Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:03
Hello and welcome to the Intelligence from The
0:05
Economist. I'm your host, Ora
0:08
Ogunbiyi. Every weekday
0:10
we provide a fresh perspective on the events
0:13
shaping your world. The
0:17
region of Nagorno-Karabakh is
0:20
on the brink of a humanitarian crisis.
0:22
The only roads in are sealed and
0:25
an ever-tightening blockade threatens
0:27
many with starvation. Why are
0:29
Armenia and Azerbaijan unable to reach
0:31
an agreement? And
0:35
Douglas Lennart transformed how
0:37
we think about computers. We
0:40
pay tribute to the mathematician whose life's
0:42
work was to make computers more human
0:45
and put some common sense into AI.
0:55
But first, we have some news of
0:58
our own to bring you.
1:04
Podcasting may seem like the new kid on the block.
1:07
For us, it's something of an old
1:09
timer. The Economist
1:11
began podcasting in 2006. Our
1:15
first offering was Money Talks, which
1:18
still leads the field when it comes to business
1:20
and finance reporting. It won gold
1:22
at the most recent British podcast
1:24
awards. The judges said
1:26
an outstanding production that grips
1:28
and informs listeners with storytelling. The
1:31
winner is
1:32
Money Talks. Other
1:34
shows have built on its success, among
1:36
them Babbage, which was
1:39
reporting on advances in AI well before
1:41
the frenzy of excitement around chat GPT.
1:44
I'm going to need your help to write an opening
1:47
for this week's Babbage. Our program is on foundation
1:50
models, a type of artificial intelligence.
1:53
I'm sure I can help, Alec. What
1:55
data should I work with? Good question.
1:57
How about we pull together... In 2019... we
2:00
step things up with our first daily
2:02
show. This one, The
2:05
Intelligence. Right
2:07
where you are, what is the feeling on the street? What
2:09
is the mood on the streets right now in Kiev? The
2:11
mood on the streets is bewilderment.
2:14
Right up to the very last minute, people didn't
2:16
believe this was going to happen. Now that it
2:18
has happened, Kiev has become a sort of city
2:20
of huddles. On the one hand, people
2:23
huddling in groups around... We've since branched
2:25
out into the blockbuster series. The
2:28
Prince, our investigation into the
2:30
mysterious life of Xi Jinping, was
2:32
a hit worldwide.
2:34
It's a Machiavellian story
2:36
of power. How it's won, how
2:38
it's wielded, and how far you can
2:41
fall when it's taken away. In
2:44
China, where information about their leader
2:46
is tightly controlled, independent-minded
2:49
listeners translated the show into Mandarin. And
2:52
The Prince was followed by Drum Tower, a weekly
2:55
dive into what's going on in China. Wow,
2:58
a Chinese blogger talking about IVF. That's pretty unusual for this country.
3:01
And are they getting a lot of views?
3:03
Yeah, I mean, so Ye Hayang is incredibly
3:05
popular. I mean, she has 724 million followers.
3:08
So there have been big changes at Economist
3:11
podcasts over the years.
3:13
And now, another one
3:15
is coming.
3:17
From next month, The Economist will
3:19
be rolling out a new podcast service.
3:22
Because Animants and Beddows is The Economist's editor-in-chief.
3:26
Listers will be able to sign up for
3:28
exclusive access to all our podcasts,
3:31
including a number that we are creating
3:33
specifically for this podcast service. It's
3:36
going to be called Economist Podcast Plus. And
3:38
if you sign up now, the monthly cost
3:41
is less than the price of a cup of coffee. Well,
3:43
that sounds like a great and punchy pitch.
3:46
But to get things straight, we're now
3:48
asking people to pay for our podcasts,
3:50
or at least some of them.
3:52
That's right. Everyone will still
3:54
be able to listen to quite a lot of our podcasts
3:56
for free. The weekday episodes of
3:58
The Intelligence, what you're looking for, listening to right now
4:01
will still remain free. But starting
4:03
next month, if you want to listen to the whole array
4:06
of our podcasts every week, including
4:08
our specialist shows like Money Talks or Drum Tower
4:11
or our special series, which we're going to be
4:13
creating a number of new ones, you
4:15
will have to have a subscription. If
4:17
you already have an economist subscription, nothing
4:20
will change. You'll simply have to sign up. You don't
4:22
have to pay any extra. If you're enjoying
4:24
the full range of our journalism, thank you.
