It's Pacey's 18th birthday, and it's full of plot holes. Did Joey and Pacey ever go to Sunday night dinners? Because if they did, why is Joey so shocked at how much Pacey's family sucks?

Dawson makes the rookie mistake of thinking just because you go on a date with someone, doesn't mean you're in a relationship.

And why the fuck is Tobey so mean to Jack, and why is Jen encouraging Tobey's crush on Jack, when Tobey and Jack seem to really not get along at all? So many questions, so few answers.

Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!

Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy

Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.

Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.

Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensleyFind Julia on Twitter and Instagram @Pesty1079Rare Bird Books is @rarebirdlit and at rarebirdlit.com