Podchaser Logo
Home
ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

Released Saturday, 18th March 2023
 1 person rated this episode
ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

ICC issues war crime arrest warrant for Putin

Saturday, 18th March 2023
 1 person rated this episode
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

ADT

0:00

is elevating your home security

0:02

by offering Google Nest devices. Nest

0:04

doorbells and indoor outdoor nest cams

0:06

can now be installed and integrated as part

0:09

of your ADT smart home security system.

0:11

Nest devices have built in intelligence and

0:13

smarter notifications, so your cameras

0:16

can tell the difference between a person, an animal,

0:18

a vehicle, or with Nestorbelle, even

0:20

a package. Now 360 can get trusted

0:23

security from ADT with the helpfulness

0:25

of Google Nest cams and doorbells.

0:26

Go to 360 dot com today

0:28

or call one eight hundred ASAP.

0:32

THEY HAVE TAKEN CHILDREN FROM THE COUNTRY THEY

0:35

INVADED, BOSTED ABOUT DOING IT, EVEN

0:37

HELPED TELEVIS CELEBRATIONS SHOWING

0:39

THEIR VICTIMS. Now Russia's president

0:41

and the official who has overseen the forced

0:44

deportation of thousands of kids from

0:46

Ukraine to Russia IN HER CAPACITY

0:48

IS THE ORWELLION TITLED COMMISSIONER FOR

0:50

CHILDREN'S RIGHTS ARE BOTH FACING WAR

0:53

CRIMINAL COURT

0:55

which has issued warrants

0:57

for their arrest.

0:59

So

1:00

is the message today that nobody is

1:02

above the law? I think the message

1:04

must be the basic principles of humanity

1:06

bind everybody, and nobody

1:08

should feel they have a free pass.

1:09

AND AS 360 KONG,

1:12

THE ICC'S CHIEF PROSECUTOR. WE SPOKE

1:14

TO HIM AT THE START OF THIS ENVASION WHEN

1:16

HE WAS IN UKRAIN AND HAVE REPORTED extensively

1:19

throughout the invasion on Russia's war on

1:21

the Ukrainian people and identity. Tonight,

1:23

an exclusive conversation with him on

1:25

his history making day along

1:27

with coverage as only CNN can of

1:30

the impact of it. First though, very

1:32

quickly, here's what President Biden just said

1:34

about the ICC's decision to CNN's

1:36

Jeremy

1:37

Diamond. Well, I

1:39

think it's justified in it, but the question

1:41

is not recognized internationally

1:43

by us either.

1:44

But I think it makes a

1:46

very strong point.

1:48

With that, let's go to CNN chief

1:50

international correspondent, Clarissa Ward, who

1:52

got the exclusive interview.

1:53

She joins us from the Hague,

1:55

a Clarissa, an historic interview

1:58

for you. Historic

2:02

interview for us and a historic

2:05

day for the International Criminal

2:07

Court, the ICC, when we sat

2:09

down and had an extensive conversation

2:12

with the chief prosecutor, 360

2:14

Khan, who said this is the first

2:17

time that the sitting head of

2:19

state of a permanent member

2:21

of the United Nations Security Council

2:24

has been issued with an arrest sworn

2:26

by the ICC, and it's all the more

2:28

significant. Because this isn't

2:30

happening years after the war

2:33

in Ukraine finished, John. This

2:35

is happening months after

2:37

it started. And what Han is

2:39

hoping is that this will really start to set

2:42

a new precedent TO SHOW THAT

2:44

THE 360 OF JUSTICE CAN TURN

2:46

QUICKLY. TAKE A LOOK. Reporter: THIS

2:50

FEELS LIKE A HISTORIC MOMENT. Well,

2:53

think it is a very important moment

2:55

as the President said that these

2:57

warrants have been issued and it shows that

3:00

individuals, whatever their position, however

3:03

high, don't have a free

3:05

pass and that the law binds

3:07

us to some basic principles.

3:08

So I think it is 360 for

3:10

that reason and many others.

3:11

What

3:11

is the next step now?

3:14

What happens next? Well, the next

3:16

step is that these worms will be

3:19

have to be circulated, and

3:22

states will have to consider

3:25

whether they can enforce those warrants. But

3:28

also we continue our investigations. There's many

3:30

other crimes in Ukraine that we're looking

3:32

at, and we also have some other options if

3:35

the warrants are not complied with. Regarding

3:37

applications for confirmation hearing in

3:39

absence in

3:40

the future. Do you believe it's

3:42

possible that one day

3:44

360 will see president Vladimir

3:46

Putin in the dark? I

3:48

think those that think is impossible fail

3:52

to understand history 360 the

3:55

major Nazi war criminals, Milosevic,

3:57

Credich, Miladich, former President Charles

3:59

Taylor, John Kebanda from

4:01

Rwanda, he's in 360, all of them were

4:04

360 powerful individuals and

4:07

yet they found themselves in courtrooms whose

4:09

conduct was being adjudicated over

4:11

by independent judges. And that

4:13

also gives cause for hope that

4:15

the law can,

4:17

however difficult it may

4:19

be, the law can be supreme

4:22

So is

4:22

the message today that nobody is

4:24

above the law? I think the message

4:27

must be that basic principles of humanity

4:29

bind everybody. And nobody

4:31

should feel they have a free pass. Nobody should

4:34

feel they can act with abandon. And

4:36

definitely 360 should

4:39

feel that they can act and

4:42

commit genocide or crimes against 360

4:44

war crimes within 360. Because

4:46

we have an international criminal court. We also

4:49

have basic norms of 360

4:51

international law. And there's

4:53

many different fora around the world. Which

4:55

is reducing the

4:58

scope and the room for

5:00

impunity and fewer and fewer

5:02

safe havens So I think that's an important

5:04

lesson that we need to render

5:06

effective. It feels

5:08

significant that we're talking about

5:10

this in terms

5:12

of months and not years.

5:15

Often, the feeling is that international

5:18

law particularly is a sort of slow

5:20

moving beast. Was

5:23

that very intentional for you to try

5:25

to start these

5:28

things these investigations moving

5:30

as quickly as possible with Ukraine? Absolutely.

5:32

Not not because it's Ukraine. I've been on

5:34

the defense. I've been representing victims

5:38

for 360 years. I've been embarrassed her. And

5:40

international law has

5:42

been effective in some cases, in many

5:44

cases. But I think the ICC has

5:48

been pedestrian in some respects

5:50

and we need to accelerate. And think that's

5:52

very important for us. If we feel that the law

5:55

is for us, as prosecutors,

5:57

as judges, as Defense

6:00

Council or victims lawyers. And we don't

6:02

feel the weight of responsibility that

6:04

there are people in refugee camps or crossing

6:07

borders with plastic bags with children in

6:09

arms and grandparents

6:11

and they're fleeing with fear.

6:14

We're not fulfilling our responsibilities. Under

6:16

the law, but also as members

6:19

of humanity as well as we should.

6:22

And this is about justice

6:23

for victims, not about

6:25

360 it takes. Absolutely. 360 must

6:27

be. The law must be about and particularly

6:29

criminal law must be about victims

6:31

and survivors in humanity.

6:34

Such an important discussion, such an important

6:36

moment, Clarissa, what has the reaction

6:39

been, though, from the Kremlin to these charges?

6:44

Well,

6:44

perhaps unsurprisingly, John,

6:47

it has not been positive. We

6:49

have heard from 360 Pesc off who, of course,

6:51

is president Putin's spokesperson. He

6:54

has said 360 that the warrants

6:56

are outrageous and unacceptable.

6:58

We also heard from Maria Zajara. WHO'S

7:01

THE SPOKE PERSON FOR THE FAREND

7:03

360 WHO SAID THAT THEY HAVE NO

7:05

MEANING BECAUSE RUSSIA IS NOT ACTUALLY

7:09

you know, is not a signature of the

7:12

ICC's Rome statute, and

7:14

therefore, is does not fall under its jurisdiction.

7:17

And we heard FROM

7:19

THE WOMAN HERSELF, THE HIGH

7:21

COMMISSIONER FOR CHILDREN OF RUSSIA 360

7:24

LOVOO VILLA WHO HAD A SORT OF

7:26

castic response saying it's great that the

7:28

international community appreciates

7:31

our work. So, fairly sardonic,

7:34

but I think beneath that, one

7:36

can be sure that there is an understanding

7:39

that at the very least, this is an

7:41

irritant that certainly will have

7:43

some concrete impact. Whether

7:46

or not we see president Putin in the dock,

7:48

it's a significant day,

7:49

John. You know, in theory or on

7:51

paper, it limits where

7:54

Putin can go around the

7:56

world. Explain that.

8:00

So 360, there are a hundred and

8:02

twenty three nation states

8:06

that do participate with the ICC

8:08

and the Rome Statute. Shoe. Right? And that's

8:10

about two thirds of the country in the world.

8:12

Some very big ones do not, not just

8:14

Russia, by the way, China 360, and,

8:17

of course, the US. So can president

8:19

Putin still go to the g twenty in India

8:21

that's upcoming? Yes, he can. Could he still

8:23

potentially go to the,

8:25

you know, night United Nations General Assembly

8:28

in New York City. Potentially, yes,

8:31

he could. And also it's important to

8:33

underscore that even for those countries

8:35

that are signatures, that doesn't

8:37

mean necessarily that they would have

8:39

to enact those warrants. We saw this

8:41

back in two thousand seventeen with South

8:44

Africa when, you

8:46

know, the 360 dictator, Omar Ghashir,

8:49

visited and there had been an expectation or

8:51

hope that potentially he would be arrested.

8:53

That did not happen. They cited the fact that

8:55

he was ahead of state and they said that South Africa

8:57

has its own laws retaining to

9:00

heads of state having diplomatic immunity.

9:03

But make no bones about

9:05

it, John. The reality is that president

9:07

Putin's world IS SHRINKING.

9:09

JUST SO PEOPLE KNOW ON THIS MAP, THE 360 IN

9:11

RED THERE ARE THE COUNTRIES THAT HAVE

9:13

SIGNED ON, THE COUNTRIES NOT IN RED, HAVENT

9:16

THAT DOESN'T CLUE, INDIA. CHINA.

9:18

THE, YOU KNOW, RUSSIA,

9:20

THE UNITED STATES AND VERY BIG COUNTRY IS

9:22

NOT PART OF IT.

9:23

Reporter:

9:23

CLARISSA, IN AN ADDRESS LAST NIGHT, THE U. 360. PRESIDENT

9:26

ZOLINSKI 360, QUOTE, The day will

9:28

come when all the perpetrators of war

9:30

crimes against 360 will be brought to

9:32

justice in the halls of the International

9:34

Criminal Court and National Court.

9:36

So HOW IS THIS DECISION?

9:38

HOW OF THESE CHARGES BEEN RECEIVED TODAY

9:40

IN UUERAINE? WELL,

9:44

WITH GREAT POSITIVITY 360, Ukraine

9:47

is also not part not

9:49

one of the senators of the ICC. And

9:51

yet, they have opened up their country and

9:54

said that they give them full jurisdiction to

9:56

their territory because they understand the importance

9:59

of having some of these crimes

10:01

paid attention to. Now the 360 of staff of the

10:04

presidency said, look, this is an important first

10:06

step, but it's just a first step

10:08

360. A lot more needs to happen. This

10:11

isn't just one single war

10:13

crime that's being investigated, and that's something

10:15

that's also important to emphasize, John.

10:18

Is that, you know, the ICC is

10:20

looking into multiple allegations

10:23

and has multiple investigations going

10:25

on.

10:25

This is just the first step,

10:27

John. Yeah. We'll talk more about that next

10:30

hour. Clarissa Ward, thank you so much because

10:32

we're gonna see much more of your interview

10:34

coming up. This warrant, as we just mentioned,

10:36

and as you can see, on the map again,

10:38

in theory, narrows Vladimir

10:41

Putin's world by roughly two thirds, which

10:43

might not matter to him as long as the 360

10:45

he needs either aren't obliged by 360 to

10:47

arrest him or they come to Moscow

10:50

instead. China falls into both 360.

10:52

PRESIDENT XI VISITS MOSCO NEXT

10:55

360. SO THERE'S THAT AND PLAY MORE TO

10:57

TALK ABOUT TONIGHT WITH 360 ZAKARIA, HOST

10:59

OF FARED ZAKARIA, GPS.

11:02

So for 360, we just heard what prosecutor Khan

11:05

had to say that no one gets a free pass.

