Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
The hugely popular Chinese
0:02
app TikTok may be
0:04
forced out of the United States. Wednesday,
0:07
President Joe Biden signed into
0:10
law a conditional ban of
0:12
the video-sharing app. India
0:16
banned TikTok almost four years ago.
0:19
Here is a look at what happened there.
0:24
In June 2020, TikTok users in
0:26
India said goodbye to the
0:28
app operated by
0:30
Chinese internet company ByteDance.
0:34
India banned the popular app
0:36
suddenly following a deadly military
0:38
clash with India along their
0:40
shared border. India
0:43
banned many other Chinese apps at
0:45
the same time. Ties
0:48
between the two Asian countries
0:51
hit a new low. The
0:54
Indian government said it ordered the
0:57
ban for security reasons and
0:59
privacy protection. The
1:02
Indian public mostly supported the
1:04
ban. The
1:06
message from the government was, how can
1:09
we allow Chinese companies to do business
1:11
in India when we're
1:13
in the middle of a
1:15
military standoff, said Nikhil Pawa.
1:18
He is a digital policy
1:20
expert and founder of technology
1:22
news website MediaNama.
1:27
Just months before the ban,
1:29
India restricted investment by Chinese
1:32
companies, Pawa added. Today,
1:34
India has banned over 500
1:36
Chinese apps to date, he
1:38
said. At
1:41
the time, India had about 200 million
1:44
TikTok users, the most
1:46
outside of China. The
1:49
company also employed thousands of
1:51
Indians. TikTok
1:54
users and content creators,
1:56
however, needed a place to
1:58
go. Within
2:00
months, Google created YouTube Shorts
2:03
and Instagram created its Reels
2:06
feature. Both
2:08
were similar to the short-form video
2:10
creation that TikTok is known for.
2:15
Pawa said those companies captured
2:17
most of the market that
2:19
TikTok had vacated. Winnie
2:23
Sangma misses posting videos
2:25
on TikTok and earning
2:27
a bit of money, but
2:30
after the ban he moved to
2:32
Instagram and now has 15,000 followers.
2:37
I have built up followers on
2:39
Instagram too, and I am
2:42
making money from it, but the
2:44
experience isn't like how it used to
2:46
be on TikTok, he said. The
2:50
US measure gives ByteDance, the
2:52
app's parent company, nine
2:54
months to sell it. If
2:57
this does not happen, TikTok will
2:59
be banned. It
3:01
would take at least a year before the
3:03
ban goes into effect. However,
3:06
the measure is expected to
3:08
face legal battles that could
3:10
delay the process. In
3:13
India, the process was quick. TikTok
3:16
and other companies were given
3:18
time to answer questions on
3:20
privacy and security, but
3:23
by January 2021, a permanent ban was
3:25
in place. The
3:28
situation in the US is
3:31
different, said Pawa. In
3:33
India, TikTok decided not to go
3:35
to court, but the US
3:38
is a bigger revenue market for them.
3:41
Pawa added that with American
3:43
free speech protections, it's
3:46
not going to be as easy for the
3:48
US to do this as it
3:50
was for India. As
3:53
Chinese apps spread across the world,
3:56
Pawa said countries should reduce
3:58
their dependence on China. companies.
4:02
He said Chinese apps can
4:04
create a national security risk.
4:07
Afghanistan, Nepal, and Pakistan
4:10
also banned TikTok. Many
4:13
countries in Europe restrict the app
4:15
as well. Chinese
4:18
intelligence law and its
4:20
cybersecurity law can allow
4:23
Chinese apps to work in the interest
4:25
of their own security. That
4:28
creates a situation of distrust
4:31
and it becomes a national security
4:33
risk for others, said
4:35
Pawah. There
4:38
should be different rules for
4:40
democratic countries and for authoritarian
4:42
regimes where companies can
4:44
act as an extension of the
4:46
state, he added. I'm
4:48
Dan Novak.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More