James interviews Vincent, the other suspect in Dakota’s case. Key discrepancies between the two testimonies are highlighted as James tries to make sense of what really happened, and what, if any, connections there are to Logan. --- Send in

S2 Ep 9: Catfish - Part 1 of 2

Apr 3rd, 2021 58m 56s

James dives into a murder case that happened in Olympia, WA shortly after Logan went missing. The two suspects in the case give conflicting testimonies about their relationship with Logan. Part 2: April 9th--- Send in a voice message: htt

S2 Ep 8: The Rest Stop

Mar 19th, 2021 57m 55s

James provides an update on the human remains found in Lewis County. He also speaks with someone close to Jacob, who shares a memory of an odd interaction not long after Logan’s disappearance..--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters

S2 Ep 7: Quicksand

Mar 6th, 2021 49m 32s

James speaks with an individual who comes forward with more information about Jacob and Chloe. He also talks with a former colleague of Jacob and discovers more holes in the "work trip" alibi.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.

Ep 1: The Hardest Case

Mar 6th, 2019 28m 15s

James dives into the mysterious case of Nancy Moyer. A 10 year old cold case that has little evidence but multiple suspects. James looks for guidance from the Detective that was once assigned to the case.--- Send in a voice message: https:/

S3 Eps2 pt1: That Sh*t Eatin Grin

Apr 16th, 2022 52m 58s

Part 1 of episode 2: James shares what happened during his first trip to Michigan. One of Brittany’s family members shares their thoughts and what they know about Brittany before she went missing.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcast

S3 Eps 28: The Case File Episodes; Presumptive Classification

Dec 31st, 2022 1h 24m

A concerning conclusion to the case file episodes.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/support

S3 Eps21: Silence of the Maverick

Oct 29th, 2022 43m

Buckle up and take a tense ride back to Mi with James. Hear Kris respond to Ashley's accusations about Jessica accessing Brittany's Facebook.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSuppor

S3 Eps20: Round 2

Oct 24th, 2022 1h 4m

One polygraph down. One more to go. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/support

S3 Eps17: Tell Me Your Story

1 Sep 30th, 2022 52m 59s

The details of the sexual domestic encounter are shared in this episode and may not be suitable for all listeners. If you'd rather not listen to this part of the episode, please stop listening at the 20:00 minute marker.--- Send in a voice

S3 Eps16: Marathon Petro 118109

Sep 17th, 2022 1h 16m

It's day 1. James and Ethan hit the ground running. They plan on meeting with a woman by the name of Kim. But Kim's availability comes into question. James has to call an audible. Times ticking. Time to move.--- Send in a voice message: htt

S2 Ep 12: Family and Friends

May 8th, 2021 1h 5m

James shares his conversation with one of Jacob’s former coworkers, who gives some insight into Logan and Jacob’s relationship. James is given the names of some individuals who were friends with Jacob, and is advised he look into their possible

S2 Ep 6: The Alibi

Feb 19th, 2021 1h 1m

James directs his investigation towards those who were closest to Logan, his family. Tough questions need to be answered.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: http

S2 Ep 4: Cellebrite

Jan 30th, 2021 41m 51s

James dives deep into Logan's cellular activity and tries to piece together Logans last known whereabouts and who he was in contact with. James sits down with "the man on the bike" who claims to have information about Logans disappearance. --

S2 Ep 3: Polehn Rd

Jan 15th, 2021 47m 24s

James heads to I5 and re-enacts what took place on May 20th 2016. When authorities get a tip about a male who is walking partially naked the night Logan’s car was impounded, they initiate a search and rescue mission. During the search, they com

S2 Ep 2: The Check in

Jan 9th, 2021 49m 40s

When Logans Facebook account post a "Checks in" 7days after his disappearance at the Olympia Regional Airport, detectives are uncertain if this was truly Logan checking in, an automated Facebook notification or if the person responsible for Log

Eps 6: Dry Bones

Apr 25th, 2019 1h 8m

James is able to track down Aaron Johns and discuss why he left the country. This is something Detective Elkins and private investigator Fred Doughty have been unable to do. James also looks into a former Tenino police officer who is considered

Ep 3: The Ruse

Mar 21st, 2019 50m 43s

James looks into a gruesome homicide that takes place in Tenino, shortly after Nancy disappears. Evidence shows this man did interact with Nancy, just before she disappeared. Is this man responsible for Nancy’s disappearance? James seeks guidan

Ep 2: Odd Duck

Mar 12th, 2019 41m 49s

Detective Haller gets his first break in the case as he notices a specific male has called Nancy's house 4 times Friday night. More details of Nancy's weekend and private life emerge.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.c

S3 EPS26: Lock & Key; The Case File

Dec 10th, 2022 1h 17m

James and Sara open up the case file and report the official statements of November 30th, 2018.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com

S3 Eps 24: 10-75

Nov 19th, 2022 1h 4m

James and Sara learn about a stolen vehicle.A network of contacts works with the team to help them track it down.--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: https://pod

S3 Eps19: Would I Lie To You?

Oct 14th, 2022 43m 33s

In today's episode, Jessica completes her polygraph examination. Would she lie to James about her daughter's disappearance?--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/james-baysinger/messageSupport this podcast: ht

S2 Ep 5: The Call Log

Feb 6th, 2021 37m 27s

James goes over what appears to be Logans phone calls, but when he realizes that there’s an issues with the calls. He sits down with Ginny and Detective Frawley to figure out what’s really going on.--- Send in a voice message: https://podca

S2 Ep 1: The Epiphany

Dec 31st, 2020 1h 1m

James goes back to Thurston County (WA) to tackle a different missing persons case. Logan Schiendelman, a 19 years old male, disappeared in May 2016. Logan vanished under mysterious circumstances when his Chrysler Sebring was reported drifting

Ep 13: Fly On The Wall

Nov 11th, 2019 54m 50s

James speaks with Barb, who gives her testimony of things she's heard and seen regarding Eric and Daves relationship around the time Nancy went missing. James gives an update on his most recent conversations with Eric and where things stand now