Podchaser Logo
Home
Who will govern Pakistan?

Who will govern Pakistan?

Released Saturday, 10th February 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Who will govern Pakistan?

Who will govern Pakistan?

Who will govern Pakistan?

Who will govern Pakistan?

Saturday, 10th February 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This is the BBC. This

0:03

podcast is supported by advertising outside

0:05

the UK. 2024

0:11

is all about new beginnings, and to

0:14

help you become the best version of

0:16

yourself this year, Cerebral just launched their

0:18

newest innovation designed to support you in

0:20

reaching your mental health goals. It's called

0:22

Cerebral Way, a personalised path to mental

0:25

wellness that is designed specifically around your

0:27

unique needs and experiences. Your Cerebral therapist

0:29

or prescriber will outline a customised plan

0:31

with clear milestones along the way so

0:34

you can get to feeling your best

0:36

in 2024. Sign

0:38

up today at cerebral.com/podcast

0:40

and use code ACAST to get 15%

0:42

off your first month. Offer only valid

0:44

on monthly plans. Other exclusions may apply.

0:47

Offer ends April 30th. See site for

0:49

details. Welcome to your 2023 work recap. This

0:52

year, you've been to 127 sync meetings. You

0:56

spent 56 minutes searching for files

0:58

and almost missed eight deadlines. Yikes!

1:02

2024 can and should sound different.

1:04

With monday.com, you can work together

1:07

easily, collaborate and share data, files

1:09

and updates. So all work happens

1:11

in one place and everyone's on the same

1:13

page. Go to monday.com or tap the banner

1:15

to learn more. Radio

1:26

podcasts. Today, in

1:28

the country of beefsteak, even a

1:30

chicken is a treat these days

1:33

as rampant inflation pushes the cost

1:35

of living ever higher in Argentina.

1:38

How harsh laws and social taboos

1:41

are risking the health of women

1:43

and girls in Kenya. Would

1:46

you choose to go into the

1:48

Amazonian jungle with a former guerrilla

1:50

fighter? These days, Colombia

1:52

invites you to do just

1:54

that, to go birdwatching. And

1:57

the law of the bratwurst in

1:59

Germany. money, don't mess around with

2:02

the recipe, and forget about making

2:04

a vegan version, this sausage means

2:06

far too much to people. But

2:10

first to Indonesia, the world's

2:12

largest Muslim-majority democracy, which will

2:14

vote for its next president

2:16

on the 14th of February.

2:20

Current opinion polls suggest that the

2:22

former general, Prabhoo Sobianto, will win

2:24

out on his third attempt to

2:26

become the country's leader. Rebecca

2:29

Henske reported for the BBC for

2:31

15 years from Indonesia.

2:33

When she recently returned, she

2:35

found, much to her surprise,

2:38

that the 72-year-old former strongman

2:41

has undergone an extraordinary

2:43

rebranding to win over

2:45

first-time voters. Puppy

2:47

Dog eyes on a smiling, chubby-cheeked

2:49

cartoon face stare down at me

2:52

from huge campaign posters that line

2:54

either side of the Java highway

2:56

I'm driving on. I'm

2:58

struggling to get my head around this

3:00

image. It's clearly

3:02

presidential candidate Prabhoo Sobianto.

3:06

But the last time he ran for office

3:08

when I was a correspondent in Jakarta, the

3:10

images were of him commanding or marching with

3:13

troops. He always appeared

3:15

happiest when a strider horse or

3:17

raising his fist in anger during

3:19

a firebrand speech. This

3:22

former top general from a powerful

3:24

family has long revelled in a

3:27

strongman image, not a

3:29

sweet, cute one. Prabhoo

3:32

was dismissed from the military after

3:34

accusations that he was involved in

3:36

the kidnapping and torture of pro-democracy

3:38

students in the late 90s

3:41

in the turbulent dying days of the

3:43

Sahato regime. He was banned

3:45

from entering the United States for a

3:47

while due to rights allegations against him.

