It’s finally time—Joey’s future is in the balance as two beautiful women remain in Tulum. There they meet his family and go on last chance dates before Joey must come to a final decision.

As one woman is confident in her future with Joey, the other is left to wonder why she wasn’t given validation, which leads to a never before seen moment in bachelor history.

We give all our thoughts on the final couple (will they go the long run?) how the runner up handled everything, and our new Bachelorette (yay)! Thanks once again for sticking with Bachelor-ish for another unforgettable season.