Podchaser Logo
Home
Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Released Thursday, 7th December 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Possibility: Dumbledore's Army (Book 5, Chapter 18)

Thursday, 7th December 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

Guess what? We're going up

0:04

Bath, baby! I'm so

0:06

excited to announce that I will

0:08

be leading a pilgrimage all about

0:10

Bridgerton next August, and you

0:12

can register for the trip today. Pilgrims

0:15

on this trip will contemplate the

0:17

theme of heartbreak while close reading

0:19

Romancing Mr. Bridgerton, the

0:22

fourth book in the Bridgerton series and

0:24

the inspiration for the upcoming season of

0:26

the Netflix show. I really

0:28

wanted to think about heartbreak and the stories that we

0:30

tell ourselves because so

0:32

much of the world and relationships can

0:34

be heartbreaking, but there's also so much

0:37

joy to be found in the aftermath

0:39

of hardship. Through long

0:41

walks, profound talks, and thoughtful writing

0:43

prompts, this trip will offer pilgrims

0:45

a creative, open space to imagine a

0:47

world in which our hearts have been

0:49

broken, but we can see the

0:51

joyful life ahead of us. You

0:54

can learn more about this trip and

0:56

the payment plans that we have on

0:58

offer by heading to readingandwalkingwith.com today. These

1:01

trips have limited spots available, so

1:03

now is the time to jump

1:05

on it. That's readingandwalkingwith.com and hang

1:08

out with me in downtown beautiful

1:10

Bath. ACAS

1:18

powers the world's best podcasts.

1:21

Here's a show that we recommend. Hi,

1:26

I'm Michelle Obama, and in my podcast,

1:28

I talk about so many of the

1:30

lessons I've learned that are

1:32

centered around finding your inner

1:34

confidence, understanding your

1:36

own story, and persisting even

1:39

if it feels like people are

1:41

judging and watching your every move. I

1:44

get into this and a lot

1:46

of other meaningful topics with some

1:48

of my closest friends on my

1:50

podcast, The Light. Take

1:52

a listen on Audible now. The

1:55

Light podcast is presented by Starbucks.

2:00

helps creators launch, grow,

2:02

and monetize their podcasts

2:04

everywhere. acast.com. Book

2:09

5, Chapter 18. Umbridge

2:12

has been reading your mail, Harry. There's

2:15

no other explanation. You

2:17

think Umbridge attacked Hedwig, he said,

2:19

outraged? I'm

2:22

Vanessa Zoltan. And I'm Jackson

2:24

Bird. And this is

2:26

Harry Potter and the Sacred Text. And

2:30

that was recorded by Emily Carr

2:32

at Camp Jackson, where you

2:34

and I got to hang out just

2:36

last summer. I know! That was so much

2:38

fun. It was. It was also fun, like,

2:40

all these ways that we got to involve people

2:43

in the different podcasts. Yep. Yep. Our

2:45

only announcement, Jackson, is announcing our bonus conversation

2:47

Patreon perk, which is you and I are

2:50

going to be talking about what would be

2:52

in our rooms of

2:54

requirement. Yes. And

2:56

I, you know, I'm guessing puppies

2:59

will come up for me. I can't

3:01

promise, but... I mean, I gotta

3:03

say, as a Taurus, like, imagining what

3:05

physical objects will be in my cozy

3:07

dream room... I'm

3:10

gonna have a lot of ideas. I'm gonna have a lot of thoughts for this. Aren't

3:12

you? I'm already having feelings. I'm

3:15

like, lavender scented candles? No.

3:18

It's really like a great dream space

3:20

I'm in. You gotta pick out the

3:23

right scent. But we will get into

3:25

all of that. We will. And you

3:27

can hear that brilliant, no doubt, and

3:29

inspiring conversation at patreon.com/Harry Potter sacred

3:31

text. Jackson, you are

3:33

going to be telling us a story on the

3:36

theme of possibility today. What

3:38

story do you have? Yeah. So

3:40

I want to take

3:42

us back in my life to the early

3:45

days of the pandemic. And

3:48

people who know me will know that I

3:50

have inexplicably lived in one of the world's

3:52

largest cities for 13 years, despite not really

3:54

being a city person. And

3:56

I had really wanted to move before the pandemic, but I

3:58

didn't. pandemic I was I

4:00

was thinking in the city I really felt stuck. And

4:03

one of the things that I ended

4:05

up doing was daydreaming like really,

4:08

really intensely about what if

4:10

I won the lottery

4:12

or what if I just had like all of

4:14

this money like what what would I do with

4:16

it and I mean the biggest thing was like

4:18

buy a house out in the country. And so

4:20

I spent way too much

4:23

time like on weekends and stuff

4:25

just like looking through Zillow million

4:27

dollar houses with you know, 10s

4:29

hundreds of acres and getting very

4:31

detailed about like, here's how I

4:33

would set up each room. Here's

4:35

how I would plan out the moving

4:37

process on moving day I would organize the

4:39

boxes like this and I would do this.

4:41

Oh my god, I should also clarify that it

4:43

was months into this before I ever

4:46

thought I could buy a lotto

4:48

ticket. Like I had never in my life

4:50

bought a lottery ticket, but I was thinking

4:52

I was gonna win the lottery somehow. Sure.

4:56

You don't know. I was also thinking

4:58

about what I would sort

5:00

of stop doing in my life. So like if

5:02

I let's say one the lottery tomorrow, are there

5:04

jobs or commitments or things that

5:06

I would no longer do because I didn't need the money.

5:08

And I'm in a very privileged position where a lot of

5:10

the times I would think about that and be like, No,

5:13

I would still want to keep doing this. I would still

5:15

want to keep doing that. So I'm a freelancer who's very

5:17

lucky to do things that I love for the most part.

5:19

But in certain periods of the last few years, there were

5:22

certain things that I had where I realized no, I

5:24

would stop doing that as soon as I could. So

5:27

even though I sometimes spent

5:30

way too much time and energy to the

5:32

point where I think it almost got unhealthy

5:34

dreaming about like this life with more

5:37

money than I could ever imagine and what

5:39

I would do, there were a few times

5:41

where it actually became a useful exercise because

5:43

on the one hand, it helped me think

5:45

about, okay, what really matters in my life? Like

5:47

what are what are the commitments that really bring me

5:49

joy? And what are the ones that are really bringing

5:51

me down that maybe I can try to take steps

5:54

to decrease in my life or get

5:56

away from? But it also opened my

5:58

mind. There were so many things. that

6:00

I put in this category of like, oh, only

6:02

if I'm a billionaire, that were like,

6:04

I would rearrange my kitchen and this

6:06

one shelf would really make a difference. And it's

6:09

like, buddy, you could

6:11

thrift that shelf and make that change

6:13

today. It wasn't like an outrageous dream.

6:16

And so it sort of helped me like

6:18

open my mind to the possibilities that were

6:20

already available in my life that for some

6:22

reason I just like wasn't seen yet. And

6:25

so I do actually think it's kind of

6:27

a valuable exercise sometimes to think like, okay,

6:29

if you had no barriers in

6:31

whatever way, what might you

6:33

change? And then sometimes it's sad to realize

6:35

maybe you'll never be able to achieve those.

6:38

But there are some little things that you

6:40

might be like, oh, wait, I could just do that. And

6:43

so that is my possibility example.