11:06

What's your response to these charges? Well,

11:09

it's a very good idea, but 360

11:12

need to understand it's not gonna make

11:14

any difference legally anytime soon.

11:17

Russia is not a signatory to the treaty

11:19

of Rome, which is ablishes the International

11:21

Criminal Court. There

11:23

is no possibility that the

11:25

Russians will ever submit to this. Some

11:27

people say, well, it means Putin won't be able to

11:29

travel abroad. That's highly unlikely

11:33

the president of Sudan. Omar 360

11:35

has has been traveling lots of

11:37

places ever since he was indicted.

11:39

He was indicted for the crimes in

11:41

Daphor. So It's

11:44

On the other hand, it it's

11:46

a moral signal. And it's a signal

11:48

that the west is taking this

11:50

seriously that a lot of Democratic

11:53

countries and many non Democratic countries

11:55

who were signatories to the court are taking

11:57

this seriously. So it adds a certain

12:00

kind of moral pressure but I

12:02

think people need to understand the international

12:04

court is not like a regular court.

12:05

So the United States, what

12:08

do you think the US connection will

12:10

be to this? How much will the US

12:12

help here?

12:12

It's a very good question, John,

12:15

because the US is not

12:17

a signatory to the court. And

12:19

generally has been wary of getting

12:22

to involve. So in this particular case,

12:24

the state department wanted to provide

12:27

American intelligence. To the court

12:29

to help them. The Pentagon

12:31

did not because the Pentagon worries

12:33

that if an American soldier

12:36

you know, sitting behind in some military action.

12:39

What if that soldier or or that battalion

12:41

or that, you know, is is brought

12:44

to the court for alleged crimes?

12:46

So the Pentagon has always been much

12:48

more wary. I think the administration

12:51

on the whole has decided correctly

12:53

that this is a case where the moral

12:56

pressure it puts on Putin and

12:58

the moral kind of box it puts him in

13:00

is worth the cost of cooperating.

13:01

It is interesting. There is more nuance

13:04

from a US perspective than you might expect.

13:06

So let's talk about when this is happening.

13:08

This is happening days. Before

13:10

Chinese leader Xi Jinping will meet with

13:13

Vladimir Putin. Does this

13:15

the fact that Putin's been charged with either

13:17

war crimes by the tribunal, will that have any

13:19

impact on these

13:20

meetings? It won't

13:21

have much of an impact, but think it has

13:23

an impact on the optics look, the Chinese

13:25

are trying to make it out as though

13:28

this alliance is solid and firm

13:30

and unyielding There

13:33

is a reality of the public atmospherics

13:36

behind it and the fact that the guy has just been

13:38

indicted by the International Criminal Court

13:41

doesn't help. China is trying to

13:43

present itself as both neutral

13:46

and an ally of Russia at the same time.

13:48

Neutral when it wants to say they're they're in favor

13:51

360. They're they're not the ones they don't want

13:53

to be taking sides on on

13:54

this. But on the other hand, they have this

13:56

alliance. So I think it it complicates

13:59

Mattis for Xi. You know, you brought

14:01

up the number one question that

14:03

we always get with the International Criminal Court, which

14:05

is okay. But how are they going to

14:07

enforce how are they gonna what difference

14:09

is it going to make to Vladimir Putin's

14:12

life? Do you think there would be a country

14:14

he won't be able to go to some conference

14:16

he wouldn't be able attend because

14:18

of this?

14:20

There are probably countries he couldn't go

14:22

to, but he isn't gonna go to them

14:24

360 times soon. He's not gonna come to the United

14:26

States anytime soon. You know, I think in in

14:28

a in a sense, it punctuates

14:31

the reality that the

14:33

world really has been divided. And

14:36

that Russia is really isolated. I don't

14:38

think you're going to see Putin, you

14:40

know, at conferences in Western

14:43

European countries or European Union

14:45

cap apitals anymore. I don't think he's gonna

14:47

come to the United States. I

14:49

I think that was probably moving in with

14:51

things were moving in that direction 360, but this

14:53

kind of puts a puts a mark on it. But

14:56

is it possible that he could go to India?

14:58

Yes. If he could go go to China

15:00

for sure. It

15:01

may be that it draws moral lines

15:03

360 if there aren't

15:04

actually physical barriers to

15:06

him in the future. Free, great to see you. Thanks

15:08

so much. Pleasure.

15:10

And a quick reminder to stay tuned. We're gonna have

15:12

much more on the this at the top of the next

15:14

hour, more from Clarissa Ward's exclusive interview

15:17

with 360 con Also, closer look at

15:19

the Kremlin official who runs this child

15:21

abduction program and a conversation

15:24

with the Yale researcher whose team documented

15:26

it all. That and more in a special

15:28

hour of three sixty coming up tonight at

15:30

nine o'clock 360. Next up, though,

15:33

a bombshell on the Trump documents case,

15:35

a judge ordering one of the former president's

15:37

attorneys, this guy, to testify,

15:41

taking the incredibly rare step of denying

15:43

him attorney client privilege under the crime

15:45

fraud exemption, all the details on

15:47

that. And later, new reporting on how TikTok

15:50

could have access to your

15:51

data, even if you've never used TikTok.

15:58

This show is sponsored by Better Help.

16:00

The ancient philosopher Aristotle

16:02

once wrote knowing yourself is the beginning

16:05

of all wisdom. On your journey

16:07

of self discovery, better help wants

16:09

you to know they're here for you. Just

16:11

fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched

16:13

with a licensed therapist and switch therapist

16:16

360 time for no additional charge, one

16:18

hundred percent online. Discover

16:20

your potential with better help. Visit

16:22

better help dot com slash AC3

16:25

sixty today to get ten percent off your

16:27

first

16:27

month. That's better help HELP

16:30

dot com slash AC3

16:32

sixty. Let's

16:34

face it. There's no shortage when it comes

16:36

to opinions. But when it comes to curating

16:39

the most important stories of the day,

16:41

CNN five Things is one of a kind.

16:43

I'm cohost, Krista Beau, and if you wanna know

16:45

about the top five news headlines happening at

16:47

any given moment. In under five minutes,

16:49

then look no further. We're bringing you the facts

16:52

fast. To listen, tell your device,

16:54

play the podcast, CNN five. Thanks.

17:04

SO AS PARTING SHOTHS GO, THIS ONE MADE HISTORY.

17:07

JUDGE BEREL HOWL AND HER LAST KNOWN ACT

17:09

360 THE FEDERAL INVESTIGATION OF THE FOMBER PRESIDENT

17:12

issued a really significant ruling.

17:14

She ordered Trump attorney Evan Corcoran

17:17

to provide additional testimony that

17:19

might otherwise have been off limits due to

17:21

attorney client privilege. The source tells

17:23

CNN that in her sealed ruling,

17:25

she said prosecutors have met the threshold

17:28

for the crime fraud exemption to

17:30

it. Exception, I should say, meaning

17:32

that prosecutors were able to show to

17:34

judge Howell's satisfaction, that corporates

17:36

the discussion with the former president might have

17:38

been part of an ongoing or future

17:40

crime. There's also this just

17:42

in the CNN. CNN. John Miller

17:44

has learned that law enforcement agencies in

17:46

New York are preparing how to

17:49

handle a possible indictment of the former

17:51

president next 360. Sources tell

17:53

John the discussions have been about how to

17:55

navigate the potential indictment by a Manhattan

17:57

ground jury and how to handle his surrender,

18:00

fingerprinting, mugshots, and

18:02

arraignment. Prospective now

18:04

from CNN's Caitlin Collins, who will break the

18:06

federal 360. Also CNN political analyst

18:08

and York Times 360 political correspondent Maggie

18:10

Abramsman, former Republican congressman

18:12

in January sixth committee member, Adam Kinzinger,

18:15

he's currently a CNN 360 political commentator

18:17

and 360 Harding, CNN's senior legal analyst

18:19

and former federal prosecutor.

18:22

SO KAYLEN, THIS IS YOUR REPORTING. WHAT WAR

18:24

ARE YOU LEARNING ABOUT THE CONVERSATIONS

18:27

THAT PROSECUTORS

18:29

wanna ask about. Well, they wanna be able to

18:31

work around attorney client privilege. They've spoken

18:33

to Trump's attorney Evan Cochrane before,

18:35

but essentially why they went to this judge

18:37

and made the case for this exception

18:39

here was they wanted to be able to ask him questions

18:42

and not have him be able to constantly cite

18:44

attorney client privilege, which was what he did when he

18:46

testified. The first time as Maggie

18:48

knows. And so they kind of embracing for

18:50

this decision to come down from the judge today,

18:53

and the judge notified them essentially

18:55

via this order saying that 360 does

18:57

believe that investigators have met the threshold

19:00

for this fraud fraud crime exception,

19:02

which means essentially prosecutors can

19:04

work around attorney clamp privates PRIVILEGE

19:06

IF THEY BELIEVE THAT THAT ATTORNEY HAS USED

19:08

THEIR LEGAL ADVICE OR LEGAL SERVICES IN FURTHERANCE

19:11

OF A CRIME FOR THEIR CLIME FOR THEIR

19:12

CLIME. IN THIS CASE, OBVIOUSLY TRUMP

19:14

So questions about what

19:16

specifically and are there limits?

19:18

There could be limits. We don't really know the full scope

19:20

of this. They haven't gotten the full order. They likely

19:23

will get it. That Trump's team, Evan Crocker,

19:25

and and his legal team himself, because 360, he's

19:27

hired his own attorney here. They'll likely get

19:29

that next week. We may see them respond

19:31

before then But 360, you know,

19:34

one of the assumptions would be they wanna talk about his

19:36

conversations he had with Trump about these

19:38

documents because he's been involved in this since

19:40

last May when this was all going

19:42

down with the negotiations with the Justice

19:44

Department. This is still really significant

19:47

though. They don't actually know how this

19:49

is going to end up? Ellie

19:51

Honey, counselor. To

19:53

Pierce, 360, client privilege,

19:56

Is a thing? How hard

19:58

everything is it? What does a judge

20:00

have to determine to allow these types

20:03

of questions now to be asked?

20:04

Well,

20:05

John, it's both difficult and

20:07

very rare to convince a judge to

20:09

pierce through 360 client privilege.

20:11

I was prosecutor for fourteen years. I only

20:14

ever did this one time successfully

20:16

as it turned out. What you have to do is go to

20:18

a judge and show by a preponderance of

20:20

the evidence, meaning it's more likely than not that

20:22

these conversations between the attorney here,

20:24

Evan Corcoran, and the client, Donald Trump,

20:27

were in furtherance of some

20:29

ongoing crime. And the fact that prosecutors

20:32

were able to make that showing and that a respected

20:34

federal judge agrees with

20:35

that, I think, is a monumental decision and

20:38

it opens the door for prosecutors to get that

20:40

testimony. 360, Maggie, that brings you into

20:42

the conversation 360. You've got reporting on this also.

20:44

Just remind us exactly where Evan Corcoran

20:46

fits in this key timeline And

20:49

also, it's just where he fits in

20:51

Trump world because he's not a name that we've known,

20:53

you know, since twenty fifteen. It's a really good

20:55

question. So Evan Crocker got introduced into

20:57

Trump World by Boris, Stein, who is a

20:59

Trump, you know, sort of universal

21:02

adviser on legal and on politics. And

21:04

this was last spring when this issue

21:07

was starting to heat up. Evan Cochrane was present

21:09

when justice department officials came to Mar

21:11

a Lago on June fifth, and this was

21:13

after this grand jury subpoena had been issued.

21:16

For any outstanding Mar a Lago documents.

21:18

Evan Corcoran is the one who drafted a statement

21:20

for another lawyer, 360 Bob, that

21:22

said it wasn't just, you know, we've given back classified

21:25

documents as as 360 noted, but it was

21:27

a diligent search has been done for everything

21:29

else. And that's a big piece of the Justice Department.

21:31

Zero in on because as he noted, when there

21:33

was an FBI search of Marlago two

21:35

months later, they discovered it wasn't true.

21:37

We also know that one one conversation

21:40

prosecutors are interested In 360 about

21:42

is a call Evan Cochrane

21:44

had with Trump the day that there was

21:46

a subpoena for security camera footage.

21:49

At Mar a Lago. Now 360 don't know whether

21:51

they have reason to wonder about that or it's just

21:53

that they can see a conversation took place because of phone

21:55

records. But Evan Corcoran, you know, is

21:57

is in an unusual position in Trump world.

