Supernatural season 2 is when SPN finally comes together — but you probably already knew that because you begged your friends to stick it out through season 1 just to get to this payoff. And hoo boy, does it pay off. Join Sara and Tanya as they walk you through all the parts of the "saying goodbye to dad" season that work so well, and prepare to take sides when Sara's least favorite episodes turns out to be one of Tanya's favorites. Drama, already in CW by the Season's second episode? Listen to find out!

(BTW, dear internet, Sara knows that the character Summer Glau played on Firefly was named River Tam, not River Song. She misspoke, she apologizes, and she understands if you need to inundate her Twitter feed with your scorn. She earned it.)