6:46

Part of what I love about this story,

6:48

Jackson, is that it's a call for imagination,

6:50

right? It's like those moments of like, if

6:53

you could do anything, if you could

6:55

start over, right? And I do, I

6:57

think that those reflections

6:59

are really generative, you know, imagining

7:01

over and over again what

7:04

a beautiful life would be. It's depressing that money is

7:06

the key to it a lot of the time. Yeah,

7:08

really is. But I do think we can imagine ourselves

7:10

to a better world. And so taking

7:12

the time and space to imagine that feels important

7:14

to me. Yeah. And

7:18

now that I think about it, like I've

7:20

been a part of like strategic planning retreats

7:22

where we've literally been led through like, okay,

7:24

if money was not an object, if all

7:26

of these other barriers weren't an object, like

7:28

what would you do? What would you want

7:30

to do for or with this organization? So

7:32

I guess my silly daydream is

7:34

actually backed up by real practice. Isn't

7:38

that funny? I will say

7:40

that I found the etymology of this

7:42

a little disappointing. Possibility

7:45

comes from the old French, and

7:47

it means a possible

7:50

thing or substance. But

7:52

it also means that which may

7:54

take place. And

7:56

so I do think it's interesting that we think of

7:58

it both as an event. and

8:01

is a thing, right? Like there's a

8:03

future invention that might

8:05

exist and be possible, but there

8:08

are also future states that could

8:10

be possible, and it feels like

8:12

your story is about those

8:15

two combined of like there could be

8:17

resources that would allow a future state,

8:20

and then you separating those two things of like,

8:22

oh I can have that state even

8:24

if I don't have the resources. Yeah.

8:27

And that's what thrift shops are for.

8:29

Right, right, and stooping. Yeah,

8:33

that is interesting. I'm still sitting with

8:35

this etymological definition. I feel like I

8:37

haven't quite digested it yet. Can you

8:39

repeat part of the sort

8:41

of binary of this? Yeah, so

8:43

a possible thing or

8:45

substance, right? So

8:48

like an object, so right, like a

8:50

COVID vaccine. Okay, yeah. So that

8:52

is a thing that could exist. A COVID

8:54

vaccine was a possibility. We made it a

8:56

reality, and then that which

8:58

may take place or come into being would

9:01

be like a vaccinated world,

9:04

and they aren't necessarily the

9:06

same thing. Yeah. Right, but

9:09

we do use possibility for both of

9:11

them, and I feel like your story

9:13

is about saying when can

9:15

we separate those two? When

9:17

can we say it doesn't have to

9:20

be a vaccinated world, we can be in a safe

9:22

world, or no, it has to

9:24

be a vaccinated world in order to be a

9:26

safe world, and so they need to be connected,

9:28

right? Like, I feel like that's

9:30

your story is about exactly separating

9:32

those two things. What do I need

9:34

the millions of dollars in order

9:37

to have and what is actually just about

9:39

a state, and I can make that

9:41

happen without the millions of dollars. Yeah,

9:43

and I think that is actually a

9:46

really important distinction that I bet we

9:48

will get into as we get into

9:50

this chapter, because there's so many instances

9:52

as like a teaser where I was

9:54

reading this chapter thinking about possibility and

9:57

just reflecting on how often possibility is

9:59

tied to life. like privilege and access

10:01

to resources. So I

10:03

love that we're setting it up with

10:05

this sort of distinction. Yeah. Okay,

10:08

well let's see what's possible for me

10:10

to remember in this 30 second recap

10:12

if you don't mind counting me in. Okay,

10:15

you ready? I'm ready. Three,

10:17

two, one. So

10:20

the Quidditch team gets reinstated probably because McGonagall went

10:22

all the way to Dumbledore and went above Enbridge's

10:24

head. And everyone is so excited and they have

10:26

practice. And then it turns out that Fred and

10:28

George have like boils on their butts and it's

10:30

raining really badly and it's horrible. And they're gonna

10:33

have their first DA meeting. And Dobby, who's actually

10:35

been taking all of the hats from Hermione, is

10:37

able to tell them about the room of requirement.

10:39

And that's when they name the DA and they

10:41

elect Harry as the person in

10:43

charge and they start all their practices. And

10:45

we already see the potential in Neville. He's

10:47

already getting better and Cho is there. I

10:51

ran out of time. Cho is there.

10:53

Cho is there. Cho

10:55

is there. Cho

10:58

is there. Adorable. It's

11:00

true. So she can't help it. Jackson,

11:03

are you ready to clean up that mess I

11:05

left for you? I'm going to try to fill

11:08

in some daps. We'll see how it goes. On

11:11

your mark, get set, go. All

11:13

right, so they're in charms class and they're talking about

11:15

how last night Umbridge maybe caught Sirius in

11:17

the fire. And they're like, did she actually know that

11:19

it was him? And they're kind of freaking out about what to

11:21

do. And now they definitely can't talk to Sirius again. So they're

11:23

feeling very stuck about that. And then the Quidditch

11:25

team is back yet. They

11:28

have practice in very bad rain.

11:31

And yeah, Fred and George have been testing stuff

11:33

and they have boils and that sounds very, very

11:35

uncomfortable. And then there's going to be

11:37

another Quidditch practice, but it's canceled because it just keeps

11:39

raining. This whole chapter, it's raining a heck of a

11:41

lot. Oh, and Harry, I think how

11:43

do? Oh, no, I didn't get into anything. Because

11:45

I remembered an important thing that neither of

11:47

us talked about, which is Harry's scar is

11:49

hurting again. And he's like

11:51

realizing he can feel Voldemort's emotions. And

11:54

that seems very important to mention. I

11:57

don't know. Book

12:00

five, Harry's scar hurts, he's feeling emotions. That

12:02

feels like it could be in almost any

12:04

chapter. You just

12:06

described book five. Exactly. Harry's scar hurts

12:09

and he's feeling emotions. Yeah.

12:11

So this time they're Voldemort's emotions,

12:13

whatever. So

12:16

Jackson, the thing that

12:18

I feel like we have to talk about

12:20

is the room of requirement because it could

12:22

easily be called the room of possibilities. Yeah.

12:25

Right? It is the room where you can

12:28

get anything you want

12:30

or need. You don't even need to need

12:32

it, right? You just have to

12:34

want it. Yeah. I

12:36

think so. Well, you know what?

12:38

When I was reading the chapter again, the way Dobby

12:40

described it this time, there was something that stood out

12:43

to me. It was almost like

12:45

he described it more as needing it. Yeah.

12:47

So Dobby describes the room of requirements of, he's heard

12:49

tell of it from other house elves. It's

12:52

known by us as the come and go room

12:54

or else as the room of requirement. It's the

12:56

room that a person can only enter when they

12:58

have a real need of it. Sometimes

13:01

it's there, sometimes it's not. But when it

13:03

appears, it is always equipped for the seekers needs. For

13:05

the seekers needs. So it does emphasize

13:08

needs. Yeah. However,

13:11

that is Dobby's perspective. There's also

13:13

like, it is such a mysterious

13:15

room that I think people make

13:18

their own interpretation of it as well when they

13:20

discover it. I just think it, you

13:22

know, the examples that were given of the

13:24

room of requirement are really interesting, right? Like

13:26

Dumbledore needs a bathroom. That's

13:28

a need. But Fred and

13:30

George, like need to escape.

