On October 16th, 2012, the city of Gresham, Oregon came to a halt when 21-year-old Whitney Heichel was reported missing. Her husband, Clinton, her friends, family, and church all came together to search for her. With a single gas station purchase and fuzzy surveillance footage as the only clues, the frantic search escalated by the hour. When the Heichel’s friends and neighbors, Johnathan Holt, started to act strangely, the police finally had a lead. Were Johnathan’s claims of being mugged factual? Did Whitney run away? What clues did police find that brought them to the horrible discovery the entire city dreaded? Follow Alisha and Emily as they trace the path of Whitney and Johnathan on that fateful Autumn day. 

Check out A Thinking Error - Episode Blog for photos, additional information, and sources for this case.

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/murder-in-the-rain/exclusive-content

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands