Podchaser Logo
Home
Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Released Wednesday, 29th March 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Nashville shooter bought seven guns legally and was under care for an emotional disorder

Wednesday, 29th March 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Introducing ADT self-setup,

0:02

featuring everything from motion sensors to

0:05

Google nest cams. It can be easily

0:07

installed at your convenience and adapts as

0:09

your needs change. You can add more products

0:11

at any time and your system easily moves

0:13

wherever life takes you. Plus,

0:16

when every second counts, you can trust ADT's

0:18

24-7 professional monitoring. When

0:20

the most trusted name in home security adds the

0:23

intelligence of Google, you've got a home

0:25

with no worries. Go to ADT.com

0:27

today or call 1-800-ADT-ASAP.

0:30

Good

0:32

evening, tonight, newly released body camera video

0:34

from the police officers who confronted and killed

0:37

a mass shooter at the Covenant School in Nashville.

0:39

We're gonna show it to you, but first we wanna tell you

0:41

what we know about those who were murdered, about

0:44

their lives, not just how their lives ended.

0:46

Three adults and three children at the school were

0:48

killed yesterday. Mike Hill was

0:50

the school custodian. Students called him

0:52

Big Mike. He loved the kids at the school

0:55

and his job, He loved his own kids

0:57

so much. There were seven of them and

0:59

his 14 grandchildren as well. He

1:01

loved to spend time with them and to cook, his family

1:03

says. He was just 61 years old. Cynthia

1:07

Peake also was 61. She was a substitute

1:09

teacher at the school. Family friend tells local

1:11

station WSMV she lived most of her life

1:14

in Alabama, recently moved to Nashville

1:16

with her husband. She had three children

1:18

of her own. Katherine Coons was

1:20

head of the school. She was 60.

1:22

A former student with learning disability that

1:25

Ms. Coons never gave up on him, telling WSMV

1:28

that there are too many educators who do.

1:30

The world, he said, needs more people like

1:33

her. Hallie Scruggs'

1:35

dad was the pastor of Covenant Presbyterian Church,

1:37

which runs the school. Hallie was in the

1:39

third grade, just nine years old.

1:41

Evelyn Dickhouse's family said she was

1:44

a shining light. Our hearts are

1:46

completely broken. We cannot believe

1:48

this has happened, they said in a statement today.

1:50

Evelyn, too, was just nine.

1:52

We don't have photos of William Kinney, also

1:55

nine years old. a family friend said that he

1:57

loved his sisters, adored his parents and grandparents.

2:00

with unfailingly kind and gentle and

2:02

quick to laugh. Sweet Will, as

2:04

she called him, knew no strangers, she said.

2:07

But a stranger did come into his school yesterday

2:09

and killed Sweet Will and Evelyn and

2:11

Hallie, Mike, Cynthia and Catherine.

2:14

What we're about to show you was released by the police

2:16

today, and it shows you how the killer was stopped.

2:19

Videos from two officers, which we've synchronized

2:22

to the clock, so you can see from each viewpoint

2:24

what actually happened as it happened.

2:27

It's hard to watch, there's no doubt about it, but

2:29

you won't see any bloodshed, you won't see any actual violence.

2:32

You will hear gunfire, however.

2:34

It's a little more than three minutes, but it shows you

2:36

what police are up against. In a situation like

2:38

this, it shows you the reality of

2:40

what's happening far too often in this country.

2:43

The video starts with one officer's camera

2:45

and is later joined in sync with the second officer's.

2:49

So, just in that day, it's gonna be first floor main

2:52

lobby of what? I'm making entry on the front

2:54

side. Yeah, yeah. So we have to put it in here.

2:57

OK. John,

3:06

OK. They're all locked down, but

3:08

we have two kids that we don't know where they are. OK.

3:10

OK? Yes ma'am.

3:26

Yeah. Into my windows, they're

3:28

upstairs. Hey!

3:33

Gimme three! Let's get

3:36

three.

3:48

Let's go. I need three. One more!

3:52

One more! Let's

3:55

go! Metropolice!

4:02

Open door! On

4:05

me, on me! I don't know where he is!

4:08

Metropolice! Open door! Back

4:10

in the bathroom, small bathroom. There you go,

4:12

second floor! That's it. Let's

4:17

go! Let's go!

4:21

Let's go! Let's go! Let's

4:24

go! All

4:26

right, let's

4:29

go. All

4:33

right, let's go. Your door.

4:35

Where do they go in? With me. First

4:39

floor. First floor. Hold

4:41

there, y'all. Somebody

4:43

hold there. Get that door. Oh,

4:47

but I got it. I got it. Go,

4:52

go, go! Move!

5:01

Oh I'm

5:04

with you Take

5:08

this, take this. It's

5:10

locked. No,

5:14

it's locked. Take this, go. Take

5:19

this door, take it. Go,

5:23

go, go, go, go, go,

5:25

go. Go,

5:28

go, go, go. go.

5:40

It's up there. Keep

5:43

pushing. Go. Shots

5:49

fired shots fired. Mike distributions

5:57

BANG! BANG! BANG! BANG!

6:03

Push the L.P.V.O. Push the

6:05

L.P.V.O. Don't write. We

6:09

love you. Some

6:17

professional perspective now from CNN, Senior

6:19

Law Enforcement Analyst and former FBI Deputy Director

6:21

Andrew McCabe. Andrew, it's really stunning

6:23

to see that you get, I mean, just the...

6:27

First of all, the coordination that they showed, and

6:30

when they heard shots

6:33

after trying to clear rooms,

6:36

the thing that stood out to me is there

6:38

was no pause from them of stopping

6:40

in the hallway seeking cover.