3:50

In a press lunch event back

3:53

in 2013, I raised in a

3:55

question this dark past of his. He

3:58

looked clearly insulted, glared, and

4:00

down at me from the speaker's podium, paused

4:03

and said, I knew this question would

4:05

come, and then

4:07

said, let the Indonesian people judge

4:10

me. But now

4:12

there's a whole generation of voters

4:14

who didn't live through the Soharto

4:16

dictatorship or experienced the Asian economic

4:18

crisis of the 1990s,

4:21

or the bloody battle for Timor

4:23

Leste's independence. And these

4:25

dark parts of Indonesia's modern history

4:27

that Prabhupala played a role in

4:29

are not taught in schools. So

4:32

he's not really getting asked that

4:34

question by young voters, and

4:36

they make up half the electorate this time around.

4:40

Instead, under TikTok videos of

4:42

the 72-year-old dancing or cuddling

4:44

his cat, they're calling

4:46

him Gemmul or Cute. It's

4:49

an extraordinary rebranding, from

4:52

a strong man to a

4:54

harmless grandfather. So

4:57

too is his selection of running mates, Gibram

5:00

Rakuboming, the son of current

5:02

president Jokowododo or Jokowi. Gibram

5:05

too has undergone quite a makeover since

5:07

I last saw him. Eight

5:10

years ago, I visited him at the cafe

5:12

he was running down a side street in

5:14

his hometown of Sohlo. He

5:16

specialised in Mataba, stuffed

5:18

fried pancakes. He

5:21

clearly wasn't thrilled to be meeting journalists.

5:24

On that day, he was moody. He

5:26

told us he wasn't interested in following

5:28

his father's footsteps into politics and

5:30

didn't want to discuss his dad's policies. What

5:33

he wanted to talk about was all

5:35

the unusual new flavours of Mataba his

5:37

cafe was offering. We

5:40

ended up not running the interview. But

5:42

here we are in 2024 and he's

5:45

running for the nation's highest office with

5:47

no political experience apart from a two-year

5:49

stint as the mayor of his hometown.

5:52

At 36, Gibram is the youngest

5:55

presidential candidate in Indonesian history. He

5:57

used to have to be faulty to run. campaign

6:00

team successfully and very

6:02

controversially petitioned the constitutional

6:04

court. And at

6:07

this stage, this pairing and rebranding

6:09

has resulted in Prabhu and Gibran

6:11

being well ahead in the polls.

