Ashley covers the case of Becky Marzo, who vanished in 2003. After a concerning, yet humorous headline, Cody covers the unsolved murders of Harvey and Jeannette Crewe.

Tale As Old As Twice The Time and Doctor Party Bacon

Feb 4th, 2023 1h 24m

Cody tells the story of a gruesome, unsolved fate of Katarzyna Zowada in Poland. After a very threatening headline, Ashley goes over the limited information in the case of missing person, Betty Fran Smith.

The Devil’s Chowder and Running with SZA

Jan 29th, 2023 1h 6m

Ashley opens the episode with the horrific case of Brittney Woods, whose home life and disappearance are extremely tough to listen to. After a brief headline, Cody tells of the unsolved murder of adult film producer and star William Arnold Newt

An Edwardian WAP and Fiery Impatience

Jan 21st, 2023 1h 17m

Cody opens with the details of Janet Smith's unsolved murder in 1920's Vancouver, Canada. After a brief, but lit, headline, Ashley covers the missing person's case of Shannon LaBau, from February 1999.

Trapped In the Attic and Barbie’s Gun Convertible

Jan 13th, 2023 1h 27m

This week, Ashley opens with the puzzling case of Ashley Fuller Reed's disappearance shortly after meeting with a man at IHOP. Then, Cody covers the crazy crimes, and unreal life of Peter Gibb. After such a drastic, eventful life, his death wil

Fired By Autum and Airport Security Stories

Jan 9th, 2023 1h 18m

Cody begins the episode with a hilarious job application story, as well as the puzzling unsolved murder of Terri (Missy) Beavers in 2016. So many things shock and puzzle us in her case. A couple of unfortunate, criminal female-empowered headlin

Croissant Ti**ies and The Goldilocks Murders

Dec 30th, 2022 1h 20m

Ashley starts us off with the bizarre disappearance of Ellabeth Mae Lodermeier, in the early months of 1974. What would be found later that year, and then 18 years later? We go beyond the caution tape with our hilarious headline. Then Cody unra

Holiday Headlines- 90lbs of WHAT, Peruvian Papa Noel, and A Wheely Bad Idea

Dec 24th, 2022 1h 23m

Merry Christmas Eve! *Warning* No editing has been done to audio, in effort to get it out sooner. Ashley and Cody unravel the festive and not-so-jolly headlines that come about this time of year. Headline-only episode this week. But believe us,

Who Killed Mufasa and 100 Miles

Dec 19th, 2022 1h 34m

We promised a longer episode since we missed a week, and here it is. Cody unravels the unsolved murder of Julie Ward in 1988, in Kenya. Ashley tells two missing persons cases, one of which is also this week's headline. The second case covers t

”Give Your Money Now” and Baguette QVC On The Phone

Dec 2nd, 2022 47m

Ashley opens with missing person's case of Dorothy Goroshko, and her 1970 Ford Maverick. Quite possibly the funniest headline story we've ever read on air is highlighted in this episode. Cody details the mysterious unsolved death of Keith Ratli

Always Surprised By Maps and 50 Yards From Home

Nov 27th, 2022 56m 42s

Cody tells the story of the life and unsolved murder of luxury call girl and expert businesswoman, Rosemarie Nitribitt, in German during the late 1950's. Ashley recounts the heartbreaking details of 8 year old Cherie Mahan's disappearance, 50 y

An Excellent Synopsis of Twilight and What Was Found In The Water

Nov 19th, 2022 1h 6m

Ashley opens the episode with the disappearance of Ann Marie Shaw Godbey, and the clues that might bring closure to what happened. Cody covers the case of two bodies found in a lake, one with a crucifix inside its mouth. This would be the "solv

Tyra Bucks and The Dangers of Self-Checkout

Nov 11th, 2022 58m 1s

Cody begins the episode with the bizarre deaths of Don Henry and Kevin Ives, and the debated cause that would puzzle us since they passed in 1987. Ashley covers the disappearance of former NCIS and Nuclear Regulatory Commission employee, Eugene

Bowling For Dona and Tigers in the Desert?

Nov 5th, 2022 58m 7s

Join us for episode 40! Ashley starts with the disappearance of Donamae Bayerl and the stellar concern by her husband, John. We cover a bittersweet headline, then Cody unravels the details of the unsolved murder of Lindsay Buziak, who met myste

Bowling For Dona and Tigers in the Desert?

Nov 5th, 2022 58m 7s

Happy Halloween and Swing Low, Sweet Sheri-ot

Oct 28th, 2022 1h 25m

Happy Halloween! This episode has both personal stories, several headlines, and even some horror movie discussion. Cody starts the episode by discussing the brutal and unsolved murder of James Adamski. After several headlines, Ashley tells the

Devil Gravel and The Metallic Dorito

Oct 21st, 2022 1h 1m

In episode 38, Ashley starts us off with the case of Stephanie Lyn Crane, whose disappearance quite possibly ties in with the case of Amber Hoopes in episode 37. Our "Between the Cheeks" headline this week felt too close for comfort, and Cody d

Inside A Fish and Idowa

Oct 14th, 2022 1h 5m

One of our most delirious episodes. Cody covers the murders of Steve Harkins, Ruth Cooper, Diana Robertson, and Mike Riemer. Multiple similarities tie the two separate cases together, one item being the most bizarre. Ashley covers a disappearan

Bert the BANANA BOSS and The Court of A-Peels

Oct 7th, 2022 59m 10s

Ashley and Cody visit the Garden of Eden, in a most unexpected manner. We delve into the disappearance of Alesha Brookshier. Plus an uplifting headline, and Cody's bananas Philadelphia "unsolved" murder of Tony 'Bananas.'

We Missed You and Cody’s Butt Pawns

Oct 1st, 2022 1h 2m

We're back! Same podcast, same shitsticks. First, we delve into the the unsolved murder case of Susanne (not Susan) Lindholm from Helsinki, Finland. There may or may not be something about anal beads and chess, thanks to Cody. Ashley covers the

Back At It and Aviation Lactation

Dec 8th, 2021 1h 6m

Do you have questions? Like where the f*ck have we been for a month and a half? We have some clarity on that and the cases that fascinate.Ashley delves into part one of disappearances related to Cropsey on Staten Island, New York. We disc

Mermaid Logistics and Avalanche of Nuttin

Oct 12th, 2021 1h 7m

SPOOKY SEASON is upon us. And as such, we would like to cover spookier stories for the remaining weeks this month. Maybe longer we'll see. Cody tells the strange happenings surrounding the death of Roland T Owens in Missouri, in 1933. It's weir

A Massachusetts Mystery and The Million Dollar Whale

Oct 10th, 2021 58m 28s

This week we go just outside of Boston as Ashley covers the disappearance of 5 year old Giovanni Gonzalez, which puzzles you at every turn. Our headline highlights new ways we're attempting to reach aliens. Then Cody covers the unsolved murder

Bettering Yourself and If We Got Kidnapped

Sep 28th, 2021 1h 5m

IMPORTANT: We forgot to thank our patrons in this episode so I want to do it in the description. THANK YOU: Kristen, Amanda, Cory, Jeremiah, Autum, Judicator, and Zane!This week we discuss the unsolved murder of April Lacy, whose life's d

Corkscrewed and A Hangover Story

Sep 21st, 2021 1h 3m

This week we've got stories; personal ones, and the cases you love. Ashley details the National Parks disappearance of Trenny Gibson, who was on a field trip in Tennessee. Cody unveils the technically unsolved murder of Eugene Mullendore, aka E