4:26
You are the people who enable us to do what we
4:29
do. But if you don't have a subscription,
4:31
if you've been listening to our podcasts and enjoying
4:33
them for free, then we're going to ask you
4:36
to pay a small amount to enjoy
4:38
the complete set of our podcasts. And
4:40
the reason we're talking about it now, a month
4:42
ahead of when we start all this, is
4:45
that if you sign up now, you can get
4:47
Economist Podcast Plus at a special
4:49
launch price
4:49
of 24.50 for the year. That's
4:52
24 euros or 24 dollars
4:55
or 24 pounds.
4:56
And that works
4:57
out at just 2 dollars or pounds
4:59
or euros a month. And for that,
5:02
just to be clear, you don't just get the whole range
5:04
of podcasts that we have now, but a host
5:06
of extras, including some brand new
5:08
shows. So, we'll come back to those
5:10
extras in a bit. But
5:12
first, why have you decided to do this?
5:15
What's behind that change?
5:17
In truth, it's not such a big departure for the economist.
5:19
We've always relied on subscribers
5:22
to fund our distinctive brand of independent
5:25
journalism. And we believe that a podcast
5:27
subscription is the best
5:28
way of giving our listeners the chance
5:30
to support our work and frankly, to ensure
5:33
that we can fund the kind of ambitious plans
5:35
we have for our podcasts in the future.
5:38
Our basic mission is to provide high
5:40
quality journalism for subscribers around
5:43
the world and to make that available at a fair
5:45
price. Since podcasting
5:48
is becoming an ever more central part of our
5:50
journalism, the logical result is
5:52
that we apply the same business approach to podcasting
5:55
as we do to the rest of our journalism.
5:57
Now, Zanny, paying for podcasts is not easy.
6:00
yet the standard. Are you worried
6:02
that because so much content is free that
6:04
people might go elsewhere? There's
6:06
always a risk, Ory, in being early
6:08
movers in any new business decision.
6:11
But I'm pretty confident that
6:14
the quality of our podcast journalism, the
6:16
quality of what you and your colleagues do,
6:18
is so good that many
6:20
of our subscribers will understand
6:22
that we need to charge a fair price
6:24
for this kind of journalism and will sign up.
6:27
If you look at what's happened to our podcast audience,
6:30
it's doubled in the last three years. We have more than 5
6:32
million monthly listeners in our first
6:34
growing platform. It's an incredibly important part
6:37
of our journalism. And the numbers clearly show
6:39
that people value your work
6:41
and the work of your colleagues. And frankly, rightly
6:43
so. It's fantastic. And it's been
6:45
a bit anomalous in the news
6:48
business recently podcasting because it is still
6:51
essentially advertising based. But
6:53
just as we have from the very beginning
6:55
relied on subscribers to fund our
6:58
written journalism, so we're very
7:00
confident that the podcast market will move
7:02
in the same direction. And that being an
7:04
early mover here simply means
7:06
that podcasting becomes less of an anomaly
7:08
for the economists than it was before. We
7:11
think our podcasts are worth paying for. We
7:13
hope that you listeners will agree. And frankly,
7:17
it's outstanding value. $2 or
7:20
two pounds a month, as I said, is less
7:22
than the price of a cup of coffee. So give
7:24
us a sense of what our listeners can look forward
7:27
to. That's the bit that I'm excited about.
7:29
There's a brilliant new series coming in October
7:31
called Boss Class, which has been put together
7:33
by Andrew Palmer, who writes our Bartleby
7:35
column on management, which is the most
7:37
popular column that we have. The
7:40
economist, he's a fantastic writer. He's
7:42
been talking to a large
7:44
number of business leaders about
7:46
how to be a good manager. I can't wait to listen.
7:49
I might learn something. We're also going
7:51
to have a number of new series
7:54
of the sort of ambitious scale that listeners
7:56
will remember. We had The Prince last year.