6:42

They in fact accelerated toward the gunfire.

6:47

Anderson, law enforcement in this country

6:49

takes a lot of criticism and we're

6:52

not perfect, we get some things wrong, but you

6:54

see the heart pounding intensity

6:58

of what those men, the

7:00

way they executed their responsibilities

7:02

and lived up to the oath that they swore under

7:05

unbelievable danger

7:07

and pressure. It's remarkable.

7:10

And yeah, what

7:12

you see there is a very highly

7:14

trained, well-coordinated response.

7:16

You see them shouting at each other and

7:18

touching each other on the shoulder and

7:21

they're not yelling for no reason. They're communicating

7:24

in an incredibly loud and chaotic

7:26

environment. You know, when you're the first person

7:28

in that, of that group of the few officers,

7:31

you cannot take your eyes off

7:33

of what you're looking at, looking for that threat.

7:35

So you can't turn around to see if your cover person

7:37

is still behind you or if you've left them. So

7:40

you wait for that tap on the shoulder. You wait

7:42

for them to say, move, move, forward,

7:44

push. And that's all

7:46

what you see happening there. They're clearing room after

7:48

room quickly. They're not slowing down. And

7:51

as soon as they hear those gunshots go, they

7:53

run to it. And that's what makes the difference

7:56

in limiting the loss of life. So.

8:00

Yeah, it's a remarkable video. It's hard

8:02

to watch. Hard to watch. Yeah, incredibly

8:04

disturbing. It's also interesting to

8:06

me that, you know, the officer whose body camera we

8:09

see first who arrives and immediately gets out of the vehicle,

8:11

gets his long gun,

8:14

hears a little bit from one

8:16

of the school administrators or a teacher about

8:18

the locations of things and what may be happening,

8:20

and then calls out, I need three,

8:23

I assume that means I need three other people with me

8:25

because it looked like there were at least two other police cars

8:27

there at the time.

8:29

I'm not sure how many officers had already been there, but

8:31

he's basically getting kind of a stack together,

8:33

getting a group together to actually

8:36

move in. That is standard procedure now.

8:39

That's exactly right. He gets out of his car, he

8:41

doesn't know how many people are in there or how many are not.

8:44

He just knows he's got a long gun, he's gotta

8:46

get in there. He heads for the door where

8:48

he sees another officer or somebody directing

8:50

him towards that door. And he just, you

8:52

know, you ideally, you wanna go in

8:54

as two, three, four people. And

8:57

so he calls out what he needs and

9:00

presumably he gets that support. If not,

9:03

he's going in anyway because he hears

9:05

that person from the school tell them that there

9:07

are shots being fired. So

9:10

it's a very quick rally

9:12

and they get inside and they find

9:14

the threat. There's no standing

9:17

around the hallway talking about it, asking for

9:19

extra equipment or more people. They

9:21

got to get the job done. Yeah, that was Officer Engelbert

9:23

who did all that, that

9:25

main body camera video we saw. It was also

9:27

interesting, the person from the

9:29

school said, you know, it's down

9:32

far at the end of the hall, there were shots,

9:36

there may be people there. And then she also

9:38

talked about people upstairs.

9:40

That message clearly got through again to

9:42

officers on the scene, because when the second body camera

9:45

comes in, it appears that that officer

9:47

and maybe other officers

9:49

are moving up to that second

9:51

floor location. Again, I'm surmising

9:53

here, but that's what it appears. I

9:55

assume that information from the

9:57

school administrator was...

9:59

which is, again,

10:01

something that in Yuvalde, communication

10:03

seemed to be a real issue.

10:05

That's absolutely right. You know, it

10:07

was remarkable to me that when

10:09

she first addresses him on the sidewalk there, his

10:12

response is, yes, ma'am. And he replies

10:15

in a very under-controlled, kind

10:17

of composed way, a courteous way. He

10:20

knows where he's going. He knows

10:22

what he's about to face. But this is somebody who's not

10:24

panicking. He is dedicated and focused

10:26

on what he has to do. She also gives him some very

10:28

important information information about where the children

10:30

are. She says most of the children have been

10:33

evacuated or are on lockdown and he

10:35

needs to

10:35

know that as he goes inside so he can

10:37

figure out which rooms need to be searched, where

10:40

kids need to be protected, and which ones he can potentially

10:43

go past or spend less time on. It's also

10:45

interesting because you know people never know,

10:47

I mean even officers who have been on the job

10:49

for a long time, very

10:51

often times an officer doesn't

10:53

take his gun out or or actually fire a shot

10:56

on the police force for years, if

10:59

at all in an actual environment

11:02

like this.

11:03

You never know how you're actually

11:05

going to respond, whether it's a combat zone

11:07

or for police, whether

11:10

you're going to become hyper-focused and laser-focused

11:13

and calm, or whether you're going to freak out.

11:16

Clearly, I mean, again, just from what he

11:18

said to the school administrator,

11:20

that officer seemed extraordinarily

11:23

focused on the task at hand?

11:25

He does, and you

11:27

know, I don't know what his personal experience has been.

11:29

Maybe he's been in situations like this or combat

11:31

before, but maybe it's just the result

11:34

of incredibly dedicated training.

11:36

You know, you don't know until you're in that

11:38

moment in a crisis situation, but the

11:40

best you can do is prepare and train

11:43

and train. You see when he reaches into the back of the

11:45

car, he knows exactly where he's going. The

11:47

gun is in the bag, it's ready. He doesn't

11:49

have to reassemble things or reload magazines.

11:52

that officer is prepared when he gets

11:54

on the scene.

