness, they are the reasons why

5:00

they decided he shouldn't be

5:02

prosecuted. A pretty grim, aren't they?

5:05

Pretty grim, but they're also almost laughable,

5:07

Justin, when I read what

5:09

their verdict was. I practically choked

5:11

because they so explicit.

5:14

The special counsel, Robert Herr, has

5:16

said that Biden can't be prosecuted

5:18

because if you put him in front of

5:20

a jury, they'll regard him as a sympathetic

5:23

elderly man who with a poor memory, who

5:25

can't remember when his son died, when he

5:27

was a little bit older, as vice president,

5:29

who, you know, is just so dodgy, it

5:32

would be hopeless to put him into court.

5:35

Well, that's all very well, but that's great.

5:37

It means he wouldn't be convicted in a

5:40

court. But does it mean that he's capable

5:42

of being commander in chief and president of

5:44

the most powerful country in the

5:46

world? That's

5:48

the bit that's terrifying now, everybody

5:51

in the Biden White House and

5:53

Democrats are absolutely gassed at this.

5:56

And that particular line about not remembering

5:58

when he was vice president. president and

6:00

when he stopped being vice president. I

6:03

mean, that is really extraordinary, isn't it?

6:06

It's excruciatingly damaging for Joe Biden

6:08

and it's something that's going to

6:11

be used against him time after

6:13

time. Of course, everybody knows that

6:15

he's getting on only recently. He

6:17

couldn't remember. He started talking

6:20

about Helmut Kohl being the leader of Germany

6:22

and Francois Mitterholl being the leader of France.

6:24

Well, that was back in the 80s,

6:26

Mitterholl. And I sat down and I

6:29

said, America's back and

6:31

Mitterholl from France looked

6:33

at me and

6:35

said, you know, how

6:38

long you back for? You

6:44

know, he got him mixed up with Macaw. He

6:46

got Kohl confused with Merkel. But those kinds of

6:49

things can be laughed off as,

6:51

oh, just a bit of misspeaking.

6:53

But when the special counsel from

6:55

the Justice Department, a Republican appointee,

6:57

I should say, but even so,

7:00

says that he can't really remember

7:02

what the time of day is,

7:04

that's very serious indeed. And yet,

7:06

as I said, almost comic in

7:08

its brutality. It's not Anthony or bring

7:10

Anthony in on this. Do we know

7:12

what the White House is making of all of

7:14

this, Anthony? Have they got a kind of defense

7:17

of him or are they trying to change the

7:19

subject as they have done previously when

7:21

his age comes up? Do we

7:23

know what line they're going to take? You

7:25

know, the first thing that Joe Biden said

7:27

today in comments to Democrats who were at

7:30

this retreat in Leesburg, Virginia, which is a

7:32

little outside of Washington, D.C., was that the

7:34

case was closed and that's good news and

7:36

everyone applauded. Now, addressing the

7:39

bigger story out of this, the

7:41

conclusion by the special counsel that

7:44

Joe Biden would be a

7:46

sympathetic defendant on the stand in

7:48

any attempt to prosecute him because

7:50

he's a daughtering old man. It's

7:54

interesting to see in that report itself,

7:56

there was a letter from Biden's counsel,

7:59

Richard S. Sauber trying to

8:01

get the special counsel

8:03

to not include this material in

8:05

the report. He said that we

8:08

do not believe that the report's

8:10

treatment of President Biden's memory is

8:12

accurate or appropriate. He called the

8:14

language highly prejudicial, describing a commonplace

8:17

occurrence that a witness could

8:19

not recall years old events. And those

8:21

those kind of comments that you just

8:23

relayed in this special counsel report have

8:26

no place in the

8:28

special counsel document. So it

8:30

is interesting. They're saying these are hers

8:34

conclusions. This is

8:36

his presentation of why Joe Biden

8:39

may be sympathetic. But that's all there is.