13:34

And so like the question becomes if

13:37

they needed to escape McGonagall, would

13:40

the room of requirements show up?

13:42

Does it have a judgment on

13:45

like what the actual needs are of

13:47

the person or is it

13:49

what they just like really want to

13:51

do? And

13:53

so it appears. Yeah, I tend to

13:55

think that it is sort of like if

13:59

the person. Themself feels like it

14:01

is a need that is right as interpreted because

14:03

one thing that is interesting to me is like

14:05

a lot of the times When we see the

14:07

room of the requirement, especially for the DA like

14:10

it is a trip down room There's all kinds

14:12

of resources and like cozy places to sit but

14:14

when Fred and George needed it It was a

14:16

broom cupboard And

14:18

I think that's because that's what they

14:21

were Imagining that they needed was a

14:23

closet like that to just go hide in they

14:25

weren't imagining that we need this big room They

14:27

were just like oh we need somewhere to hide

14:29

and so it sort of turned into what they

14:31

had in their head Yeah, one thing

14:33

that I find interesting is the distinction you

14:35

made between Them being caught

14:37

by silch and then being caught by McGonagall, which

14:40

I heard and you could correct me if I'm wrong

14:42

But I heard from you in that that like they're

14:44

sort of in more danger

14:46

There's a bigger consequence being caught by filch or

14:48

if they're caught by McGonagall sure They're still gonna

14:51

get punished but it like she's a little bit

14:53

more understanding of them Like they're still gonna kind

14:55

of be safe around her where filters may be

14:57

more of a loose cannon You don't know what's

14:59

gonna happen. They have a greater fear. So I

15:02

don't know I'm also just sort of trying to tease

15:04

that out in terms of the the need

15:06

versus want and the Possibility factor

15:08

of the room of requirement. I guess

15:11

we find out more about this in the next

15:13

book where you can Need

15:15

two different things, right? Harry really really

15:17

deeply desires to catch Draco But

15:19

Draco feels as though he needs the room to

15:22

be private and like

15:24

Harry can't get into the room I just

15:26

I guess I find it interesting that the room

15:28

doesn't seem to have a moral agenda That

15:31

it's like hey if you need it, I'll provide it.

15:34

I think that there's something about to saying if

15:36

you feel as though you need something It's

15:39

my job to meet your needs and it's like not

15:41

my job to assess Whether

15:43

or not you need it and just sort of

15:46

like to believe people that they need what they're

15:48

asking for Yeah, it's

15:50

making me think a lot about clicknet neutrality

15:53

and the way that we classify the internet

15:55

and yeah, is it a communications

15:58

device in the same way that like telephones

16:00

are that, you know, we can use a

16:02

telephone for anything on an individual

16:04

level. But with the internet where things can get

16:06

complicated is it is also a community resource. And

16:08

so like, if you want to have a good

16:11

community online, you need proper moderation, and there do

16:13

need to maybe be some values agreed upon and

16:15

stuff like that. And so with the room of

16:17

requirement, when it's just like one

16:20

person or one community using it at

16:22

once, that lack of sort

16:24

of like moral value judgment from the room

16:26

of requirement is maybe

16:28

arguably fine. But yeah, then when you

16:30

get into like dynamics of like Harry

16:33

and Draco's conflicting needs or wants with

16:35

it, it gets a lot more Harry. Yeah.

16:38

And when we want to say

16:40

to someone, yes, this is a

16:43

possibility that I will help you

16:45

have. And when you're

16:47

saying to someone, no, that's an unreasonable

16:50

possibility. Right. And

16:52

where that comes from? Is it

16:54

because it's a scarce resource? Is it because

16:56

you think that they want to

16:59

be possible? Shouldn't be possible?

17:01

I don't know. I just feels like

17:03

this is how we decide a lot

17:05

of the world, right? It's making me

17:07

think a little bit about like, okay, all the

17:10

examples that we've said so far, and a lot of the

17:12

ones that we see in the books, I think you could

17:14

very well make a pretty clear argument of it

17:16

being like a need. This person has a need

17:18

for this, and it's very helpful. But I'm trying to

17:20

imagine like, I don't know, let's say some random kid

17:22

at Hogwarts hears about it. I was like, wow,

17:24

that'd be really cool to make like, you know,

17:26

the coolest room ever. And there's, you know, it's gonna

17:28

be a bunch of like records and a cool sound

17:31

system and a lava lamp. They just think it would

17:33

be cool, right? And so I think right on the

17:35

one hand, you could see that and be like,

17:37

that's not a need. That's just a want. So

17:39

will the room of requirements fulfill that or not? Maybe

17:41

it wouldn't. But I then start thinking about, well,

17:44

maybe that kid who thinks that would

17:46

be really cool is also like, having

17:49

trouble like being around so many people in the

17:51

common room all the time need some alone time

17:53

like, like, so it makes me start thinking about

17:55

like access needs and accommodations and stuff like that,

17:57

where you can hear something at first and maybe

18:00

think how could that be a need? We don't need

18:02

that to be possible and then like you get some

18:04

of the larger context and it's like oh no that

18:06

now makes sense why that would actually be need. Right

18:09

it is interesting because as someone who grew up

18:12

outside of Christmas

18:14

culture like I understand

18:16

why it feels like a need right

18:19

around the darkest day of the year

18:21

to like light up a tree and

18:23

bring joy to children in the middle

18:25

of winter right? But it always looked

18:28

like excess to me from the outside

18:30

and there's like kids getting

18:32

their wish lists and like you know

18:34

whatever right like not being

18:36

necessary but as I get older I'm like no

18:39

festivals in the middle of the winter really make

18:41

a lot of sense to me which makes me

18:43

think of right that even

18:46

if we don't need everything that we

18:48

want to be possible what we do

18:50

need is the feeling of possibility. Mmm

18:54

yes I think that is so important

18:56

and I think it is a really

18:58

tough thing sometimes to feel that

19:01

possibility. Right absolutely I

19:03

love John Green's definition of hope which

19:06

is like hope is the belief that

19:08

people can change and I feel like

19:10

belief in possibility is the

19:13

belief that like circumstances can change that

19:15

it's possible for you to get a

19:17

million dollars so you can

19:19

you know buy a house or it's

19:22

possible that there's affordable housing. Right

19:24

yeah it's possible that there's other ways to get

19:26

to what what you think is is the

19:28

dream yeah right I also

19:30

think with with that John Green quote that can also

19:32

apply to you of like the belief that you

19:35

can change yeah I think that's important too is

19:37

like not trying to be prescriptive of like don't

19:39

just tell people change your mindset but again that

19:41

for myself sometimes that is really helpful to be

19:43

like why do I think this way why am

19:46

I approaching this this way let me open my

19:48

mind a little bit to this right and open

19:50

my mind to possibility. When

19:53

I was reading this chapter the character

19:55

that really illustrated this for me was

19:58

Dobby and it wasn't Super

20:00

much from what we saw of Dobby in

20:02

this chapter in particular, but just being reminded

20:05

of Dobby's story. And Dobby was

20:07

given that one opportunity when Harry

20:09

sort of accidentally freed him. But since

20:11

then, Dobby's perspective on the world has

20:13

been one of just absolutely abundant possibility.

20:15

And just dreaming and achieving all of

20:18

these things that he was never told

20:20

he could do that no one like

20:22

him ever does. And I see

20:24

that as it's a very complicated thought, given

20:27

the whole Howselves thing. But honing in

20:29

on Dobby in particular and his

20:31

story, I think is a really

20:33

beautiful example of possibility. Yeah.