11:55

And that shows you he's somebody who

11:57

is thought through what he's gonna need. he gets

11:59

in. before he gets in the car to leave on his shift.

12:02

He knows where his gear is in

12:04

the back. He knows how to get to it quickly. That's

12:06

how you save lives. Yeah, Andrew McCabe,

12:08

I appreciate it. Thank you. President Biden today renewed

12:10

his call for lawmakers to pass a ban on so-called

12:13

assault weapons just short of 19 years

12:15

since the 1994 version expired and wasn't

12:17

renewed. He also signaled how constrained

12:19

he says he is as chief executive to do more,

12:22

telling reporters, quote, I can't do anything except

12:24

plead with the Congress to act reasonably. As

12:26

for what Congress will do, so far Democrats have yet to

12:28

decide how to proceed

12:30

or if to proceed and fair to say many if

12:32

not most Republicans aren't willing to Proceed

12:34

at all in the house at least on any gun restrictions

12:37

There's

12:37

what some of them said or flat-out refused to say when

12:39

asked by reporters including our men are on a Raju

12:41

I appreciate it.

12:43

What happened in Nashville is obviously incredibly serious. Do

12:46

you not think it will require a response from the state

12:48

of the house? Do you

12:50

think there will

12:52

be any gun restrictions at all?

12:55

I think with respect to any

12:58

discussion of legislation, it's

13:00

premature. You seem to indicate there is nothing

13:03

more Congress can do in terms of... You

13:05

know, we want to legislate evil.

13:07

It's just not going to happen. We

13:10

need real revival in this country. Why does the

13:12

president have a Corvette in his garage that will do 115 miles

13:14

an hour, not 55? Because

13:17

it's freedom. I believe in the Second Amendment. And

13:21

we shouldn't

13:24

penalize law-abiding American

13:25

citizens. Before they even know the

13:27

facts, the first thing they talk about is taking

13:29

guns away from law-abiding citizens. People

13:31

are allowed to possess firearms. Need

13:34

is in the eye of the beholder. I

13:37

don't question why you need a blue suit, but you got one. But you got one

13:39

what should be done to protect

13:41

people like your little girlfriend being safe at school Well,

13:45

we homeschooled That

13:47

is Tennessee Congressman Tim Birgitte

13:49

who also said he does not see quote any real

13:52

role for Congress in the wake of yesterday's slaughter

13:54

This morning, Senate Chaplain Barry Black argued

13:57

there certainly is.

14:00

Lord, when babies

14:03

die at a church school,

14:07

it is time for us to move

14:10

beyond thoughts and

14:14

prayers. Remind

14:17

our lawmakers of

14:19

the words of the British statesman

14:23

Edmund Burke. All

14:26

that is necessary for

14:29

evil to triumph is

14:33

for good people to

14:36

do nothing.

14:39

And Chaplain Barry Black joins us now.

14:41

Chaplain, I appreciate you being with us. Is

14:45

evil triumphing? Are good men

14:47

doing nothing? Well,

14:50

I think indeed there

14:54

is a triumph of evil

14:56

when six people die

15:00

in such a horrific way. And And

15:03

of course, we've had to

15:05

face challenges

15:08

like this repeatedly. There

15:11

is almost a danger of desensitization.

15:15

I think that

15:17

there are

15:19

people who are doing something,

15:21

but that we can do more.

15:24

And I believe that

15:26

when you are faced with a challenge, you

15:29

have to expect setbacks and

15:32

failures, but you

15:35

persevere until you

15:37

find better ways of solving

15:40

the problem.

15:41

I remember when

15:44

I was very young, probably pre-teen,

15:49

JFK talked about putting a

15:51

a person on the moon and bringing

15:53

that person back

15:55

to

15:56

Earth by the end of the decade.

16:00

he must have inhaled something

16:02

to embrace that kind of optimistic

16:06

challenge. But with

16:12

setbacks and challenges, they

16:14

managed

16:16

to accomplish that goal time

16:18

and time again.

16:20

When Americans

16:21

have made

16:24

up their minds, we're going

16:26

to tackle this problem and solve

16:28

it, that

16:29

they have eventually done so.

16:32

And so that is what

16:34

I am challenging us to

16:36

do. One of the purposes of government

16:40

is to hold evil in check.

16:43

So the idea that there is nothing

16:45

that

16:46

government can do

16:48

is not true of the

16:50

facts of our history. In your

16:53

prayer, you also said, deliver

16:56

our senators from the paralysis of an analysis

16:59

that waits for the miraculous.

17:02

Talk about that a little bit. You also said it's

17:04

time to move beyond thoughts and prayers. What does that look

17:06

like moving beyond thoughts and prayers?

17:09

I think moving beyond

17:11

thoughts

17:13

and prayers,

17:15

it means doing

17:18

something. Praying is doing something,

17:20

but it is ethereal. The

17:23

first Psalm verse 3

17:26

talking about the happy

17:29

believer says, whatever

17:31

he or she does will

17:33

prosper. God

17:37

prospers what we do. And

17:40

so we have to begin

17:42

to try some things that

17:44

may be counterintuitive. intuitive. It

17:47

took Thomas Edison

17:49

thousands of attempts

17:51

before he found the filament for

17:53

the incandescent light bulb,

17:55

but he thought

17:57

that these were steps.

18:00

toward accomplishing that goal

18:02

and eventually he did. So

18:04

I am talking about developing a proclivity

18:08

for substantive action

18:11

and not just waiting

18:14

for something

18:16

beatific to occur because

18:20

of the movement of the transcendent.

18:22

Chaplain Black, I appreciate your time tonight. Thank you.