21:59

He's not especially close to Trump. He

22:01

was, you know, very aggressive for a while and

22:03

suddenly started receding as this

22:06

issue pressed forward. What is so

22:08

unusual here, John, that's really

22:10

important to remember, is these lawyers who are

22:12

under scrutiny themselves ARE STILL

22:15

INVOLVED IN

22:16

DEFENDING THESE CASES THAT

22:18

TRUMP IS VERY INVESTION. Reporter: IT

22:20

IS AN OLD. OLD THING. Alright,

22:22

congressman. Often for the last several

22:24

years when something like this happens, people say,

22:27

Well, how will Trump's base react?

22:30

To this. I'm not sure that's a relevant

22:32

question anymore. We've been asking so long.

22:34

What I'm curious about, you know,

22:36

there are people running against him now. Or about

22:38

to run against him for president. So

22:40

what goes on in these campaign headquarters

22:43

with these other candidates?

22:44

How did they look at all of these

22:46

things that are going

22:46

on? They look at it,

22:49

John, with absolute fear. Like,

22:51

you know, they look 360, if this

22:53

is the candidate 360. Hopefully, organically,

22:56

this is gonna affect Donald Trump. But

22:58

man, if I go out and attack him, I'm gonna take

23:00

off his base. I'm gonna

23:02

anger them. And so I might just kind

23:04

of do the old What's this case you've

23:07

you're speaking of? I've never heard of it. You know? So

23:09

I think that's one way. Now there is a lane

23:11

for 360, whether it's like a 360 Haley or,

23:13

frankly, Mike Pence has been kind of stepping up

23:15

in this area to put that all together

23:17

and say, look, it's not just abandoning

23:20

Ukraine. It's also this lawless

23:22

issue. And then there's the raw politics

23:24

of saying, do you really think an indicted

23:26

former president can win again? That'll

23:29

probably be the most effective argument

23:31

in a primary. I do think this will rile

23:33

up Trump's base. He's good at being

23:35

a professional victim. But I

23:37

think it may kind of hurt him around the

23:39

edges as people are just kind of exhausted and

23:41

fatigues.

23:41

Ellie Honey, two quick mop up questions.

23:44

On this case. Number one, Evan Cochrane,

23:47

does he have to testify? Or can he take

23:49

the fifth 360? And

23:52

number two, Trump's lawyers are saying, oh, the fact that

23:54

they had to go appears the time attorney client Clifford

23:56

shows they have a weak case. Is that actually

23:58

accurate?

23:58

So

24:00

on number one, yes, Evan Korchren can

24:02

take the fifth here. If he does that, prosecutors

24:04

can then counter move by giving him 360,

24:07

meaning You have to testify, but we're not going

24:09

to use your testimony against you. On the

24:11

second point, I think Trump's lawyers have it exactly

24:13

backwards. I don't think it's a sign of weakness. I think

24:15

it's a sign of strength. You only do this as

24:17

a prosecutor. If you're confident you

24:19

can make this showing and as I said 360

24:22

it's a very rare thing for prosecutors to

24:24

do and they did it successfully here.

24:26

Maggie and Caitlyn here. I want talk to both

24:28

of you now about what could happen

24:30

soon, which is the, you know, Manhattan County District Attorney,

24:32

Alvin Bragg, you know, could get indictments

24:35

for Donald Trump on the 360 Daniels

24:39

matter. What's going

24:41

on inside Trump world? Do they

24:43

appreciate the significance

24:46

of this? Perhaps 360 under indictment within

24:48

days?

24:50

Yes. They do appreciate the significance of

24:52

it. I think that it it crept up on

24:54

them a bit. And despite the fact that this has been

24:56

being telegraphed, for such a long time that

24:58

this might happen. From their perspective, Trump

25:01

has been under investigation for a number

25:03

of years, and it didn't materialize into anything.

25:05

Didn't materialize primarily because he was a sitting

25:07

president, but put that aside he wasn't gonna get indicted,

25:09

but put that aside. They are prepared for

25:12

it. It's not clear to me how prepared they are on the legal

25:14

front. I think that'll become clear us in the coming days.

25:16

If an indictment comes out, they are they are very much

25:18

preparing on political front. And they are preparing

25:20

to suggest that this is of

25:22

the cases, the weakest of them. I want

25:25

to note that when people keep calling this a weak case,

25:27

they don't know what the evidence is. We don't either

25:29

It is a more trivial case, I think, is

25:31

the argument that people are making. By comparison

25:34

to other investigations Trump is facing, the

25:36

argument that folks prosecuting what make is the

25:38

law is the law. And so the Trump folks are are

25:40

planning to paint this as part of broader

25:42

conspiracy by Democrats. They

25:44

have often made a case with that evidence, but suggesting

25:46

this is about helping Joe Biden, and I think you're gonna

25:48

start 360 that immediately.

25:49

Yeah. And Trump has been watching closely

25:51

as people 360 one of them have

25:53

talked about how they don't believe it's a slam dunk

25:55

for prosecutors and that it actually will be QUITE

25:57

A DIFFICULT CASE. AND YOU HEARD LEGAL EXPERTS

25:59

SAY THEY KIND OF SURPRISED IF THEY

26:02

DO MOVE FORWARD WITH THE INDICTMENT WHICH WE ARE ALL PRETTY MUCH

26:04

EXPECTING AT THIS POINT. THAT THEY ARE SURPRISED THAT

26:06

THEY WOULD TAKE THAT STEP BECAUSE OF THE RISKS

26:08

OF WHAT HAPPENS. IF

26:10

THEY ARE NOT SUCCESSFUL, IF PROSECUTORS DO GO

26:12

THIS FAR and take this unprecedented step

26:14

of indicting of former president.

26:16

Caitlin Collins, Maggie Haberman, Ellie Holding.

26:19

Adam Kinzinger, what a reporting and

26:21

analytical team this fight and I thank you all

26:23

so much.

26:26

Coming up, a new report suggests that the

26:28

already trained relationship between the US

26:30

government and the Chinese company that owns TikTok

26:32

may be getting a lot more tense. We'll explain

26:35

why and whether this could lead to the end

26:37

of TikTok in the United States.

26:39

Also a new report on how TikTok may

26:41

have your data 360 if you never

26:43

use the app. That's next. The

26:46

New York Times and Forbes 360 that the

26:48

justice department is now investigating the Chinese

26:51

company that owns TikTok after

26:53

allegations that it was being used to spy

26:55

on US citizens, including journalists

26:57

to cover the tech industry. If true is

26:59

another major development and an already tense

27:01

standoff after the Biden administration this week

27:04

threatened to ban the popular social media

27:06

app in the US due to security and privacy

27:08

issues already. The app is banned on

27:10

government devices in the US, Europe,

27:12

and dozens of US states. There's

27:15

also a new report tonight that TikTok may

27:17

have access to your data. Even

27:19

if you've never used the app, we're gonna have much more

27:21

on that in a moment. First of all, let's go to see 360 a

27:23

tech

27:24

report, Brian Fung, on the justice department

27:26

reports. Brian, what more can you tell us about that?

27:28

Yeah, John, this all goes back to a spying

27:31

incident that we learned about in December

27:33

when Forbes broke the news that a

27:36

number of It's a

27:38

number of journalists had been spied on

27:40

by ByteDance 360. ByteDance, of

27:42

course, being the parent company of TikTok.

27:45

And TikTok later confirmed this

27:48

to to news outlets, including

27:50

CNN, saying that ByteDance had fired

27:52

several employees who had been involved

27:55

in improper data access. Now

27:57

it appears through this report from Forbes

28:00

and The New York Times, that the

28:02

Justice Department is investigating to

28:04

see whether or not there may be more to

28:06

this 360. And, you

28:08

know, we're seeing here this this is just adding

28:11

to the concerns that the US government

28:13

has about TikTok and whether

28:15

or not it poses a national security

28:17

threat. To the United States. So

28:19

TikTok's

28:19

parent company did admit to accessing

28:21

the data. What are they saying about this now?

28:24

Yeah, John, mainly they're reiterating

28:26

their earlier position on this. So let me just read

28:28

you a little bit of a statement that we got from ByteDance

28:30

earlier tonight. If they said,

28:32

quote, we have strongly condemned the actions

28:35

of the individual's found to have been involved

28:37

and they are no longer employed at by chance.

28:39

Our internal investigation is still ongoing

28:42

and we will cooperate with any official

28:44

investigations when brought to us. So

28:46

it all looks like, you know, TikTok

28:48

and ByteDance are looking to cooperate with this

28:51

investigation.

28:52

But of course, you know, still too early

28:54

to say where this is all going to lead.

28:56

How soon could US lawmakers get

28:58

a chance to talk to TikTok

29:00

executives about this directly?

29:02

Well, TikTok's CEO

29:04

showed the Choo is expected to testify

29:07

before the House Energy and Commerce Committee next

29:09

Thursday, lawmakers are gonna

29:11

have an opportunity to ask the CEO

29:13

some questions about not just the

29:15

national security concerns, but also about

29:17

how TikTok may be impacting 360

29:20

Mental Health, for instance, which has been a

29:22

major, major issue of discussion

29:24

here in the United States. Brian fung, great to

29:26

see it, and I thank you very much. I'm

29:28

joined now by Ivan 360. He is the CEO

29:30

and founder of the cybersecurity firm for root

29:33

security, which published that new report

29:35

mentioned moment ago that says TikTok could

29:37

have your data 360 if you've

29:39

never used it. 360, even if

29:41

you have deleted the app, it can still

29:44

collect your data. So

29:45

Ivan, what more can you tell us about this report?

29:48

Yes. Thank you. So what we

29:50

found out is that how common

29:52

tools like big sourcing trackers

29:55

that companies like TikTok owned

29:57

by Baidans are across the websites we

29:59

all use on day to day

30:00

basis. So The

30:02

idea that people who have

30:04

never used TikTok

30:05

could be affected by this, hey,

30:07

I have never used TikTok, but they could be

30:09

getting my stuff. Yes. That's

30:11

that's exactly correct. And so what

30:13

we found is first of all, what is pixels? It's like,

30:15

you know, those that giant spike balloon

30:18

that was shot out of the sky couple of weeks ago.

30:20

So pixels are like tiny spy balloons that

30:22

are embedded in two websites 360 all use when

30:24

you book it up, there's a point that'll log in to your

30:26

bank account. And TikTok,

30:29

you may never have had a TikTok

30:31

account or use the app

30:32

yourself, but TikTok can still have your data

30:34

and does collect your data across all the sites

30:36

that we always use on day to day basis. So

30:38

US lawmakers and others have said,

30:41

360 TikTok. If you have it,

30:42

delete it. Is that enough?

30:46

In my personal opinion, I don't think it's

30:49

enough because they

30:51

collect data on the websites

30:53

that we all use, not just

30:55

necessarily from the mobile app that

30:57

is on your phone. So if you delete the 360, you never

31:00

use the ever again,

31:01

you'll still see what you're typing in

31:03

in the form when you're booking an appointment that you're

31:05

signing up for a mortgage. So what can

31:06

you do? I is there anything you can do? Great

31:09

question. So one, you

31:11

know, discussion is having about change of

31:13

ownership. don't think even change of ownership

31:15

can change it. What is really

31:18

making a difference is, you know,

31:20

integrity 360 people who are

31:22

who have access to the data, who have control

31:25

over the data, who can make it make

31:27

decisions.

31:27

So it's I think it's

31:29

about having people who are as

31:31

as as valid and trusted as people who

31:33

work for Pentagon. So a TikTok spokesperson

31:36

told us that I quote, like other platforms,

31:38

the data we receive from advertisers is

31:40

used to improve the effectiveness of our advertising

31:43

services. Our terms instruct

31:45

advertisers not to share certain data

31:47

with us, and we continuously work with our partners

31:49

to avoid inadvertent

31:50

transmission. Of

31:53

such data. So what

31:55

are the chances that these trackers are just

31:58

inadvertent transmission of data? It

32:01

is pretty common. We we saw it

32:03

what it was really surprising is we set

32:05

out to actually establish a baseline. What

32:08

what we do, we help companies ensure that

32:10

the data they collect goes only to the

32:12

intended places and and servers

32:15

and countries. So what we've set

32:17

out and found is that pixels broadly

32:19

operated by many companies, not just TikTok.

32:21

They do collect a lot of information. They

32:24

360 are not aware of. Like 360, addresses,

32:27

home address, dates of birth,

32:29

everything that you can possibly share on

32:31

on the website.