20:37

And that it is reliant on a

20:39

material change, right? Dobby

20:41

actually didn't believe really in possibility before.

20:43

He had hoped for Harry in Harry.

20:46

But he truly believed

20:48

that he was stuck as the

20:50

Malfoy's Howself in being

20:52

granted freedom, right? His life

20:55

has materially changed. And so the world

20:57

that literally had no possibility in it

20:59

now is full of possibilities for him.

21:02

And just like how important that

21:04

material change is in order to create

21:06

a world of possibilities for Dobby. Yeah.

21:09

And I do think it's important to

21:11

think as we talk about how

21:13

much is your sort of

21:15

perspective and mindset and how much is the material

21:18

change in the context of it. Like Winky was

21:20

also given freedom, but she was like let go

21:22

in a very traumatic

21:25

way. And so that's different. So like she

21:27

is not going to have the

21:29

same perspective about it as Dobby. And she is not

21:31

one where we could just be like, oh, you just

21:33

need to change your thinking, which is what Dobby says

21:36

to her many times. It's

21:38

like, no, her situation was completely

21:40

different and it wasn't like this

21:43

kind of gift. It was more of a hardship. Absolutely.

21:47

No, she was kicked out

21:49

of her home where she was happy.

21:51

We can judge the dynamic that was there, but

21:53

she was happy. Yeah. And

21:55

she was evicted, forcibly evicted. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. particular

22:00

in this chapter is collecting

22:03

all of Hermione's knitting projects.

22:06

I just love it so much.

22:09

I love the excess of it.

22:12

Right? Like I as a maximalist

22:14

where I'm like, no, but more

22:16

is more. And especially

22:19

when it comes to decoration and

22:21

fashion, right? Like, let's be honest,

22:23

I got back from my brother's wedding yesterday

22:25

and was I in a sparkle dress

22:27

with like sparkle hair. Yes, I was

22:30

nice. So I love that Davi is

22:32

like hats on hats, right? Like symbols

22:34

of freedom on top of symbols of

22:37

freedom. I love that once to shower

22:40

himself in this new thing that he

22:42

is allowed to do. Yeah. The

22:45

symbols of freedom on top of symbols of

22:47

freedom just for the first time made me

22:49

think of this through a trans lens

22:51

of shocking that I

22:53

would think of something through a trans lens,

22:55

but made me think about like when you

22:58

are first like exploring your gender or especially

23:00

like maybe buying clothing of

23:02

a different gender expression than you ever

23:04

have before. And like sometimes

23:06

like we can view that as a little like

23:09

cringe here and there because you haven't figured out

23:11

your style yet and maybe it doesn't like look

23:13

great and or you're like older and you're trying

23:15

to wear stuff that you wish you could have

23:17

wore as a kid and it's like, oh, this

23:19

doesn't look my age. But there is such a

23:21

beauty and joy in that as well as like,

23:24

like this person like finally feeling free to dress

23:26

how they want and express themselves how they want.

23:28

So I actually really love the way you just

23:31

described all of these, you know, wearing seven hats

23:33

on top of each other as symbols

23:35

of freedom on put on symbols of freedom and

23:37

just the absolute joy of that. Yeah.

23:39

And like you're never too old to

23:41

wear anything. I just like go deeply

23:43

believe like fashion

23:46

is a place where we can just enjoy

23:49

ourselves, whatever that enjoyment

23:52

feels like. Right. Whether it be comfort

23:54

or glam or, you know, minimalism,

23:56

whatever it is. But I

23:59

don't know. for yourself and that's what Dobby

24:01

is doing. It is funny

24:04

that Hermione, without talking to anyone,

24:06

has decided that hats are going

24:09

to be this world of possibility

24:11

for how selves. And

24:14

of course it's not, right? Like... Yeah.

24:17

I think this is one reason why I've, even

24:20

though it's a funny visual, I have never

24:22

actually like seen this moment in, as

24:24

a moment of joy because all I hear is

24:26

Dobby saying, oh I have to clean the common

24:28

room all by myself now because no one else

24:30

will come here because Hermione's doing this thing that

24:32

she thinks is good. But she never talked to

24:34

the community she's trying to help. She never asked

24:36

them what they actually need. She just assumed and

24:38

it's actually making life harder for all of them.

24:40

I know. I know. I was

24:43

raised by someone who really believes that,

24:45

and raised us, that if somebody asks

24:47

you for money, if you can give

24:49

it, you give it without

24:51

conditions, right? Like, you

24:53

don't give it as a loan, you don't ask

24:56

for it back, and you definitely don't look at

24:58

how they're going to spend the money, right? So

25:00

if someone asks for money to

25:02

help pay their rent and then they spend a

25:04

lot of money on a meal, it's not up

25:06

to you to be like, hey, that's not what

25:09

I lent you that money for, that's not what

25:11

I gave you that money for. That people know

25:13

what they need and what they need might be

25:15

different than what you think

25:17

that they should need. And I think that

25:19

that is the mistake that Hermione is

25:21

making here, right? She's like, no, no,

25:24

you need freedom so

25:26

much that I will trick you into

25:29

doing it, right? And I think

25:31

my father really sees things like

25:34

restrictions on EBT cards, right? As

25:36

like deeply paternalistic. And

25:38

it's funny the ways that we

25:41

choose to criticize

25:43

these policies, right? Because diapers aren't covered

25:45

on EBT cards and we're like, diapers

25:48

not a need. But also

25:50

cigarettes aren't covered. And

25:52

I think what my father would say is like, if

25:55

someone feels like they need cigarettes, like, right? Like that's

25:57

not up to us to tell them whether or not

25:59

they need cigarettes. Yeah, to me this

26:01

goes back to our room of requirement discussion of just

26:03

like you don't really know why

26:06

a need could be someone's need but it absolutely can

26:08

be and even if it like looks more like a

26:10

want to you like you don't know Everything

26:12

they're going through you don't know their whole like

26:14

background and perspective on on why that Thing

26:17

might have like jumped up to the level of

26:19

need for them, right? And

26:21

so yeah, I think what Hermione

26:23

wants is a world full of

26:26

possibility for the house elves Mm-hmm, and

26:28

it's really hard if that's what you want

26:30

for someone to believe that that's not What

26:33

they want? Mm-hmm, and I again feel

26:35

for her cuz she's 15 and I

26:37

feel much less for systems of oppression

26:39

that try to tell people what they

26:43

Feel is possible for them or not, but

26:45

I understand that right? It's

26:47

why Parents really

26:49

feel as though their kids absolutely should go

26:51

to college They want them to have all

26:53

the possibilities in front of them Even

26:56

if their kid is like no, that's not the right place

26:58

for me Right and like we

27:00

just really have to be careful about

27:02

even wanting possibilities for other people Right,

27:05

it's the two different sort of definitions

27:07

of possibility again There's the world that

27:09

you sort of want and then the

27:11

like thing that you think is

27:13

what will get you there and Hermione Didn't

27:17

ask what the house elves need to

27:19

get to that world which Depending

27:22

on the definition of this, you know equitable world

27:24

They might even have a different idea of what

27:26

that world is that they want, right? I Don't

27:31

know about you, but I feel like 2024 is Sast

27:35

approaching and I haven't quite had

27:37

the time or space to

27:39

prepare for the start of the new year

27:41

That is why I am running a program

27:43

in the month of January to unwind from

27:46

2023 and begin 2024

27:49

with intention Living

27:51

courageously is a four-week program

27:54

led by me all

27:56

about living more courageously in 2024 every

27:59

session participants will gather to consider

28:01

a unique theme. Our

28:04

themes will be vulnerability,

28:06

creativity, activism, and self-love.