6:15

I know some former journalists and press

6:17

freedom activists who did everything to see

6:19

the end of the Sahato regime and

6:22

then to keep Prabhu out of office

6:24

in previous elections who are now campaigning

6:26

for him. One asked

6:28

one to explain to me why they said

6:30

it was a complex

6:32

political decision. Another

6:34

said it was being pragmatic. But

6:37

the question remains what kind

6:39

of president would Prabhu or be? What

6:42

version of him might show up to run

6:44

the country? Or will it

6:46

be Jokowi who's really pulling the

6:48

strings? After two terms

6:51

in office, the former furniture maker can't

6:53

run in this election but he's

6:55

very present in it. In

6:58

another campaign poster, his image

7:00

looms large over Prabhu and

7:02

Gibran. And the pair have made

7:04

no secret of this. If elected,

7:07

they will be Jokowi 2.0. They're

7:10

promising to complete all his

7:12

infrastructure projects, including the building

7:14

of a new capital on the island of

7:16

Borneo. This

7:18

loyalty from Prabhu to a man

7:21

he suffered two previous humiliating defeats

7:23

to is in stark contrast to

7:25

what he said before. When

7:28

Prabhu lost to Jokowi the first time

7:31

around, he marched into our Jakarta bureau

7:33

and sat down for a live TV

7:35

interview. He was clearly

7:37

angry. On air he rejected

7:39

the early results, saying Jokowi's image of

7:42

being a man of the people was

7:44

just an act and calling him a

7:46

puppet of the political oligarchy. Now

7:49

it looks like Prabhu is a puppet of

7:51

Jokowi, who's proven less a humble

7:54

man of the people and

7:56

more a shrewd political operator with

7:58

a clever social media. media team. Rebecca

8:02

Hensky When Javier

8:04

Millet won Argentina's presidential contest

8:06

in November, nobody predicted an

8:08

easy ride for him or

8:10

for the country. He

8:13

was elected thanks to his promises

8:15

to break with the political establishment

8:17

and take bold steps to get

8:19

Argentina out of its dire economic

8:21

straits. He's pushing for

8:23

a huge package of changes,

8:25

nicknamed the ahustato, or the

8:27

big adjustment, which proposes a

8:30

blizzard of measures. Some

8:32

are radical and highly controversial, like

8:35

abolishing entire state ministries, reducing

8:37

the powers of trade unions,

8:39

and limiting rights to public

8:41

protest. Millet's critics

8:43

called a national strike last week

8:45

in response, and more than one

8:47

and a half million people turned

8:50

out at demonstrations across the country.

8:53

A small majority of Argentines still

8:55

back him, but how far and

8:57

for how long will they stick

8:59

with him? James Menendez.

9:02

Every morning over breakfast in Buenos Aires,

9:04

I'd look out of the hotel window

9:06

at the bustling street just below. Smartly

9:09

dressed workers hurried towards their offices, and

9:11

none of them seemed to notice the

9:14

rather sad-looking red postbox that sat awkwardly

9:16

on the corner, leaning like the Tower

9:18

of Pisa. I'd flown in

9:20

from London, so a red postbox on

9:22

a street corner was hardly a novelty.

9:25

Except I was now in Argentina, and

9:27

this one looked identical to some of

9:29

the postboxes back home. After

9:32

a few inquiries, it turns out it

9:34

is the same model, a remnant of

9:37

the close ties between the UK and

9:39

Argentina in the 19th and early 20th

9:41

centuries. Back

9:43

then, Britain was at the height of its

9:45

imperial and commercial power. Argentina

9:47

had, and still has, abundant natural

9:49

resources, namely the vast fertile grasslands

9:52

of the Pampas and the cattle

9:54

that graze on them. Exports

9:57

of beef, grain and minerals turned Argentina.

10:00

Argentina into one of the richest countries in

10:02

the world, richer even than

10:04

France or Germany. And

10:06

the streets of Buenos Aires are a

10:08

constant, haunting reminder of that wealthy past.

10:11

Wide avenues lined with grand

10:13

and ornate bellipoc architecture, handsome

10:15

squares with manicured lawns and

10:17

even a Victorian clock tower.

10:20

And of course the red, British-style post

10:22

boxes which fell out of use years

10:24

ago, in which no one, it seems,

10:26

has the heart to remove. With

10:29

the government now saddled with huge debts,

10:31

the question I hear again and again

10:33

is are Argentina's best days behind it

10:36

or are they still to come? One

10:39

glib answer you sometimes hear is that this

10:41

is the only country that's gone from being

10:43

developed to developing. It's

10:46

certainly true that it's slipped well

10:48

down the global rankings, after decades

10:50

of boom and bust and a

10:52

series of often vicious military dictatorships.

10:55

Democracy is now well established, but

10:57

the economy is definitely beast.

11:01

Inflation last year was more than

11:03

200% and prices are still soaring.