8:41

Although I will add that they did cite

8:44

specific instances of Joe Biden not being able

8:46

to recall things like when his son died

8:48

or when he was vice president as supporting

8:50

evidence for why they included it in the

8:52

report. Do we know much about

8:54

this guy, Robert Herr? I mean, is he a

8:56

Republican? Is he an enemy of Joe Biden? Is

8:59

there any kind of sense that these

9:01

incredibly damaging things that he's saying come

9:04

from some kind of political animus? I

9:06

think that this is exactly what Democrats will be

9:09

now digging into and doing a hell of a

9:11

lot of opposition research into. One

9:13

leading Democrat has said, look, this basically

9:16

amounts to a hit job on Joe

9:18

Biden by somebody really acting on behalf

9:20

of Donald Trump within the Justice

9:22

Department. So, you

9:24

know, this is really I mean, it's

9:27

such a wounding verdict that everybody's looking

9:29

for a way out. And the other

9:31

thing that they're pointing out is that

9:33

all these interviews happened the day after

9:35

the Hamas attacks

9:37

on Israel on October the 7th. And

9:40

that perhaps his mind was on more

9:43

statesmanlike things such as what

9:45

on earth is going on in the Middle

9:47

East. But it's not very comforting to think

9:49

that he was handling a Middle East crisis

9:51

at the same time as not really mumbling

9:54

his way through an interview. It's reminiscent

9:56

of what we saw with Donald Trump and the way

9:58

he was keeping his... classified documents

10:00

after he was president in Crete, in

10:02

a bathroom in Mar-a-Lago. I mean, the

10:05

look is just not good, and those

10:07

photos are good, and those are visual

10:09

evidence that I think people can relate

10:11

to, a box full of classified documents

10:14

about Afghanistan sitting in his garage next

10:16

to exercise equipment. Looks like anybody's garage.

10:18

I think Americans can identify with a

10:20

cluttered garage, but they don't have classified

10:22

documents that they have in their possession.

10:25

I will say Robert Herg, he was

10:27

appointed to be a U.S.

10:29

attorney by Donald Trump in 2017, a

10:33

U.S. attorney for the District of

10:35

Maryland. So he also worked in

10:37

Donald Trump's Justice Department, and he

10:39

resigned from his position as

10:42

a U.S. attorney when Joe Biden

10:44

took office, shortly after Joe Biden

10:46

took office, as is normal for

10:48

political appointees. It is

10:50

typical for them to all resign from their office

10:53

when a new president from a different party comes

10:55

in. So, yes, he's a political appointee by Donald

10:57

Trump, but he was also picked

10:59

by Merrick Garland, Joe Biden's attorney general,

11:01

to do this job, and they wouldn't

11:04

pick, you would think, a partisan hack,

11:06

an enemy of Joe Biden's to fulfill

11:08

this position. Yeah, it's

11:11

an extraordinary situation. I

11:13

think Merrick Garland deciding that this guy was

11:16

going to be OK despite being a Trump

11:19

appointee was a sort of act of

11:21

faith by Democrats that they were being

11:23

super bipartisan, and it's really come back

11:25

to bite them. Now, of course, Donald

11:27

Trump says crazy things all the time

11:30

as well. I mean, he muddled up

11:32

Nikki Haley, his leading opponent

11:34

for the presidential nomination, with Nancy

11:36

Pelosi. I mean, even today, Donald

11:39

Trump was saying nutty things

11:41

about Nancy Pelosi, blaming her

11:43

for being responsible for the

11:45

insurrection. And he used those words at

11:48

the Capitol on January 6th. Information,

11:50

all of the evidence, everything deleted and

11:52

destroyed, all of it, all of it,

11:54

because of lots of things like

11:56

Nikki Haley is in charge of security.

11:59

We offered her 10. 10,000 people, soldiers.

12:03

Donald Trump gets a pass on saying crazy

12:05

things in a way that Joe Biden doesn't.

