Podchaser Logo
Home
Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Released Sunday, 28th April 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Murder before Divorce - April 28 2024

Sunday, 28th April 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Did you know nearly 75% of people have

0:02

subscriptions they've forgotten about? Do you think you

0:04

are part of that 75%? I

0:07

really didn't think that I would be

0:09

but when asked to list out all

0:12

the subscriptions I paid for one or

0:14

two slipped through the cracks that I

0:16

totally forgot about. One of which was

0:18

for something that I swore I canceled

0:20

forever ago. Think about it between streaming

0:22

platforms, apps, delivery services and even parenting

0:24

slash kids subscriptions. Though they all seem

0:26

like small amounts when pulled together that's

0:28

a pretty big chunk of your spending

0:30

money out the door. Rocket Money is

0:32

a personal finance app that finds and

0:34

cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending

0:37

and helps lower your bills so that

0:39

you can grow your savings. Rocket Money

0:41

has over 5 million users and

0:43

has saved a total of 500 million in canceled

0:46

subscriptions saving members up to $740 a year

0:48

when using all of the app's features. Stop

0:53

wasting time on things you

0:55

don't use. Cancel your unwanted

0:57

subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com/

1:00

morningcup. That's

1:02

rocketmoney.com/morningcup. rocketmoney.com/morningcup.

1:04

Today's podcast is brought to you

1:07

by newspapers.com, the ultimate destination for

1:09

exploring the mysteries of the past.

1:11

If you're fascinated by true crime

1:14

get ready to dive into the

1:16

stories that made headlines. newspapers.com offers

1:18

a billion pages of historical newspapers

1:21

from the U.S. and beyond and

1:23

you can search the entire collection

1:25

in seconds. Their vast newspaper collection

1:28

is a gold mine for eyewitness

1:30

accounts, crime scene photos, news reports

1:32

and more. Whether you're interested in

1:35

famous crimes or long forgotten cases, newspapers.com

1:37

gives you a front row seat to

1:39

more than 300 years of history. For

1:43

our listeners, newspapers.com has a special

1:45

offer. Use the code CUPOFMURDER for

1:47

an exclusive 20% discount

1:50

on your subscription. That's promo

1:52

code CUPOFMURDER at newspapers.com. Sign

1:54

up today and start unraveling

1:56

the true crime mysteries that

1:59

keep you. up at night. There

2:01

were two Mormons 15 miles away.

2:04

I found a telephone and electricity

2:06

line. We have a weird. I've

2:09

seen described by one investigator as reminiscent

2:11

of a weird. For

2:16

some divorce isn't enough.