11:06

Officially 40% of the population are

11:08

now living in poverty, although most

11:10

believe the real figure is even

11:12

higher. Life for all but

11:14

the wealthiest families is a constant struggle to

11:16

pay the bills and put food on the

11:19

table. As one young

11:21

mother put it to me, we're the country of beef

11:23

but we can only afford to eat chicken, and

11:25

even chicken is a treat these days. Everyone's

11:29

doing whatever they can to survive, and

11:31

everyone's an expert in finding bargains. Pablo

11:34

knows this only too well. A middle-aged man

11:36

with a bad leg that makes it difficult

11:38

for him to find work, I ran into

11:40

him by chance one morning by the side

11:42

of the road. Or rather I

11:44

noticed a queue of people snaking up to the

11:46

back of a small car and wonder what was

11:48

going on. When I came

11:50

round the other side, I saw Pablo reaching

11:52

into a boot piled high with trays of

11:55

eggs. He told me

11:57

he buys them cheaply from a farm outside

11:59

Buenos Aires and brings them into the city

12:01

to sell to passers-by. At about £2

12:04

for two dozen, he said he doesn't make

12:06

much money. And it's not legal,

12:08

he said, so there's always the risk of a

12:10

tap on the shoulder from the police. Even

12:13

though he's trying to run a small business legally

12:15

is struggling to keep their heads above water. Claudio

12:18

Pius has the air of a born

12:20

entrepreneur. Squat, shaven-headed and with

12:22

a restless energy, he runs a chain

12:24

of corner shops. Or rather, he

12:26

did. He used to own 12, but

12:29

now he's down to just two because

12:31

of rising costs. If things didn't get

12:33

better soon, he told me, he'd have

12:35

to shut down completely. This

12:37

level of financial hardship is one of

12:39

the reasons why so many people voted

12:41

for Argentina's new president, Javier Mille. He

12:44

won just over 55% of

12:46

the vote on a pledge to

12:48

take a metaphorical chainsaw to what

12:51

he calls the profligacy of the

12:53

previous left-wing populist government. The theory

12:55

is that a currency devaluation, privatisations

12:57

and cuts to public spending will

13:00

encourage the motors of the Argentine

13:02

economy to start turning again. That

13:05

will enable the country to pay off some

13:07

of its vast debts. And then,

13:09

at some point, the rate of inflation

13:11

will start to come down. The

13:14

trouble is, his plan, if it happens, is

13:16

going to be painful. And painful

13:18

for many of those who took a chance

13:20

on this political novice. As

13:22

one analyst here put it to me,

13:24

people voted for Javier Mille because they

13:26

desperately wanted a change, any

13:28

change, but they may not realise what they've

13:31

let themselves in for. James

13:33

Menendez. In many

13:35

ways, Kenya is a case study

13:37

in the demographic changes happening across

13:40

Africa. Overall, the population

13:42

has risen sharply, having doubled over

13:44

the past 30 years to

13:47

over 55 million citizens

13:49

today. That means increased

13:51

pressure on farming land and

13:53

water resources and burgeoning cities.

13:56

It's a youthful country with an

13:58

average age of just 20 years.

14:00

years but the fertility rate is

14:02

now declining and fast. Back

14:05

in the 1960s the average

14:07

Kenyan woman could expect to have

14:09

at least eight children during her

14:11

lifetime. Today that's down to

14:13

just over three. Contraception

14:16

is available to most women who seek

14:18

it but every year there

14:20

are still many women and girls

14:22

who face unplanned and unwanted

14:24

pregnancies. Linda Ngarri

14:27

has investigated what choices

14:29

they have. At

14:31

a petrol station on the outskirts of

14:33

Nairobi it is finally gets into our

14:36

car. That's not her real

14:38

name. I've changed it to protect her

14:40

identity. We've been waiting for her

14:42

to finish her day as a domestic worker

14:44

and it's already dark. She's

14:47

nervous saying she left her three kids

14:49

on their own. She asks her

14:51

to make this quick. The

14:53

last time I saw her she was lying

14:56

on a bed in a backstreet clinic waiting

14:58

for abortion medication to take effect. It

15:00

had taken her four months to save the money

15:02

for the procedure. She

15:05

was already well into her second

15:07

trimester. The room

15:09

smelled of blood and medicine. It is

15:11

said the process felt like giving birth. A

15:15

few days later when we meet at the petrol

15:17

station it is revealed to me

15:19

she is HIV positive. I think

15:21

about the backstreet clinic where she had queued

15:23

along with other women to get a walk-in

15:26

abortion. Others lay on the

15:28

same bed after her. The

15:30

clinic at best covered the beds I

15:32

saw with old newspaper or nothing at

15:34

all. They cleaned the tools in

15:36

a bucket of bleach. I

15:38

later spoke to a lawyer who told

15:41

me it is HIV status could have

15:43

entitled her to a legal abortion but

15:45

she felt this was her only choice. She

15:48

could not afford a safer one. She

15:50

is not alone. Almost two-thirds

15:52

of pregnancies in Kenya are unplanned

15:55

and thousands of women seek unsafe

15:57

abortions every year at backstreet clinics.