12:07

It's just so depressing, isn't it, for so

12:10

many Americans. We know from recent polls that

12:12

as many as three quarters, I think the

12:14

last poll I saw, actually

12:16

don't want this matchup to be

12:18

between Biden and Trump, with half

12:21

of all Democrats saying they don't

12:23

want that matchup. As

12:25

you say, Trump tends

12:27

to come out on top in these things

12:29

because he has a vigor, whereas

12:32

Biden plainly doesn't. But the idea

12:34

now that these are two elderly

12:36

men and that they shouldn't be

12:38

in this position, and more importantly,

12:40

that the country shouldn't be in

12:42

this position, I really see it

12:45

taking shape in people's minds. But

12:47

what I don't see, Anthony, is

12:49

what anyone does about it. You

12:52

can have all these discussions, and Americans

12:54

are having these discussions around their kitchen

12:56

tables, and Democrats are having

12:58

these discussions behind closed doors. We

13:01

know all of that, but I

13:03

don't see quite where it leads.

13:06

Right. As long as Joe

13:08

Biden still wants to run for president, Joe

13:10

Biden is going to run for president, run

13:12

for reelection. I think the strategy out of

13:15

the White House could be to say, okay,

13:17

well, at least there's not going to be

13:19

a court case against him or charges filed,

13:21

although those charges wouldn't go to trial until

13:24

after Joe Biden was out of office because

13:26

of that Justice Department standing order

13:28

that presidents can't be prosecuted while in office.

13:30

But they're just going to try to wait

13:33

out the storm, and hopefully

13:35

there won't be any other big

13:37

bombshells that call into question Joe

13:39

Biden's competency, and that by November,

13:41

all of this will blow over.

13:43

I think where we might see

13:46

this contribute to an

13:48

important development in this presidential race

13:50

is it might make a third

13:53

party candidate more interested in jumping

13:55

in the race. The door is

13:57

now wide open for... say,

14:00

a no labels candidate to step forward, no

14:02

labels being that independent organization

14:04

that's searching for a third party,

14:07

independent presidential candidate for someone to

14:09

willingly take on that mantle because

14:11

Donald Trump, in their view, is

14:13

clearly not qualified to return to

14:16

the White House. And

14:18

Joe Biden, there's more and more mounting

14:20

evidence that the oldest

14:22

man ever to serve as president right

14:24

now shouldn't be in office

14:27

well into his mid 80s, given

14:30

all of these developments, all of this evidence that

14:32

we're seeing now. I mean, Sarah, what

14:34

do you think comes of all of this?

14:37

Yeah, third party candidate is really a

14:39

good threat to Joe Biden. It's a

14:42

big deal because people are looking for

14:44

an alternative to the president.

14:46

When it comes to Donald Trump, he's got

14:48

about 40% of the vote

14:50

locked down. His base absolutely love him.

14:52

So he's less vulnerable to defections. On

14:55

the other hand, has anybody heard Robert

14:57

F. Kennedy Jr. speak recently? Because he

14:59

sounds like he's more likely to croak

15:01

than Joe Biden. And he's got really

15:04

weird views on Covid-19. Yet

15:06

at the moment, he's polling relatively strongly

15:09

as a third party candidate and

15:11

wounding Biden because, of course, his

15:13

famous father was Robert F. Kennedy,

15:16

a hero for the Democrats. So

15:18

on the name alone, he's going quite well

15:21

at the moment. What

15:23

the rest of this means for Joe Biden, I

15:25

mean, some people in the Democrats are saying, look,

15:28

we just can't keep going with this and hoping

15:30

that he's of Joe Biden lost till the next

15:32

election and beyond. We've got

15:34

to find somebody else. But then you're back

15:36

to the old problem of, well, who

15:38

do you find? Kamala Harris is

15:40

doing better than she has been

15:42

doing. She's found a few issues

15:45

like abortion that she's

15:47

getting some results on. But nobody

15:50

thinks she can beat Donald Trump in a

15:52

head to head match up for president. And

15:54

nobody wants to tell the first African-American

15:57

and Asian female vice president.