7:58
Fantastic series. on Xi Jinping, narrated
8:01
by Su Lin Wong. We had Arkady
8:03
Ostrovsky, our Russia editors, superb
8:06
next year in Moscow. And in addition to
8:08
that, the other show that I'm very excited
8:10
about is a new Saturday show called
8:12
The Weekend Intelligence. And we
8:14
think of this as the audio version
8:17
of an immersive weekend read. There'll
8:20
be long form reporting and interviews that showcase
8:22
the best of economist journalism and
8:24
that give our reporters a chance to show off the depth
8:26
of their knowledge. I've just returned from Kiev,
8:29
as you'll know, if you heard Monday's show. And
8:31
this new weekend show, spoiler alert,
8:34
will contain much more reporting that
8:36
Arkady and I were working on in Ukraine. There's
8:39
going to be lots of long form reporting, interviews.
8:42
So all told, it's everything
8:44
we've now got,
8:45
plus quite a lot more at a very fair
8:47
price.
8:48
So for all the listeners who
8:50
are now incredibly eager to find
8:52
out what's in Economist Podcast Plus, how can they
8:54
do this? So if you are an
8:56
existing subscriber of The Economist, then
8:59
you automatically get access. You're going to get an
9:01
email update explaining how to do that. We've
9:03
published a list of frequently asked questions
9:05
in the show notes for this podcast. That
9:08
should be reasonably easy. To sign
9:10
up for the podcast only subscription, go to
9:12
economist.com forward slash podcast
9:15
plus or again, look at our show notes
9:17
for more information and a list of frequently
9:19
asked questions. If you sign up now,
9:22
you get a special introductory offer, which,
9:24
as I've said, works out as just a couple
9:26
of dollars or pounds a month or less
9:29
than the price of a good cup of coffee.
9:30
Zannie, thank you so much
9:32
for coming on the show. You are very welcome.
9:46
In 2020,
9:49
a long simmering conflict reached
9:51
boiling point in Nagorno-Karabakh,
9:54
a region that has been a source of tension
9:56
between Azerbaijan and neighboring Armenia
9:59
for nearly three decades. Over
10:06
six weeks of open warfare between the two
10:08
nations, thousands were
10:10
killed. Then
10:13
there was a ceasefire.
10:16
There were hopes that it would hold up, but
10:19
a year ago this week, violent
10:21
clashes broke out yet again.
10:24
We are deeply concerned about continued
10:27
attacks along the Armenian-Bajjan border.
10:30
We are particularly disturbed
10:32
by continued reports of civilians being
10:34
harmed inside the Armenian border.
10:36
Now, in the midst
10:38
of yet another detente, an
10:40
ever-tightening blockade is pushing the
10:42
mountainous enclave to the point of starvation.
10:47
This week, in a one-off agreement,
10:49
a single truck's worth of food entered
10:52
the region, the first since June
10:54
15th. A
10:56
deal for more remains elusive,
10:59
and as Azerbaijan pushes for ultimate
11:01
control of the region, a
11:03
humanitarian disaster is
11:05
unfolding. So
11:07
about nine months ago, Azerbaijani protesters who were
11:11
backed by the Azerbaijani government launched
11:13
a de facto blockade of what's
11:16
called the Laxin Corridor, which is the only
11:18
road leading from this territory
11:20
of Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia
11:23
and therefore to the outside world. Joshua
11:27
Kuchera writes for The Economist,
11:30
At the time, shipments of food and
11:32
fuel were curtailed, but still
11:34
enough got through to keep the situation from
11:36
getting too dire. Step by step,
11:38
the Azerbaijanis have tightened the screws
11:41
on this blockade. In April,
11:43
they installed an official border checkpoint
11:45
on that Laxin road, and then
11:47
in mid-June, they shut it down
11:49
completely, and since then virtually
11:51
nothing has gotten through. So the situation
11:54
has become quite dire.
11:56
So why is Azerbaijan doing
11:58
this? How is it in their
11:59
interest for the people of Nagorno-Karabakh
12:02
to stop. So the
12:04
population right now of Karabakh is ethnically
12:07
Armenian. This is part of what
12:09
was in the Soviet Union, an autonomous oblast,
12:12
part of the Azerbaijan Soviet
12:15
Republic that was at the time a majority
12:18
ethnic Armenian. In the late 80s
12:20
and early 90s, as the Soviet
12:22
Union was collapsing, there was a war
12:24
between ethnic Armenian forces and
12:26
Azerbaijanis. Armenians won that.
12:29
As a result, they took control of Karabakh
12:32
and they also took control of seven
12:34
territories surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh,
12:37
which were populated mostly by
12:39
ethnic Azerbaijanis. As a result,
12:41
about 600 ethnic Azerbaijanis
12:44
were ethnically cleansed from that territory.
