Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Did you know nearly 75% of people have
0:02
subscriptions they've forgotten about? Do you think you
0:04
are part of that 75%? I
0:07
really didn't think that I would be
0:09
but when asked to list out all
0:12
the subscriptions I paid for one or
0:14
two slipped through the cracks that I
0:16
totally forgot about. One of which was
0:18
for something that I swore I canceled
0:20
forever ago. Think about it between streaming
0:22
platforms, apps, delivery services and even parenting
0:24
slash kids subscriptions. Though they all seem
0:26
like small amounts when pulled together that's
0:28
a pretty big chunk of your spending
0:30
money out the door. Rocket Money is
0:32
a personal finance app that finds and
0:34
cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending
0:37
and helps lower your bills so that
0:39
you can grow your savings. Rocket Money
0:41
has over 5 million users and
0:43
has saved a total of 500 million in canceled
0:46
subscriptions saving members up to $740 a year
0:48
when using all of the app's features. Stop
0:53
wasting time on things you
0:55
don't use. Cancel your unwanted
0:57
subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com/
1:00
morningcup. That's
1:02
rocketmoney.com/morningcup. rocketmoney.com/morningcup.
1:04
Today's podcast is brought to you
1:07
by newspapers.com, the ultimate destination for
1:09
exploring the mysteries of the past.
1:11
If you're fascinated by true crime
1:14
get ready to dive into the
1:16
stories that made headlines. newspapers.com offers
1:18
a billion pages of historical newspapers
1:21
from the U.S. and beyond and
1:23
you can search the entire collection
1:25
in seconds. Their vast newspaper collection
1:28
is a gold mine for eyewitness
1:30
accounts, crime scene photos, news reports
1:32
and more. Whether you're interested in
1:35
famous crimes or long forgotten cases, newspapers.com
1:37
gives you a front row seat to
1:39
more than 300 years of history. For
1:43
our listeners, newspapers.com has a special
1:45
offer. Use the code CUPOFMURDER for
1:47
an exclusive 20% discount
1:50
on your subscription. That's promo
1:52
code CUPOFMURDER at newspapers.com. Sign
1:54
up today and start unraveling
1:56
the true crime mysteries that
1:59
keep you. up at night. There
2:01
were two Mormons 15 miles away.
2:04
I found a telephone and electricity
2:06
line. We have a weird. I've
2:09
seen described by one investigator as reminiscent
2:11
of a weird. For
2:16
some divorce isn't enough.
2:19
On April 28, 2004,
2:21
a man lost his life to a
2:23
woman who decided to skip the step of divorce
2:26
and go straight to murder. So
2:30
if you like your coffee hot, but your bones chilled,
2:32
sit back and start your day with a
2:34
morning cup of murder. Bill
2:37
McGuire, born in September of 1964,
2:39
met Melanie Lynn Slate when they
2:41
worked at the same restaurant. And
2:44
immediately they fell head
2:46
over heels for one another. Later
2:49
joining the Navy and becoming a computer
2:51
programmer, Melanie became a nurse at a
2:54
fertility clinic. And eventually the pair
2:56
married in 1999
2:58
and later welcomed two beautiful
3:01
boys into their family. Raising
3:04
the boys in their Woodbridge, New Jersey
3:06
apartment, the couple had just recently
3:08
purchased a much larger half a million
3:11
dollar home in the area and
3:13
planned on moving in sometime very
3:15
soon. Closing on their
3:17
dream home on April 28, 2004, the happy family never got
3:19
the chance to move in. That's
3:25
because on that very night, Melanie
3:28
drugged her husband, shot him twice,
3:31
and then dismembered his body so
3:33
she could place them into three
3:35
matching suitcases. The
3:38
next day, the now single
3:41
mother, whose children were only
3:43
four and one when their
3:45
father was killed, began
3:48
trying to cover up her tracks by
3:50
stating that after a domestic
3:52
disagreement, Melanie finally
3:54
slapped her with an open palm, stuffed
3:56
a dryer sheet into her mouth, and stormed
3:59
out of her mouth. of their apartment. While
4:02
she established an alibi on April
4:04
30th, Phil's 2002 Nissan
4:07
Maxima was found parked outside the
4:09
Flamingo Hotel in Atlantic City. And
4:12
just five days later, the first
4:14
of three suitcases containing his
4:16
remains floated to the surface, launching
4:19
a full-blown murder investigation. The
4:23
second suitcase was found on May
4:25
11th by a graduate student out
4:27
birdwatching on Fisherman's Island, this one
4:29
containing Bill's head and torso. And
4:32
on May 16th, a boater
4:34
found the third and final suitcase floating
4:37
in the bay near the second island of
4:39
the bridge and tunnel. On
4:42
May 20th, Virginia Beach police released a
4:44
composite sketch of the man whose remains
4:46
were discovered on Fisherman's Island. And
4:48
a woman named Susan Rice just
4:50
