Jake and Allie close up this season of Come On In, Guys by giving their thoughts on the season overall. They talk about the finale of Bachelor: Listen to Your Heart, the strengths and weaknesses of this season, and brainstorm stunts for Jeff. T

"My Daily Earpod I Use For Sports" with Ty McCarthy (Winners at War FINALE)

May 16th, 2020 1h 9m

Ty McCarthy dials in to talk about the FINALE episode of Winners at War! They talk about the merits of each of the finalists, the gender bias in Survivor, and why the hell Survivor is putting out the call for teens.Remember to Rate and Subscrib

"Put Together by a Hungover Gym Teacher" w/ Ashley Franks and Joshua Philips (Winners at War episode 13)

May 10th, 2020 1h 11m

Super fans Ashley Franks and Joshua Philips hop on the line to talk about a special 2-hour penultimate episode of Winners at War. They discuss the succession of Jeff Probst, whether "goodness" can win Survivor, the paths to victory for the rema

"What Bird is in the Night-time?" with Jordan Lee Cohen and Rachel Paige (Winners at War Episode 12)

May 1st, 2020 1h 2m

This week on a very special double-guest episode of Come On In, Guys: Survivor fans (and players??) Jordan Lee Cohen and Rachel Paige hop on to talk about their experience with the game, roast this week's bad liars, discuss the merits of a low-

"Men Have Enough, Let Them Die" with Allie Ring (Winners at War episode 11)

Apr 24th, 2020 1h 8m

Allie Ring pops in to talk about this episode of The Tony Show! They cover Allie's personal history with Wendell Holland, discuss the most single-player dominant episode in Survivor history, and lament over this week's heartbreaking boot.Rememb

"Get Up and LEAVE!!" with Molly Jones (Winners at War episode 10)

Apr 17th, 2020 58m 52s

Grab your tissues! Molly Jones drops in to talk to Jake and Allie about a very moving episode of Survivor. They talk about the family visits, who's getting the best and worst edits so far, and break down the rollercoaster ride that was this epi

"Rein Them In, Probst!" with Jess Rubin (Winners at War Episode 9)

Apr 10th, 2020 1h 3m

Jess Rubin phones in to talk about a Survivor episode we'll be talking about for years. They cover Adam's descent into madness, Kim's return to form, and most importantly: Ethan's new accessories.⚜Remember to rate and subscribe!

"The Ultimate Daddy" with Josh Cahlik (Winners at War episode 8)

Apr 4th, 2020 1h 18m

Josh Cahlik brings his encyclopedic knowledge of the game to talk to Jake and Allie about the big Merge episode! They talk pros and cons of advantages in the game of Survivor, the exciting come-back-in challenge, the delusional "big targets", a

"It is NOT pornography, trust me" with Kevin McConnell (Winners at War episode 7)

Mar 28th, 2020 1h 12m

Kevin McConnell phones in to talk to Jake and Allie about The Queen's exit, whether or not Wendell is an actual villain, and reality tv shows beyond our prudish American sensibilities.Don't forget to rate and subscribe!______________________Fin

"V is for Vindictive" with Anna Dierksheide (Winners at War episode 6)

Mar 20th, 2020 1h 13m

THE QUARANTINE IS UPON US. Jake, Allie, and their special guest/Boston Rob stan Anna Dierksheide phone in from 3 separate locations to talk about tonights episode. They cover the long-awaited usage of Fire Tokens, the shocking Dakal tribal coun

"Spit on me, Jeff" with Kennon McKinney (Winners at War episode 5)

Mar 16th, 2020 2h 1m

Kennon McKinney drops by and the trio of Survivors accidentally have such a blast they record for over 2 hours. Oops! In this jam packed episode they talk all about The Finale of The Bachelor, their Survivor favorites through the years, rank th

"Dead in the Water" with Derek Martz (Winners at War episode 4)

Mar 10th, 2020 1h 10m

Derek Martz joins the gang (Jake and Allie are the gang) to discuss this weeks episode. They talk about Adam's frenetic gameplay, reminisce on emotional moments in Survivor history, and reference the CW's "Arrow" more times than anyone else eve

"She's Probably Hungry!" with Hannah Rumsey (Winners at War Episode 3)

Feb 28th, 2020 1h 4m

Hannah Rumsey pops in to talk about how much she hates Adam, who gets credit for catching the shark, and play a game of 'Jeff or No Jeff'.

"A Hot Little MacGyver" with Alec Herr (Winners at War Episode 2)

Feb 21st, 2020 1h 13m

Jake and Allie are joined by Alec Herr to discuss some hidden immunity idols, new alliances (willing and unwilling), bedazzling, the ways to get breadfruit, and the many, many bad plays in this episode.

"Pull Me!!" with Josie Benedetti (Winners at War episode 1)

Feb 17th, 2020 58m 52s

Jake and Allie are joined by Josie Benedetti to discuss the first episode of Survivor: Winners at War. They talk about the big moments of the premiere including first formations of alliances, early strategies, and whether or not we can take Bos

Are You Proud of Us, Jeff? (Winners at War Pre-Season)

Feb 5th, 2020 41m 37s

Jake and Allie discuss the format of their belligerent new podcast, talk about what we know about Survivor's new season "Winners at War", make bold predictions on winners, and beg for Jeff Probst to be proud of them.