Podchaser Logo
Home
Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Released Friday, 29th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Sarah Fay: ...recovery is possible and mental illness is not proven to be chronic

Friday, 29th March 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:09

Welcome to Nobody Told Me. I'm Laura

0:11

Owens. And I'm Jan Black. More than

0:13

47 million people

0:16

in the United States have been diagnosed

0:18

with a mental illness, and that means

0:20

that nationwide, almost one in five people

0:22

are living with a mental health condition.

0:25

Our guest on this episode, activist and

0:27

author Sarah Fay, is one of those

0:29

who've been diagnosed with a mental illness.

0:32

In fact, Sarah Fay has been diagnosed

0:34

or rather misdiagnosed with six mental illnesses

0:36

over the last 30 years. She writes

0:39

about her experience and raises important

0:41

mental health questions for all of

0:43

us in the new book Pathological,

0:45

the true story of six misdiagnoses.

0:48

Sarah, thank you so much for joining

0:51

us. Thank you both for

0:53

having me. It's great to be here. Tell

0:55

us why you decided to write this book,

0:57

why you felt it was really necessary. Well,

1:00

as you mentioned, I was diagnosed with six

1:03

different disorders, and it started when I was

1:05

12. So anorexia, generalized

1:07

anxiety disorder, major depressive

1:10

disorder, then ADHD, OCD,

1:12

and then bipolar disorder.

1:14

So I spent 25, 30 years

1:17

in total in the mental health

1:19

system, and I still

1:21

wasn't getting well. And I couldn't

1:23

understand why have I been given

1:26

six different diagnoses, and still I'm

1:28

not any better. And so when

1:30

I was in crisis,

1:32

actually, and I was

1:35

without a psychiatrist, and

1:38

I was suicidal at the time. And my

1:41

sister swept in. Anyone who's

1:43

been through this knows that the families are

1:45

the heroes of these stories. Certainly my family

1:47

is the hero of mine. They've been amazing,

1:49

but she swept in, she found me a

1:51

psychiatrist, and I went to see him. And

1:53

we had our 30 minute consultation. And at

1:55

the end, I waited for him to give

1:57

me a new diagnosis, a seventh one. I

2:00

was on my sixth or to

2:02

confirm the bipolar diagnosis. And

2:04

he looked at me and he said, I don't know what

2:06

you have. And my whole world shifted.

2:08

And I left his office. It was the

2:11

dead of winter in Chicago, a polar

2:13

vortex. And I just remember the

2:15

city looked so crisp, but

2:17

also harsher, but I felt

2:19

like no one knows what I have. Wait a second.

2:22

And I just realized I don't know anything about

2:24

the diagnoses I've been given. I know nothing. I

2:26

don't know where they come from. I don't know

2:29

what they really are. I don't know how

2:31

these doctors have determined that I have them.

2:33

And so because I have a doctorate and I spent six

2:35

years researching, I'm a bit of a research

2:38

dork. So what I did was I just

2:40

dove in and I started researching

2:43

mental health diagnoses. I said, I'm going to

2:45

learn everything about them. And I did. And

2:47

it was disturbing and a lot

2:49

of every day of nobody told

2:51

me, nobody told me, over and over again.

2:56

So you write in detail about what

2:58

you call the psychiatrist Bible,

3:00

which is how psychiatrists base

3:02

these diagnoses on. And

3:05

it's called the Diagnostic and Statistical

3:08

Manual of Mental Disorders and all of

3:10

the flaws that it has. So what

3:13

is the DSM and how is it

3:15

so detrimental? Yes, and

3:17

if your eyes just glazed over, listeners,

3:19

don't worry, mine did too. Like,

3:21

those words like diagnosed as well.

3:24

Like, diagnostic and statistical manual. But

3:27

what's interesting is the DSM, whether you know it

3:29

or not, that's what it's referred to as.

3:31

Also, as you said, psychiatry's Bible is

3:33

a huge part of our culture. So

3:35

you know it whether you know it

3:37

or not, meaning we have diagnoses, the

3:40

diagnoses that come from it. It's just

3:42

a book. I didn't know this. It's

3:44

a manual with pages and like

3:46

any other book. And so

3:49

All of our mental health diagnoses are in there.