32:32

Hi, mister Rainey. Thanks so

32:34

much for scaring us. This Friday. I 360

32:36

your time. So

32:38

a very unwelcome visitor has

32:40

arrived in Florida, a humongous, smelly,

32:43

and potentially toxic so called

32:46

blob of seaweed that stretches for thousands

32:48

of miles across the Atlantic. The havoc

32:50

it might cause next.

32:56

This week on my podcast, who's

32:58

talking to Chris Wallace. I can't turn

33:00

my back on. The very thing

33:02

that brought me over. I've never do that. My mother told

33:04

360. Keep my deal around before she

33:05

dies. So as long as people wanna see it, she'll be around.

33:08

Because Chris Volalla, you know, I was

33:10

late to the Tyler 360 train.

33:12

I will watch every move will you make from now

33:14

on? Thank you. I appreciate it. Listen

33:17

to who's talking to Chris Wallace on Apple

33:19

Podcasts,

33:20

Spotify, iHeartRadio, or

33:22

your favorite podcast app.

33:27

360 my guest with Ina Garten is back for a

33:29

third 360. On this season of be my

33:32

guest, Ina talks to Stanley Tucci,

33:34

Nora Jones, 360 Copeland, and

33:36

Laura 360, here's Ina to tell you more

33:38

about the show.

33:39

Hi. I'm Anna Garten, the barefoot contesa.

33:42

When friends come to visit, of course, I want them to

33:44

have something delicious to eat. But what's also

33:46

important to me is the conversation. It's the

33:48

glue that binds us together, how we take

33:50

care of one another. I've invited some

33:52

really interesting people to visit me to come

33:54

to my Barn and 360 Hampton. We'll share stories

33:57

that will hopefully and use and inspire

33:59

you and you're invited too. Hope you'll

34:01

join us wherever you get your podcasts.

34:06

As if hurricanes are not enough to worry

34:08

about, Florida is now bracing for

34:10

a seaweed invasion. 360,

34:13

the five thousand mile massive tangled

34:15

vegetation has already begun to arrive on

34:17

the shores there. It is twice as wide

34:19

as the entire continental United States.

34:21

So If you're wondering, what's

34:24

that smell? It could be what we've

34:26

all been calling for days now, the

34:28

blob or the blobs. But

34:31

360 as Lilis Santiago reports the first

34:33

thing she learned, whatever you do, don't call

34:35

this blob like massive blob

34:37

ish stuff floating in the great big

34:39

blobs up to sixty miles long in the ocean.

34:42

Blah.

34:45

It's

34:45

thick in the summertime

34:47

builds up and smells terrible.

34:50

Joe Kaplan captured these images about

34:52

a week ago, massive amounts of

34:54

seaweed washing up at Smithers 360.

34:55

A beach he knows well because he walks

34:58

it several times week. I was shocked

35:00

when I saw it that day where it

35:02

wasn't even spring

35:03

yet. It's still winter,

35:06

which is very unusual.

35:07

And this is about five thousand mile long.

35:10

Professor Shelman, who is one of the leading

35:12

experts on what many have referred to as

35:14

a massive blob of seaweed heading

35:16

to Florida's

35:17

coast. Fair to call it

35:19

a blob? Nope. No.

35:21

We can't call it a blob.

35:23

Well, I would never call that Paul. Okay.

35:24

Why? Because

35:26

he's not. Satellite images,

35:28

he says, show it's not one massive

35:31

body of seaweed, rather a bunch of patchy

35:33

clumps traveling from West Africa. It's

35:36

called the Atlantic sarcasm belt

35:38

and is considered a natural phenomenon.

35:41

Right now, it's twice the width of the

35:43

US, carrying six million tons

35:45

of seaweed and headed to the 360

35:47

Coast.

35:48

In June of this year, it may turn

35:50

into twenty million pounds. So let me

35:52

get this straight. This, what we're seeing

35:54

the last month, is six million tons and

35:56

it's going to get bigger. Yes.

35:57

There's no way to stop that.

35:59

This is nature. It's just like no one can stop

36:02

a hurricane. Should we be worried about that?

36:04

Nope. Reason

36:06

is the 360 is not toxic. But it

36:08

smells pretty bad and it's a nuisance

36:10

for those trying to keep beaches clean to

36:12

attract tourists Just a few years ago,

36:14

here's what it looked like in Mexico. Officials

36:17

in Monroe County, which includes the Florida

36:19

Keys, have set a side more than two hundred

36:21

thousand dollars to clean and remove sarcasm

36:24

from its beaches. 360

36:25

is a mixed blessing. 360

36:28

need it. The seaweed is a nursery

36:31

for all these large 360 fish. The negative

36:33

side to that seaweed is if it comes in the

36:35

concentrations, that are 360 we're

36:37

gonna see. Our fishing grounds are gonna

36:39

be completely covered with it. There's almost no point to

36:41

fishing because we're gonna be spending the entire day

36:43

cleaning weed off our lines.

36:45

And

36:45

is this orgas and belt heads toward Florida.

36:49

Another natural phenomenon is already

36:51

hitting its beaches on the West Coast, red

36:53

tide. It can be toxic, kill

36:55

fish, and cause respiratory issues.

36:58

This year's red tide concerns were enough to cancel

37:00

at least one major event here in Indian

37:02

rocks where one family visiting told

37:04

us as soon as my son and my husband

37:06

and I got out of our car, we all started

37:08

coughing. But for spring breakers like this

37:10

group from Iowa, the concerns of massive

37:13

amounts of seaweed or red tide WERE

37:15

NOT ENOUGH TO CHANGE VACATION PLANS.

37:16

I

37:17

WOULD RATHER IT BE RED TIED THAN RENÉE.

37:20

Reporter: TOURIS, NOTING FRIENDS BACK home.

37:22

They'd be pretty jealous regardless of having a

37:24

little bit of the the red tide symptoms. They'd be

37:26

pretty jealous that we're here and there not. Because

37:28

the pristine beaches of the Sunshine State

37:31

THEY'RE HARD TO RESIST FOR 360,

37:32

DESPITE WHAT MAY BE LOOMING

37:34

OFFSHORE. Reporter: AND LAYLA

37:37

360 JOINS US NOW. SO LAYLA,

37:40

what can you tell us about where this and I'm not

37:42

gonna call it a

37:42

blob. This not blob of

37:45

seaweed is headed now. Where is it going?

37:49

WELL, LISTEN, RIGHT NOW THAT SAME SCIENTISTS

37:51

WHO SAID DON'T CALL THE SUPPLOB, SAID IT

37:53

IS REALLY HARD TO FORCAS. IN FACT, HE

37:55

SAYS they can't forecast this because

37:57

this is something that kind of popped up in

37:59

the tropical Atlantic in in

38:02

twenty eleven. So they still need more research

38:04

to be able to forecast it. But they

38:06

do understand its movement sort

38:08

of how it moves and where it goes. So

38:10

that's why right now, they wanna be able

38:12

forecast it like a hurricane. And if you think about

38:14

this like a hurricane. What we're seeing now? Come on. Let's

38:16

get little closer. Are kind of the outer

38:18

bands of this massive

38:21

not blob, as you

38:23

mentioned, that's coming in. And although

38:25

this is normal, what

38:27

we're seeing here is a mix

38:29

of stuff. And if you look really closely, I can

38:32

pull out some of this. This

38:34

right 360. Is the

38:36

actual sarcasm. But again, it is

38:38

mixed in with a lot of the stuff that comes

38:40

in. And I gotta tell you, I was just having a conversation

38:42

with one gentleman that works with weddings 360.

38:45

And he was really concerned about what's to

38:47

come because he said last weekend, I spent

38:49

all of this time cleaning up this beaches

38:51

to make wedding look nice and he was afraid

38:53

of what will come next. John?

38:55

They they do say a seaweed blob

38:57

invasion at a wedding is supposed to be good luck.

39:00

For the marriage.

39:00

Love us.

39:01

I think that's what they say. That's what they

39:03

say. Okay.

39:05

Stay safe. Thank you so much for your 360.

39:07

Appreciate it. Thank you.

39:09

So if you have filled out a bracket for the NCAA

39:12

men's basketball tournament, you have my

39:14

condolences. It's only the second day of the tournament,

39:16

and already millions of brackets are busted

39:19

360 Harriet and joins us next with the numbers.

39:21

Stay with us. Perhaps

39:23

the only thing more busted than bank stocks

39:25

this week are people's n c double a

39:28

brackets another upset today

39:30

in the men's college basketball championship

39:32

tournament number eleven. Beat number

39:34

six Iowa State. I'm

39:36

sorry, Christine Jones. That comes one

39:38

day after the tournament began with huge

39:40

upsets, including Princeton beating

39:42

number two seat Arizona. Final

39:45

360 Ivy League kids catching a

39:46

break. That that laid waste to

39:48

millions of brackets. Our senior

39:50

data reporter 360 joins us with

39:52

the latest on the card is, you know, 360,

39:55

I mean, how many brackets were wiped

39:57

out here? I I mean, based on, you know,

39:59

Princeton losing and principal winning, excuse

40:01

me, 360 Fuhrman winning, less than a million

40:03

people had those had those two teams

40:05

in combo winning. We are now talking about

40:08

in terms of the perfect brackets in the 360,

40:10

Less than 360. Less than fifty

40:12

out of tens of millions of brackets

40:14

are currently still perfect, and we're keeping

40:16

an eye on this Purdue Purdue Game,

40:19

who says, number one 360. John has it

40:21

up on his computer right now. Purdue's trailing

40:23

by 360. And if that goes and you have

40:25

a number one seed going down, my goodness gracious,

40:27

And this is the reason why mister Berman,

40:29

that the chance of getting a perfect bracket is like

40:31

one and nine

40:32

quintillion, which is eighteen zeros.

40:35

I'm Ryan with Total now down by five, but I'm not

40:37

watching that. I'm paying very close attention to you,

40:39

Harry, and and the rest of the

40:41

news. Oh, now it's a two point Kim, giving the running

40:43

play by

40:43

play here. I'm not sure the legalities of

40:45

all of that. Harry, just

40:48

because though you've got a

40:50

bust busted

40:50

bracket, right, It's not all bad news.

40:52

Right? Right. It's not all bad news. The thing

40:54

to keep in mind, of course, is the way these brackets

40:57

work is that the games in the later

40:59

rounds count for more. So let's just

41:01

say, you know, oh, a number four

41:03

loss to a number 360, and you had that

41:06

number four winning. As long as you didn't have that number

41:08

four, going to the final four,

41:10

you're in pretty good shape because essentially what

41:12

it is, each round is worth the same amount

41:14

of points. But if there are more games in particular

41:16

round, 360 individual game is worth

41:19

significantly less when there's like say

41:21

sixteen games in round versus when say there are

41:23

only two games in round. So the key

41:25

thing here, John, is that you want your

41:27

final four to be 360. Of course, the big

41:29

question is after all these upsets, will

41:31

people's final fours actually be intact?

41:33

For speaker, you said fewer than fifty people

41:35

in all of America right now have

41:37

their pools intact? Less than fifty people

41:40

in America. I was looking at ESPN. It was

41:42

less than 360. I was looking at the NCAA's

41:44

website, there was less than thirty there.

41:46

When you combine it all together, there was less

41:48

than fifty. Now maybe there's someone who's betting

41:50

with their friend right out on the side. And

41:53

we don't know if that particular person

41:55

has a perfect bracket. But in terms of the official

41:57

brackets, the one you and I keep a count on, the

41:59

ones that maybe the Guinness Book of World Records would

42:01

keep an I add on, there's less than

42:03

fifty. Not the CNN

42:03

bracket, which I was not invited to participate.

42:05

No. I wasn't invited to participate 360. That's

42:07

either here nor there. Not invited. Just saying,

42:10

but there are brackets that I did do

42:13

in in our final fours are still okay.

42:15

We Okay

42:17

for another minute. Yeah. Maybe okay for

42:19

another minute. So if you look at our final fours,

42:21

right, we each have Purdue in there.

42:23

My question to you, mister Berman, is

42:26

what is going on with your Alabama Fed

42:28

this year, both Auburn and Alabama in

42:30

there. And why with Gonzaga? What

42:32

is with you and Chris Wallace? You both

42:34

pick Gonzaga one year,

42:36

they're not a number one scene. Every single year,

42:38

I picked

42:39

Gonzaga, they 360 to lose. What what

42:41

is the deal here? Do you just love John Stockton? Well,

42:43

truth be told my son,

42:45

filled out my entire Wow. --

42:46

for me. Oh, so you're cheating. But I think he's a big

42:48

Caitlyn Collins fan. So I think that's why he put

42:51

Alabama, you know, and all, but just because the

42:53

Alabama centric

42:54

Gonzaga, you know, it's got

42:55

a nice name. I I will say, you know,

42:57

my I I have family member that lives down

42:59

in Alabama. I also have Alabama in my

43:01

final four So I'm a big fan of Alabama,

43:04

but Auburn being an H. C. That would be

43:06

quite the thing if Auburn was able to advance.