28:09

Together, we'll close read a short text

28:11

on that week's topic, do

28:13

some self-reflection through a writing prompt,

28:15

and then go into small groups

28:17

for intimate discussions. The

28:19

goal of this program is for individuals

28:22

to come out of January with some

28:24

sort of mantra that can serve as

28:26

a guide for braver living for the

28:28

year. If you are drawn to

28:30

this kind of internal work but need

28:32

help building intention and ritual, then this

28:34

program is definitely for you. Head

28:37

to notsorryworks.com to learn

28:39

more. This

28:47

week's episode of Harry Potter and the Sacred

28:49

Text is brought to you by Bombas. When

28:51

you give Bombas' holiday, you are giving more.

28:54

More comfort because their socks, underwear, and T-shirts

28:57

and slippers are made of such absurdly soft

28:59

materials that you'll want to keep a few

29:01

for yourself. And more good because for every

29:03

item you purchase, they donate another to someone

29:06

in need. I love Bombas' socks. I also

29:08

love giving Bombas' socks. They make shopping for

29:10

my husband so easy. All I have to

29:13

do is go and get him some new

29:15

socks for the year, and he's just

29:17

like, you did it, you remembered, you

29:19

got me something I love. He cycles

29:21

to and from work. He's on his

29:23

feet at work all day. Having good

29:25

socks is very important to him.

29:27

And now Bombas has ready-to-go gift

29:29

boxes filled with high-quality basics that your loved

29:31

ones, my husband, will enjoy all year long.

29:34

And the best part is that they come

29:36

in a beautifully designed package box so I

29:38

do not even have to wrap. They are

29:40

covered with 100% happiness guarantee. That

29:43

means super easy returns and size

29:45

exchanges. It is truly no hassle.

29:49

Go to bombas.com/potter and

29:51

use code potter for

29:54

20% off of your

29:56

first purchase. That's bombas.com/potter

29:58

and use code potter. Potter at

30:01

checkout. bombas.com/Potter code

30:03

Potter. This

30:08

week's episode of Harry Potter and the Sacred Text

30:10

is brought to you by Proz. Most

30:13

of you have probably heard me sing the

30:15

praises of Proz and their truly custom made

30:17

to order hair care. Switching to a custom

30:20

routine from Proz was one of the best

30:22

things I've done for my hair and the

30:24

results I'm seeing just keep getting better. My

30:26

baby brother got married a couple of weeks

30:28

ago and I decided to get my hair

30:30

done for the wedding. And I

30:33

got into the car and took a selfie and

30:35

sent it to friends and was like this is

30:37

the hairdo that I'm gonna undo. I

30:40

hated it. I hated it. And so

30:42

I went home and I washed my

30:44

hair with my Proz products and I

30:47

just wore my hair natural with my

30:49

Proz products and guess what? I looked

30:51

amazing. If you're not 100% positive

30:54

that Proz is the best hair care

30:56

you've had, they will take products back

30:58

no questions asked. Custom made to

31:00

order hair care from Proz has your

31:02

name all over it. Take your free

31:04

in-depth hair consultation and get 50% off

31:07

your first subscription order

31:09

today plus 15% off

31:11

and free shipping every

31:14

subscription order after that.

31:16

Go to proz.com/Harry Potter.

31:18

That's p-r-o-z.com/Harry Potter for

31:20

your free in-depth hair

31:22

consultation and 50% off

31:25

your first subscription order. I

31:30

mean the last thing that I feel like we have to talk

31:32

about is that what

31:34

Umbridge is trying to do is create

31:38

a world without any possibility. Yes.

31:40

Right? Like there was a requirement

31:42

for corruption just to get a

31:45

Quidditch team off the ground. And

31:48

what's interesting to me is how solidarity

31:52

is how people recreate

31:54

a sense of possibility. Right? Yeah.

31:56

Angelina went to McGonagall who went

31:59

to Dumbledore. and like things

32:01

feel possible again. And Cho

32:03

brings Marietta and like going to

32:05

the DA feels possible even in

32:07

Cho's extreme grief. Right?

32:10

That when things don't

32:12

feel possible, it literally it can

32:14

just make such a difference to have a

32:16

buddy or just like one person on your

32:18

side. Yeah, someone who maybe

32:21

has access to other resources or someone

32:23

who just has a slightly different perspective

32:25

that can then open your mind to

32:27

possibility or just like kind of like

32:29

Marietta just be there to hold your hand. Just be there with

32:31

you. Right? And like really

32:33

the big example of this is Harry and

32:35

Hermione, right? Like the

32:38

world needs Harry to be teaching this

32:40

class in order to keep this a

32:42

world where Umbridge's demise is possible. The

32:45

DA does need to be formed, but

32:47

Harry never would have done it without

32:49

Hermione. Right? Like in order to

32:52

live into all that is possible within

32:54

us. We just like need we

32:57

need friends Jackson. Yeah,

33:00

you need we need friends. We need

33:02

community. We need yeah, we need other

33:04

people and feeling that in our lives. Yeah,

33:07

because I mean this this book especially

33:09

is just a lot about feeling

33:11

a lack of possibility of

33:14

all the ways that Umbridge is just like

33:16

cutting off communication channels putting all these restrictions

33:18

on things. You know, there's a

33:20

couple of times in this book where Harry, Ron and

33:22

Hermione are like, well, we need to do this but

33:24

we can't do this because Umbridge like said like is

33:26

watching this and is doing this and so like when

33:28

you feel that run down well, not just

33:31

feel when you are that run down and

33:33

have all of these systems working against you it

33:35

can be so so hard to feel

33:37

that possibility at all. So I love some of

33:39

the examples you brought up even like the Quidditch

33:42

example of like again, is

33:44

Quidditch a need? Well, I think for a lot of

33:46

these kids to have an outlet and a morale

33:49

booster and like feel that possibility

33:51

again, like here was something that Umbridge took

33:53

away and they were able to work together

33:55

to bring it back like that is a

33:57

huge boon to feeling that sense of possibility.

34:00

Possibility again. Yeah, and that's one of the

34:02

things that we know that fascist regimes intentionally

34:04

try to do right is withhold a sense

34:06

of possibility Because

34:09

you become downtrend and stop fighting right

34:11

when yeah, yeah when you just like

34:13

give in that is

34:16

when it's easiest for these

34:18

regimes to take over so Yeah,

34:21

it's a strategy right like this the

34:23

status quo is a strategy and umbridge is

34:25

trying to make this the new status quo

34:27

of Just removing

34:29

all sorts of possibilities from the school.