18:26

Thank you. Coming

18:28

up next the AR-15 type rifle

18:30

that this killer and so many others have carried why

18:33

It's so deadly and what if anything might be

18:35

done to keep it out of the wrong hands Later

18:38

what a judge told former vice president Mike Pence

18:40

about what he'll have to tell grand jurors and why

18:42

his former boss Will

18:44

not be happy with that decision

18:49

This show is sponsored by better help the

18:51

ancient philosopher Aristotle once wrote

18:54

knowing yourself is the beginning of all wisdom

18:56

On your journey of self-discovery,

18:59

BetterHelp wants you to know they're here for

19:01

you. Just fill out a brief questionnaire

19:03

to get matched with a licensed therapist and

19:05

switch therapists anytime for no additional

19:07

charge. 100% online.

19:10

Discover your potential with BetterHelp. Visit

19:13

BetterHelp.com slash ac360

19:15

today to get 10% off your first

19:18

month. That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P

19:20

dot com slash ac360.

19:24

How long does it take to tackle a home

19:26

project? With Angie, you

19:28

could cross it off your list before this ad

19:30

is over. Just select the service

19:32

you need at an upfront price and Angie

19:34

handles the rest, sending a top pro

19:37

to get it done. You don't have to lift

19:39

a finger, except to tap the screen

19:41

or click the mouse. Plus, Angie

19:43

is free to use, so bring them your next

19:46

home project and they'll bring it home. Download

19:48

the app or go to Angie.com. It's

19:51

A-N-G-I dot com to get

19:54

started.

19:55

and

20:00

the Nashville mass killer was carrying one. Light,

20:02

easy to carry, easy to shoot, the AR-15 variants

20:05

of it are civilian versions of the US military's M16

20:07

series. And like the M16, they

20:09

fire relatively small caliber bullet at

20:11

very high velocity.

20:13

What that does to a human body used to be only

20:15

seen in wartime. We're now from CNN's

20:17

Josh Campbell.

20:21

They're known as assault style weapons. Their

20:23

deadly firepower seen yet again. When

20:26

a shooter opened fire on an elementary school

20:28

in Nashville, Tennessee.

20:29

It's just the latest. From Yuvaldi,

20:32

Tulsa, and El Paso, to Parkland,

20:34

San Bernardino, and Sandy Hook, the

20:37

high-powered assault rifle has been the weapon of

20:39

choice for many of the killers. Line is hot.

20:44

The Los Angeles Police Department demonstrates

20:47

an AR-style semi-automatic rifle for

20:49

us on the department's gun range. You have

20:51

a 16-inch to 20-inch barrel. You

20:53

have a stock that is shouldered. You

20:56

are gonna be accurate at farther distances

20:59

as opposed to a pistol. Not to mention, like

21:01

some other weapons, it can fire a bullet with

21:03

enough power to pierce soft body armor,

21:06

something Sergeant James Zabora Van knows firsthand.

21:09

Jesus, it's definitely an automatic

21:11

weapon. He took assault weapons fire

21:13

during the now infamous 1997

21:14

North Hollywood shootout, where

21:17

two bank robbers wearing body armor fired

21:19

on police for nearly an hour,

21:21

injuring eight people and 12 officers, including

21:24

Sergeant Zabora Van. You're being hit

21:26

with pieces of the vehicles were

21:28

hiding behind asphalt, radiator

21:31

fluid, felt like we're being stunned by bees.

21:33

That shooting changed policy, prompting

21:35

the LAPD and other departments to upgrade

21:38

their own weaponry to counter the increasingly

21:40

powerful guns used by assailants. That

21:43

fire power from weapons is studied inside

21:45

a ballistics lab at Wayne State University

21:48

where researchers simulate a bullet's impact

21:50

on the human body.

21:51

It's a block of 20% gelatin

21:54

and it's meant to the human tissues. So

21:56

soft tissues. Watch as Cynthia Burz team

21:58

fires a Second, elves have a the

22:02

For this particular round you'll see the bullet coming in on this

22:04

side. You see this temporary cavity here

22:06

happening. So that expansion

22:09

is what happens in the body and then it collapses

22:11

down. So that's where your damage comes

22:13

in. Now

22:13

watch as the team fires a round from

22:15

an assault rifle. We see a lot more

22:17

disruption. This round actually breaks

22:19

apart. It doesn't exit so it's about

22:22

3,000 feet per second and all

22:24

of that energy goes into the soft tissue. We have a piece

22:27

of plastic here of plastic here to reflect to do

22:29

the videos and it actually lifted

22:31

the plastic up off the table with the energy.

22:33

An aftermath photo of the handgun round

22:36

shows a relatively straight line through the

22:38

tissue exiting the other side.

22:40

But not so with the round from an AR-15. It

22:43

basically goes into the body and creates an explosion

22:46

inside the body. Trauma surgeons say

22:48

the wound from an assault rifle can be catastrophic.

22:51

And the worst part is in a child, all the

22:53

vital organs are that much closer together. So

22:55

each of those bullets causes, you

22:58

know,

22:58

irreversible damage. In Yovoldi,

23:00

Texas, families were asked for DNA swabs

23:03

to help the authorities identify their children.

23:05

As a mom, it really affects me, right?

23:08

Because I cannot imagine having

23:11

a child endure this. And

23:14

with high-capacity magazines, suspects

23:16

can shoot for much longer. Now the discussion

23:19

about high-capacity magazines largely centers

23:21

on reducing the amount of of time that a suspect

23:24

can fire without having to reload. As

23:26

a former FBI agent, we were trained to quickly

23:28

get your weapon reloaded and back up on target.

