In the Season One Finalé, Jenn & Jess bookend as they started, sharing an episode between the two of them and one of the most infamous murderers in history.

JOHN LENNON with Julia Murney

May 3rd, 2021 51m 14s

Broadway star and NYC native Julia Murney joins J & J this week to discuss the case that still haunts fans worldwide. As an upper west sider, Julia shares her long personal history not only to the neighborhood but to this beloved, global icon.

Martha Wise - The Borgia Of America with Sally Wilfert

Apr 26th, 2021 41m 40s

Broadway diva, singing star & BFF Sally Wilfert joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss one of the oldest female serial killers from the state of Ohio.

The Long Island Lolita with Marissa Rosen

Apr 19th, 2021 40m 59s

Broadway Beltress and BFF Marissa Rosen joins Jess & Jenn this week to discuss her personal connection to the case that took place in her hometown in Long Island.

The Disappearance of Susan Powell with Claybourne Elder

Apr 12th, 2021 53m 6s

Broadway/TV Star and Utah native Claybourne Elder joins Jenn & Jess this week to do discuss this tragic and confounding case.

Michael Peterson with Beth Leavel

Apr 5th, 2021 50m 28s

Tony Award Winner and North Carolina native Beth Leavel joins Jenn & Jess for their silver anniversary episode to discuss the case made famous by the documentary "The Staircase"

The VAMPIRE Murder with Christopher Sieber

Mar 29th, 2021 38m 58s

Two-Time Tony Award Nominee Christopher Sieber joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss this unusual crime that took place in his home state of Minnesota.

The Beale TREASURE with Rashidra Scott

Mar 22nd, 2021 44m 28s

Broadway star & Virginia native Rashidra Scott joins Jenn & Jess this week to solve to try and solve the ciphers leading to this elusive, missing treasure.

SELENA with Mauricio Martinez

Mar 15th, 2021 1h 1m

Mexican actor and singer Mauricio Martinez joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss the shocking murder of the "Queen of Tejano music" Selena.

The Ken & Barbie Killers with Danielle Wade

Mar 8th, 2021 54m 31s

Canadian TV & theatrical star Danielle Wade joins Jenn & Jess on this week's episode to discuss one of the worst crime sprees in Canadian history.

The Dating Game Killer with Betsy Wolfe

Mar 1st, 2021 40m 5s

Broadway star and California native joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss serial killer Rodney Alcala.

THE WESSON CRIMES with Heidi Blickenstaff

Feb 22nd, 2021 43m 32s

Broadway and TV Star Heidi Blickenstaff joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss one of the most gruesome cases from her hometown of Fresno, California.

Ted Bundy with Caitlin Kinnunen

Feb 15th, 2021 1h 7m

Tony Award Nominee & Washington state native Caitlin Kinnunen joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss one of the most infamous serial killers of all time.

Homicidal Sleepwalking with Max Crumm

Feb 8th, 2021 48m 56s

This week, Broadway & TV Star Max Crumm joins Jenn & Jess to discuss this rare phenomenon.

Connecticut Witch Trials with Patti LuPone

Feb 1st, 2021 59m 44s

Two time Tony Winner, Grammy Winner & Two time Emmy nominee Patti LuPone joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss the Connecticut Witch Trials.

THE NIGHT STALKLER with Alex Brightman & Jamie DuMont

Jan 25th, 2021 1h

Richard Ramirez aka The Night Stalker terrorized the citizens of Los Angeles. On this week's episode Jenn & Jess have two California natives, two time Tony Award nominee Alex Brightman and The Fabulous Invalid Co-Host Jamie DuMont to help them

Pamela Smart with SARAH SILVERMAN

Jan 18th, 2021 50m 42s

Emmy winner & NH native Sarah Silverman joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss the infamous case of Pamela Smart which inspired the movie "To Die For." It was the first gavel to gavel murder trial to be broadcast on television in U.S. history.

THE KILLER CLOWN with Bonnie Milligan

Jan 11th, 2021 1h 4m

John Wayne Gacy aka The Killer Clown is the subject of this week's episode. We are honored to be joined by Broadway star and Illinois native Bonnie Milligan as we delve into the crimes of this infamous serial killer.

Special: HEAVEN'S GATE

Jan 4th, 2021 59m 45s

Screenwriter Andrew Briedis & his wife, Broadway/film actress Sarah Jenkins join us to recount the final days of the cult members along with (thanks to their intrepid sleuthing) an interview with Dave Riley who served the cult their last meal a

Special: PSYCHIC MEDIUM John Edward

Dec 28th, 2020 1h 3m

Renowned Psychic Medium John Edward joins Jenn & Jess this week for a special episode.

Special: NXIVM Cult Whistleblower Sarah Edmondson

Dec 21st, 2020 54m 35s

On this special episode, NXIVM Whistleblower Sarah Edmondson joins Jenn & Jess to discuss her role in the group and what it took to ultimately leave, reclaim her life & break the organization wide open.

BOSTON STRANGLER with Mario Cantone

Dec 14th, 2020 40m 17s

Massachusetts native & TV/Film/Broadway star Mario Cantone joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss one of history's most famous cases.

MURDER in Vermont with Kate Wetherhead

Dec 7th, 2020 37m 16s

Broadway star Kate Wetherhead joins Jenn & Jess to discuss this tragic crime from her home state of Vermont.

The Woolfolk MASSACRE with Grey Henson

Nov 30th, 2020 43m 5s

Tony award nominee and Georgia native Grey Henson joins Jenn & Jess to recount a tale of murder that happened on the land on which his family lives!

The Murder of Carla Walker with Betty Buckley and Norman Buckley

Nov 23rd, 2020 47m 36s

Texas siblings, Tony Award winner Betty Buckley & her acclaimed Director/Producer brother Norman Buckley join Jenn & Jess to discuss this 46 year old cold case and Norman's personal connection to it.