15:59

president to step aside and let

16:02

somebody else take over. And maybe

16:04

they would if they could think

16:06

of that somebody else who would

16:08

do better than Kamala Harris. But

16:10

they can't. So the Democrats are

16:12

absolutely stuck with Joe Biden. It's

16:14

embarrassing. I'd say two

16:16

things to add to that. Number one

16:18

with Robert Kennedy Jr. I mean, he's

16:21

toying now, isn't he, with running as

16:23

the Libertarian Party candidate. And the relevance

16:25

as that is, is that the libertarians

16:28

can get him onto the ballot all

16:30

around the United States. So oddball as

16:32

he may be, Sarah, it

16:34

is possible that he does mount a

16:37

real challenge in quite a few places

16:40

and a challenge frankly to both

16:42

candidates, one would assume because it'll

16:44

take people off them both, but just add a kind

16:46

of a sense

16:48

of unknowability to the race,

16:50

which is already pretty unknowable

16:52

and volatile, which I think

16:55

might persuade the Biden people

16:58

to go to him and to say, for goodness sake,

17:00

get out. When I say the Biden people, and this

17:02

is the second point, it's Dr.

17:04

Joe, isn't it? She styles herself. It's

17:06

his wife, and possibly one or two

17:09

other close family members. But you assume

17:11

that if something is going to persuade

17:13

him to go, as Anthony

17:16

was saying, there's no mechanism. There's no

17:18

sort of party mechanism to get him

17:20

to go. But there is a family

17:23

mechanism and a

17:25

desire for him not to be

17:27

humiliated and a desire for his

17:29

place in history to be assured.

17:32

And you do wonder whether they might

17:34

act. And as for the timing and

17:36

whether it leads to Kamala Harris, which

17:38

would be, I think everyone accepts probably

17:40

a disaster against Trump. She could not

17:42

win. But actually, is there a way

17:44

of it not being Kamala Harris, but

17:46

also not being the firing of

17:49

Kamala Harris, as it were, which would

17:51

tear the party apart? And I just

17:54

wonder whether in that

17:56

circumstance, you're looking at not

17:58

a contested, prime But it's

18:00

something that happens later

18:02

on in the year, possibly

18:04

during the summer, when the

18:06

Democratic National Committee, the DNC,

18:09

pretty much would have the chance to

18:11

choose someone and would be forced to

18:13

choose someone and would not choose her.

18:15

And I think with

18:17

people's minds so concentrated then on

18:19

the threat of Donald Trump, assuming

18:21

Trump was by then the Republican

18:23

candidate, I just wonder whether all

18:25

the kind of civil war stuff

18:27

within the Democratic Party might be

18:30

put forward for another day. It's

18:32

certainly possible. I

18:35

wrote a while back that only Jill

18:37

Biden could tell Joe Biden to step

18:39

down, that he's done enough, you know,

18:42

thank you for your service, sir, and all

18:44

the rest. It has to come from his

18:46

wife. But the truth is, recently, she's been

18:48

his most ardent defender, and seems to really

18:51

enjoy being in the White House and believes

18:53

in her husband as the only man capable

18:55

to defeat Donald Trump. So I don't think

18:57

necessarily that Jill's going to be on side.

19:00

I don't think that Democrats can say, come

19:02

on, First Lady, do your bit, tell your

19:04

man to stand down. Whether

19:06

anyone's got the nerve to do it right

19:09

at the Democratic Convention this summer, I don't

19:11

know. Obviously, a lot can happen in

19:14

the next six months, including threats to

19:16

Joe Biden's health. So we'll have to

19:18

see. Right. One one report from a

19:20

special counsel I don't think is going to be

19:22

enough to change the dynamic. Even a damning one

19:25

like this is not going to be enough

19:27

to change the dynamic within the Biden family.

19:29

If his poll numbers totally tank and they're

19:32

already not that great, but he's kind of,

19:34

you know, around the margin of error had

19:36

to head against Donald Trump. If he drops

19:38

down precipitously, maybe that would

19:40

nudge him. But it seems like the ship

19:42

has failed for getting Joe Biden to stand

19:45

down and let someone else go in. We've

19:47

already had the South Carolina primary. We're going

19:49

to have a Super Tuesday here in a

19:51

matter of weeks. He's going

19:54

to start amassing the kind of delegates to go

19:56

to the National Convention that will deliver him the

19:59

nomination. know whether other Democrats

20:01

like it or not. Think

20:03

about how hard it is to take the

20:05

keys to the car away from an

20:08

elderly grandparent or a parent. Now think

20:10

about how hard it would be to

20:12

take the keys to the

20:14

country, to the nation away from

20:16

Joe Biden. It

20:19

is a massive task and the

20:21

potential for disruption, the potential for

20:23

ending up with someone who or

20:25

infighting that would lead Donald Trump

20:28

to a stroll into the White

20:30

House is just too great I think in

20:32

the Democrats' calculations at least at this point.

