Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
The. Following is an encore presentation of
0:02
everything everywhere. daily. In.
0:07
Eighteen forty five farmers around Europe suffered
0:09
from a blight that devastated the potato
0:11
crop. This. Lasted for several years but
0:14
no one was a more pronounced than it
0:16
was on the Island of Ireland where it
0:18
resulted in death in mass migration. The
0:20
effect of this potato blight can still be witnessed
0:22
in the world today. Learn more
0:24
about the Great Irish Famine also known as
0:26
the Irish Potato Famine. on this episode of
0:28
Everything Everywhere Daily. This.
0:43
Episode is sponsored by He Harmony. The
0:45
best relationships are the ones that make us
0:47
feel most like ourselves. the people we can
0:50
be ourselves around, or the people who really
0:52
see us For us, they really get us.
0:55
Some want to use a dating app
0:57
that's designed to specifically do that. He
0:59
Harmony helps you find someone you can
1:01
be yourself with. This. Is
1:03
extremely difficult to do on most dating apps
1:05
because all you get is a paragraph or
1:08
two and a couple of images which are
1:10
somehow supposed to summarize who you are as
1:12
a person. The majority of
1:14
people surveyed agree that they're dating profile doesn't
1:16
give a false sense of who they are.
1:19
The Harmony Sign Up process gives
1:21
each person a distinct personality profile
1:23
that shows what makes them them
1:25
based on a set of questions
1:27
that everyone on the platform answers.
1:30
He. Harmony members see how share personality
1:32
traits with people, feel instantly related will
1:34
and how differences can complement one
1:36
another. Get someone who
1:39
gets you. Try He harmony and
1:41
get started today for free. This.
1:43
Episode is sponsored by Draft Kings. Draft.
1:46
Kings Sports Book and official Sports betting partner
1:48
of the Nfl Playoffs is bringing you an
1:51
offer that will help make the playoffs electrifying.
1:53
New customers can bet five bucks on any
1:55
game and get two hundred instantly in bonus
1:58
bets. This. Week the money line for the. The
2:00
Buccaneers game is plus One Twenty Buccaneers.
2:03
Download the Draft Kings Sports Book app
2:05
now and use code Everything New Customers
2:07
can bet just five bucks to get
2:09
two hundred instantly and bonus bets only
2:12
A Draft Kings Sports Book with code
2:14
every sang. The. Crown is yours.
2:17
Can. We from Albany hundred and of is attributable
2:19
to have.one hundred ever done that in New York's
2:21
colleagues of inseminate hoping why or test for than
2:23
Whites for Six Seven Three Six Nine Synthetic It
2:26
helps build for problem again We call it it
2:28
Eight Seventy Nine Some Seven Seven Seven or visit
2:30
ccp.org Spike responsibly I have a Boot Hill consumers
2:32
or in Kansas. Twenty One Plus Eight varies by
2:34
your second point Ontario Sports metics by one hundred
2:36
and sixty eight hours after issuance. Ctk engine dot
2:38
coms like for of eligibility as possible for concerns
2:40
and response Beginning resources. To
2:47
understand how and why the Irish Potato
2:49
Famine occurred, there are a few things
2:51
we need to understand First and most
2:53
important was economic and political situation in
2:55
Ireland at the time. Despite
2:57
the fact that Ireland was supposedly fully
2:59
integrated into the United Kingdom, it was
3:01
in reality a colony, having been conquered
3:03
by England. Almost all major landowners in
3:06
Ireland where English or Anglo Irish. In
3:09
theory, they had representation in parliament in both
3:11
the House of Commons in the House of
3:13
Lords, but almost all of those people were
3:15
also wealthy Englishman. Many of
3:17
the landowners in Ireland also didn't even live
3:19
there. They simply had no connection to the
3:21
land with people who work on the land.
3:23
It was simply and investment. Almost
3:26
all of the land was confiscated by
3:28
force by aristocratic English starting back in
3:30
the seventeenth century. Irish
3:32
Catholics were, for all practical purposes
3:34
second class citizens in their own
3:36
country. The way the
3:38
absentee landlords would make money was by renting their
3:40
lands out to peasants who would grow crops for
3:42
export. This was all conducted via
3:44
system known as the middleman system. Agents
3:47
would be hired who lived in Ireland and collected
3:49
all the rents. These. Agents
3:51
held great power and they could and
3:53
did abuses power on a regular basis.
3:56
Their. Bosses weren't there and quite frankly didn't
3:58
really care. As long as there rent for
4:00
paid, almost all of the money made in
4:02
Ireland was sent out of the country. This
4:05
system resulted in Ireland being the poorest country
4:07
in Europe in the mid nineteenth century. Parliament.
4:10
Connected many inquiries into the problems of
4:13
Ireland's one such report which the Earl
4:15
of Devon oversaw reported quote. He.
4:17
Would be impossible adequately describe the privations
4:19
which the Irish labor and his family
4:21
habitually and silently endure It Many districts
4:23
they're only food is the potato and
4:26
they're only beverage water. Their cabins are
4:28
seldom a protection against the weather. A
4:30
bed or blanket is a rare luxury.