3:51

And Just to give you a visual of what

3:54

the book looks like, you have the diagnosis at

3:56

the top of the page. So Let's say Major

3:58

depressive Disorder. And Then there are. Them Less.

4:00

So you have to qualify for

4:02

the diagnosis by having five of

4:05

nine symptoms in the case of

4:07

major depressive disorder. And so it

4:09

it's It's very orderly, And

4:11

at face value. It looks okay.

4:13

I mean you wouldn't pick it up

4:15

and and question it. But what I

4:18

learned in my research is that really

4:20

the diagnoses are just series, so. I

4:22

pictured it like physical illnesses we discover

4:24

and illness and then we theorize about

4:26

at let's say so but we can

4:28

see it. We have an objective marker

4:30

avec meaning there's a blood test for.

4:33

Major The shows you have major depressive disorder Or let

4:35

me show you this brain scanner. Let me show you

4:37

this x ray. We don't have any of

4:39

that for. The diagnoses in that book

4:41

and the diagnoses that we receive And

4:44

then what I learned as well is

4:46

Robert Stitzer who is one of the

4:48

main architects of. Modern. Psychiatry and

4:50

the Dsm. He was asked, why do

4:53

you need five of nine symptoms. To

4:55

received a diagnosis of major depressive

4:57

disorder and me said. Mrs. Arbitrary

4:59

We went around the table unforeseen. like

5:01

to see you and sixteen. Make too many.

5:04

Ah, and I mean that

5:06

was how. That's. The same

5:09

criteria we use today. So

5:11

irrationally is different going to a medical doctor

5:14

for a broken bone and they can see

5:16

it on an x ray and say oh,

5:18

you have a broken bone or you have

5:20

a. Blood tests that tells them that

5:22

you have an infection and done

5:24

that just. Doesn't exist for

5:27

mental health issues. Exactly

5:29

an end to. you know, In some ways

5:31

when we think about it, there's nothing wrong

5:34

with that, diagnoses or what we have.

5:36

That's just what we as what we've been

5:38

dealt. Think about it. We've got a brain

5:40

and a mind. What is even a mind

5:43

that may resume Human is. So the

5:45

psychiatry up against a lot. We've gotta give

5:47

them a little gray. see it our read

5:49

in the sense of they're trying to do

5:51

something that essentially is almost impossible with

5:53

what we have now what we know. So

5:56

there's nothing wrong with the fact that Tsm

5:58

diagnoses and medical diagnoses. Or. really what's

6:01

called scientifically invalid, meaning you have no

6:03

biological marker, like you said, there's no

6:05

blood test for them. And

6:07

they're unreliable, which means the symptom lists

6:10

that we have don't always lead

6:12

to consistent diagnoses, but among clinicians,

6:14

but also for people, which is

6:16

why you can receive six in

6:18

your lifetime, perhaps. So

6:21

none of that, there's nothing wrong with that. We

6:23

have to use what we can. What I see

6:25

and why, going back to your question, why I

6:28

wrote the book was that I didn't know this.

6:31

And as a patient, I feel entitled

6:33

to that information. And I

6:35

started to see all these people

6:37

around me accepting mental health diagnoses

6:39

without knowing it too. And

6:41

that just seemed a real disservice to

6:44

the public. I was actually on NPR

6:46

recently with Paul Applebaum, who is chair

6:48

of the steering committee of the DSM, so like

6:50

the head of the DSM. And

6:52

I wrote a book critiquing it, I thought we

6:55

were gonna rumble or something, but

6:57

he was wonderful. And Tom Insel was

6:59

on there too, another really prominent figure

7:01

in psychiatry. And they both just agreed,

7:03

yes, the public needs deserves to know and

7:06

they deserve to know what psychiatry knows. And

7:08

so that's really the gap I'm trying to fill with

7:11

the book. So telling my story, which is

7:13

a page turner, I hope, and then

7:15

also giving people, I sprinkled in surreptitiously

7:17

all the information you need to know about

7:19

the DSM. Because a

7:22

lot of people just go from doctor

7:24

to doctor if they don't like the

7:26

diagnosis, right? I mean, is that a

7:28

bad thing to do? It seems like it would be,

7:30

but at the same time, if you're not fitting into

7:33

one of these categories and you're

7:35

not having any luck with psychiatric

7:37

drugs, that makes sense. Yes,

7:40

and I do know what that's

7:42

like. And that's why I don't want anyone

7:45

to think two things. One, I always wanna preface

7:47

mental illness is very, very real. And

7:50

I'm not at all questioning that category.