12:47
In 2020, there was a second war. Azerbaijan
12:51
reversed many of those losses. They gained control
12:53
of all those seven territories, plus part of
12:55
Nagorno-Karabakh itself. Now
12:58
it has surrounded Karabakh completely
13:01
and Azerbaijan is pushing to take
13:03
full control over Karabakh
13:06
itself and that Armenian population. And
13:09
this blockade is effectively
13:11
a hard bargaining tool in
13:13
order to get the Armenians
13:15
to give up control and
13:18
cede control to the Azerbaijani government.
13:21
And so what's standing in the way of that
13:23
agreement?
13:24
So diplomatic negotiations have been going on
13:27
between Armenians and Azerbaijanis about
13:29
a final resolution to the conflict. And
13:32
Armenian Prime Minister, Nikol Pashinyan,
13:34
has signaled that he's willing to
13:36
cede control of Karabakh back
13:39
to the Azerbaijanis. But
13:41
the Armenians want, in exchange for that,
13:43
some kind of guarantee that the
13:45
rights and security of the ethnic population
13:48
of Nagorno-Karabakh will be respected under Azerbaijani
13:51
rule. The Azerbaijani government has
13:53
been claiming that they want to reintegrate
13:55
the Armenian population back into Azerbaijan
13:58
and that doing so, the Armenians have all
14:00
the same rights as Azerbaijan's citizens, Armenians
14:03
don't trust them on that. This is a
14:05
crux of the political disagreement
14:07
now. If one were trying to give
14:10
Azerbaijan the benefit of the doubt about
14:12
their sincerity before this blockade, I
14:15
think that as the blockade has continued
14:17
and gotten more harsh, it's becoming more and
14:19
more difficult to believe that this is anything other
14:21
than an attempt to force out
14:24
the Armenian population by making
14:26
life unbearable for them. This has
14:29
really poisoned the diplomatic negotiations
14:31
that have been going on between the two sides, and
14:34
it's made the Armenians unwilling
14:36
to cede control of this territory because
14:38
they believe that the Azerbaijanis are
14:41
just going to force them to leave.
14:44
So give us a bit more detail of just
14:46
how dire things are looking in the region.
14:48
So since the blockade has become
14:50
virtually total over the last two or three
14:52
months, virtually no food, no
14:55
fuel, no medicine has gotten
14:57
in. Bread is rationed to half
15:00
a loaf per person per day. Grocery
15:02
stores are closed. Critical
15:05
medicines have run out. Fuel
15:07
has become rationed very heavily.
15:09
Public transportation was shut down some time
15:12
ago. There are reports of patients
15:14
who are very ill and they need to get to the
15:16
doctor, but A, there's no gas
15:19
in their car to get them there, and B, there's
15:21
not any medication at the hospital
15:24
even if they were to get there. Doctors
15:26
are reporting deaths and sicknesses
15:28
because of malnutrition. People themselves
15:31
cannot get in and out, and so you have families
15:33
separated. The situation is really
15:35
getting quite dire. So
15:37
what's
15:37
the way forward?
15:39
So as this has been going on, Azerbaijan
15:41
has been offering to open up a
15:43
different road into Karabakh. This one from Azerbaijan
15:46
Proper. They're arguing that since Karabakh
15:49
is internationally recognized as Azerbaijan
15:51
territory, that they should get all of
15:53
their necessary goods from Azerbaijan rather
15:55
than from Armenia. The Karabakh Armenians
15:58
have been refusing. seeing this offer
16:01
as a kind of Trojan horse that
16:03
would eventually lead to Azerbaijan
16:05
gaining political control over the
16:07
territory. So they've even gone so far
16:09
as to erect blockades of their own on
16:11
that road in order to prevent any Azerbaijani
16:14
traffic or goods getting in. This
16:17
is the impasse we're at now. International
16:19
mediators, including both the EU and
16:22
Russia, have been trying to broker
16:24
some kind of deal that would involve both roads being
16:26
opened. There's disputes over the details,
16:29
in particular the sequencing. Azerbaijanis
16:31
want their road to open first. Armenians,
16:34
however, don't trust them and they believe that if they do
16:36
it like that, then Azerbaijan will renege on
16:38
their part of the deal. So they want both roads
16:40
to be open simultaneously. There were reports
16:43
this weekend that a deal had been reached, but
16:45
then it quickly broke down and it seems like
16:47
we're back at the same impasse now.