43:08

But then again, I guess 360 wouldn't necessarily have

43:10

thought that 360 Dickinson University

43:13

might be with

43:14

the potential upset over Purdue. And just

43:16

to be clear, FDU is it sixteen

43:18

360 Purdue is a

43:21

one seed -- Correct.

43:21

-- only once in the history of history

43:23

-- Correct. -- is what happened. -- 360

43:26

back in two thousand eighteen beat UVA

43:28

by twenty points. That was the biggest shocker.

43:30

The only other time that really came close was

43:32

a Princeton back, I believe, in nineteen

43:34

eighty nine against Georgetown, was a

43:36

very close match that they only lost by a point in that

43:38

one, but this would be the second time in history. Reason which

43:41

it does state the

43:41

shockers? III digress. Yeah. Harry

43:43

and thank you. Very much for being with

43:45

us. Best of luck to you. I'm going to

43:48

need it after this Purdue game. Alright. That wraps

43:50

wraps up our hour coming up. Or devoting

43:52

an entire hour to the historic war

43:54

crimes warrant issued by the International Criminal

43:57

Court for Vladimir Putin. That includes

43:59

more of Clarissa awards exclusive

44:01

interview with the ICC's chief prosecutor,

44:03

Korean Khan, and why he decided to pursue

44:06

allegations involving the abduction of children

44:08

from Ukraine rather than the attacks on civilians,

44:11

OR THE 360 IN BUKA. JOHN

44:14

BORDIN HERE IN FOR ANDersen AND THIS IS A

44:16

SPECIAL LIVE COVERAGE OF TODAY'S HISTORIC

44:18

DECISION BY THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT

44:21

to issue arrest warrants on war

44:23

crimes charges for Russian president Vladimir

44:25

Putin and his deputy who runs

44:27

Russia's program of taking children

44:29

from Ukraine, thousands of them

44:32

to Russia for indoctrination and

44:34

in some cases adoption by Russian

44:36

families. Today, CNN's Chorus Award

44:38

got this exclusive interview with

44:40

Korean Convey, ICC's chief

44:43

prosecutor. She joins us from the Hague.

44:45

CNN's Matthew Chance, is moderating

44:47

Russian reaction. He joins us as well as

44:49

as seen as Ivan Watson from Ukraine.

44:51

This is a story that he and three sixty have been

44:53

reporting on extensively. We

44:55

start things off with Clarissa

44:58

Ward and her interview at the head.

45:00

Clarissa?

45:03

John, well, 360 Khan was keen to tell us

45:05

that this is really just the first step

45:07

in what promises to be a long

45:09

journey. The arrest warrants that were given

45:12

out today for president Putin and

45:14

also for the Russia high

45:16

commissioner for children, 360 LOVOVA,

45:19

360. 360 are just

45:21

the first two 360. There

45:23

may be more coming. There may be other

45:25

areas that they will be exploring.

45:27

There is no shortage of

45:30

alleged war crimes that have taken place

45:32

in Ukraine. The prosecutor's

45:35

office for here from the ICC

45:37

have made multiple trips

45:39

to Ukraine, but they were keen

45:41

really to stress the importance of

45:44

this historic day. Take a look.

45:48

There are many different war

45:50

crimes or potential war crimes

45:53

that we've seen playing out in Ukraine,

45:55

whether it's bombing of

45:57

the theater in Maruy up, where people

45:59

were sheltering, civilians were sheltering,

46:01

whether it's the atrocities of Búcha,

46:04

why did you decide to pursue

46:06

this line of prosecution

46:09

first?

46:09

360 absolutely right. Firstly,

46:11

I stated when I was outside six

46:13

hundred Church in brochure

46:16

about a year ago, just less than

46:18

a year ago, that Ukraine is a

46:20

crime 360. And there's many terrible

46:22

allegations that have been received and were analyzing

46:24

them and reviewing them. But before

46:27

my election as prosecutor, before

46:29

I started in June of twenty twenty one.

46:31

I also identified the crimes against

46:34

or crimes affecting children. Are

46:36

under investigated and 360. And

46:38

this is why when you look at the factual

46:40

matrix, the actual evidence that we received,

46:42

it was only right and 360.

46:44

To focus on the most vulnerable

46:47

parts of our 360, which are children. We

46:49

understand that miss Liva 360

46:51

is the Russian commissioner

46:54

for children. She's been very vocal and

46:56

visible in her role. How

46:58

did you take the next step also

47:00

in terms of pushing for execution of

47:02

president Putin

47:03

himself? And how unusual is

47:06

that? Well, I've said repeatedly

47:08

over the last year that we don't start with targets.

47:11

And we start with the evidence. We

47:13

investigate incriminating and

47:15

exonerating evidence equally. We want to

47:17

find the truth. We are structurally 360.

47:21

To get to the truth. And we,

47:23

as I've said, started looking at a range

47:25

of white spectrum of allegations, but

47:28

the evidence was quite clear because what

47:30

has been said publicly from

47:33

those individuals, what has become available

47:35

from publicly available sources

47:37

and also the result of our direct

47:39

investigations ourselves

47:42

cooperation with other states and also Ukraine.

47:45

That these 360 crimes appear to have

47:47

been committed and one follows the evidence.

47:49

And the the simple reality is

47:51

these crimes have not been hidden. Because the first

47:54

time in history, any

47:56

head of state of the permanent members of the

47:58

five permanent members of the 360 council

48:00

has had a warrant of arrest issued

48:03

by independent and impartial judges. It

48:05

shouldn't give us any celebration. It's

48:08

a matter of real regret that

48:10

we've had to do this.

48:12

The evidence compelled us to move in this manner.

48:15

It's

48:15

a historic moment 360, but

48:17

will we ever 360 president Putin

48:19

in the dock? Well, the president of the

48:21

court made it very clear our job is

48:23

to independently and impartially

48:25

without any political motivations or agendas.

48:28

Look at – apply the law to the facts.

48:30

The facts that have been verified, that have been

48:33

independently 360, and

48:35

rigorously 360. Now

48:38

it's for others to decide whether

48:40

or not arrest opportunities are

48:43

available and if show to enforce them. The

48:45

first is many thought

48:48

it was impossible. The

48:50

powerful leaders like former

48:53

President, Milosevic, former President,

48:55

Charles Taylor, Karadich,

48:58

Miladich, Jean Cabanda of Rwanda,

49:01

Kussopan in of 360, the

49:04

list goes on. He said 360

49:07

would ever be subjected to

49:09

the rule of

49:09

law, and yet they were. Some of them are

49:11

in custody. Of

49:14

course, award is back with us. Clarissa, no

49:16

expectation, obviously, that Vladimir

49:18

Putin would surrender or

49:20

or be arrested. So did the ICC give

49:23

you a sense of how it intends

49:25

to proceed legally? Well,

49:29

that's the question 360, John, because

49:31

the ICC can't trial, can't

49:33

have a trial of someone in absentia.

49:36

BUT WHAT THEY CAN DO, ACCORDING

49:39

TO PROSECUTOR CON AND AGAIN, THIS HASN'T

49:41

BEEN DONE HISTORICALLY 360 THERE IS

49:43

LEGAL PRESIDENT FOR IT is

49:45

what they call a confirmation hearing

49:48

in absence. And that would essentially

49:51

allow for the evidence to

49:53

be preserved in a judicial setting

49:56

in a timely way, paving

49:59

the way for some potential future

50:01

trial. What they have seen traditionally, the

50:03

ICC, is that very

50:06

rarely do people charge with war crimes

50:09

360 to face justice until

50:11

those wars have reached an

50:13

end and whichever side is victorious gets

50:16

to choose who ends up facing

50:19

trial at the ICC.

50:21

So what they want to do at least with

50:23

this possibility of the confirmation

50:25

hearing is in sure that that evidence

50:27

is put out there in a timely manner

50:29

that victims of these

50:32

alleged atrocities are able to still

50:34

have their day in court even if it might

50:36

be quite some time before you

50:38

would potentially see president

50:41

Vladimir Putin appearing on

50:43

trial, though, I think for the moment, that

50:45

does seem like a very distant prospect,

50:48

John. Of course, stay with us, I wanna bring in Matthew

50:50

Chants and Ivan Watson. Ivan, what what has the

50:52

reaction been from the 360 GOVERNMENT

50:54

TO THESE ARREST WORDS?

50:58

John, THE 360 GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN UP plotting

51:01

this decision, the arrest warrant issued

51:03

by the International Criminal Court. According

51:05

to government statistics, they

51:07

say that some sixteen thousand

51:09

two hundred twenty six Ukrainian children

51:12

the government believes have been taken

51:14

and deported to Russia since

51:17

the start of the Russian invasion a

51:19

bit more than a year ago. Take

51:21

a listen to what the Ukrainian president Volodymyr

51:24

Zelensky had to say about this, which

51:26

he calls and historic decision.

51:32

Separating children from their families

51:34

depriving them of any opportunity to

51:36

contact their relatives, hide in children

51:39

in Russia, dispersing them to remote

51:41

360, All this is obvious

51:43

Russian state policy, state decisions,

51:46

and state evil, which

51:48

begins with the first official of the state.

51:53

So, you know, another top Ukrainian

51:56

official has just called this a first

51:58

step 360, the top prosecutor in

52:00

the country, he says that he hopes that this will make

52:03

other world leaders think twice about

52:05

in the future. Shaking hands with Vladimir

52:07

Putin or sitting down at the negotiating table

52:10

with him now that he's effectively become

52:13

a suspected war criminal. While

52:15

the ICC move is important,

52:18

it's also important, I think, to

52:20

to understand that the

52:22

Ukraine judicial system, that

52:24

police here on the ground, that investigators and

52:27

prosecutors, that they are also

52:29

separately ACTIVELY GATHERING

52:31

EVIDENCE FOR THEIR OWN CASES TO

52:33

ACCUSE Russian

52:36

MILITARY COMMANDERS IN INDIVIDUAL

52:38

Russian SOLDIERS. Of

52:40

alleged war crimes that after

52:43

every kind of rocket strike or

52:45

or 360 strike on a Ukrainian

52:48

city or town after every death of

52:50

a civilian. You have police coming

52:52

in later if it's at all safe

52:55

in an 360. Gathering evidence and

52:57

putting their own cases together to

52:59

try to prosecute prosecute

53:02

Russian military units 360 probably

53:05

going to see more of this coming from

53:07

just the Ukrainian judicial system

53:09

in the the months and years ahead.

53:12

So Matthew, the the Kremlin has called these warrants

53:14

outrageous, but did they actually

53:16

deny what the warrants accused?

53:19

No, not at all. They you're right. They

53:21

say it's outrageous and unacceptable that

53:23

these indictments have been made.

53:26

But they're actually quite boastful of the

53:28

fact that these, you know, what the Ukrainian

53:30

leadership calls these these forceful deportations

53:33

are taking place because they cast it inside

53:35

Russia as a humanitarian act.

53:38

What what they regard it as

53:41

is Russia rescuing orphans

53:44

who have essentially been abandoned inside

53:46

the war zone and then embracing them into

53:48

the the bosom of mother Russia. As

53:51

it were. And 360, talking quite

53:53

a lot on Russian television within the past few

53:55

days and weeks about how

53:58

some of them have been adopted. Maria

54:01

LaVver herself is said

54:03

to have adopted a fifteen year old from

54:05

the city of of Mario Poel. She's

54:07

also spoken about how they've been re educated,

54:10

how many of them said negative

54:12

things about Russia and sank the 360 national

54:15

anthem when they were first taken into Russian

54:17

360. But now that don't do that 360,

54:20

and they speak much more 360, apparently, she

54:22

says, about Russia. And

54:24

so this is how Russia

54:27

and its officials describe these

54:30

alleged crimes that that president

54:32

Putin has been indicted for.

54:34

And all this remember, as these children,

54:37

at thousands of them, have parents

54:40

in many cases that are still alive inside

54:42

Ukraine and desperately trying to

54:45

get their loved ones back.