23:31

But for a suspect, for example, who isn't trained,

23:33

you can see using this training weapon, that is

23:35

a process. It involves removing the

23:37

empty magazine, obtaining a fresh

23:40

round of ammunition, loading it into the

23:42

weapon, charging the weapon, getting it

23:44

back up on target. Those are all precious

23:46

seconds where victims can be fleeing. The

23:48

gun can jam or the suspect could be

23:50

engaged law enforcement or bystanders.

23:54

Regardless

24:01

of where one comes down on the gun control debate,

24:03

it's indisputable that the assault weapon

24:06

causes significant damage inside the body.

24:08

Definitely. But this is the reality.

24:11

This is what's happening. Josh Campbell,

24:13

CNN, Los Angeles.

24:16

This is What is Happening Time and Time Again, joining

24:18

us to CNN's senior political commentators,

24:20

former Illinois Republican Congressman Adam Kinziger and

24:23

David Axelrod, former senior advisor to President Obama.

24:26

David, I mean, I don't know how many times you and I have

24:28

had this discussion. Is there any chance

24:31

of anything actually getting done in Congress?

24:33

You know, I'm eager to hear from Adam on this, but I'm

24:36

very, very doubtful. You know, last

24:38

year we passed a relatively

24:41

modest gun control

24:43

or gun safety law out of the United

24:46

States Congress after Yuvaldi.

24:49

And still

24:52

Republicans in the House, led by Kevin McCarthy,

24:56

moved against it. There were 14

24:58

Republicans who were willing to stand up. Adam Kinzinger

25:01

was one of them. But now

25:03

Kevin McCarthy is the Speaker of the House. And

25:06

I see no evidence in his reaction to

25:08

this latest tragedy that he has

25:10

changed his view on this issue at all.

25:12

Congressman, as David said, you were one of 14 House Republicans

25:15

who voted for the new gun safety legislation

25:17

last June. You're also a member of the military, supporter of

25:19

the Second Amendment.

25:21

I mean, AR-15s aren't going away,

25:23

it seems. Senator Murphy last night mentioned

25:26

the idea of, you know, maybe someday mandating

25:28

training before somebody could get one.

25:30

Is anything possible to move on this?

25:33

Yeah, I mean, I think David's right, probably

25:36

not right now. And I can tell you the inside

25:38

of what a conference, the Republican conference

25:40

is like right now, because I sat

25:43

through that for 12 years, which is every time there's

25:45

a mass shooting, you basically are sitting around

25:47

and you can't wait till the next story overtakes

25:50

this one. And that's why you're gonna

25:52

stay quiet, you're not getting comments from these members.

25:54

Look, I think what we have to do is, you know, there

25:57

are folks that probably very rightfully their

25:59

mind advocate.

26:00

for a complete ban of ARs, and

26:02

there are some that won't even address the issue. There is

26:04

middle ground here. Look, this is

26:06

an exception, but a lot of these school shootings

26:08

that happen, or mass shootings, are people under

26:11

the age of 21. You have to be 21

26:13

in America to buy a handgun. In many

26:16

states, you only have to be 18 to buy

26:18

an AR. Well, that's one thing. And why

26:20

is it that you have to be licensed to drive

26:22

a car in this country, in every state?

26:25

But yet there are states now that are moving to say You

26:28

don't even have to have a license to conceal carry.

26:30

I can seal carry. I have a license to conceal

26:33

carry. And why don't we say that with

26:35

ARs, at least in the near term, maybe

26:37

you have to have a license to have one of those too. Look,

26:39

if you are somebody that's sitting around saying,

26:41

look, you know, I'm not going to go do a mass

26:43

shooting with my AR, which is 99.99 repeating percent of

26:47

those gun owners,

26:48

then I don't think you'd be upset about going and getting

26:51

a license to own one. These are intermediary

26:53

steps, but everybody, particularly

26:55

my party right now, the Republicans, are too scared

26:58

to talk about this. They couldn't even raise the age

27:00

to 21. It does seem also, you know,

27:02

Congressman, if you're, you know, at

27:05

a gun range, you want people who are also at

27:07

a gun range who have training, who know what they're

27:09

doing, and are not going to shoot somebody,

27:11

you know, taking their

27:14

AR out of the case it's in.

27:17

Yeah, there's multiple points to this. So, number

27:19

one, one of the better things about getting licensed

27:21

to conceal carry is you learn the

27:23

laws in the state. For instance, Illinois

27:26

has a much different standard for when you

27:28

can shoot somebody in your home than,

27:30

say, Texas does, right? So you

27:32

get to learn that stuff. The other thing is, people

27:35

assume, I think, a lot that a

27:38

police officer with a handgun against

27:40

an assailant with an AR is an even match.

27:43

It is the furthest thing from an even match. I've

27:45

shot ARs. I've shot them both in the military

27:47

and in the civilian sector. They are much more

27:49

accurate. They have much better

27:52

ability to hit somebody at a distance than

27:54

a pistol does. So this idea

27:56

that it's the same thing, it's not. Recognize

27:58

that. And that's why I think as a country...

28:00

And a step is to say maybe you have

28:02

to go through some training to understand what these things can

28:04

really do David I mean there is a line

28:07

for Democrats of thinking well, this

28:09

doesn't necessarily drive people to the polls It's

28:11

not the top issue that people say they vote on

28:14

or hasn't been traditionally

28:17

And there's concern about driving

28:19

voters I guess to Republicans

28:22

among some Democrats. Yeah, I mean,

28:24

I think that's been true Historically,

28:26

it may still be true today I

28:28

think if there were a chance to pass some

28:31

really significant legislation that you'd see

28:33

the vast majority of Democrats do

28:35

it, but I think that there is a reluctance to

28:37

push it if at the end

28:39

of the day there are those who are gonna have To walk

28:42

the plank as it were to vote

28:44

for something that has an uncertain future

28:47

so You know, I

28:49

mean, I don't I think people should stand up on

28:51

this issue and I appreciate everything that Adam

28:55

is saying, I still don't understand exactly

28:57

why weapons that he uses in war

28:59

are ones that people

29:01

should casually have on

29:04

their own. And they

29:06

have increased exponentially since

29:09

the ban on assault weapons went out in 2004.

