When Rebekah Gay went missing from her home on Halloween in 2012, local Pastor, John Douglas White, asked his congregation at Christ Community Church to pray for her safe return. But less than 24 hours later, this very congregation, and the community of Broomfield Township, Michigan, will learn their prayers went unanswered, and the Devil was in their midst the entire time.

PLUS: A Florida town where one man was the local Town Commissioner, Fire Chief, Santa Claus and Pedophile.

Time Stamps:·     Announcements: 00:00·     Florida Man: 07:10·     Main Story: 14:55

Executive Producers for this episode are Christine Rivera, Beth Davis, Dusty Jay Hicks and Terri Burke Wolin.Associate Producers: Paul Hodge, Courtney Seddon, Tara Mazur, Shantal Daggett, Jay Rollings and Laura Shinn.Producers: JD, Ashley O’Connor, ElizabethPlus4, Trent Gobble, Devin Dean, Lissa Porrello, Alicia Knight, Maria Selene, Kris Owen, Justin Wear and Emily White.Research and Documentation: Kris Owen

This episode is brought to you by Hello Fresh. Visit HelloFresh.com/50CriminalAF and use code “50 CriminalAF” at checkout to receive 50% off and FREEshipping.HELLO FRESH - AMERICA’S #1 MEAL KIT

Share Criminal AF with your friends or leave a review:-    Apple Podcasts-    SpotifyTo Support Criminal AF:Membership:-    PatreonOne-Time Donation:-    Buy us a Coffee!!-    PayPalFor EXCLUSIVE Criminal AF Merch and MORE. Visit:-    Criminal AF ShopAffiliate Links:-    Do you have a podcast, YouTube channel or a Twitch account? Look no further for unparalleled, high-quality music for commercial use. Epidemic Sound gives you access to a broad range of high-quality background music for every format, ads, podcasts, videos or live streams.Tap into exclusive, authentic tracks HERE-    Staying safe online is an ever-growing concern. Between potential government tracking, hackers and other forms of exploitation, NordVPN changes your IP address, allowing you to virtually disappear on the web, securing your privacy.Get up to 69% off + 3 extra months HERE-    Looking to start your own website for your Podcast or YouTube channel? Podcastpage.io is THE website builder you’ve been looking for. Grow your business, save time, and increase your show’s visibility with no coding required!Click HERE to begin today!-    Everyone shops on Amazon, why not do it through Criminal AF’s link?  Help support Criminal AF by doing your online shopping HERE!Criminal AF is a part of The Debauchery. A group of independent podcasts who support and cross promote one another. Visit all of our podcasts at WelcomeToTheDebauchery.comLeave us a message:-    [email protected]    [email protected] and Outro Music by David MercurioAll music, including the music for Florida Person of the Day, Riverboat Rambler by Bo the Drifter, is licensed through Epidemic Sound.#criminalaf #welcometothedebauchery #truecrimedouchebags #truecrimecomedy #followme #truecrimepodcast #thankyou #truecrimeaddict #friends #truecrimejunkie #trending #love #look #popular #truecrimeandchill #spicy #comedic #informative #funny #truecrimefans #awesome #truecrimemafia #darkhumor #podcast #murder #truecrimepodcasts #truecrimecommunity #share #truecrimestory #comedyhour

Sources:John Douglas White – Murderpedia.comJohn White: How a killer was set free - By Ken Kolker - WoodTV.com - 2012Rebekah Gay homicide: John White says he watched necrophilia porn before attack. By Mark Tower - Mlive.com – 2012The Murderous Pastor Who Craved Sex With The Dead – by Matt Gilligan for ID CrimefeedLearn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices