Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:02
Welcome to brain Stuff from how Stuff Works,
0:06
Hey, brain Stuff, Lauren vocal bomb here. According
0:09
to the Beverage Marketing Corporation, bottled
0:11
water was an eighteen point five billion
0:13
dollar industry in the United States in seen
0:17
and by volume. The bottled water industry
0:19
grew by seven percent from six to
0:22
seventeen, going from twelve point
0:24
eight billion gallons to thirteen point
0:26
seven billion gallons, helping bottled
0:28
water surpass soda as Americans favorite
0:30
drink. But just one hundred
0:33
years ago, bottled water was hardly even a business.
0:35
Water was just something we got from our taps. So
0:38
how did we get here? How in the world
0:40
did something we used to get ford seemingly free
0:43
turn into a billion dollar industry. Like
0:46
so many modern day products successes, marketing
0:49
has played a huge role, but so
0:51
have some other factors. Let's explore. Bottled
0:54
water was a thriving industry early in United
0:57
States history. There are records of it being
0:59
sold in the u US as early as seventeen sixty
1:01
seven, but business really started
1:03
flowing at the beginning of the nineteenth century
1:06
as dip mold glass technology made
1:08
bottles more affordable and easier to mass
1:10
produce. Back then, two
1:12
types of customers drove bottled water sales,
1:15
the rich and people who lived in cities.
1:17
The wealthy took trips to spas and resorts
1:19
built around natural springs, so mineral
1:21
water bottled at the source was away for them
1:23
to continue enjoying those supposed therapeutic
1:26
benefits. Just for perspective,
1:28
by eighteen fifty six, Saratoga
1:30
Springs in New York was producing seven million
1:33
bottles of water a year for
1:35
the average city dweller. In the eighteenth and nineteenth
1:38
centuries, bottled water was the safest
1:40
drinking option because municipal water
1:42
was often sickening. Literally, drinking
1:45
bottled water helped people avoid diseases like
1:47
cholera, typhoid, and dysentery.
1:50
By ninety most U S. Cities
1:52
offered free, filtered chlorinated
1:54
water, which dramatically improved public
1:56
health. According to the National Bureau
1:58
of Economic Research, of the decreases
2:00
in depths in major cities was due to clean
2:03
water. But what was a breakthrough for
2:05
public health was also a blow to the bottled
2:07
water industry. At the beginning
2:09
of the twentieth century, with free and safe public
2:11
water, the bottled water industry had adapted
2:14
to markets it could serve primarily
2:16
selling five gallon that's about nineteen liter
2:18
bottles too large operations that needed water
2:20
for employees. Even with mass
2:22
produced glass, the bottles were heavy to ship,
2:25
and that cost weighed down the bottled water
2:27
business. The nineteen
2:29
seventies and eighties were the real turning point
2:31
for the new bottled water industry thanks
2:33
to three major influences. First,
2:36
that's when pet plastic bottles
2:38
were patented. Unlike heavy glass, pet
2:41
bottles could stand the pressure of carbonated drinks
2:43
because they were lighter than glass. Pet bottles
2:46
helped propel the bottled water industry forward.
2:49
Second, these two decades are also when French
2:51
sparkling water company perry A launched
2:53
its aggressive marketing campaign to get Americans
2:55
to spend money on water. In
2:57
the seventies, perry A hired or sin Well to
3:00
do voiceover for its TV ads, touting Perier
3:02
as more quenching, more refreshing,
3:05
and naturally sparkling from the center of
3:07
the earth. Perrier also
3:09
began sponsoring athletic events like the New
3:11
York City Marathon to associate its water
3:13
with fitness and health. By night,
3:16
Perrier was predicting sales of seventy
3:18
five million bottles that year alone.
3:20
By the eighties, Perris ads used the
3:22
tagline Earth's first soft
3:25
drink. But the final
3:27
push to bottled water came in nineteen
3:29
eighties six, when the Environmental Protection
3:31
Agency released a report showing tap
3:33
water used by thirty six million Americans
3:36
contained high levels of lead. Even
3:38
though cities rushed to fix these problems after
3:40
congressional investigations, the distrust
3:42
of municipal water lingered, making
3:45
the switch from public water to bottled water a
3:47
permanent one for many families. So
3:50
the health halo that has graced bottled water
3:52
since ancient times largely explains
3:54
our spending habits, even when what we're
3:56
buying is simply filtered tap water, such
3:59
as pepsicos off affina and Coca Cola's
4:01
Desani. These ad campaigns
4:03
around health, purity and youth work
4:05
so well because they appeal to our desire
4:07
for immortality. Researchers
4:09
at the University of Waterloo conducted a study
4:12
in that tested this terror
4:14
management theory, the idea that much
4:16
of our thinking and behavior is driven by our
4:18
fear of death, even in things like buying
4:20
bottled water. The results
4:22
found that a fear of dying does play a
4:25
role in why people buy bottled water even
4:27
though they know it may not be better for them or
4:29
good for the planet. Stephanie
4:32
Cote, one of the researchers on the study, set in
4:34
a statement, bottled water advertisements
4:36
play on our greatest fears in two important
4:38
ways. Our mortality fears make us
4:40
want to avoid risks, and for many
4:42
people, bottled water seems safer,
4:44
somehow purer or controlled.
4:48
The other psychological, but real aspect
4:50
that drives people to spend money on bottled water
4:52
is the continued lack of trust in the government
4:54
to provide clean, safe drinking water and
4:57
maintain water systems. Consider
4:59
the people of Flint, Michigan, who have relied on
5:01
bottled water through the contamination crisis
5:03
that's lasted years there, as have the
5:05
First Nations people in Canada, where water
5:08
too reserves has been under drinking advisories
5:10
since January.
5:12
Attempts by the Trump administration to repeal
5:15
the Federal Clean Water Rule have deepened
5:17
public distrust. We
5:19
spoke via email with Dr Peter H. Galek,
5:22
President Emeritus and Chief Scientists at
5:24
the Pacific Institute for Studies in Development,
5:26
Environment and Security. He
5:28
said the use of bottled water in emergency
5:30
situations is a perfectly good idea, but
5:33
the challenge is rebuilding public trust
5:35
after such emergencies so that private
5:37
bottled water use can then be eliminated.
5:39
Bottled water should never be a permanent solution
5:42
to providing safe, affordable, reliable drinking
5:44
water for people, also considering
5:47
the environmental costs of bottled water a
5:49
mass s which would help the planet. There
5:51
is promise in campaigns that give people reusable
5:53
bottles, laws that banned single use bottles,
5:56
and the new incarnation of drinking fountains
5:58
as bottle refillings nations, but
6:01
the messages to change our habits need to match
6:03
the power of those that drive sales of bottled
6:05
water. Gleek explained.
6:08
The other challenge, of course, is that private bottled
6:10
water companies have large budgets for advertising
6:13
their product, while municipal water agencies
6:15
do not. This imbalance has produced
6:17
a situation where it is easy to lose trust
6:19
in a municipal water system and hard to
6:21
regain it, even when the vast majority
6:24
of our water systems are safe and far
6:26
far cheaper than bottled water, and
6:29
in places around the world where safe tap water
6:31
isn't available. The answer is to make it available,
6:34
not to give up and rely on costly private
6:36
bottled water. Today's
6:42
episode was written by Sean Chavis and produced
6:44
by Tyler Clang. If you enjoy our show and
6:46
want to support us directly, check out our online
6:49
store at t public dot com, slash brain
6:51
stuff, and of course, for more on
6:53
this and other environmental topics, visit
6:55
our home planet, how stuff works dot com
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More