7:52

I had one and I know it's

7:54

real. So that, I just

7:56

wanna be clear, questioning the DSM diagnoses are

7:58

really about questioning. the tools that

8:01

we're using to tell you what's wrong, or

8:04

by labeling people, this or that, that's

8:06

really what's being called into question, not

8:08

mental illness. So I always wanna just

8:10

be clear about that. But

8:12

what you bring up is the DSM, as I said, is such

8:15

a huge part of our culture, that

8:17

sometimes we're actually going and requesting

8:19

diagnoses. And that's something that never

8:22

happened before. We never had- And you

8:24

can look at these symptoms online and

8:26

say, oh, that's right, that's right, and

8:28

lead the doctor into that diagnosis. Yes,

8:30

exactly. And without anything to

8:32

prove or disprove it, then we're running

8:35

into trouble. And then I think the

8:37

other thing is doctors are as susceptible to

8:39

that, so they are looking for diagnoses too.

8:42

And this is my book, why I

8:44

think it's so important for people, is that

8:46

it represents what a lot

8:48

of people right now are going through,

8:50

and not the typical mental illness memoir

8:53

tends to be about psychiatry and anti-psychiatry,

8:55

and very much about

8:57

these extreme experiences. My

8:59

experience became extreme, but I really stumbled

9:01

into the mental health system in some ways.

9:04

And I think a lot of people do, looking

9:06

for an answer and looking for help. And

9:08

then the other part of my story that's more

9:11

like what a lot of people are going through is

9:13

that five of my six

9:15

diagnoses came from GPs, from general

9:17

practitioners, family doctors. So

9:20

I was not, I can't blame psychiatry for

9:22

what happened to me. And

9:24

so, and what I learned in

9:26

my research, which is shocking, is that actually

9:28

GPs are doing most of the diagnosing and

9:31

prescribing. They prescribe 80% of antidepressants.

9:35

And they prescribe- Wow, I have no idea. Yeah, I didn't

9:37

mean to- I never would have thought that they did really

9:39

any of them. I would think that would be a referral.

9:41

Yeah. I hate to say it,

9:43

but nobody told me. I mean, it's going over and

9:45

over again. But the, and

9:47

then they prescribe 50% of

9:49

anti-psychotics to children. So

9:52

you've got this, and then what gets more

9:54

disturbing, and again, I don't wanna, I

9:57

think that this is disturbing, but also a great

9:59

opportunity. is that in

10:02

a University of Michigan study from 2019, they

10:04

found that only 24%, so

10:07

less than a quarter of medical schools

10:09

offer GPs more than 12 hours

10:12

of psychiatric training. That's

10:14

all they have. That's it, I mean, like

10:16

let that sink in. That's a season of Grey's Anatomy.

10:18

You know, what are we, you know,

10:21

and then what's also even

10:23

more disturbing is they ask

10:25

those same doctors, do you feel

10:27

comfortable diagnosing patients with psychiatric disorders,

10:29

and the majority of them said,

10:32

very comfortable. So there's

10:34

a real problem there, which I think is

10:36

very fixable, which is nice in the sense

10:38

of, and I'm being blithe about this. I

10:41

teach at a University, so I know how hard it

10:43

is to change curriculum, but change

10:45

the curriculum, train our GPs. I mean,

10:47

they're there for a reason, and they're given

10:49

that privilege of diagnosing for a reason, which is

10:51

that a lot of us don't have access to

10:53

psychiatrists. And so it's about

10:56

access to care, so it comes from a good

10:58

place, but we really

11:00

need to change that and make

11:02

sure that they're being trained, or that the other

11:04

thing I really recommend for people is, if

11:07

you are diagnosed by a GP, see

11:11

a psychiatrist if you can. Again, I know

11:13

that's a luxury, but the other thing is

11:15

ask your psychiatrist to confirm the diagnosis,

11:17

I mean your GP to confirm

11:19

the diagnosis with a psychiatrist. That

11:23

can happen. Now, what

11:25

happened in your story after you

11:27

had these six misdiagnoses and

11:29

you went to the seventh

11:33

doctor who said, I don't know what you

11:35

have, then what happened in your story? Well,

11:38

then it's kind of fascinating. So he

11:40

never told me what I had, and

11:43

I never asked again.

