I've been listening to It's Super Effective for the better part of 9 years now? I think? I know I started on Episode 50. The Greatest Hits episode. It's crazy to think that I've been listening for so long, and it really has only gotten better and better year after year. PKMNCast is the show that got me into competitive Pokémon, back in the BW era when SBJ was just starting to compete in the live events, and in a way, is probably one of the biggest reasons I continued playing Pokémon into adulthood. And one of the best things about this podcast is, for as great as the show is and has been, the community they have built is the true highlight. I have met so many great friends because of them, and even though I don't interact with them as often as I used to, the hosts still make me feel so welcome whenever we interact. This show definitely deserves the 5-Star rating it has at the moment on Podchaser.
Short Version: Great banter, even greater community. It's fun being a Pokémon Trainer with these guys keeping you updated on the latest happenings in the Pokémon world!