16:49
And all
16:51
the while, the people of Nagorno-Karabakhstov,
16:55
what happens next?
16:57
It's difficult to know precisely what's going
16:59
on inside because since 2020, no
17:02
independent journalists, no foreigners have been able
17:05
to get into Karabakh at all. There
17:07
are indications of a kind of power
17:09
struggle inside Nagorno-Karabakh.
17:12
There's internal disputes among the
17:14
political elite of Nagorno-Karabakh
17:16
about how to deal with this blockade.
17:19
Some people are advocating accepting
17:21
the Azerbaijani aid. Some people are against
17:23
it. The de facto president
17:25
of the territory just stepped down and was
17:28
replaced over the weekend. So I
17:30
think, however, this road situation
17:32
is resolved in the bigger picture.
17:34
I think what the result of all of this is going
17:36
to be is that whatever hope
17:39
there might have been that the ethnic
17:41
Armenian population of Karabakh could
17:43
live safely and securely with
17:45
their rights respected under
17:47
the Azerbaijan flag as part of Azerbaijan,
17:50
that hope is mostly gone.
17:53
Joshua, thank you so much for your time. Thanks
17:55
for having me.
18:12
One day when Douglas Lennison, his wife Mary,
18:15
were driving along the road, a trash
18:17
truck
18:18
in front of them started to shed its load.
18:20
Anne Rowe is
18:22
the Economist's obituary's editor. Storage
18:25
bags were bouncing all over the road,
18:28
and he had to decide instantly whether
18:30
to swerve into another lane, which he couldn't
18:32
as there were cars all round him, or drive
18:34
over the bags. And then
18:36
he thought, well, I won't go over the household bags
18:39
because they've probably got sharp stuff
18:41
thrown away in them. If that's a restaurant
18:43
bag, I'll go over that because it will only
18:46
have
18:46
styrofoam cups and food waste.
18:51
So he drove over the restaurant
18:53
bag and the car survived. And
18:58
he reflected how long had it taken
19:00
him to make all those decisions, probably
19:02
a
19:03
few seconds.
19:04
How long would a computer take? Well,
19:08
much too long in any case, because
19:10
the problem with computers was that they
19:13
simply had no understanding
19:15
of how the world worked. For
19:17
four decades, he had been trying
19:19
to train computers to
19:22
think in a more human way. He
19:24
had devised a system called PSYCH
19:27
in which he was handwriting and feeding
19:29
into the system rules of
19:32
thinking and rules about the world.
19:36
In the end, he had 25 million
19:39
such rules,
19:39
but
19:41
he had to begin with the simplest propositions,
19:44
such as a cat has four
19:46
legs, that is, if you leave
19:48
uncovered things out in the rain, they will
19:50
get wet. If you turn
19:53
the coffee cup upside down, the coffee in it
19:55
will fall out. All
19:57
these little rules and pieces
19:59
of paper. of information about the world which he
20:02
as a human being had been learning
20:05
unconsciously almost since he was
20:07
tiny and now had to
20:09
somehow be fed into
20:11
a machine.
20:17
The main problem he found was
20:20
disambiguation.
20:21
It
20:24
was pronounced
20:25
as in a sentence like, Tom
20:27
was mad because Joe stole his lunch.
20:30
Or who does the his refer to?
20:33
Humans just know who hates Tom, but
20:35
a computer doesn't know that.
20:37
So you have to go back right to the
20:39
beginning of the construction of the sentence and make
20:41
sure everything is crystal clear. So
20:44
this is what his work consisted of year
20:46
in and year out.
20:50
It was a very very slow process.
20:54
In 1984 when he was
20:56
first taken on as chief scientist
20:58
when he'd come down from Stanford, he
21:01
gathered together the six cleverest people
21:03
he knew and he asked them how long they thought
21:05
it would take to train a computer
21:08
to think this way. And
21:10
to his surprise they all more or less agreed
21:12
that it would need a million rules
21:14
and that it would probably take a hundred
21:17
person years to achieve. It
21:21
took him more than 2000 person
21:23
years to get to his 25 million
21:25
rules and still counting on
21:27
both of them. And while he
21:29
was slowly going on, a
21:32
different way of doing AI was coming
21:34
into the ascendant and this was machine
21:36
learning by which vast
21:39
troves of data were presented
21:41
to computers and they were encouraged to find
21:44
their own rules and patterns in it.