29:11

So the point where we have 20 million

29:14

of them or so, or 20 million people own

29:16

them.

29:17

And, you know, even

29:20

if we passed a law, it'd be very hard at

29:22

this point to enforce it. Yeah, David Axelrod,

29:25

Adam Kinziger. Thanks so much. Appreciate it. Coming up the latest

29:27

on whether

29:28

that Manhattan grand jury investigating the former president will

29:30

make a decision this week. Plus a judge

29:32

telling former vice president Mike Pence, he has

29:34

to testify about his private conversations

29:36

with then president Trump

29:38

in the weeks and days leading up to January 6. Pence

29:40

has just spoken out about it. What he said next

29:42

sources tell CNN that the Manhattan

29:44

grand jury investigating the former president's role

29:47

in an alleged hush money scheme involving an adult film

29:49

star will not hear the case again this week. Source

29:51

also tells CNN the grand jury adjourned Monday without

29:53

taking a vote on whether to indict. So that means no

29:56

answer this week on whether there there will be an indictment

29:58

or not. in a separate investigation

30:00

with potentially more serious consequences

30:02

for the former president. Multiple sources tell CNN

30:04

the special counsel leading the federal probe

30:06

into his actions surrounding January 6th scored

30:09

a big legal victory involving testimony from Mike

30:11

Pence, who tells Newsmax he is now evaluating

30:14

the court's decision that he has to testify.

30:16

Our senior justice correspondent, Emprez, joins us.

30:18

So does CNN legal, so does CNN legal

30:21

analyst, Elliot Williams, a former federal prosecutor and a deputy

30:23

assistant attorney general. So Evan, talk more about

30:25

what this judge is, what he ruled, and

30:27

if he's given former vice president, Eni Leeway.

30:30

Well, Anderson, the important thing from this judge

30:33

is that he's basically saying that

30:35

there's plenty that Mike Pence

30:37

can talk about with prosecutors

30:39

as part of this investigation, the January 6th investigation.

30:43

Judge James Boseberg said that while

30:46

Mike Pence does have the

30:49

protection of the speech and debate clause

30:52

under the Constitution, as the

30:54

Senate president, he was serving as a Senate

30:56

president during part of this, he

30:59

does have to answer questions, however, for

31:02

everything leading up to January 6th when

31:04

he wasn't acting in that capacity.

31:07

So that means that there's a lot of questions that

31:10

the former vice president is going to be facing

31:12

when he goes before the grand jury. Now it

31:15

is important to note that there are limitations

31:18

that the Justice Department is going to have to observe. It

31:21

is not clear though Anderson, when

31:23

the former vice president goes before the

31:26

grand jury, where that line will

31:28

be. It may be that the judge will have to say, that

31:30

question is allowed, that question is not allowed.

31:33

Keep in mind, he was at the center of all

31:35

of this, right? He was the one that was facing

31:37

the pressure campaign by the former president and

31:40

his allies that he had the power,

31:42

they said, to not certify

31:45

the election of Joe Biden

31:47

as president. And so those are the

31:49

questions that really, I think

31:51

the prosecutors want to get at. Elliot, do you

31:54

know where that line is? Because that's confusing

31:56

then. I mean, if he does have to

31:58

testify about conversation.

32:00

he had with the former president, but maybe

32:02

there are some things he doesn't have to say. Do you know

32:04

where that one is? No, Anderson, there's a lot

32:06

of gray area here between Mike

32:09

Pence, the vice president of the United States,

32:11

who was also sort of Mike Pence, the candidate

32:13

for office, and Mike Pence, the guy whose boss

32:16

might be investigated by the Justice Department. Where do

32:19

you slice up where those different roles

32:21

lie and excise and take

32:23

out Mike Pence, the congressional

32:26

officer who was presiding over the

32:28

Senate. Now, anything he did in his capacity

32:31

as the person overseeing the Senate, as

32:33

president of the Senate, as the Constitution, well, that's

32:36

all protected. But where does everything else go? And

32:38

look, looking, I mean, we haven't seen this opinion

32:40

yet. It's all under seal. But there's something

32:42

for everybody to appeal in this. If Mike

32:44

Pence wished to appeal the fact that he

32:46

has to testify at all, he would have

32:48

a perfect basis for doing so. And the Justice

32:51

Department could actually say, you know, Your Honor, this

32:53

is actually quite vague. And

32:56

because Because of all the gray areas and sort of trying

32:58

to determine where exactly

33:00

or how much wiggle room the

33:02

former vice president has is actually quite

33:04

difficult and we really need clarity on this.

33:06

And, Elliott, do we know what specific information

33:08

about January 6th that investigators would like

33:11

to get out of the former vice president? Sure.

33:13

If the ruling stands up and he ends up complying? Absolutely.

33:16

And it's important, Anderson, to get out of the frame of

33:18

Mike Pence and Donald Trump were bickering and are mad at each

33:20

other, sort of the palace intrigue stuff. And where is there

33:23

legally operative information that could come from Mike Pence?