20:36

I think the Democrats are also

20:38

counting on one thing that in

20:40

actual elections they've actually overperformed expectations

20:42

that people are very worried about

20:44

issues like abortion, they're worried about

20:47

MAGA extremism as Joe Biden calls

20:49

it. Don't get too worried, actual

20:52

elections have gone pretty well for the Democrats

20:54

and that's the ultimate test. I think they're

20:57

going to hang on to Joe Biden for

20:59

as long as they possibly can. Is

21:01

anyone actually convinced by that Sarah, by that

21:04

line? Well I think that's

21:06

what they tell themselves in the

21:08

small hours of the morning when

21:10

they're lying awake at night worrying.

21:13

That's their consolation. Okay, talking of which

21:15

Sarah we'll let you go, you've got other things

21:17

to do and other fish

21:19

to fry, it's really nice of you to

21:21

take the trouble very suddenly at very short

21:23

notice to drop everything and take part in

21:26

an emergency America. Nice to talk to you

21:28

Sarah, great to have you on. Right,

21:31

it was good to talk to Sarah,

21:33

we should stress that the White House

21:35

is saying nothing to see here, at

21:37

least not much to see here, that

21:39

this is actually the end of something

21:42

not the beginning, it is the end

21:44

of the case against Joe Biden. Bottom

21:47

line is the special counsel in my

21:49

case decided against moving forward on any

21:51

charges and this matter is

21:54

now closed. in

22:00

the concerns that many Americans have about

22:02

Joe Biden's age and mental capacity. I

22:05

think the one thing that Joe Biden

22:07

and the Democrats have going for them

22:09

is that it is February. It is

22:11

not October. It is not on the

22:14

eve of the election that this is

22:16

coming out. There is time for them

22:18

to rebound and for Joe Biden to

22:20

prove to Americans that he is capable

22:23

of serving another four years

22:25

in office. And I think

22:28

that is the one thing that they

22:30

hope that they are clingy to, that

22:33

come November when Americans head to the

22:35

polls, at the forefront of their mind

22:37

is not going to be some lines

22:39

that a special prosecutor was appointed by

22:41

Donald Trump put in a report where

22:43

he did not charge Joe Biden with

22:45

a crime. It is going to be

22:47

about things like the economy and immigration

22:49

and abortion. And that is

22:52

where this election is going to be decided. But

22:54

as we said time and time again, there is a long

22:56

time to go between now and November.

22:59

And this may not be the

23:01

end of the concerns and the

23:03

evidence coming out of Joe Biden's

23:05

age and capacity. Yeah.

23:07

And the point being, Anthony, that all of

23:09

those things may well be right. There will

23:11

be other issues that people will vote on.

23:13

But they haven't, it seems to me, in

23:15

the White House, found yet a convincing

23:18

way of rebutting

23:20

the argument that Joe Biden is too old

23:23

to carry on. It is that simple argument

23:25

that you hear time and time again, including

23:27

from Democrats and Democrat supporters and people who

23:30

are being asked to support him, but

23:32

it seems would only do so reluctantly.

23:34

And again and again, you see these

23:36

clips, though, where someone throws a question

23:38

at him about his age or his

23:40

mental capacity, and he kind of bats

23:43

it away. And it is slightly

23:46

defensive, in fact, very defensive often,

23:48

instead of kind of going out

23:50

there and saying to the American people,

23:52

look, here is the deal. This guy is old.

23:54

And yes, he forgets things occasionally. He gets people's

23:56

names wrong, but at least he is not crazy,

23:58

as I was hearing. hearing someone suggest his

24:01

hand in the other day, which you can

24:03

sort of see, can't you? You need to

24:05

have a kind of vigorous way of taking

24:07

this argument and turning it on its head.