16:00

or using dangerous methods on their own.

16:03

The man who carried out Edith's procedure claimed

16:05

to be a clinician, but there

16:07

was no trace of him on the

16:09

official registry of medical professionals. He

16:12

told me he performs up to 150 abortions each month.

16:17

Not everyone makes it through alive.

16:20

Complications from unsafe abortions are a

16:22

leading cause of maternal death in

16:24

the country. Kenya's

16:26

penal code bans abortion unless it's

16:28

to save the mother's life. Its

16:31

constitution and case law, however, allow

16:33

for more exceptions, such as in

16:35

cases of rape, incest, or

16:37

when the mother is under 18. The

16:41

legal ambiguity has created a

16:43

climate of fear, preventing women

16:45

from seeking legal abortions and

16:47

medical professionals from offering it.

16:50

Abortion here is a cultural taboo

16:52

shrouded in stigma and misinformation. One

16:56

teenage girl I met at a crisis

16:58

pregnancy center told me the

17:00

organization running it, which is funded by

17:02

churches in the US, convinced her to

17:04

keep her child. She was

17:06

told there that if she had a

17:08

termination, she would never be able

17:10

to have another baby. Some

17:13

religious organizations teach that abortions lead

17:15

to death. But

17:18

it's also a class issue. It

17:20

took Edith four months to save less

17:23

than half the amount that a safe

17:25

procedure at a registered clinic usually costs.