34:32

Yeah, you know we sort of talked around it But

34:34

now I'm really Envisioning this first meeting

34:36

of Dumbledore's army as just being a

34:38

moment of like explosive Possibility for all

34:40

the kids in there who were feeling

34:42

very run down by everything that umbridge

34:44

is doing and suddenly like they're

34:46

feeling There is a

34:49

possible way out But also like feeling

34:51

possibility in themselves as they were all

34:53

like getting better in learning these skills

34:55

that they themselves can use Wow,

34:58

I I love the end of this

35:00

chapter with with the DA like it's

35:02

it's a really beautiful scene to me

35:05

I mean, I love that. This is the

35:07

chapter where we start to see Neville's excellence

35:09

Mm-hmm. You know, it's only gonna be in

35:12

book six when he gets his own wand

35:15

That like is a wand fit for him

35:17

that he will really start to excel at

35:19

magic And I know that it's

35:21

also made light of in this chapter, right? He's

35:24

effectively able to disarm Harry, but it's only because

35:26

Harry isn't paying attention But also

35:28

like you need that little boost of confidence

35:30

to then ever get to the next point

35:33

Exactly. And so it just makes sense to

35:35

me that it's like without a teacher's harsh

35:37

gaze It's without any

35:39

Slytherins in the room, right? Like

35:42

it's amongst friends that

35:44

Neville can see this possibility within himself

35:46

for the first time Do

35:48

I think late again going back to our etymology

35:50

which you know, I said bad

35:52

things about that ended up being really helpful All

35:55

right, like Neville was able to

35:57

see this possibility within himself so that the

35:59

new wand can make all the difference.

36:01

I do think we need both of those things,

36:03

right? Like McGonagall says it in this book too,

36:05

just a few chapters ago, right? Like all you

36:07

need to do is, you know, believe

36:09

in yourself a little more. What you're lacking is

36:12

confidence. And again, it turns

36:14

out he is lacking something material, but he

36:16

needs both. Yeah, yeah, you need both to

36:18

get it to work. Yeah. No, I

36:20

love this moment so much with Neville. Like that

36:22

was kind of my big moment of joy in the

36:25

chapter, but also part of it, like, like I sort

36:27

of was rereading it and Neville does expelliarmus correctly and

36:29

I kind of like fist punched the air. I was

36:31

like, yes. But then like reading sort

36:33

of before and after everything around that

36:35

moment is Harry just really

36:38

stepping into this natural ability as a teacher.

36:40

Like he's going around to everyone else, helping

36:42

them out. Even how he immediately was like,

36:44

Oh, Neville, you're going to partner with

36:47

me. Like, I don't know where any

36:49

of this came from with Harry. Like

36:51

he's just immediately knows what to do

36:53

as a teacher. And I just absolutely

36:55

loved seeing that talent emerge from him

36:57

in a way that I don't think

36:59

I've picked up on before when I've read it. And

37:01

I don't know, that was just so beautiful to me

37:03

seeing that in Harry of like, sure,

37:06

he gets all these accolades, all this attention and

37:08

fame for all of these things. But this is

37:10

something that is like a natural

37:12

skill of his that I don't think is ever really celebrated

37:15

or noticed. Yeah. No,

37:19

it's really beautiful him going around the room

37:21

and like helping people

37:23

quietly while also having them, you

37:26

know, work by themselves. Right. And

37:28

it's funny, just in this chapter,

37:31

we see Footwick go

37:33

around the room in order to

37:35

help students who are practicing with their

37:37

silencing charm, but he's not as pedagogically

37:39

sound in the way. He's like, well,

37:41

let's see you do it. Right.

37:43

He like asks Ron to perform,

37:46

whereas Harry is there and is like

37:48

gently changing people's strategy and is

37:51

like encouraging them. And so it's

37:53

interesting that potentially the best pedagogy

37:55

that we see at Hogwarts comes

37:58

from this child. So

38:13

Jackson, we are going to do

38:15

Pardes, the Jewish practice, and I

38:17

have picked a sentence for us.

38:19

Okay. It is, Harry shook

38:22

his head and covered his eyes with

38:24

his hands, pressing down upon

38:26

them with his palms. And

38:29

so the first step of Pardes is

38:31

shut, which is when we talk about

38:33

the intended meaning of the sentence, but

38:36

we'll also do a little context. So

38:38

this is when Harry's scar has just

38:40

hurt and he's like

38:42

processing that he can understand what

38:44

is going on with Voldemort. And

38:48

so Ron has just asked him, how do you know that that

38:50

is what's going on with Voldemort? Right.

38:53

And this is when they're in the locker

38:55

room after Quidditch practice, everyone else is left.

38:58

Right, Harry. Yes, yes. And

39:00

so literally in the sentence, right, it's

39:02

very physical, disjointed his head, covering his

39:04

eyes, pressing down upon them, right? You're

39:07

getting a sense, like this is the behavior

39:09

of someone with a migraine. That's exactly what

39:11

I was going to say. Yeah. Like you

39:13

can feel this pain if you've ever had a headache right there

39:15

where you're just like, I got to like somehow putting your hands,

39:17

the pressure on your head is going to help somehow. Right.

39:20

It's also him trying to concentrate, right?

39:23

Like really trying to like block everything

39:25

out so that he can focus. But

39:27

it feels like it's yeah,

39:29

it's both at the same time. Okay,

39:32

so step two is when we pick a word

39:34

and sort of see where else it comes up

39:37

in the novels. And so I will

39:39

read the sentence to you and pick a word that

39:41

sparkles up at you. So Harry shook

39:43

his head and covered his eyes with his hands,

39:46

pressing down upon them with his

39:48

palms. Hmm.

39:50

I think I want to

39:52

go with palms. Ooh, okay.

39:54

We had a lot of body parts

39:56

in that but palm is much more specific than

39:59

like hands or Yeah, so

40:01

what comes to mind immediately for me is

40:03

Trelawney. Me too. In like poem reading. Yeah.