2:19

On April 28, 2004,

2:21

a man lost his life to a

2:23

woman who decided to skip the step of divorce

2:26

and go straight to murder. So

2:30

if you like your coffee hot, but your bones chilled,

2:32

sit back and start your day with a

2:34

morning cup of murder. Bill

2:37

McGuire, born in September of 1964,

2:39

met Melanie Lynn Slate when they

2:41

worked at the same restaurant. And

2:44

immediately they fell head

2:46

over heels for one another. Later

2:49

joining the Navy and becoming a computer

2:51

programmer, Melanie became a nurse at a

2:54

fertility clinic. And eventually the pair

2:56

married in 1999

2:58

and later welcomed two beautiful

3:01

boys into their family. Raising

3:04

the boys in their Woodbridge, New Jersey

3:06

apartment, the couple had just recently

3:08

purchased a much larger half a million

3:11

dollar home in the area and

3:13

planned on moving in sometime very

3:15

soon. Closing on their

3:17

dream home on April 28, 2004, the happy family never got

3:19

the chance to move in. That's

3:25

because on that very night, Melanie

3:28

drugged her husband, shot him twice,

3:31

and then dismembered his body so

3:33

she could place them into three

3:35

matching suitcases. The

3:38

next day, the now single

3:41

mother, whose children were only

3:43

four and one when their

3:45

father was killed, began

3:48

trying to cover up her tracks by

3:50

stating that after a domestic

3:52

disagreement, Melanie finally

3:54

slapped her with an open palm, stuffed

3:56

a dryer sheet into her mouth, and stormed

3:59

out of her mouth. of their apartment. While

4:02

she established an alibi on April

4:04

30th, Phil's 2002 Nissan

4:07

Maxima was found parked outside the

4:09

Flamingo Hotel in Atlantic City. And

4:12

just five days later, the first

4:14

of three suitcases containing his

4:16

remains floated to the surface, launching

4:19

a full-blown murder investigation. The

4:23

second suitcase was found on May

4:25

11th by a graduate student out

4:27

birdwatching on Fisherman's Island, this one

4:29

containing Bill's head and torso. And

4:32

on May 16th, a boater

4:34

found the third and final suitcase floating

4:37

in the bay near the second island of

4:39

the bridge and tunnel. On

4:42

May 20th, Virginia Beach police released a

4:44

composite sketch of the man whose remains

4:46

were discovered on Fisherman's Island. And

4:48

a woman named Susan Rice just

4:50

so happened to see it and recognize

4:52

the man as the longtime friend

4:55

and Navy buddy of her husband's,

4:57

William Bill McGuire. This

5:00

is the same day that Melanie signed

5:03

the papers seeking a divorce from her

5:05

39-year-old husband. While she officially

5:07

filed the papers in Middlesex County on May

5:09

25th, investigators, unbeknownst

5:12

to her, had already named her

5:14

as the prime suspect in her

5:16

husband's murder. However, since

5:19

the murder did not occur in Virginia,

5:21

officials had to turn the investigation over

5:23

to the New Jersey State Police, who,

5:25

also seeing Melanie as their prime

5:28

suspect, found a handful of incriminating

5:30

evidence against her. Like

5:32

the video of her parking Bill's car

5:35

at the Flamingo Hotel, which

5:37

when asked, she claimed was a

5:39

harmless prank she committed against the

5:41

husband who by this point she

5:44

had already applied for a protection from abuse

5:46

order against. They

5:48

soon learned that on April

5:51

26, 2004, she purchased a .38 caliber

5:54

handgun from a store in Easton,

5:56

Pennsylvania, the murder weapon, as well as

5:59

some bulletproof guns. and that

6:01

she began searching the internet around this time

6:03

for things like undetectable poisons

6:06

and how to commit

6:08

a murder. They also

6:10

found out that she had been engaged

6:12

in a longtime affair with co-worker Bradley

6:14

Miller and she had

6:16

used her EZ Pass tag on a toll

6:19

in Delaware just two days after

6:21

the murder. So she claimed

6:23

this was for furniture shopping. Just

6:26

before they charged her with murder, Melanie

6:28

called EZ Pass and attempted to have

6:30

the charge removed from her account history.

6:33

When that didn't work, an unidentified

6:35

man, believed to be her father,

6:37

also made a similar call. The

6:40

plastic bags found with Bill's body were

6:42

forensically matched with the role in Melanie's

6:44

home. The luggage was matched to

6:46

the set pieces she still had in her basement

6:49

and when they found out that he was drugged, they

6:51

determined that she likely used medications from

6:53

her job at the fertility clinic. Melanie

6:57

McGuire was officially arrested on June 2nd, 2005, just over

6:59

a year after her husband was killed. Charged

7:05

with first-degree murder, Melanie made her

7:09

$750,000 bail and she pleaded not

7:11

guilty through her attorneys. Facing

7:14

additional charges on October 11th, 2005, Melanie

7:18

was indicted by a grand jury

7:20

on four more counts and

7:22

her bail was raised to $2.1 million. Again

7:27

making the bail and walking out of jail, on

7:29

October 26th, 2006, she

7:32

was charged with two counts of hindering

7:35

apprehension for allegedly writing letters to police

7:37

trying to get them off her trial.

7:40

She pleaded not guilty again and was released

7:43

after posting the $10,000 bail. Finally

7:46

brought to trial almost three years after

7:49

the murder, prosecutors claimed that

7:51

her motive was to finally make a

7:53

new life with her lover, Bradley Miller.

7:56

Insisting Her innocence, however, she claimed

7:59

her husband. The compulsive gambler who

8:01

owed a lot of people money.

8:03

And fate of her believe that he was

8:05

killed by the implants x City mob. On

8:08

April twenty third, two thousand and

8:10

seven, Melanie Mcguire was found guilty

8:12

of first degree murder and was

8:14

convicted of the lesser charges of

8:17

perjury desecration of human remains. An

8:19

possession of a weapon for unlawful

8:21

purposes. She. Was acquitted

8:24

however of the two counts of

8:26

hindering apprehension as well as tampering

8:28

with evidence and possession of Xanax

8:30

without a prescription. On July nineteenth,

8:32

she was sentenced to life in

8:35

prison for sixteen additional years. Said

8:37

the other charges. She. Will

8:39

not be eligible for parole until she

8:41

has one hundred years old. Thank.

8:44

You for joining me and my morning

8:46

top of murder these shiny again tomorrow

8:48

Direct terrible thing happened on April Twenty

8:50

nine. Don't. Forget to rate and

8:52

subscribe and let me know how you like it. If

8:55

you want to have what the podcast there though

8:57

is patriot on or just sharing it with your

8:59

true crime of best friends. And

9:01

remember. They. Say. Summer

9:04

barbecues in the backyard, game nights,

9:06

holiday parties. it all happens at

9:08

all in Ohio. Housing Finance Agency

9:10

wants to help you realize your

9:12

dream of homeownership. Ohio Housing Finance

9:15

Agency or Over may be able

9:17

to help. If you're ready to

9:19

buy a home, visit myohiohome.org for

9:21

more information or down assistance. Lower

9:23

interest rates and more. Oh makes

9:26

purchasing a whole more affordable. Visit.

9:28

My Ohio whole.org That's My Ohio

9:30

home.org Homeownership: Make it part of

9:32

your view.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features