54:45

You know, Clarissa, I think

54:47

one of the most interesting parts of your

54:50

discussion with the prosecutor from the ICC was

54:52

about the timing here.

54:53

These warrants are coming out While

54:55

the conflict is still going on, how unusual

54:57

is that?

55:01

It's highly unusual. And

55:03

and it was interesting to hear Korean

55:05

Kong was even critical of the ICC

55:07

and said in the past, you know, we've been too pedestrian

55:10

to use his word. 360 need to

55:12

accelerate. There needs to be a sense

55:14

that the wheels and justice turn in

55:17

a timely manner. And so

55:19

as opposed to traditionally where we

55:21

might be talking about years after conflict

55:23

has ended within a month

55:25

of the Russian invasion. Khan

55:28

and his team were already beginning

55:31

their investigations. And just

55:33

over a year after the war

55:35

began, you have the first to

55:37

arrest warrants being issued. And

55:40

the idea is that this will continue

55:42

a pace now, that you will see more

55:45

arrest warrants 360, more

55:47

investigations as all the

55:49

different allegations that have been made

55:52

our research. Now, obviously, this takes a huge

55:54

amount of resources, John. Right? There is

55:56

no shortage of

55:58

war crimes as we've mentioned before taking

56:00

place in Ukraine. In fact, to use cons

56:03

of words. He said, Ukraine is

56:05

basically a crime scene. And

56:07

so there's now an inordinate amount

56:10

of work that needs to be done,

56:12

to go, to try to verify, and

56:14

to build up solid cases.

56:17

In this instance,

56:17

and in future investigations

56:20

taking place. Close

56:22

to war, we're 360 have more of your interview coming up.

56:24

Ivan Watson, Matthew Chancellor, thanks to both

56:26

of you. Next, more

56:28

on the woman we've been talking about in

56:30

the program she runs, bringing Ukrainian

56:33

children to Russia and erasing their

56:35

Ukrainian identity. And later, My

56:38

conversation with Elena Nash, who

56:40

360 sixty, whom three sixty viewers got to

56:42

know in the early days of the war, sheltering

56:44

with her children AND 360, SHE IS NOW HERE

56:46

IN THE UNITED STATES AND WE SPOKE ABOUT

56:48

TODAY'S ARREST WARRANCE HER THOUNS AHEAD

56:50

ON 360 sixty.

56:55

I'm Dr. Sanjay Gupta. This week on

56:57

chasing life, the average teen is like living

56:59

so much of their lives in the digital world on

57:01

social 360. That's Professor Kinesha

57:04

Sinclair McBride. Her entire job

57:06

is treating adolescent's mental health.

57:08

She's a licensed clinical psychologist at

57:10

Boston Children's Hospital and so much

57:13

of this is impacting their

57:15

mental health. Listen to chasing

57:17

life on Apple Podcasts,

57:20

Spotify, iHeartRadio 360 your

57:23

favorite podcast app.

57:26

360

57:27

wanna tell you more about the lesser known

57:29

of the two individuals there on

57:31

your screen. The one with the job title

57:33

that in this context is just chilling. She

57:35

is Russia's commissioner for

57:37

children's rights. You heard that

57:39

right. The woman heading up and

57:42

even boasting about an operation that has

57:44

already documented to be violating the rights

57:46

of Ukrainian children.

57:46

More from 360 Melissa

57:49

Bell. She

57:51

claims to be the savior of

57:53

Ukrainian children. Demure

57:59

devout and devoted, 360 says,

58:01

to welcoming orphaned or abandoned

58:03

children of war. To the motherland. But

58:09

this is no humanitarian adoption

58:11

program. Russia's children's

58:13

rights commissioner is in fact in charge

58:16

of something far more sinister. According

58:18

to American and European governments

58:21

and to a report by Yale University,

58:23

360 of children have

58:25

been forcibly deported to Russia.

58:28

Although

58:28

Moscow denies its doing this against

58:30

their will, some have been taken

58:32

thousands of miles and several

58:35

time zones away from Ukraine. Maria

58:37

La VOva Bel VOBA is basically

58:40

the point person at Kremlin level

58:42

for this entire program.

58:44

And so

58:44

360 children are essentially being held hostage?

58:47

Yes.

58:49

The woman in charge is herself a thirty

58:51

eight year old mother of at least ten,

58:54

including five adopted

58:55

children. And her work takes

58:57

her all the way into the occupied

58:59

territories. This

59:03

time, we came to Mario Paul itself.

59:05

We will do everything for the children and teenagers

59:08

who are here.

59:09

From Lava, Belava's telegram

59:11

channel to Russian propaganda videos

59:14

the deportations are no 360, yet

59:16

the children are totally beyond the reach

59:19

of either their families or Ukrainian

59:21

authorities.

59:22

Some of those children are really small.

59:24

We see on the propaganda video of fresh and

59:27

that seven, six

59:29

months, you know, four years,

59:31

those children just do not remember

59:34

where they form, who are their parents.

59:38

And

59:38

once across the border, there is no

59:40

contact anyway. Some are adopted

59:43

by Russian families, others, are taken

59:45

to water build as summer camps. In

59:47

fact, reeducation centers

59:49

aimed at turning Ukrainian children into

59:52

Russian citizens. Unfortunately,

59:56

we see that these children

59:58

were brought up in a completely different culture,

1:00:01

and they did not watch the same films our

1:00:03

children watched.

1:00:03

They did not study history as

1:00:05

our children did. But

1:00:08

Ukrainian lawyers fighting for the return

1:00:10

of the children fear that those already adopted

1:00:12

may be lost for good.

1:00:13

During this process of adoption,

1:00:16

parents can change all personal

1:00:18

data. NIMs, some

1:00:21

names, a a date of birth.

1:00:23

And they think that some

1:00:26

children, the transfer to Russia,

1:00:27

these are all documents. Among

1:00:30

those already adopted, is a young

1:00:32

boy from 360 Paul by Maria Lava

1:00:34

Bilava herself. At

1:00:36

first, she says he sang the Ukrainian

1:00:39

national

1:00:39

anthem. Now, he's a good

1:00:41

boy, as she told Vladimir Putin

1:00:44

himself.

1:00:48

Did you adopt child from Mario Paul yourself?

1:00:53

Yes. So thanks to you. Fifteen years

1:00:55

old. Now I know what it means to be mother

1:00:57

of a child from Don Bass.

1:00:58

It's difficult, but we definitely

1:01:00

love each other. Minnesota

1:01:04

And joining us now is Nathaniel Raymond, whom

1:01:06

you saw a moment ago in Melissa Bell's report.

1:01:08

He's executive director of

1:01:10

Yale University's 360 research

1:01:13

lab you've worked on

1:01:15

this project for a long time. Your report was

1:01:17

responsible for shining a light on so much of

1:01:19

what's been going on in Ukraine.

1:01:20

So what does this moment mean for you? Well,

1:01:23

John, on one hand, I'm still in

1:01:25

shock from the announcement and the indictments

1:01:28

this morning by the 360. Which

1:01:30

is a critical first step, but only a

1:01:32

first step towards justice

1:01:34

for the people of Ukraine. On the

1:01:36

other hand, I'm thinking about

1:01:39

the parents tonight of

1:01:41

the children who have yet to come home

1:01:44

and some may not come home.

1:01:46

And so on one hand, I

1:01:48

feel hope because of today's

1:01:50

indictment. On the other hand, I feel

1:01:52

the urgency of trying to get these kids

1:01:54

back.

1:01:54

You mentioned

1:01:56

that

1:01:56

you're still sort of in shock. Did

1:01:59

you have any idea this was coming? No.

1:02:01

I the only thing I knew is what I read

1:02:03

in The New York Times. A few days ago.

1:02:06

And at that point, we thought it could

1:02:08

happen. And then this morning,

1:02:11

I was walking my dogs and my

1:02:13

phone went bizarre. And

1:02:15

suddenly it had happened. And

1:02:18

and so since that point, it's

1:02:21

really been an effort to get our heads

1:02:23

around the fact that what we've been

1:02:25

working on is now the subject of an ICC

1:02:27

indictment.

1:02:28

So, 360 Vovalova, who we saw --

1:02:30

Yeah. -- in that piece right there. 360

1:02:32

called the ICC warning against her

1:02:35

great. Yes. What's

1:02:37

your view of her who is this woman in your mind?

1:02:41

Maria LOVOVA BOLOVA is

1:02:43

basically the center

1:02:45

of the command and control of

1:02:47

a synchronized coordinated

1:02:50

whole of government operation that

1:02:52

has two major parts to it. One

1:02:55

is the reeducation camps you mentioned and

1:02:57

the other is forced adoption. And

1:02:59

you have to understand that this

1:03:01

network and it is a network of camps

1:03:04

stretches as the graphic showed three

1:03:06

thousand five hundred miles from the black

1:03:08

sea to the Pacific and involves more than

1:03:10

forty three facilities.

1:03:11

We think that number is significantly higher.

1:03:13

She sounded proud. 360 is proud.

1:03:15

Today, though. So do you think that the

1:03:17

warrants -- this historic moment --

1:03:19

Yes. -- do you think it will do anything to deter

1:03:22

her or slow her down? At

1:03:25

every moment that the Russians

1:03:27

have faced the possibility of accountability for this

1:03:29

program, they've doubled down. In that 360, you

1:03:31

played, there's another clip after where

1:03:33

they talk about a military training facility

1:03:35

for 360, seventeen year old boys in Chechnya.

1:03:38

And they say, this is forty eight hours after our

1:03:40

report comes out. They say, the pilot

1:03:42

program has been a success. Let's expand

1:03:44

it by two thousand Russian and Ukrainian

1:03:46

boys. And so the

1:03:48

point is they are probably going to,

1:03:51

360 term, try to show that they are

1:03:53

undeterred. But today,

1:03:55

the international community show that we are also

1:03:57

undeterred. What do you want to

1:03:59

see happen to Vladimir

1:04:01

Putin and Maria VOV blah blah.

1:04:03

One word, handcuffs.

1:04:07

What do you think the future is for

1:04:10

those Ukrainian children who

1:04:12

are already in Russia? I've

1:04:14

worked on efforts to

1:04:17

identify through DNA testing children

1:04:19

in Guatemala who were separated

1:04:21

from their parents during civil wars in

1:04:23

the 360. That process took decades.

1:04:26

I don't want to see that here, but we're

1:04:28

in as emergency medicine

1:04:30

surgeons call the golden hour. And

1:04:32

that golden hour is fast slipping away, John,

1:04:35

where if we don't get them back now,

1:04:37

we're going to be talking about DNA identification

1:04:39

and processes that will take decades So

1:04:41

360 have to act now because time is technique.

1:04:44

This type of human writes work

1:04:46

that you do -- Yeah. -- can can be thankless.

1:04:48

I mean, you can get no results for for

1:04:50

years on certain things. Years. Like Ted

1:04:52

Williams said about baseball, you know, you fail

1:04:55

sixty, seventy percent of the times for doing your

1:04:57

job. Right? And So this is history today

1:04:59

in your mind. Absolutely. This is

1:05:01

the moment where the dog caught the

1:05:03

postal truck, and

1:05:05

this usually doesn't happen. Now

1:05:07

the fact is, is that we have to

1:05:10

take this moment, which validates the anguish

1:05:12

of the people of Ukraine and those parents, and

1:05:14

then turn it into, okay, What's

1:05:16

next?

1:05:16

You gotta make account those

1:05:19

kids 360 it. Nathaniel Raymond, thank

1:05:21

you for the work that you do and thank

1:05:23

you for being with us tonight. Thank you for telling the

1:05:25

story 360. Coming up more from

1:05:27

Clarissa Ward's exclusive interview with

1:05:29

ICC 360 Prosecutor Kareem Khan,

1:05:31

including whether he thinks he will ever

1:05:33

see Putin taken into custody in

1:05:35

handcuffs. As Nathaniel just

1:05:37

said, and what may be coming next in

1:05:39

the ICC's investigations. We

1:05:42

continue

1:05:42

our look tonight at the historic

1:05:44

arrest warrants handed down by the International

1:05:46

Criminal Court for Vladimir Putin and a top

1:05:48

Russian official. Now with

1:05:50

more of Clarissa Ward's exclusive conversation

1:05:53

with the ICC's chief prosecutor Korean

1:05:55

Khan and why the ICC decided first

1:05:57

to focus on the kidnapping of Ukrainian children

1:06:00

as well as what charges may be coming next.