4:33
And in nearly all, their pig and
4:35
a manure heap constitute their only property.
4:38
And. Quote. On top
4:40
of this, Ireland also had the highest population
4:42
density of any country in Europe at the
4:44
time, and I had a population of about
4:46
eight point, seven, five million people. I
4:49
should also note that at this time, much of
4:51
the native population in Ireland didn't even speak English.
4:53
They spoke Gaelic. A poor,
4:55
large population resulted in high rents for very
4:58
small plots of land, which were the only
5:00
things that peasants had to grow their own
5:02
food. And this brings me to the
5:04
subject of a potato. If
5:06
you remember back, I did an entire
5:08
episode on potatoes. Potatoes were actually a
5:10
miracle crop for Europe. Wants Europeans opened
5:12
up to it. Potatoes provided far more
5:14
calories and nutrients than any other crop
5:16
which could be grown. If the amount
5:18
of land you had was limited than
5:20
the smart option was to grow potatoes.
5:23
For poor Irish Catholics, Potatoes for the
5:25
foundation of their diet. They would
5:27
literally eat potatoes in almost every form
5:29
for every meal. They might occasionally have
5:31
some butter and onions with them, but that
5:33
was about it. Not only
5:36
did people eat potatoes, but so did the
5:38
lifestyle. It turns out that
5:40
Ireland was also very well suited for potato production.
5:42
They grew well, and Ireland was one of the
5:44
first countries in Europe to adopt a potato. Potato
5:47
was really the food the made life in
5:50
Ireland even possible in the mid nineteenth century.
5:53
And then something happened around eighteen. Forty
5:55
Two Eighteen Forty Four. In
5:57
the Toluca Valley in Mexico or Passage and. The
6:00
and spread and potatoes was a fungus
6:02
second wipe out entire crops and make
6:04
the products inedible. The blight
6:06
spread north into the United States, but the
6:08
impact wasn't that severe because Americans weren't reliant
6:10
on potatoes that a wide variety of foods
6:13
of are grown. and without potatoes they are
6:15
plenty of substitutes. From the U
6:17
S, the blight spread by shipped to Europe. And
6:20
here I should note that the potato blight
6:22
didn't only occur in Ireland. The Irish Potato
6:24
Famine was just a subset of what was
6:26
known as the European Potato Failure, which affected
6:29
most of Europe where potatoes were grown. In
6:32
fact, many countries suffered worse potato harvest
6:34
then Ireland. It. Would magnify
6:36
problems in Ireland was the poverty,
6:38
land ownership, and over reliance on
6:40
a single crop. When. The
6:42
Blade arrived in Ireland and eighteen forty five. Nobody
6:45
was your what caused it. It was a bad
6:47
year for whether the worst that any one of
6:49
any age could remember. The. Blight
6:51
was first reported on the Isle of Wight and
6:53
mid August, and it was spreading through Ireland like
6:55
wildfire by September. It became clear
6:57
that Ireland was going to have big problems.
7:00
Estimates are that a potato crop and eighteen
7:02
forty five was down by a third to
7:04
assess. Not to be sure a
7:06
failed crop is a bad thing, but if a
7:09
single year's crop goes bad, it usually is something
7:11
that you can survive. This. Happened before
7:13
in Ireland and it wasn't an unfamiliar
7:15
occurrence in all a cultural societies. What
7:18
made this so bad is it the blaze
7:20
didn't go away. In eighteen, forty
7:22
six was estimated that seventy five percent
7:24
of the potato crop was lost. Or
7:27
was just widespread hardship and now turned
7:30
into an actual famine. The
7:32
government's reaction to this was totally out of
7:34
the hands of the Irish who really didn't
7:36
control anything. All. Around Europe governments
7:38
did two things immediately. first be remove tariffs
7:41
on food imports are the more food could
7:43
come into the country from on affected areas.
7:45
Second the usually band food exports so more
7:47
food was available to the people in their
7:50
own country. This is exactly
7:52
what Ireland did back and seventeen Eighty Two
7:54
and seventeen Eighty three when Ireland face to
7:56
food shortage. The. british parliament did
7:58
the first thing They removed what were
8:00
known as the Corn Laws which were high tariffs on
8:02
grain. However, they never did
8:05
anything about exports. During
8:07
the entire time of the famine, Ireland
8:09
was exporting food out of the country,
8:11
usually to England. Food
8:14
which was owned by wealthy Englishmen who
8:16
didn't live in Ireland. The
8:18
person who the British sent to Ireland had up
8:20
relief efforts was Sir Charles Trevlyn. The
8:23
problem was Trevlyn pretty much hated the
8:25
Irish. He didn't view the famine
8:27
as a problem of food or even land ownership. He
8:30
viewed the famine as a result of the moral failure
8:32
of the Irish. He thought
8:34
that this was the judgment of God on
8:36
the Catholics and said, quote, the real evil
8:38
with which we have to contend is not
8:40
the physical evil of the famine, but the
8:42
moral evil of the selfish, perverse and turbulent
8:44
character of the Irish people. End
8:47
quote. 1847
8:49
was probably the worst year of the famine. Parliament
8:51
passed the Poor Law Amendment Act which modified the 1838
8:53
Irish Poor Law. This
8:56
law mandated that anyone who owned at least
8:58
a quarter acre of land was ineligible for
9:00
any aid or assistance. This
9:02
meant that someone who had sold off everything
9:05
to pay their rent would now receive nothing
9:07
until the land reverted back to the landowner.