17:28

And the morning after, she had

17:30

to go back to work, her body

17:32

still reeling from an induced termination

17:34

in non-sterile conditions the night before. I

17:38

was raised in a typical Christian home

17:40

in Mombasa, Kenya's second largest city. When

17:43

I was a girl, my parents, teachers,

17:45

and church warned me against playing with

17:47

boys, lest I end up pregnant. I

17:50

wasn't taught about my sexual and reproductive rights

17:52

at school. Girls in Kenya

17:54

are told by their elders to

17:57

practice total abstinence. That sex

17:59

is shameful. So they learn whatever

18:01

they can from their peers. It

18:04

breeds misinformation. In

18:06

high school, I heard of teenage

18:08

girls drinking bleach, coffee, and cordial

18:10

juice to self-induced abortions. Some

18:13

of those I met, while reporting on

18:15

this story, only realized they were

18:17

pregnant four or five months in. None

18:20

of the women I spoke to took the decision

18:22

to have an abortion lightly, but becoming

18:24

a parent was a burden they could not

18:27

face. The mothers of the

18:29

two teenage girls I interviewed could not hold

18:31

back their tears when I asked

18:33

how they felt about their children becoming

18:35

pregnant so young. Both

18:37

had been teenage mothers themselves, one

18:40

of them as a result of rape. She

18:42

told me, I tried to protect her,

18:44

to help her build a life to be

18:46

different, but it did not happen. What

18:49

I feared and did not want to happen

18:51

to her is what happened. She

18:54

had hoped her daughter would have a better future

18:56

than she did. But now they

18:59

faced the same fate. Linda

19:02

Ngarri Colombia

19:04

has much to attract travelers,

19:06

tropical beaches, Amazonian rainforests full

19:08

of wildlife, cities humming

19:11

with music and culture. But

19:13

decades of drug violence and

19:15

a long-running guerrilla insurgency kept

19:18

most visitors away. Given

19:20

the risks of being kidnapped and held

19:22

for ransom or just mugged, only the

19:25

boldest would dare. Now with

19:27

the war officially over, some former

19:29

rebels are hoping to capitalize on

19:31

the country's natural assets and bring

19:34

in new business. Roofing,

19:36

trekking and abseiling are just

19:38

some of the attractions they're

19:40

selling to tourists, seeking a

19:42

truly off-the-beaten-path experience. Zoe

19:45

Gelber 4

19:47

in the morning and I'm standing outside in

19:49

a valley in the south of Colombia, drinking

19:51

weak sweet coffee, or tinto, from a tiny

19:53

plastic cup. We're surrounded by rolling

19:55

green hills, although I can't see much of anything

19:58

yet. In a huddled group, someone

20:00

hands me a head torch and a small bag. Inside

20:03

are a pair of binoculars, because we're about

20:05

to go bird watching. Ricardo,

20:08

our guide, a wiry man with a moustache

20:10

and a distinctly 80s crew cut, leads us

20:12

over a small river before we start to

20:14

climb one of the nearby slopes in the

20:16

dark. Nearing the top, we pass

20:18

a big boulder and he stops. We

20:21

used to use this as a lookout point, he tells us.

20:23

From here you can see all across the valley

20:26

without being seen yourself. You could see

20:28

if the army was coming. For

20:30

over 30 years, Ricardo had been a

20:33

member of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of

20:35

Colombia, or the FARC, which until fairly

20:37

recently was the country's largest and most

20:39

powerful left-wing guerrilla group. The

20:41

rebel army formally disbanded seven years ago

20:43

following a historic peace agreement between FARC

20:46

leaders and the government, bringing

20:48

more than half a century of violent civil conflict

20:50

to an end. The

20:52

agreement saw thousands of rebels emerging from

20:54

their bases in the jungles, handing over

20:56

their weapons and agreeing to rejoin peaceful

20:59

society, which is why Ricardo

21:01

is now starting a new life in

21:03

ecotourism. Guerrilla soldier to

21:05

nature guide is a fairly drastic career change,

21:07

but it's not quite the screeching handbrake turn

21:10

you might at first imagine. For

21:12

decades, FARC members like Ricardo lived and

21:14

fought in Colombia's remote jungles, which also

21:17

happened to be some of the most

21:19

beautiful and biodiverse places on earth. Now,

21:22

with the war over, these unspoiled areas

21:24

are finally starting to open up to

21:26

researchers and tourists, and former

21:28

fighters who know these places by

21:30

heart have started leading tours through

21:32

them. It's something that

21:34

comes naturally to many of them. The

21:37

forest was our home for all the years we were

21:39

in arms. It was our protector.

21:41

It's where we slept, where we ate, where

21:43

we lived, Felix, another former guerrilla

21:45

tells me. Felix

21:47

says he joined the FARC at just

21:49

11 years old and spent nearly 40

21:52

years with the group, working as a

21:54

security guard for FARC commanders before he

21:56

was captured and imprisoned by the Colombian

21:58

army. He goes on to explain that the FARC

22:00

had strict rules prohibiting deforestation in

22:02

the areas they controlled, which they'd

22:05

enforced with sanctions, fines and guns.

22:08

This was not primarily for environmental reasons.