21:48
And these large language models
21:51
soon became a direct rival to his
21:53
own system which he'd called psych.
21:57
So he would puzzle how he
21:59
was going to do it. to survive
22:01
in this world in which large
22:03
language models were making all the running
22:06
and he was plodding on. He
22:09
didn't abandon his project, he never
22:12
thought of doing that. He
22:14
knew he was in it for the long haul and he didn't
22:17
care that he was not going
22:19
to conferences or playing the academic game,
22:21
he was keeping a very low profile in
22:23
a tiny little office off a highway
22:25
in Austin, Texas. But
22:28
he was still determined to
22:31
get his system going and he thought
22:33
that the ideal thing to
22:35
do would be to use both
22:38
large language models, machine learning
22:41
and his psych system so that you got
22:43
the speed of the machine
22:45
learning together with the
22:48
subtlety of his
22:50
own system. And
22:52
he felt this would give him an AI which
22:54
was fantastically ubiquitous
22:57
and useful to everybody. This
23:00
is what had intrigued him about it from the very
23:02
beginning. He'd got hooked
23:03
first of all as a schoolboy on the novels
23:05
of Isaac Asimov
23:07
and then he'd gone to Stanford to
23:09
study maths and physics but had found
23:12
that at the level he took them they'd
23:14
got very abstracts and divorce from physical
23:16
reality. He wanted to study
23:19
something that was going to make a real difference to the
23:21
world and that turned out to be AI.
23:26
He dreamed of a world in which AI
23:29
was helping to make human beings smarter
23:33
and they had them as a sort of amplifier
23:35
to all their mental processes. He
23:38
also thought they would make humans more
23:40
creative and
23:42
he found his work nothing but joy because
23:44
with every rule he fed into a computer.
23:47
He had actually improved
23:50
the whole system of AI. He had
23:53
created a being
23:55
almost that did not need
23:57
to be recreated that could only be improved
23:59
as he did. went on adding to it. But
24:03
was his system actually intelligent?
24:06
It could do a lot of things. He found that psych
24:08
could offer pros and cons
24:10
to an argument. It
24:14
knew about human emotions and how they influenced
24:16
actions.
24:18
It could argue in a real world
24:21
context or in other contexts. It
24:23
had that power to do so. But
24:26
its main interest to him was
24:29
not whether it was intelligent in itself, but
24:31
whether it would add to the intelligence of humans.
24:34
And he felt that it would do so
24:36
to such a degree that our descendants
24:39
would look back at all the pre-AI
24:42
generations and think that they were like
24:44
cavemen, not really quite
24:46
human.
24:49
Psych asked him one day, am
24:52
I a person?
24:54
But rather sadly he had to say no.
25:03
Anne Rowe on Douglas Lennon
25:05
who has died aged 72. For
25:09
the next few weeks our sister
25:11
podcast Babbage is uncovering
25:14
the future of artificial intelligence.
25:16
In the most recent episode my colleague
25:19
Alok Jha asked leading researcher
25:21
Mr. Farsulayman whether society
25:23
should be worried about the new age of AI.
25:27
Listen to Babbage wherever you found this
25:29
and wherever machines learn supervised
25:32
and unsupervised.
25:46
That's all for this episode of the intelligence.
25:49
As you heard we are launching a new
25:51
subscription economist podcast plus
25:54
next month. Don't worry we
25:56
aren't going anywhere everyone will be
25:59
able to listen to our new videos. day episodes of The Intelligence.
26:02
But to enjoy our full suite of
26:04
podcasts, including our specialist
26:06
weekly shows like Money Talks and Drum
26:08
Tower, and our new weekend
26:10
show, you'll need a subscription. If
26:13
you're already an Economist subscriber, don't
26:15
worry, you'll have full access to all
26:17
of our shows. But if you're not a subscriber
26:19
yet, listen up. If you sign up for
26:21
Economist Podcast Plus before October
26:24
17th, you can get a year-long subscription
26:26
for half price, about $2 a month. So
26:29
come on, follow the link in our show
26:32
notes to find out more. And we'll
26:33
see you back here.
26:35
Bye.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More