11:46

He did tell me that he's changed it two more times.

11:49

I don't know what number we're on,

11:52

but I've never asked, so I still

11:54

have a diagnosis, I am still on

11:56

medication, I still see him, he's still

11:58

my psychiatrist. He's very open with... me about

12:00

the flaws in mental health diagnoses.

12:02

We talk about it. He knows he's in the book. He's

12:04

okay with being in the book. I don't know if he's

12:06

going to read the book. I don't know. But I

12:09

think he comes off looking pretty good. So I told

12:11

him that. But he, you know, so I

12:13

have never asked for it because what happened to

12:16

me and not everyone does this, but I

12:18

think quite I've heard from a lot of

12:20

readers who have, which is that I

12:22

over identified with my diagnosis, I

12:25

really became it each one. So

12:27

I really could see myself in the diagnosis.

12:29

And there's a good reason for that. Our

12:32

diagnoses are mental health diagnoses, the

12:34

symptoms of them are all things

12:36

that are a part of daily life,

12:38

depression, anxiety, you know, so they're just

12:40

part of being alive with the notion

12:42

of maybe psychosis, and a couple of

12:44

other things. But so it's

12:46

very easy to see yourself in any

12:49

diagnosis, not everybody, but if you're

12:51

slightly, you know, hardwired, like I am

12:53

a sensitive creature, you know, which is

12:55

how I see myself. But

12:57

so that you know, you're going to see

12:59

yourself in the diagnosis, and I certainly did.

13:01

And that also came from a place it's

13:04

not faking it. I mean, I want

13:06

to be very clear, I was never faking.

13:08

But when you do over identify what happened

13:10

is it became my whole life. And

13:13

every emotion, every thought, every

13:15

behavior I attributed to my

13:17

diagnosis. So if I was

13:19

sad, unexplainably sad, one

13:21

day, it was my depression. That was

13:24

my depression, like I owned it. And

13:26

now that I don't have a diagnosis, when I

13:28

wake up sad, which happens, unexplainably, I don't

13:30

even nothing's wrong, but I'm terribly

13:32

sad, I have to wrestle

13:34

with that now. And I can't just say it's

13:37

my depression. And I,

13:39

it kind of forces me to really

13:41

feel my emotions and and, and allow

13:44

them to be in my life and to

13:46

look at my thoughts, but also to look

13:48

at my circumstances and say, Okay, am

13:50

I working too much? Is there something that might

13:52

be pushing me to feel this way? Am I

13:54

not listening to myself or, you know, something along

13:57

those lines. So it's been very beneficial for

13:59

me. not to have a diagnosis.