40:05

Okay, where else do we have poems? I

40:08

feel like probably in cases

40:11

either of maybe like learning some type of

40:13

wand movement or like in dueling I almost

40:15

feel like there's maybe an instance where we

40:18

do see like Voldemort holding up his poem

40:20

or something like that. Yeah, I don't

40:22

know Later in this

40:25

book the prophecy is gonna be

40:27

something that Harry is constantly clutching

40:29

in his palm And it's

40:31

like his I think of

40:33

basketball players as people with like really

40:35

good palm strength, right? And Harry

40:38

it makes sense right like from Quidditch has

40:40

palm strength gotta catch that snitch You

40:42

gotta catch that snitch And I

40:45

just read the end of book five a lab

40:47

with my kids and we were just like Laughing

40:49

about how much happens to Harry and he manages

40:51

to hold on to the prophecy Like

40:54

really you still haven't dropped or

40:56

broken this prophecy Really,

40:58

but maybe it's this incredible palm

41:01

strength Yeah I think that is

41:03

probably it is like, you know him

41:05

being a seeker is almost like that

41:07

that has led us to be able

41:10

to Maybe believe that

41:12

he could hold that I think this is interesting

41:14

that Probably the main cases

41:16

that palms come up in the stories

41:18

are Divination stuff which

41:20

is like an open palm

41:22

trying to see the future

41:24

and then holding things Like

41:27

just grasping things in your hand. Yeah. Yeah,

41:30

like a closed clutched palm And so

41:32

that is a direction stone. Mm-hmm

41:35

in book seven the snitch Yeah,

41:38

yeah specifically like holding very

41:40

important things Yeah, yeah,

41:44

and it's also interesting that the first

41:46

example you brought up of like a

41:48

palm holding something was the prophecy When

41:51

the other like before the other thing we

41:53

had said was divination Yes,

41:55

both are that's a lot. Hey, yeah,

41:58

yes a physical man manifestation of

42:00

a thing. Oh, I love that. Him

42:02

holding the prophecy in his palm is

42:04

a form of palmistry. That's

42:07

his future in his hands. Oh

42:10

my God, that's fascinating. So

42:14

step three is trash. This

42:16

is where we talk about what lesson

42:18

we would pull from this

42:20

sentence, and so I'll read it one more time. Harry

42:24

shook his head and covered his eyes

42:26

with his hands, pressing down

42:28

upon them with his palms. So

42:32

I'm not at the point in my thought process where this

42:34

is a lesson yet, but one thing that

42:36

stood out to me when you read it this time

42:38

is, you know, we talked about how

42:40

this sentence, his actions are really showing

42:42

us like the pain of what he

42:45

was feeling. They're illustrating, this is a

42:47

very painful situation, but here, you know,

42:49

shaking his head, blocking things out, to

42:51

me was like also emotionally not wanting

42:53

this to happen, trying to like shake

42:55

it off just so badly, like he

42:58

knows what this means anytime soon as

43:00

his scar hurts and it's bad news,

43:02

and so he's like physically trying to

43:04

shake this off from being a thing

43:06

that is happening to him. I

43:09

love that, the like desire for this to not

43:11

be the case. Mm-hmm.

43:14

I think I would talk about, I just

43:16

feel cliche, but it just also

43:18

feels so true. I

43:20

think I would talk about the need for

43:23

like quiet sometimes,

43:26

right? Like he's

43:29

so desperate for like some form of

43:31

like privacy and reflection that he's just

43:33

like closing his eyes, right,

43:35

like closing himself off, and you know, it's not

43:37

that he doesn't want Ron in the room with

43:40

him, it's that he needs to really concentrate in

43:42

order to like have a thought and fixate on

43:44

what's happening. And I'm just

43:46

someone, I mean this is really me preaching

43:48

to myself, like I'm never not listening to

43:50

something, like I listen to podcasts while I'm

43:52

in the shower, I like never

43:54

go on a walk without either music or a

43:56

podcast playing, and I Like

44:01

really, our bodies just like need quiet.

44:05

Yeah. And whenever I do

44:07

eke out some quiet from myself,

44:09

I'm like, whoa, that's actually important.

44:11

And so I think I would,

44:14

yeah, talk about that and

44:16

like why we're afraid to be alone,

44:18

right? Like what

44:20

it is that we're trying to

44:23

drown out by always having noise with us.

44:25

Yeah, I strongly agree with

44:28

that. And I also listen to music and podcasts

44:30

in the shower. And anytime I'm like walking in

44:32

and leave the house. And with Harry in this

44:34

moment, what I'm thinking of is it's

44:36

related to that, but I think there's

44:39

the noise of his life. I mean, he

44:41

was at a boarding school. There's so many

44:43

other kids around. He's got so much on

44:46

his plate as a student, but he

44:48

could spend all day every day as

44:50

we see in the seventh book, like trying

44:52

to figure out this situation with Voldemort. And,

44:54

you know, with Harry, I think it's

44:57

maybe less like a, oh, I

44:59

should find quiet or like

45:01

quiet for reflection, but more like he

45:03

just needs the space in like his

45:06

time commitments and everything to be able to

45:09

think about this and process what is going

45:11

on, which I also find very relatable in

45:13

my life. Like it's not so much that

45:15

I like want to be alone or want

45:17

to be in quiet sometimes, but it's like,

45:20

I just need a minute to

45:22

try to process what's happening and think

45:24

about what I'm doing. Yeah, and that

45:26

there are good and bad places for

45:29

that, right? Like Harry had

45:31

all summer, quote unquote,

45:33

to reflect. True. But that's

45:35

not the vibe of the Dursley house, right?

45:37

Like even though he's left alone, it is

45:39

not in a productive or supported way. So

45:43

last up is Soad, and

45:45

Soad means secret. And so the idea is that

45:47

it's possible that a secret that we didn't think

45:50

of when we first read the sentence is

45:52

sort of emerged by talking about it.

45:54

So here is a sentence. Harry

45:57

shook his head and covered his eyes.

46:00

with his hands, pressing down

46:02

upon them with his palms. It

46:06

occurred to me that it's like one kind of prayer that

46:08

I know of, which is when

46:10

you're welcoming the Sabbath in Judaism,

46:12

you light the candles and then close

46:15

your eyes and Sabbath is often personified

46:17

as a bride that's like coming in

46:19

as a gift to like give

46:22

you quiet and a weekend. And

46:24

that it's often

46:26

traditionally, right, women

46:28

who do all the preparation

46:31

for Shabbat, right, who like make sure

46:33

all the food is cooked ahead of

46:35

time, make sure that everything is ready

46:37

so that you can have this radical

46:39

rest. And it is also

46:41

traditionally women who cover their eyes in

46:44

order to welcome in Shabbat.

46:47

And so it's just interesting that like it's

46:49

an intentional moment in

46:51

Judaism for like a moment of quiet to

46:55

reflect as you transition from one

46:57

moment to the other. You

46:59

know, Friday afternoons in Orthodox

47:02

Jewish households are incredibly chaotic

47:04

because you're not just doing your

47:06

normal activities but you're also preparing

47:08

to not be able to

47:10

do any activities for 24 hours and

47:13

that you need this moment of like supreme

47:15

quiet before you like step

47:17

over the threshold into the Sabbath and

47:20

like cover your eyes I think

47:22

is really beautiful. It's something that

47:25

I really love about sort of

47:27

like Sabbath traditions. Yeah, it's taking

47:29

that time to sort of pause from

47:31

all the chaos and now be like okay

47:33

like take some deep breaths and now we're

47:36

gonna slow down. Yeah, light a candle and start

47:38

a new space. Well and in this way

47:40

I mean we just had how more chaotic could

47:42

you get than Quidditch practice in a huge

47:44

downpour of rain and

47:47

then this like burst into your

47:49

head and so he is trying

47:51

to take that that moment of closing

47:53

his eyes and slowing down. I was

47:56

also thinking a little bit about you know we

47:58

talked about he's trying to block

48:01

everything out and like

48:03

figure out what he's feeling but something about

48:05

him like pressing into his eyes really

48:08

illustrated for me him getting deeper

48:10

into what's happening in his head

48:13

and really going like you know fully

48:17

cerebral fully inside or like trying to

48:19

figure out what

48:21

he's hearing from Voldemort. Yeah so

48:23

something about that which I think

48:25

is connected to the sort of

48:28

pause and the prayerful like

48:30

body language. Yeah and it's

48:32

interesting it's a transition he's always tried to

48:34

push Voldemort away and this is

48:36

him actually trying to go in and

48:39

understand right it is

48:41

a transition. Yeah and so

48:43

I love that even more now that we're

48:45

seeing this

48:48

as like almost more like prayerful

48:50

or like spiritual in a way because this

48:52

is a big moment it's the first time

48:55

that he's cognitively aware these are Voldemort's emotions

48:57

he then realizes in retrospect when he felt

48:59

that before but this is the first time

49:01

he's figuring it out and as we know

49:04

this is going to become a very major

49:06

like plot point. Yeah wow

49:09

I did not thought of that. Yeah wow

49:11

thanks for days and thanks for having us. Yeah

49:14

thanks Vanessa. ACAS

49:20

powers the world's best conscience.