9:10
This resulted in massive evictions which began
9:12
in 1847, but increased all the way
9:14
through Also,
9:16
because of the hunger deaths which began in
9:19
1846, there were few seed potatoes available for
9:21
1847, which just made matters worse. An
9:24
estimated 50,000 families were evicted from their land between
9:26
1847 and 1850. The
9:29
total number of deaths from 1845 to 1851 is unknown, but the estimates are
9:32
usually around
9:35
one million and as high as 1.5 million. This
9:39
includes deaths from starvation and from disease.
9:42
In addition to the deaths, the famine also
9:44
resulted in a massive wave of immigration out
9:46
of Ireland. There was a
9:48
peak of 250,000 people who immigrated to the United States
9:50
in just 1847 with another 100,000
9:53
who left for Canada. Immigrants
9:56
brought diseases with them which ravaged the ships as
9:58
they crossed the Atlantic and they were were responsible
10:00
for a large outbreak of typhus in the United
10:02
States in 1847. Many immigrants were
10:05
often sent away by their landlords in exchange
10:07
for their land. Most of
10:09
the immigrants in North America were young people,
10:12
predominantly, from the western counties of Ireland. Many
10:15
people also immigrated to England. Liverpool became a
10:17
quarter Irish by the year 1851. Aidan
10:21
donations were sent to Ireland from around the world.
10:23
The most interesting donation came from the Choctaw
10:25
Nation of Oklahoma, who had been forced to
10:27
live there via the Trail of Tears just
10:29
a few years earlier. They raised $170,
10:31
which was a fair amount of money for
10:35
1847, and a whole lot of
10:37
money for a mid-19th century tribe that had lost its
10:39
land. The Great Famine
10:41
set off a spark that resulted in massive
10:44
changes to Ireland. It really could be said
10:46
to have kicked off the Irish National Movement,
10:48
which eventually resulted in Irish independence decades later.
10:51
The biggest example of this was the young Ireland
10:53
Rebellion of 1848.
10:55
Immigration from Ireland didn't stop
10:57
once the famine was over. Ireland
10:59
saw a decrease in population every
11:01
decade until the early 1960s, when
11:03
the population bottomed out at around
11:05
2.1 million people. Even
11:08
today in the 21st century, the population of Ireland,
11:10
both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, is
11:12
less than what it was in 1841. As for
11:14
the blight
11:17
itself, it was eventually identified as
11:19
the fungus Phytophthora infestans, which can
11:22
still infect potato and tomato crops
11:24
today. In fact, there was
11:26
another potato blight which occurred in Ireland in 1879, but it
11:28
never resulted in a mass death. So
11:32
one of the big questions for historians is
11:34
why did crop failures before and after the
11:37
Great Famine not result in the same things?
11:40
Why did the same potato blight in other
11:42
European countries not result in famine when it
11:44
did in Ireland? The overwhelming
11:46
historical consensus is that it was due to
11:48
the British response and the rule over Ireland.
11:51
The land confiscation, absentee landlords, the
11:53
middleman system, the evictions, the failure
11:56
to stop food exports all contributed
11:58
to turning a bad situation. into
12:00
a disaster. John Mitchell,
12:02
one of the leaders of the Young Ireland Rebellion in 1848,
12:05
wrote one of the first academic accounts of the famine in
12:07
1860 and in
12:10
it he wrote, quote, The Almighty indeed
12:12
sent the potato blight but the English
12:14
created the famine. Today
12:16
there are many commemorations of the Great Irish
12:18
Famine. There is an unofficial National Famine
12:21
Commemoration Day in Ireland which is celebrated on
12:23
the third Sunday in May. In
12:25
2015 a sculpture titled Kindred
12:28
Spirits was installed in County Cork which
12:30
honors the donation of the Choctaw people.
12:32
There is an Irish Hunger Memorial located near
12:35
Battery Park in New York and the National
12:37
Famine Museum is located in Strokes Town Park,
12:39
County Ross Common, Ireland. The
12:41
Great Famine remains probably the singular most
12:43
influential event in the history of modern
12:45
Ireland. It has directly or
12:48
indirectly shaped the history and demographics of
12:50
the island of Ireland for over a
12:52
hundred and seventy-five years. The
12:58
executive producer of Everything Everywhere Daily is Charles
13:00
Daniel. The associate producers are Peter Bennett and
13:02
Cameron Kiefer. I wanted to
13:04
give a big thanks to everyone who supports
13:06
the show on Patreon. Your support helps me
13:09
put out a new show every day and
13:11
if you're interested in Everything Everywhere Daily merchandise,
13:13
Patreon is currently the only place where it's
13:16
available and if you'd like to
13:18
talk to other listeners of the show and get
13:20
notified of future episodes and projects, please join my
13:22
Facebook group or Discord server. Links to
13:24
Everything are in the show notes.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More