1:06:02

Under

1:06:04

the Rome Statute, the

1:06:06

forced deportation of children, is

1:06:09

also listed as a component of genocide

1:06:12

potentially. Now, the arrest warrants

1:06:14

today are for war crimes.

1:06:17

I wonder how did you decide

1:06:21

whether to pursue war crimes versus

1:06:23

crimes against humanity versus

1:06:24

genocide, for example?

1:06:26

Yes. So we're

1:06:28

still at an early stage of the investigations. We

1:06:30

are continuing to look at

1:06:32

all the allegations

1:06:35

that we have received, that we are

1:06:37

uncovering, and we will make

1:06:40

the necessary applications to

1:06:42

the judges if

1:06:44

and when the evidence fulfills those requirements.

1:06:47

So the fact that today, the

1:06:49

judges of the International Criminal Court

1:06:51

pursuant to their statutory responsibilities have

1:06:54

decided to issue the two warrants that

1:06:56

have been mentioned. Does it mean that's it?

1:06:59

360 will keep on going to the best

1:07:01

of our ability to ensure

1:07:04

that the many other crimes,

1:07:04

the many other allegations that

1:07:07

seem to have been committed are uncovered. So

1:07:09

is it fair to say this is essentially just the

1:07:11

first step? And there are multiple

1:07:13

other investigations into

1:07:16

potential war crimes in Ukraine that

1:07:18

your office will be looking into?

1:07:20

Yes, I think it's very clear that it's an ongoing

1:07:24

360 of battle and war

1:07:26

is not illegal, but law the war

1:07:28

has certain constraints. There's not

1:07:31

an unlicensed. There's not a free license to

1:07:33

commit every type of 360.

1:07:35

You can't rape. You can't attack

1:07:37

civilian objects. You can't attack

1:07:39

civilians. You can't execute people that

1:07:42

have laid down their arms.

1:07:42

These are the basic principles that have been

1:07:45

well understood by all sides. You've

1:07:47

obviously worked in international

1:07:50

law for a long time. You've

1:07:52

spent quite some time on the ground

1:07:55

in Ukraine. How

1:07:57

does Ukraine compare? Not that one can

1:07:59

make these types of comparisons, but are

1:08:01

you struck by what you see

1:08:04

in Ukraine in terms of

1:08:07

the levels of violence or potential

1:08:09

war crimes.

1:08:11

You know, you're quite right,

1:08:13

I've had the privilege of

1:08:16

seeing the

1:08:17

charisma of victims and survivors in

1:08:19

so many parts of the world.

1:08:21

And I don't have a 360 table,

1:08:24

of course. But what we see

1:08:26

in parts of Ukraine, have

1:08:29

been seen by different

1:08:31

people of

1:08:33

different cultures and different languages. I

1:08:36

was also leading the team investigating

1:08:38

crimes by Daish in Mosul.

1:08:41

We've seen the Balkans. I was a

1:08:43

junior prosecutor many decades

1:08:45

ago at the London tribunal as

1:08:47

well as Yugoslav tribunal in Cambodia. So

1:08:53

you know very well about the banality of evil

1:08:55

and you you you also know very well

1:08:57

about the kind of crimes that have

1:08:59

afflicted humanity from timing

1:09:01

360, but also since the Holocaust. And

1:09:04

unfortunately, despite the promises of never

1:09:06

gain and despite the

1:09:08

publicity, the understanding that

1:09:10

the law is out there, there is this

1:09:13

still very prevalent proclivity of

1:09:15

people with power. To

1:09:18

believe that they can

1:09:20

subject weaker

1:09:21

people to that power and do what they

1:09:23

want. Fact

1:09:25

with the snap clause award also joining is

1:09:27

Gary Kasparov, Russian pro democracy leader

1:09:29

and chairman of the Human Rights Foundation He's

1:09:32

also the author of Winter is

1:09:33

coming, why Vladimir Putin and the enemies

1:09:35

of the free world must be

1:09:37

stopped. Carrie, you've been a long time critic.

1:09:40

Of Vladimir Putin. So what is your reaction

1:09:42

to these arrest warrants today?

1:09:43

It's a great joy. It's

1:09:45

very important with the first step as we

1:09:47

heard today. Because

1:09:49

this war and the crimes committed

1:09:51

by Russian troops on the equated

1:09:53

soil is quite unique with so many

1:09:56

genocides before. But we learned of

1:09:58

them afterwards, Holocaust,

1:10:01

Cambodia, Rwanda, we

1:10:04

didn't see them life. Yeah,

1:10:06

we had to accumulate evidence and then recognize

1:10:09

the horrors of these crimes. These

1:10:11

crimes committed virtually online. And

1:10:15

I think that what's happened today, it's

1:10:17

a very strong message for Russians,

1:10:19

for Russian 360. That there's no way back.

1:10:22

It's no one that's going to close their eyes

1:10:25

and sort

1:10:27

of turn the blind eye on on on

1:10:29

on 360 crimes. And somehow, I think

1:10:31

Putin probably was shocked because he's

1:10:34

he's killed 360 of blood.

1:10:36

But now 360 being charged with kidnapping.

1:10:39

It's It's like Al Capone

1:10:41

being charged with tax evasion because

1:10:43

they could actually get him on on on on

1:10:45

tax evasion. And and it's it's not being

1:10:48

mentioned, but putting bragged about this crime,

1:10:50

kidnapping kids on television. Actually, they

1:10:52

recorded it. So which get it? It's you

1:10:54

don't even have to prove it because you have to put

1:10:56

put in personal confession. About

1:10:58

the program that he authorized, and

1:11:01

he's subordinate, the so called commissioner

1:11:04

on children's rights. 360 has been executing

1:11:06

the program, which by the way was a part of

1:11:08

Putin's long term strategy of

1:11:11

destroying Ukraine's statehood and

1:11:13

eradicating 360 as a nation.

1:11:15

It's not me saying Putin said it many

1:11:17

times, and it has been repeated by Russian

1:11:19

propaganda That's the goal of the war. No matter

1:11:21

what DeSantis talked about

1:11:24

about 360

1:11:26

dispute. This is a general side award

1:11:28

that has been planning for a long time.

1:11:31

360 children, bragging about steer

1:11:33

stealing children. They both have we just played some of that

1:11:35

before That is what he is charged with,

1:11:37

but as you heard in Clarissa's piece there,

1:11:40

there may be other charges.

1:11:42

Do you spec and hope that there will

1:11:44

360?

1:11:44

Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. This is the first

1:11:46

one just because we actually could see

1:11:48

him on television saying about that. Other

1:11:51

charges, you know, you have to connect directly to Putin.

1:11:53

But this one, again, you have his post confession.

1:11:56

I think it's every prosecutor could

1:11:58

dream about post confession. Recorded

1:12:00

by by major major TV station.

1:12:03

But I hope it's just as they have

1:12:05

been saying first step because crimes

1:12:07

are endless there. And it's it's not just

1:12:09

war crimes. It's a general side. And 360,

1:12:11

Europe is the end of America because part

1:12:14

of this program is not only to convict

1:12:16

these criminals. And and

1:12:19

by issue warrants as a first step, but

1:12:21

also to remove the state immunity

1:12:24

from Russian frozen fans. Europe

1:12:26

is working now very aggressively to confiscate

1:12:29

hundreds of billions of dollars of frozen funds

1:12:31

to pay Ukraine for reconstruction. It does

1:12:33

not have to be paid by American taxpayers or German

1:12:35

taxpayers or French taxpayers. There's money

1:12:37

stolen by Putin's 360 from

1:12:40

Russia and kept abroad that

1:12:42

could be actually transferred to Ukraine. So,

1:12:45

Clarissa, 360 know, we talk about the idea of other

1:12:47

possible charges than you did with Korean con.

1:12:49

Right? There are any sense of what other evidence

1:12:51

they're collecting at this point to try to make those

1:12:53

other charges?

1:12:54

Donald Berwick:

1:12:57

Well, I think perhaps understandably, John,

1:12:59

there are being a little bit circumspect about

1:13:01

giving any details about

1:13:04

ongoing investigations. But

1:13:06

what 360 Khan did say is

1:13:08

that essentially 360 is

1:13:10

a crime scene right now. And whether

1:13:12

it's the massacre of Búcha, whether

1:13:14

it's some of the atrocities that we've seen

1:13:17

in 360 where civilians

1:13:19

taking shelter in a theater were

1:13:21

killed in the hundreds by air

1:13:23

strikes where a maternity hospital

1:13:26

was also bombed. There

1:13:28

are multiple avenues that they can

1:13:30

pursue. Now, obviously, there's always

1:13:33

the constraint of time and resources

1:13:35

because what I do think, prosecutor

1:13:38

Khan feels very intensely is the pressure

1:13:40

of getting it right if

1:13:42

you're going to build the case. It's

1:13:44

got to be rock solid. It's got to be ironclad.

1:13:47

And that's as you just heard mister

1:13:49

Casper of kind of elucidating

1:13:51

their why it was in important to start with this

1:13:53

forced deportation of Ukrainian

1:13:55

children is because this was done

1:13:58

flagrantly, basically. 360

1:14:02

by the Russian state, by Vladimir

1:14:04

Putin in conjunction, of course, with miss

1:14:06

LOVOO, 360. And so it

1:14:08

makes sense as a starting point, but there

1:14:10

are many other lines of inquiry

1:14:13

and investigation and allegations that

1:14:15

they are looking into. And the

1:14:17

hope is that this is just the beginning,

1:14:19

that they're building momentum, and we will

1:14:21

see more like

1:14:23

this to come. So 360,

1:14:25

you tweeted today, I don't care if Putin leaves

1:14:27

his bunker in chains or in a box, but

1:14:29

his trial could be an education for

1:14:32

brainwashed Russians who must confront

1:14:34

their culpability on his crimes. There would be

1:14:36

backlash and denial, but the facts

1:14:38

would come out. You really think that

1:14:40

you really

1:14:40

think at this point that the Russians will learn

1:14:42

something from this? 360,

1:14:45

yes, that before this moment comes,

1:14:47

we need Ukraine to win the war. Ukraine

1:14:49

victory. As I've been saying for a long time,

1:14:52

alongside those my 360, like Michael Khodorkovsky

1:14:54

and other foreign Russians who believe that

1:14:56

Victor for Ukraine is the beginning of liberation

1:14:59

of Russia from Putin's fascism. Only

1:15:01

decisive Korean victory. It will include full

1:15:03

liberation of the country, including Crimea

1:15:05

and 360 of Sarvastopol, reparations being

1:15:08

paid and war crimes

1:15:11

tribunal. Those are three key components

1:15:14

for Russia to have a chance, historic

1:15:16

chance, to leave behind Empire,

1:15:19

about all 360 illusions and

1:15:22

and a hero past,

1:15:24

mostly criminal past, and to

1:15:27

try to build a new state, a nation

1:15:29

state. Some kind of loose confederation

1:15:32

of of many Russian regions that would like to

1:15:34

to have a fresh start. 360

1:15:36

Kasperoff, we do appreciate your time tonight, Corus,

1:15:38

award as always. Thank you so much. FOR

1:15:40

YOUR REPORTING. NEXT, YOU'RE

1:15:42

GOING TO HEAR FROM ALENAGENESS, A

1:15:44

360 MOTHER OF THREE NOW LIVING HERE IN THE

1:15:47

UNITED STATES HER THOUGHT ON THE ARREST WARRENS

1:15:49

SOMETHING SHE'S BEEN DEMANDING SINCE HER VERY FIRST

1:15:51

APPEARANCE ON three sixty. TODAY

1:15:54

A PROSECUTOR IN THE HAG MADE 360. Sadly

1:15:57

though, the largest story has already been

1:15:59

written month after month in

1:16:01

tears. Days after the Russians

1:16:03

invaded Ukraine, Anderson's SPOK FOR THE FIRST

1:16:05

OF MANY TIMES TO OUR NEXT GUESS, ALONG

1:16:08

WITH HER HUSBAND AND CHILDREN, THEY WERE LIVING

1:16:10

PEACEfully IN THE CAPITOL 360 WHEN THE

1:16:12

ATTACK BEGAN AND missiles

1:16:14

first landed there. And she's given

1:16:16

us a grounds eye view of this war at

1:16:19

every critical stage from the initial invasion

1:16:21

to the siege of Kiev to the Ukrainian counter

1:16:23

assault. In fact, It was during that

1:16:25

first interview on February twenty eighth of

1:16:27

last year when she said this about her

1:16:29

hope that Vladimir Putin would one

1:16:31

day face justice.