49:24

Here's the show that we recommend. Hi

49:28

I'm Michelle Obama and in my

49:30

podcast I talk about so many

49:32

of the lessons I've learned that

49:34

are centered around finding your inner

49:37

confidence, understanding your own

49:39

stories, and persisting even if

49:41

it feels like people are

49:43

judging and watching your every

49:45

move. I get into

49:47

this and a lot of other

49:49

meaningful topics with some of my

49:51

closest friends on my podcast The

49:53

Light. The Light

49:56

podcast is presented by Starbucks.

50:00

ACAST helps creators launch,

50:02

grow, and monetize their

50:04

podcasts everywhere. acast.com.

50:10

This week's voicemail is from Serena.

50:15

Hi, Harry Potter Sacred Text team.

50:17

My name is Serena, and I'm

50:20

calling in with a blessing. I

50:23

was listening to Matt and Vanessa talk

50:26

about Sirius and

50:29

Molly Weasley and who would

50:32

be a better guardian

50:34

for him or what

50:36

kind of guardian Harry needs maybe. And

50:40

it made me think about my own experience. My

50:43

mom died when I was 15 years old, and

50:46

she was sick for a long time, and so she was able

50:48

to put a lot of things in

50:50

order before she died. She

50:54

was a queer single parent,

50:57

and she made the choice for

51:00

me to live with a

51:03

heterosexual couple

51:06

who had children after she

51:08

died because she was

51:10

worried that her family would take

51:13

me away to live

51:15

with them if I

51:17

lived with any of our

51:19

queer, chosen families. And

51:24

it was really hard. I

51:28

know now as an

51:30

adult that the laws

51:32

in the state and county where

51:35

I lived actually would have protected

51:37

me had she chosen a

51:41

different set of guardians for me. But

51:45

the folks that I lived with

51:47

were very loving but also had

51:49

a lot

51:52

of their own dysfunction and

51:54

pain. And

51:56

when I became an adult, the...

52:00

Mom of the family ended up writing me

52:02

a letter talking

52:05

about how part of

52:07

the reason that it

52:09

went so badly was that she

52:11

mistook me for my mom who had

52:14

been her great friend. And

52:18

I don't know that I would trade the experience

52:20

if I could because it made me the person who

52:23

I am today, but all

52:26

of your conversation made me

52:28

want to bless actually Dumbledore

52:30

and my mom and all

52:33

adults who have to make these impossible

52:35

choices or maybe even the wrong

52:37

choices for the right reasons. They're

52:41

doing their best with the information that

52:43

they have. And

52:46

Dumbledore had to put Harry

52:49

with the Dursleys and it wasn't

52:51

a choice. I think that his parents

52:54

would have made and I think if Dumbledore

52:56

had had more information, maybe there's this alternate

52:58

timeline where Harry gets to go live with

53:00

the Weasley's. So

53:03

thank you and thank you for your work

53:05

that you do. Hey.

53:10

Serena, thank you for your beautiful

53:13

voicemail. I love the forgiveness

53:16

in your voicemail. It's just

53:18

like profound assumption of good

53:21

intentions. I think it's

53:23

so generous of you to know

53:26

that you were impacted negatively

53:28

by something and to still see that

53:31

the intentions were all good. I think

53:33

that is not something that you owe

53:35

the world or anyone and

53:37

I'm just incredibly inspired

53:40

by that response. So I

53:43

want to thank you because yeah,

53:45

I think I can use a little more of

53:47

that in my life some forgiveness for things I

53:49

resent. And so thank you.

53:52

Yeah. Thank you for that. It

53:54

was really beautiful and I agree with

53:56

Vanessa. A good reminder and modeling of

53:58

forgiveness in a beautiful way. It

54:03

is now time for us to remember members

54:05

of our community who have been loved and

54:07

lost. David

54:13

Bransstrom, 37, a

54:15

sweetheart, husband, son,

54:18

brother, and coworker. Sonia

54:24

Bose, 89, a grandma

54:27

and where our listener got their sense

54:29

of humor. Caitlin

54:35

Burns, 39, hilarious, sensitive, and thoughtful

54:38

adventurer. Martine

54:46

Bryan, 97, the best

54:49

nana and a big Hagrid lover.

54:56

May their memories be a blessing. Jackson

55:08

it's now time for us to offer blessings

55:10

to characters. Who would you like to bless

55:12

this week? I would

55:14

like to bless Cho Chang because

55:17

I love seeing a little bit of her in

55:19

this chapter. These books are from Harry's

55:22

perspective and so a lot of what

55:24

we see of Cho Chang in these books is

55:26

like the object of Harry's desire. But

55:28

she is a full person who is

55:30

going through a lot as a 16 year old

55:32

and that is so so hard and

55:38

it doesn't sound like from the little bits

55:40

we get that like she's getting maybe the

55:42

support she needs at home like her parents

55:44

are maybe not realizing the kind

55:46

of grief that she's going through. She's

55:49

not getting it at Hogwarts and so I

55:51

just wanted to send a blessing to Cho who

55:54

is doing great despite not quite

55:56

getting the support she needs. Amen.

56:00

So I would like to bless Ginny

56:02

for her team moment with Cho. So

56:05

they're coming up with a name for

56:07

this organization. And

56:10

Cho comes up with the great idea of calling

56:12

it the Defense Association. And then

56:14

she's like, but for code reasons, we can call it

56:16

the DA. And her team

56:18

member Ginny turns it into the best

56:20

name ever, Dumbledore's Army. Because

56:22

she's like, no, let's just call them what

56:24

they're afraid we are. And

56:27

it's very confrontational and very humorous.

56:29

And I love that it's a yes

56:32

and moment between two brilliant young women.

56:34

It's true. Next week, we'll

56:37

be reading book five, chapter 19, The

56:39

Lion and the Serpent through the theme

56:41

of heartbreak with Matt Potts. Just

56:45

a few reminders before we give our

56:47

thanks. We have some amazing classes coming

56:49

up early in the new year. Find

56:51

out about those by going to not sorry works dot

56:53

com. And also we have some

56:55

amazing new iTunes reviews that

56:57

we want to thank. The

57:00

writers of ESM 888, The

57:02

Noah, Brit 1135, Rational Passion,

57:06

Kusebella 007, The

57:09

DeBola, Burr Pommie, Jillian Bell and

57:11

Evangeline. Thank you so much for

57:14

leaving reviews. It really helps new listeners find

57:16

us and we're really grateful. This

57:19

is a not sorry production. We are a

57:21

feminist production company. Our executive producer is Caitlin

57:23

Hofmeister. We are edited and produced by AJ

57:25

Yurama. Our music is by Ivan

57:27

Paizau and Nicole and we are distributed by

57:29

APAL. We want to thank Serena for

57:31

your great voicemail this week. Laura Glass,

57:34

Ariana Nettleman, Julia Argy, Margaritie Twiels

57:36

and Nikki Goldkine, Hannah Rehac, Tiffany

57:38

Brown, Christopher Torquayle, Matt Potts, Natalie

57:40

Feltert, Stephanie Pasell and everyone who

57:42

sent in the names of their

57:44

loved ones. Thank

57:54

you. for

58:00

eight years. I'm

58:02

like, what does this bad dad sound like?

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features