22:11

In fact, some FARC-controlled areas were

22:13

deforested to make way for coca

22:16

cultivation, the raw material used in

22:18

cocaine and illegal gold mining. Both

22:20

were sources of income for the group. But

22:23

the fighters limited this activity because they

22:25

needed thick tree cover to disguise them

22:27

from government planes overhead. Ironically,

22:30

with the war now over, Colombia has

22:32

seen a huge spike in deforestation as

22:34

other armed groups have moved onto the

22:36

land the FARC left behind, clearing

22:39

trees for their own illegal plantations and

22:41

mines. Over

22:43

the next three days, I accompany Felix,

22:45

Ricardo and other former FARC members as

22:47

they lead group workshops in identifying native

22:49

plants, spotting macaws, ocelots

22:52

and other wildlife and monitoring

22:54

deforestation. Right now, the

22:56

state is giving former rebels a stipend

22:58

as they transition to peaceful society. When

23:01

that eventually runs out, ex-competents will need a

23:03

way to earn an income so they can

23:06

support themselves in peacetime. If they

23:08

can't, it's feared that they might take up arms

23:10

again. It's still

23:12

early days, but tourists are starting to

23:14

arrive in greater numbers, adventurous travellers from

23:16

abroad and some curious Colombians from the

23:18

cities. But to many Colombians, the idea

23:21

is a bit of a hard sell. There

23:23

is still widespread distrust and stigma

23:25

around former guerrieros, who during the

23:27

war became notorious for kidnapping thousands

23:29

of civilians for ransom to finance

23:31

their operations. Many hostages

23:33

died or disappeared and others were subjected

23:36

to brutal and degrading treatment. Colombians

23:39

want peace, but for many people, the idea

23:41

of hiking and birdwatching with people they see

23:43

as responsible for this violence is a bit

23:45

too much to stomach. For

23:48

another former rebel called Lina, coming face to

23:50

face with wider Colombian society is part of

23:52

the point. They can get

23:55

to know us, she tells me, as we walk through

23:57

the forest with her five-year-old daughter bouncing along beside us.

24:00

They'll see we're not monsters, that most of us

24:02

want peace too. Nature can be

24:04

a bridge for us to communicate. Zoe

24:07

Gelber. Champagne

24:09

and brie. Parmesan

24:12

and parmesan cheese. Kalamata

24:14

olives. Many of the

24:16

finer things in life have been

24:18

seized on by the European Union

24:20

regulators in an attempt to

24:22

protect them rather than ban them. The

24:25

rulers governing these products are meant to

24:27

give the real thing an extra edge

24:30

and clamp down on cheap and

24:32

shoddy imitations as a way of

24:34

keeping food traditions alive and keeping

24:36

the people who preserve them in

24:38

business. Amid the

24:40

long list of protected items, lurks

24:43

one you might not have expected

24:45

as Rob Croson recently found in

24:47

Bavaria in central Germany. Bjorn

24:51

grins at me and laughs as

24:53

he rubs his thumb against his fore and

24:55

middle fingers. It seems like

24:57

a warning at first and

24:59

it transpires it is against those

25:02

who would dare to trespass against

25:04

Bjorn's most cherished passion. Yes

25:07

it would be very expensive for anyone

25:09

who tried to break the rules I

25:11

think, he says with

25:13

satisfaction. Bjorn turns and

25:16

briskly strolls over to the cashier's desk

25:18

of his museum where two

25:20

rather confused looking Japanese tourists

25:22

are standing nervously. They

25:25

stare somewhat as scants at

25:27

the displays of medieval butchery equipment

25:29

scattered among reproductions of portraits of

25:32

the burgers of Nuremberg going about

25:34

their business in the shadow of

25:36

half-timbered houses. Yes

25:38

that is correct, this is the

25:41

Bratwurst Museum. Bjorn tells the

25:43

new customers who hand over their four

25:45

euros in cash and are led into

25:47

this temple to Nuremberg's most notable contribution

25:49

to the culinary world. I

25:52

promise you Rob, Bjorn confides. Before

25:55

protection began in 1998, the Nuremberg

25:58

Bratwurst was the grocery item... with

26:00

the most fakes in the world. And

26:02

most of the coffees were really terrible too.

26:06

Bjorn Becker has been the manager of

26:08

the Bratwurst Museum since it opened two

26:10

years ago in the middle of the

26:12

city's medieval outstat. It tells,

26:14

in a sober, almost liturgical tone, the

26:16

story of the Bratwurst, which dates back

26:18

to at least 1313. This is the

26:20

year that the earliest

26:23

mention of the marjoram-flavoured roly-poly sausage

26:25

has yet been found, contained within

26:28

a doctrine from the city elders,

26:30

which, dictating how meat should be

26:32

treated, specifically mentions Bratwurst. "'We

26:35

wanted to protect this little sausage. That's

26:38

why they wanted to keep the

26:40

tradition of over 700 years safe,'