24:10

And it just seems to me that

24:12

they're in a defensive crouch about it.

24:14

And things like this event will

24:17

damage him really seriously, unless they

24:19

can find a way of fighting

24:21

their way out of it, surely.

24:24

The argument you can't prove, you can't say,

24:26

well, no, actually, Joe Biden isn't that old

24:28

because he is old. And

24:31

Joe Biden can think on his feet when

24:33

clearly there are times when he stumbles over

24:35

his words and seems to not be able

24:37

to think on his feet. And that is

24:40

the real challenge, and there's no obvious

24:42

solution for it. Come

24:56

to your 2023 work recap. This

24:58

year, you've been to 127 sync meetings. You

25:01

spent 56 minutes searching for files

25:03

and almost missed eight deadlines. Yes.

25:08

2024 can and should sound different. With

25:10

monday.com, you can work together easily, collaborate

25:12

and share data, files and updates. So

25:15

all work happens in one place and

25:17

everyone's on the same page. Go to

25:19

monday.com or tap the banner to learn

25:22

more. There's

25:26

something magical about unboxing. When

25:28

you unbox BritBox, you uncover

25:30

a world of British entertainment.

25:32

Stream the UK's most brilliant

25:34

series, including new and upcoming

25:36

seasons of Shetland, Father Brown

25:38

and Death in Paradise. Plus

25:40

new originals like Payback, Irvin

25:42

Welsh's Crime and Archie, the

25:44

story of Hollywood's greatest leading

25:46

man, Cary Grant. Unbox BritBox

25:48

and escape to the best

25:50

of British TV. Stream with

25:52

a free trial at britbox.com

26:00

And while we have been talking

26:02

about Joe Biden, another major story

26:04

has dropped into our lap. And

26:06

that is the transcript of the

26:08

Tucker Carlson Vladimir Putin interview has

26:10

been released. And for people

26:12

who want to know Vladimir Putin's views

26:14

on the history of Russia-Ukraine relations dating

26:17

back to the 12th century

26:19

AD, this is going to be a real treat

26:21

for you. But it is kind of a muddled

26:23

mess just looking through this, isn't it, Justin? Oh,

26:26

my goodness. Oh, my goodness. It

26:28

starts off with, so as I have both

26:30

got the transcript in front of this,

26:32

and it's us, of course, Tucker

26:34

Carlson desperately trying to get a

26:36

question in because this lecture has

26:38

obviously started and there's what appears

26:41

to be quite a testy exchange

26:43

between the two of them, with

26:45

Putin obviously having expectations of the

26:47

seriousness of this interview from his

26:50

perspective and his ability to

26:52

go through all this historical stuff. And Tucker Carlson

26:54

obviously thinking, oh, my goodness, I need to get

26:56

a news line out of this. So

26:58

that tension that often exists between

27:01

interviewer and interviewee, it's good to

27:03

see, also existed during this weird

27:06

interview. And then when they do get down

27:08

to business, Anthony, I don't know how far

27:10

you've got through it. I mean, there are

27:12

various things. I see at one stage in

27:14

a more kind of Western-style approach,

27:16

Tucker says to him, Tucker Carlson says

27:18

to Putin, who blew up Nord Stream,

27:20

in other words, the Nord Stream pipeline

27:23

was blown up by someone and nobody's ever been quite

27:25

sure who. And Vladimir Putin says,

27:27

you for sure. And Tucker Carlson says,

27:29

I was busy that day. Who

27:31

blew up Nord Stream? You

27:34

for sure. I was busy that

27:36

day. Nate, do

27:39

you have... I

27:41

did not blow up Nord Stream. Thank you,

27:44

though. You

27:48

personally may have an alibi, but the

27:50

CIA has no such alibi. I

27:53

didn't blow up Nord Stream. Thank you, Vladimir Putin. I

27:56

see it's just about understanding. the

28:00

joke says you personally may have an

28:02

alibi, but the CIA has no such

28:04

alibi. So in other words, on

28:08

Nord Stream and on a whole lot

28:10

of other things, including more seriously what's

28:12

going on in Ukraine, Putin again and

28:14

again, doesn't he, Anthony, blames the United

28:17

States and sort of suggests that the

28:19

United States is getting involved in Ukraine

28:21

in order to avoid its

28:23

own problems. And you wonder at

28:25

that stage whether this kind of

28:28

interview does begin to impinge on

28:30

and possibly have an impact on

28:32

American politics. He blames the

28:34

CIA for a lot of things. He

28:36

blames the CIA for meddling in Russian

28:39

internal affairs, for helping to overthrow Russian

28:41

friendly governments in Eastern Europe, which is

28:43

all not new things that

28:45

Vladimir Putin is saying. He's been saying that for

28:47

quite some time. But yeah, it is interesting. He

28:49

says, doesn't the United States have

28:51

other things to worry about, about their border security

28:53

and the economy and everything like that? Don't

28:56

you have anything better to do? You

29:00

have issues on the border, issues

29:02

with migration, issues with the national

29:04

debt, more than

29:06

$33 trillion. You have

29:08

nothing better to do, so you should fight

29:10

in Ukraine. And that plays

29:12

into the domestic debate, like you say,

29:14

that we're having here right now in

29:16

the U.S. about what America's priority should

29:19

be. And the conservatives in

29:21

particular who are opposing continuing USAID to

29:23

Ukraine are saying that money should be

29:25

spent elsewhere, that we should be spending

29:27

it on the border security and on

29:30

American jobs and not on a war

29:32

that is on the other side of

29:34

the world. So he touches upon it.

29:36

But the interview really doesn't focus

29:39

on much of anything. I

29:41

mean, Vladimir Putin's not just answering

29:43

in paragraphs, he is answering in

29:45

full on multi-page essays. So I'll

29:47

be curious to see if Tucker

29:49

Carlson can edit this down to

29:51

something that creates sound bites that

29:54

will be useful for his purposes.

