In the first ever CODJ four-way, I am joined by Cracked contributors J.F. Sargent, Amanda Mannen, and Isaac Cabe to discuss the controversial and polarizing series finale of How I Met Your Mother. Should Robin and Barney have broken up? Was killing off the Mother the right move? Does anyone really care about Lily and Marshall at this point?

Sarge explains what he thinks the series was really all about, I explain how I think the last season should have gone, Isaac pines for more Mother screen time, and Manna has a nervous breakdown over Barney and Robin. Whatever your feelings about the finale, you'll find someone to agree with.

Podcast up!