26:42

says Bjorn. 2003 was our big

26:44

year when the Njumburga Rust Bratwurst was

26:47

protected by the European Union. If

26:50

you have a sausage factory in Brussels or

26:52

Bratislava and you label it Bratwurst, you

26:54

can expect legal proceedings and a

26:57

very angry Bjorn." It's

26:59

partly thanks to Bjorn and the Njumburg

27:01

Sausage Protection Association that visitors like myself

27:04

can opt for plates of half a

27:06

dozen to a dozen of these venerable

27:08

protected articles usually served on a heart-shaped

27:10

tin plate with full confidence that they

27:12

were all made within the city limits

27:14

of Njumburg. One of

27:16

the city's oldest sausage house

27:18

restaurants, called Zungildenstern, is run

27:20

by 23-year-old Sophia Hillaprant, who

27:22

also presents her own podcast, called,

27:25

wait for it, Bratwurst in the

27:27

City. "'Look around you,'

27:29

she says as I enter the

27:31

cosy wooden-beamed interior. We're very

27:33

busy at the moment. I think after Covid

27:36

people are more keen than ever to have

27:38

a taste of something homely, maybe

27:40

something they missed for a few years. We

27:42

try not to change anything. Bratwurst

27:44

means too much to people.' Legends

27:47

have, over the centuries, been prepared to

27:49

prove their love in various, not always

27:52

pleasurable ways. Legend has

27:54

it that in Njumburg's ominously named

27:56

Gilt Tower, Hans Thromer, a 16th

27:58

century judge, was in for

28:00

treachery. Whilst incarcerated, it said

28:02

he ate 28,000 bradversd, which were

28:05

passed through

28:07

a keyhole to him as the door could not

28:09

be opened. But

28:11

with veganism on the rise throughout Germany,

28:13

alongside plant food innovations, I

28:16

wonder if the love of bradversd is likely to

28:18

wane, or if there are any plans

28:20

to tweak the sausage to cater for this new

28:22

shift in consumer habits. Could there ever be

28:24

a veggie bradversd?

28:27

Bjorn and Sophia both laugh up

28:29

roriously when I ask this question.

28:32

I tell you, to make the bradversd out

28:34

of anything other than pork is impossible. It

28:37

is then, quite clearly, no

28:39

longer a bradversd, Sophia

28:41

insists. In a

28:44

city that was almost completely levelled in

28:46

1945, it seems hot wars,

28:48

cold wars, reunification, and now 20

28:50

years of official protection, one thing

28:53

has remained constant. This

28:55

little thing reminds us that tradition is

28:57

very important. It reminds us of our

28:59

childhood, reflects Bjorn. The

29:02

bradversd survived 700 years, and it will

29:04

be surviving the next 700 years, he

29:06

tells me triumphantly.

29:09

It's simple. You should never try

29:11

to change a winning team. Rob

29:15

Crossan in Nuremberg, and that's all for today,

29:17

but we'll be here again on Saturday morning

29:20

at half past eleven. Do

29:22

join us. Thirty

29:24

years ago, Britain's farms were hit

29:26

by an epidemic of an infectious

29:28

brain disorder. They called it

29:30

Mad Cow Disease. I'm

29:33

Lucy Proctor, and in The Cows are Mad

29:35

from BBC Radio 4, I

29:37

tell the story of a very weird time

29:39

in our history. The media started calling

29:41

me the Mad Cow Professor. Mad

29:44

Cow Disease rampaged through Britain,

29:46

first killing cows and then

29:48

humans. And the

29:50

thing is, after all this time, nobody

29:52

knows for sure where Mad Cow

29:54

Disease originally came from. The general

29:57

feeling is that we will never know the

29:59

answer. Subscribe to

30:01

the Cows Amad in BBC scenes. That's

30:30

eight numbers to understand China. Listen

30:33

next by searching for the Global

30:35

News podcast wherever you get your

30:37

BBC podcasts.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features