Popular Reviews of either

Incredible story with believable characters and an interesting world. Aster and Only became very dear to me very early on, and you get a lot of time to explore their relationship alongside the overarching mystery.

So 4 stars is just the average of my two ratings. It gets 5 stars for story and acting, and 2 stars for editing and accessibility. (yes that averages 3.5 but I rounded up) The story is amazing, if you like Welcome to Night Vale, you'll likely enjoy this show as well. But be warned, the intro, intermission, and outro music is significantly louder than the dialogue and there are no transcripts which makes listening to any episode with Multiple people in one scene difficult, and nearly unlistenable if you have any time of auditory processing issues. Especially once red hands shows up or whenever Lucia and Aster as talking together. Spotify's autogenerated transcript was the only way I could get through some of the first season