29:56

But it is Vladimir Putin holding

29:58

court just by... the best efforts

30:00

of Tucker Carlson to get some real answers

30:03

like would Russia be happy with the territory

30:05

they already control in Ukraine and would go

30:07

to the peace table with that? And

30:10

Vladimir Putin doesn't really answer that. So

30:12

we'll be poring over these words in

30:15

the coming days, hours. At

30:18

the moment, however, the nuggets that are

30:20

in there are really well buried in

30:22

a sea of verbal detritus. I

30:25

tell you what I get from it, though, I

30:28

don't get the threats that at

30:30

one stage the West was getting

30:32

over and over again from Russians

30:35

either suggesting that they were speaking for

30:37

Putin or that they were closely advising

30:39

him. And that was this threat that

30:42

if you do any more in Ukraine,

30:44

it will bring the world into a

30:46

war and we will be forced to

30:48

use nuclear weapons. And occasionally,

30:51

of course, on Russian TV, people saying, yes,

30:53

we should use nuclear weapons, all that kind

30:55

of talk, possibly at the behest of the

30:57

Chinese, has gone quieter

30:59

in recent months. And

31:02

I don't see it being reinvigorated by

31:04

Putin in this interview. He

31:07

seems to be, I mean, the word charm is not quite the

31:09

right one, but he seems to be on

31:11

a mission, if anything, through all that

31:14

verbiage to kind of reach out to

31:16

America. Wouldn't it be better

31:18

to negotiate with Russia, make

31:20

an agreement, already understanding the

31:22

situation that is developing today,

31:25

realizing that Russia will fight for its

31:27

interests to the end, and

31:30

realizing this actually returned to common

31:33

sense, start respecting our country and

31:35

its interests and look for certain

31:37

solutions? It

31:40

seems to me that this

31:42

is much smarter and more

31:44

rational. And interfere with its

31:46

will to carry on backing Ukraine

31:49

rather than threatening people and threatening

31:51

Americans with mass destruction

31:54

and the world with mass destruction, which

31:56

I suppose possibly the calculation is on

31:58

his part that actually. The

32:00

former is likely to work and no matter,

32:02

probably wouldn't if you're looking for things that

32:04

are going to make you clutch the table

32:06

and and worry that were on the edge

32:08

of World War Three or four. Whatever World

32:11

war right now. Ah, did. There is nothing

32:13

in this interview that supports that. Are

32:16

no matter you know and mapping we probably

32:18

will to call him a day on this

32:20

emergency Edition of America. Awesome. That's quite enough

32:22

nice to discuss, and frankly, in the White

32:25

House I think they'll be much more worried

32:27

about Joe Biden suture than they are to

32:29

Nine is at least and over the next

32:31

few days about you. As

32:43

an American politics sunny question that

32:45

has broken in the last few

32:48

hours is a by Joe Biden

32:50

says teacher does that. Mean

32:53

a special edition of America as they

32:56

say, the end of some American news

32:58

broadcast with Anthony him with me and

33:00

with surpass that earlier on on. many

33:02

many thanks to her unseal later sale

33:04

letters been a heck of a week

33:07

at it's only Thursday. America.