1:16:34

You see, he just decided to take

1:16:36

to stand here his troops and airplanes and

1:16:39

to bump my city and kill my people simply

1:16:41

because he wanted And for this, Putin

1:16:43

has to be punished. And for this, Putin has

1:16:46

to be imprisoned. He to

1:16:48

take him to hug international court

1:16:51

because what he has done is an international

1:16:54

360 and awful crime. Because thousands

1:16:56

of people already died and

1:16:58

they are not they are innocent

1:17:01

victims. We are

1:17:02

glad that Elanaganese who now lives

1:17:05

the United States under the uniting

1:17:07

for Ukraine program could join us once

1:17:09

again on this historic day.

1:17:12

Elena, thank you so much for joining us. You've been

1:17:14

calling for Vladimir Putin to be punished and held accountable

1:17:17

for the 360 that have happened in your country

1:17:19

from the very beginning of the

1:17:20

invasion. So so what are you feeling today

1:17:23

after this announcement from the ICC?

1:17:27

I feel that it's better later

1:17:29

than ever, so I welcome the decision,

1:17:32

but I also know that the list of

1:17:34

the crimes that Putin has committed is

1:17:36

much longer than this. We

1:17:38

see killed civilians, injured

1:17:40

civilians, raped women

1:17:42

and men and children 360 see destroyed

1:17:45

villages and towns, the whole

1:17:47

towns which has scorched, you know,

1:17:49

to zero level. So

1:17:51

the list is very long and now I'm looking

1:17:53

forward for more decisions,

1:17:56

for more tough decisions because

1:17:58

The only there is no alternative, but,

1:18:01

you know, to have put

1:18:03

him to hold him accountable and

1:18:05

to have him in the International Criminal

1:18:07

Court.

1:18:07

So when Anderson

1:18:09

visited you in Kiev last year, there was this moment,

1:18:12

this incredible moment, when your

1:18:14

daughter, Kasha, listed places in you FreIM

1:18:16

WHERE 360 HAVE TAKEN PLACE. I WANT TO LISTEN

1:18:18

TO THAT.

1:18:21

WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IN BUTCHA IS

1:18:25

In my new open. In my new open. It's

1:18:26

it's awful. And now I am ready to

1:18:28

fight. You know, this

1:18:31

is for tangible. You know, when now I The

1:18:35

children know by heart the names

1:18:37

of places, atrocities have been committed.

1:18:40

So as we said, it really is something that your

1:18:42

daughter knew the names of these places.

1:18:45

Even though these ICC charges

1:18:47

aren't related to those atrocities, 360 do

1:18:50

you think that this moment, this historic moment

1:18:53

represents for the people in Ukraine?

1:18:56

I

1:18:56

think that you see even a child

1:18:58

knows the evidence says

1:19:01

that on the surface. You cannot pretend

1:19:03

you are blinds and don't see them. You know,

1:19:05

even a child could tell you the names

1:19:07

of this cities. And unfortunately,

1:19:09

360 then, a lot of more

1:19:11

places were heavily destroyed. A

1:19:14

lot of more crimes happened.

1:19:15

And unfortunately, Putin,

1:19:18

he doesn't get 360

1:19:19

doesn't care about this decision.

1:19:22

I mean, I welcome this decision, but this decision

1:19:25

doesn't stop Putin right now. And

1:19:27

unfortunately, as we are talking

1:19:29

right now, Putin continues destroying.

1:19:32

Ukraine and killing people in Ukraine.

1:19:34

So what more needs to happen in your eyes

1:19:37

to hold Putin accountable? 360

1:19:40

needs to be arrested. What needs

1:19:42

to be done to a terrorist who is

1:19:44

committing crimes? Who to any

1:19:47

criminal who commits crimes? I

1:19:49

mean, what if your neighbor just, you know,

1:19:51

starts destroying your home,

1:19:53

killing your people, raping your

1:19:55

children and then you addressed to the police

1:19:57

and what police tells you that, you know, this

1:20:00

guy has 360 big guns so we can

1:20:02

address him. So just try to negotiate

1:20:04

with him. It's not an option.

1:20:06

We cannot normalize any crime

1:20:09

and a crime of this huge,

1:20:11

you know, level. Can it be normalize

1:20:14

at all? Because, you know, the world is

1:20:16

watching. And we have other countries

1:20:18

who are watching right now. So,

1:20:20

okay, Putin violated all international

1:20:22

360 and so what? He

1:20:25

still can go forward and

1:20:28

only force can stop them. So what

1:20:30

Ukraine needs is weapon. More

1:20:32

weapons and, you know, in

1:20:34

half of weapons to stop. I'm not saying that

1:20:36

America is given and other countries

1:20:39

are given little, not it's

1:20:41

a lot. But unfortunately, it's not enough.

1:20:43

Not because you are not helping Ukraine

1:20:47

much. But because Putin is more aggressive,

1:20:49

360 insane. That's insane.

1:20:51

TIRON. Adrienne: JUST

1:20:54

LASTLY, YOU AND YOUR FAMILY ARE TEMPORARILY ALL

1:20:56

IN THE UNITED STATES STAYING WITH THE HOST FAMILY.

1:20:59

WE SPOKE WITH YOU JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO AROUND THE ONE

1:21:01

YEAR anniversary of

1:21:02

the invasion. How are you all doing?

1:21:05

We are doing krillin'

1:21:07

great, apart from the feeling of guilt,

1:21:10

is it we are alive? But I think

1:21:12

every Ukrainian has this guilt. But

1:21:14

we've been on a very amazing travel.

1:21:16

We visited subscribers of my YouTube channel

1:21:18

in Florida and we visited some 360.

1:21:21

Kite visited Everglades. It's your dream

1:21:23

destination because when she was in the basement,

1:21:25

she was saying that she wants to become

1:21:27

a crocodile and eat food.

1:21:29

So she saw the place of the crocodile. And

1:21:32

we also visited the Canada Space

1:21:34

Center and my children, they touched

1:21:36

the 360 of the moon. And I learned

1:21:38

in the many things think about America, you

1:21:40

know, the worst of 360, when he said,

1:21:42

we go to the moon, we choose to go to the moon.

1:21:46

360 do things because

1:21:48

they are not because they are easy, but because

1:21:50

they are hard. And this

1:21:53

is the real America. And America is

1:21:55

a great country and other grateful

1:21:57

to American people who

1:21:59

are helping us. And

1:22:01

in all these people that were visited.

1:22:04

They are both Democrats and

1:22:06

Republicans, but it doesn't

1:22:08

matter when we talk about

1:22:10

humanity 360, you know, freedom

1:22:13

about this values it, unite

1:22:15

all of us, you know, people of different political

1:22:17

use in America and in

1:22:20

Ukraine and in other countries. We just

1:22:22

have to be united, and we have to be

1:22:24

strong, and we have to be bravely like

1:22:26

Ukraine. Now, brave like my daughter wanted

1:22:29

to become a crocodile and eat

1:22:31

Putin. Putin has to be punished.

1:22:33

Russia is behaving like a 360,

1:22:35

and it will not stop behaving like a terrorist.

1:22:38

Until it is stopped by

1:22:39

force. Well, in the United

1:22:42

States, we are lucky to have you here

1:22:44

if only temporarily I hope

1:22:46

you get to get back to your country

1:22:47

soon. And while I understand the feelings of guilt,

1:22:50

you didn't ask for this. This was done to you. We

1:22:52

thank you 360, very much.

1:22:55

Thank

1:22:56

you. Thank

1:22:56

you. It's always on Earth. Thank you.

1:22:58

Up next,

1:23:00

more on the question that matters so much to

1:23:02

Elena and so many others. Namely, whether

1:23:04

Putin will in fact ever face trial.

1:23:06

We're gonna look at how the International Criminal Court

1:23:09

has brought some of history's other bad actors

1:23:11

to justice AND PROVIDED ACCOUNTABILITY

1:23:13

FOR SOME OF THE PLANET'S WORST MOMENTS

1:23:16

OF INJUSTICE. UNTOUCHABLE

1:23:19

ABOVE THE LAW, 360 TO THINK

1:23:21

SOMEONE LIKE Vladimir Putin, the leader of

1:23:23

global nuclear power, would ever end

1:23:25

up in international custody in go

1:23:27

on trial for war crimes. But

1:23:30

there have been some cases in history where those

1:23:32

seemingly invincible have been held to

1:23:34

account. Matthew Chants has more.

1:23:37

The suspected crime of overseeing the

1:23:40

abduction of Ukrainian children has

1:23:42

earned Vladimir Putin and Maria

1:23:44

LaVolva Belva a place in

1:23:46

a rogue's gallery of alleged

1:23:48

war criminals. Although the ICC

1:23:51

established in the Hague in two thousand and

1:23:53

two, has a checkered record

1:23:55

of bringing those accused of wrongdoing

1:23:58

to justice. Mister Thomas 360 Daido

1:24:01

is guilty of the crimes of ripping and

1:24:03

enlisting children. It took the

1:24:05

court nearly ten years to

1:24:07

get its first conviction. Thomas

1:24:09

Lebanger of the Democratic Republic

1:24:11

of Congo sentence for his role

1:24:14

in recruiting child soldiers. 360

1:24:17

ICC cases have focused on

1:24:19

African states prompting criticism

1:24:22

of disproportionality. 360 former

1:24:25

leader, Momo 360, was charged

1:24:27

with crimes against humanity 360 twenty

1:24:30

eleven. We are implementing that with

1:24:33

clear signals to

1:24:35

those who commit crimes in Libya

1:24:38

or elsewhere. You

1:24:41

cannot gain power or

1:24:43

retain power, 360 drugs as

1:24:45

humanity. The wall will not allow you

1:24:47

to do it. But he was brutally

1:24:50

killed by a Libyan mob before

1:24:52

he could be brought to justice. Before

1:24:54

the ICC, war crimes were

1:24:56

handled by special UN tribunals.

1:24:59

Like that set up to prosecute war crimes

1:25:01

perpetrated in the 360 war

1:25:03

and break up of Yugoslavia. 360 the

1:25:08

high profile trial of SLOBIN

1:25:10

AMOLOSOVICH, the former Eugoslav president,

1:25:13

for the mass killing of innocent people.

1:25:15

I consider this tribunal of force

1:25:18

tribunal an indictment's

1:25:20

force indictment It

1:25:23

is illegal. He died in

1:25:25

jail before his trial ended

1:25:27

denying many the justice they

1:25:29

yearned for. Ratcoma Laddich,

1:25:31

the Bosnian Serb military leader,

1:25:34

was indicted in nineteen ninety

1:25:36

five, but evaded arrest until

1:25:38

twenty eleven The court found

1:25:40

he was guilty of

1:25:41

genocide. And in twenty seventeen,

1:25:43

he began a lifetime prison sentence.

1:25:47

That the bill sentence you sentences

1:25:49

you did by Hayne. But

1:25:51

it was, of course, the new rub rubrics

1:25:53

trials of prominent Nat after

1:25:56

the Second World War had set the standard

1:25:58

for war crimes prosecutions as

1:26:01

far less unity among nations

1:26:03

today, though, about who is guilty

1:26:05

and who is knowledge. And despite

1:26:07

the indictment, few expect the

1:26:10

Russian leader ever to

1:26:12

see the inside of a

1:26:13

court. Matthew Chants,

1:26:15

CNN, London.

1:26:18

Perhaps justice will prevail. The

1:26:20

news continues here on CNN right after

1:26:23

a quick break.

1:26:27

This podcast is supported by ADT.

1:26:29

ADT is taking your home security to the

1:26:31

next level, by offering the installation

1:26:34

and integration of Google Nest devices.

1:26:36

Now you can make nest doorbells as well

1:26:38

as indoor and outdoor nest cams part

1:26:41

of your ADT smart home security system.

1:26:43

Nest devices have built in intelligence

1:26:46

and smarter notifications. So your

1:26:48

cameras can tell the difference between a person

1:26:50

and animal a vehicle. The nest

1:26:52

doorbell even recognizes packages. Plus,

1:26:55

your ADT video or complete service

1:26:57

comes with Nest aware, which adds thirty

1:27:00

days of event video history and

1:27:02

even smarter notifications. With

1:27:04

Nestaware, you can add notifications like

1:27:06

familiar face alerts, which lets you

1:27:08

know who's coming and going. Now 360

1:27:11

can get trusted security from ADT.

1:27:13

With the added power of Google Nest cam's

1:27:15

indoorbells. Go to ADT dot com

1:27:18

today or call one eight hundred ADT

1:27:20

AS

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features