33:25

Number one, what evidence or information

33:27

did he hear about the president knowing

33:29

he was going to obstruct the actions of

33:31

Congress,

33:32

which is itself a federal offense? Was

33:34

the president — did the president make any threats to Mike

33:36

Pence? Was he aware of violence on

33:38

the day of January 6th? Was he aware

33:41

of any other crimes

33:43

that may have transpired? Those are all legally

33:46

relevant questions to charges that could

33:48

either come to the president or other people around

33:50

him. So yes, it's

33:53

interesting as a human matter, but

33:55

there's actually some law there, and Mike Pence is a

33:57

very central figure who might have heard important information.

34:00

Kevin, is it clear what phase this

34:02

investigation, the January 6th investigation is in at

34:04

this point?

34:05

Well, look, I mean, I think we often use the word accelerating,

34:07

but really, Anderson, I mean, we're getting the picture,

34:09

certainly with all of the legal activity you're

34:11

seeing. The prosecutors are giving

34:14

deadlines, very tight deadlines for

34:16

people to come in to the grand jury. People

34:18

who are asking for more time, they

34:20

don't get it. They're also going to the

34:22

appeals court in very accelerated

34:25

timelines. So it gives you the impression that

34:27

prosecutors certainly want to try to get everybody in

34:30

and then be able to make a decision

34:32

as to who they're going to charge or if they're going to charge

34:35

anyone. Now, we don't know who those

34:37

people will be. There could be some of the allies

34:40

of the former president, people who were very involved

34:42

in trying to overturn the election

34:44

results, right, and then push this whole idea of

34:46

fraud, could be the former president himself.

34:49

And so that is, right

34:51

now, what we know is, certainly

34:53

I think the political calendar is also playing

34:55

into this. I'm impressed, appreciate

34:57

it, Elliott Williams as well. quick programming

34:59

note in about 20 minutes, CNN prime time presents

35:01

inside the Trump investigations an hour

35:03

long in-depth look with CNN anchor

35:05

and chief investigative correspondent, Pamela Brown. At

35:08

the multiple investigations facing the former president,

35:10

she'll have new reporting on former vice president Pence's

35:12

mindset after the judge's ruling today, whether

35:15

he'll testify, that's at 9 p.m. Eastern tonight.

35:17

Coming up for us, we're gonna dive into the details of how separate

35:20

allegations made by two women about affairs

35:22

with the former president in the years before his election

35:25

turned

35:25

into a present day criminal investigation.

35:30

How long does it take to tackle a home

35:32

project? With Angie, you

35:34

could cross it off your list before this ad

35:36

is over.

35:37

Just select the service you need at an upfront

35:39

price and Angie handles the rest,

35:42

sending a top pro to get it done.

35:44

You don't have to lift a finger, except

35:46

to tap the screen or click the mouse. Plus,

35:49

Angie is free to use, so bring them

35:51

your next home project and they'll bring it

35:53

home. Download the app or go

35:56

to angie.com. That's A-N-G-I

35:59

dot com.

36:00

get started.

36:30

you get 30 days of event video history

36:32

and even smarter notifications, like when a

36:34

familiar or unfamiliar face is seen.

36:37

Plus, when every second counts, you can trust

36:39

ADT's 24-7 professional monitoring. You

36:42

can view video of an alarm event and

36:44

verify or cancel an alarm with

36:47

just a tap. When the most trusted name

36:49

in home security adds the intelligence of Google,

36:51

you've got a home with no worries. Go to ADT.com

36:54

today or call 1-800-ADT-ASAP. Google,

36:59

Nest Cam, Nest Doorbell, and Nest Aware

37:01

are trademarks of Google LLC.

37:04

As we mentioned earlier, we learned today

37:06

that the Manhattan grand jury investigating the former president

37:08

will not hear from any more witnesses this week.

37:11

Though yesterday, they heard from David Pecker, once a confidant

37:13

at Donald Trump. He was the former head of the company that

37:15

publishes the National Enquirer, and he's central

37:18

to the alleged hush money scheme under investigation. It's

37:20

a story I've covered on this broadcast, and on 60 Minutes

37:23

for some time now, and how Now it works

37:25

and the purpose of the alleged payoffs may determine

37:27

the severity of any charges the former president now

37:29

faces.

37:30

Randy Kay explains. And

37:33

you had sex with him? Yes.

37:36

You were 27, he was 60. Were

37:38

you physically attracted to him? No.

37:41

Porn star Stormy Daniels opening up to Anderson

37:43

Cooper about her alleged affair with Donald Trump.

37:46

She says she first met Trump at a celebrity golf tournament

37:48

in Lake Tahoe in July 2006. A

37:51

year later, she says they met at his bungalow

37:53

at the Beverly Hills Hotel. He came and sat next

37:56

to me and touched

37:58

my hair and put his hand on my leg.

38:00

Nearly a decade later during the 2016 campaign,

38:04

Stormy Daniels was shopping her story about

38:06

the alleged affair and says she got a

38:08

phone call from her lawyer saying, I

38:10

think I have the best deal for you. That

38:13

deal was essentially a non-disclosure

38:15

agreement, or NDA, a promise

38:17

to keep silent.

38:18

It came about after Daniels had approached

38:21

the National Enquirer with her story. At

38:23

the time, longtime Trump ally David

38:25

Pecker was running American Media

38:28

Inc., or AMI, which published

38:30

the National Enquirer.

38:31

The Enquirer forged an alliance

38:33

with Donald Trump. They would go out and

38:36

seek unflattering and usually tawdry

38:38

stories about Donald Trump,

38:40

and they would pay money

38:42

for the rights to those stories, which

38:45

entailed essentially muzzling the people

38:47

in possession of those stories. AMI's

38:49

Pekker helped broker the $130,000 hush money payment to Daniels.

38:54

Was it hush money to stay silent? Yes.