33:10

America. From Bbc News. Thanks

33:12

for listening to America! Asked from

33:14

Bbc News You can subscribe to

33:17

this mod cast on the free

33:19

Bbc Sounds, which is now available

33:21

worldwide. There's

33:29

something magical at the has some. Boxing.

33:32

When. You on thought that box you

33:34

uncover a world of was is

33:36

entertainment seen the Uk. Putting

33:39

things into the new. And upcoming

33:41

season is a Shetland how the burn

33:43

and dancing Cardinals class more originals like

33:45

a That said in those is com

33:47

an artsy the story of Hollywood's greatest

33:50

leading man carried last and of flip

33:52

flops and escaped to the best is

33:54

that is T V stream at a

33:57

seats on. That bookstore com. I'm

34:01

touched your employer from the Global Story

34:03

podcasts. And we talking about the

34:05

world's biggest pop star, Taylor Swift

34:08

and and economic powerhouse That could

34:10

she really swing the Us Presidential

34:13

election? It's a matter of furious

34:15

debate in republican circles. Are they

34:17

on to something? The global. Story

34:20

brings he first takes and smart

34:22

perspectives from Bbc journalist. Around the

34:24

wells signed. Us wherever you get to B

34:26

B C Cuckoo's Nest.

Rate

From The Podcast

Americast

The authoritative twice-weekly US news and politics podcast from BBC News, Americast investigates the social and cultural issues that define America today.Is Joe Biden too old to win another go in the White House? What does Donald Trump’s latest criminal charge mean for the Republican campaign? And why have issues such as LGBT rights, global warming and the war effort in Ukraine become so divisive across the US political spectrum? From foreign policy to pop culture, Americast keeps you up to date and in the know about the stories that matter with on-the-ground insights from right across the US.Americast is hosted by trusted journalists including the BBC’s North America editor Sarah Smith, North America correspondent Anthony Zurcher, presenter Justin Webb, and disinformation and social media correspondent, Marianna Spring. Joined by special guests each week such as former chief medical adviser to the president, Dr Anthony Fauci, former FBI director James Comey, CNN anchor and author Jake Tapper, Succession actress J Smith-Cameron, and Suruthi Bala and Hannah Maguire from podcast RedHanded, they look at America through an international lens, trying to make sense of the increasingly polarised political debate.Each week on Americast, Marianna Spring also brings listeners the latest update on BBC Undercover Voters, the award-winning investigation into the content that is recommended to US voters on social media. Marianna has created undercover voters – multiple social media accounts belonging to different characters who sit across the US political divide. By tracking the content that is pushed at each of them, this investigation will cover a turbulent time for US politics with speculation over a Trump bid for the presidency and Biden facing domestic and international challenges.GET IN TOUCH:• Join our online community: https://discord.gg/qSrxqNcmRB• Send us a message or voice note via WhatsApp to +44 330 123 9480• Email [email protected]• Or use #AmericastFind out more about our award-winning "undercover voters" here: bbc.in/3lFddSF.

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features