so happened to see it and recognize
4:52
the man as the longtime friend
4:55
and Navy buddy of her husband's,
4:57
William Bill McGuire. This
5:00
is the same day that Melanie signed
5:03
the papers seeking a divorce from her
5:05
39-year-old husband. While she officially
5:07
filed the papers in Middlesex County on May
5:09
25th, investigators, unbeknownst
5:12
to her, had already named her
5:14
as the prime suspect in her
5:16
husband's murder. However, since
5:19
the murder did not occur in Virginia,
5:21
officials had to turn the investigation over
5:23
to the New Jersey State Police, who,
5:25
also seeing Melanie as their prime
5:28
suspect, found a handful of incriminating
5:30
evidence against her. Like
5:32
the video of her parking Bill's car
5:35
at the Flamingo Hotel, which
5:37
when asked, she claimed was a
5:39
harmless prank she committed against the
5:41
husband who by this point she
5:44
had already applied for a protection from abuse
5:46
order against. They
5:48
soon learned that on April
5:51
26, 2004, she purchased a .38 caliber
5:54
handgun from a store in Easton,
5:56
Pennsylvania, the murder weapon, as well as
5:59
some bulletproof guns. and that
6:01
she began searching the internet around this time
6:03
for things like undetectable poisons
6:06
and how to commit
6:08
a murder. They also
6:10
found out that she had been engaged
6:12
in a longtime affair with co-worker Bradley
6:14
Miller and she had
6:16
used her EZ Pass tag on a toll
6:19
in Delaware just two days after
6:21
the murder. So she claimed
6:23
this was for furniture shopping. Just
6:26
before they charged her with murder, Melanie
6:28
called EZ Pass and attempted to have
6:30
the charge removed from her account history.
6:33
When that didn't work, an unidentified
6:35
man, believed to be her father,
6:37
also made a similar call. The
6:40
plastic bags found with Bill's body were
6:42
forensically matched with the role in Melanie's
6:44
home. The luggage was matched to
6:46
the set pieces she still had in her basement
6:49
and when they found out that he was drugged, they
6:51
determined that she likely used medications from
6:53
her job at the fertility clinic. Melanie
6:57
McGuire was officially arrested on June 2nd, 2005, just over
6:59
a year after her husband was killed. Charged
7:05
with first-degree murder, Melanie made her
7:09
$750,000 bail and she pleaded not
7:11
guilty through her attorneys. Facing
7:14
additional charges on October 11th, 2005, Melanie
7:18
was indicted by a grand jury
7:20
on four more counts and
7:22
her bail was raised to $2.1 million. Again
7:27
making the bail and walking out of jail, on
7:29
October 26th, 2006, she
7:32
was charged with two counts of hindering
7:35
apprehension for allegedly writing letters to police
7:37
trying to get them off her trial.
7:40
She pleaded not guilty again and was released
7:43
after posting the $10,000 bail. Finally
7:46
brought to trial almost three years after
7:49
the murder, prosecutors claimed that
7:51
her motive was to finally make a
7:53
new life with her lover, Bradley Miller.
7:56
Insisting Her innocence, however, she claimed
7:59
her husband. The compulsive gambler who
8:01
owed a lot of people money.
8:03
And fate of her believe that he was
8:05
killed by the implants x City mob. On
8:08
April twenty third, two thousand and
8:10
seven, Melanie Mcguire was found guilty
8:12
of first degree murder and was
8:14
convicted of the lesser charges of
8:17
perjury desecration of human remains. An
8:19
possession of a weapon for unlawful
8:21
purposes. She. Was acquitted
8:24
however of the two counts of
8:26
hindering apprehension as well as tampering
8:28
with evidence and possession of Xanax
8:30
without a prescription. On July nineteenth,
8:32
she was sentenced to life in
8:35
prison for sixteen additional years. Said
8:37
the other charges. She. Will
8:39
not be eligible for parole until she
8:41
has one hundred years old. Thank.
8:44
You for joining me and my morning
8:46
top of murder these shiny again tomorrow
8:48
Direct terrible thing happened on April Twenty
8:50
nine. Don't. Forget to rate and
8:52
subscribe and let me know how you like it. If
8:55
you want to have what the podcast there though
8:57
is patriot on or just sharing it with your
8:59
true crime of best friends. And
9:01
remember. They. Say. Summer
9:04
barbecues in the backyard, game nights,
9:06
holiday parties. it all happens at
9:08
all in Ohio. Housing Finance Agency
9:10
wants to help you realize your
9:12
dream of homeownership. Ohio Housing Finance
9:15
Agency or Over may be able
9:17
to help. If you're ready to
9:19
buy a home, visit myohiohome.org for
9:21
more information or down assistance. Lower
9:23
interest rates and more. Oh makes
9:26
purchasing a whole more affordable. Visit.
9:28
My Ohio whole.org That's My Ohio
9:30
home.org Homeownership: Make it part of
9:32
your view.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More