38:57

Pekker and one of his editors contacted

38:59

Trump's longtime lawyer Michael Cohen, who

39:01

then reached out to Daniels and offered

39:04

the $130,000 payment to make her story go away.

39:08

When Daniels threatened to take her story elsewhere,

39:11

court filings say Pekker called Cohen

39:13

on an encrypted phone app and said

39:15

the deal needed to be completed,

39:17

or it could look awfully bad for everyone.

39:21

Trump has denied the affair and any fault

39:23

with the payment.

39:24

Still, in the end, Daniels took

39:26

the deal. She signed the agreement 11 days

39:29

before Election Day in 2016. Playboy

39:33

model Karen McDougall says she too

39:35

was essentially muzzled by Pekka and AMI

39:38

after trying to sell her story about an alleged

39:40

affair with Trump. I met Donald when

39:42

they were filming the celebrity apprentice at

39:44

the Playboy mansion. She says she met Trump

39:46

in 2006, and their affair

39:49

lasted about 10 months.

39:51

Were you in love with him? I was, yeah. And

39:54

do you think he was in love with you? He was, yeah.

39:57

McDougall told Anderson she and her attorney

39:59

met with a...

40:00

AMI. You told them your story.

40:02

I told them the story. She says AMI

40:04

was only interested in buying her story

40:06

after Trump won the Republican nomination.

40:09

The side deal was, oh,

40:10

we're squashing the story. You think it's because of

40:12

a personal relationship with

40:14

the guy who runs AMI as

40:17

friends with Donald Trump? Correct. Federal

40:19

prosecutors cut a non-prosecution agreement

40:22

with American media back in 2018, ruling

40:25

out charges for the publisher.

40:27

As part of that agreement, AMI admitted

40:29

to paying Kerry McDougal $150,000 to prevent her

40:33

claims of an affair from being made

40:35

public.

40:38

And Anderson, in that interview with you,

40:41

you probably recall Kerry McDougal went into quite a

40:43

bit of detail about what was offered

40:45

as part of that catch and kill scheme, not only

40:47

the $150,000 to silence

40:49

her, but she also said that she had been promised

40:52

that She would be on magazine covers,

40:54

that she would be able to write columns

40:56

for their Health and Fitness magazine, which was

40:58

certainly a passion of hers, I should say.

41:03

And none of that ever really panned out for her,

41:05

but they were successful, of course, in

41:07

sinking her story before

41:08

Election Day, Anderson. Yeah, and that's

41:11

who testified on Monday, David Hecker,

41:13

Randy Kay. Thanks so much. Coming up, you'll notice

41:15

some names, including Sean Hannity and Tucker Carlson,

41:17

the Dominion Voting System wants testimony

41:20

from, and it's $1.6 billion defamation

41:22

lawsuit against Fox News. Who

41:24

else they want on the stand?

41:26

Next. Tonight, we're learning about who might be called

41:28

to testify in Dominion Voting System's $1.6 billion

41:30

defamation case against Fox News over the 2020

41:32

election. Both sides have some

41:34

similar names and ones you'll recognize. Senior

41:37

media reporter, Aldrich Darcy, joins us with details.

41:39

So what happened in court today? Well, this trial

41:41

is shaping up to be quite a high

41:43

profile case if it does actually move forward

41:45

a trial. They're learning some of the names that Dominion

41:48

and Fox hope to call to the stand. On

41:50

Dominion's front, they're hoping to call Fox

41:53

News CEO Suzanne Scott to the stand,

41:55

Fox News

41:56

president Jay Wallace and then notable

41:58

host people like Sean Hannity. Tucker

42:00

Carlson, Maria Bartiromo, Brett Baer,

42:02

people that are recognized by viewers.

42:05

So very high profile case if this

42:07

does move forward at trial. And how are the, how's

42:09

the judge been responding to the arguments

42:11

being made? It's safe to say he's not impressed with

42:14

Fox's arguments in court. A couple

42:16

times today he really scoffed at Fox's lawyers.

42:19

In one time they were talking about the objections

42:21

to the exhibits that Dominion wants to admit in a

42:24

trial and the judge- They're making sort of blanket objections

42:26

to all the exhibits. To everything. And the judge

42:28

said this to Fox. He says,

42:30

if I think you're going to be, to interrupt

42:32

testimony out of gamesmanship, you may

42:34

have a problem. Be careful people, keep

42:37

your powder dry on this stuff. This isn't

42:39

a game, this is a trial, and you're going to

42:41

be presenting to a jury.

42:43

And at another point in time, they were talking about Murdoch

42:45

and whether he can come to testify in

42:48

the case. And the judge told Fox's

42:50

lawyers this. He says, Mr. Murdoch

42:52

has claimed that he's traveling and that it

42:54

is an inconvenience. But

42:56

I also have people telling me that he's hardly

42:59

infirm and is able to travel around. I

43:01

think he recently got engaged on St. Patrick's

43:03

Day, and he said he looks forward to traveling between

43:05

his various residences in Montana,

43:07

New York, and London. And of course, we just

43:10

saw him at the Super Bowl with Elon Musk just

43:12

a few weeks ago. So I think the trial's scheduled for April

43:14

15th. Is it clear if it's actually gonna get to

43:16

trial? I mean, there could be a settlement, perhaps.

43:18

There could always be a settlement right before the clock

43:20

strikes midnight, but it looks like all

43:23

things are pointing to a trial happening in

43:25

just a few weeks, Anderson.

43:26

If there is no settlement,

43:29

the jury selection will begin on April

43:32

13th, and then this would go to trial

43:34

April 17th again, you'd see some really

43:36

big names appearing.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features