14:02

And I said to my family for, you

14:05

know, I've been saying this for a couple of years. I

14:07

said, I think I'm well, I mean, I

14:10

don't think well, I mean, I think I'm

14:12

cured. And my family said, Yeah, I

14:14

know, I think you are too. So because there's

14:17

this, I mean, I live in a different

14:19

mind right now. And so I'm

14:21

writing the sequel to pathological, which is about

14:23

how I healed, and how,

14:26

you know, that recovery from mental illness, and I don't

14:28

like that word, but people have

14:30

been hesitant to say, you know, that you

14:32

can be cured. There isn't a cure

14:35

being meaning the noun, there isn't a

14:37

pill we can take, there isn't one

14:39

practice of meditation that we can do,

14:41

that will cure mental illness. But I

14:43

believe that going through certain processes and

14:45

doing certain things, and maybe not necessarily

14:47

the way I did, it might be

14:49

individual for each person, I

14:51

am cured. And then I

14:53

didn't feel comfortable saying that. And certainly not writing

14:55

it in a book, but Thomas Insel, who was

14:57

former head of the NIMH, he just came out

14:59

with a book, a wonderful book called Healing

15:01

our Path from Mental Illness

15:04

to Mental Health. And he has said,

15:06

mental illness is not chronic, we need

15:08

to start giving people hope and letting them know

15:11

that they can heal. So now

15:13

I'm always Tom. We

15:18

love having you as part of our

15:20

nobody told me family of listeners, we

15:22

know a lot of you want to

15:24

be your own boss or already operate

15:27

your own business. That's why we want

15:29

you to know about Shopify. Hear

15:33

that? That's the sound of

15:35

another sale on Shopify. In

15:37

the moment, another business dream

15:39

becomes reality. Shopify puts you

15:41

in control of every sale

15:43

channel. So whether you're selling

15:45

satin sheets from Shopify's in

15:47

person POS system, or offering

15:49

organic olive oil on Shopify's

15:51

all in one e-commerce platform,

15:53

you're covered. Shopify is the

15:55

all in one commerce platform

15:57

that's revolutionizing millions of businesses.

16:00

worldwide. Whether you're a garage entrepreneur

16:02

or IPO ready, Shopify is the

16:04

only tool you need to start,

16:06

run, and grow your business without

16:09

the struggle. And once you've reached

16:11

your audience, Shopify has the internet's

16:13

best converting checkout to help you

16:15

turn them from browsers to buyers.

16:18

Once you start selling, Shopify makes

16:20

getting paid simple by instantly accepting

16:22

every type of payment. Running a

16:24

growing business means getting the insights

16:27

you need wherever you are. With

16:29

Shopify's single dashboard, you can manage

16:31

orders, shipping, and payments from anywhere.

16:34

What I love about Shopify is how no

16:36

matter how big you want to grow, Shopify

16:39

gives you everything you need to

16:41

take control and take your business

16:44

to the next level. Shopify

16:46

powers 10% of all e-commerce in

16:48

the US, and Shopify is truly

16:51

a global force powering all birds,

16:53

Rothy's in Brooklyn, and millions of

16:55

other entrepreneurs of every size across

16:58

170 countries. Plus, Shopify's award-winning

17:01

help is there to support your

17:03

success every step of the

17:05

way. This is possibility powered by

17:07

Shopify. Sign up for a $1

17:09

per month trial period

17:12

at shopify.com/nobody, all lower

17:14

case. Go to shopify.com/nobody

17:17

to take your business

17:19

to the next level

17:22

today. shopify.com slash

17:25

nobody. I

17:27

think as a society, we're not

17:30

really doing a service

17:35

by whether or not we're trying to do

17:37

it by saying like with a celebrity, I

17:40

don't know Pete Davidson, for example, okay, he's

17:43

depressed. And so whenever I think

17:45

about him, it's absolutely no judgment,

17:48

but it's just something that I think

17:50

about. And I know even, you know,

17:52

when my mom and I are having

17:54

conversations, it's like, Oh, yeah, he's depressed

17:56

or something. So do you think that

17:58

that's not a good thing? and

18:00

that's making it so that people are

18:02

kind of afraid of, you know, coming

18:04

out and telling the world what they

18:06

have because they don't want to be like

18:09

Pete Davidson or any celebrity. He

18:11

may not be depressed nowadays. That's

18:14

true. He may be

18:16

cured now. Yeah, I don't maybe

18:18

it's Kim Kardashian is the cure. But

18:22

yeah, it's I mean, it's, it's

18:24

interesting that you bring that up. I'm

18:26

actually finishing up an op-ed and opinion

18:28

essay on this and how mental health

18:30

awareness has backfired. It

18:32

comes from a great place. I mean, it meant,

18:35

you know, Mental Health Awareness Month, which is May,

18:37

you know, that started in 1949. It's

18:40

been around and the point of it

18:42

is wonderful to educate people about mental

18:44

health and diagnoses and mental illness and

18:47

to eliminate stigma. There's nothing wrong with

18:49

that. But what's happened is

18:51

the focus of all of our discussions

18:53

about mental health have become centered on

18:56

diagnoses, like that's the starting point in

18:58

the end point, and there's nothing else

19:00

there. Even when we

19:02

talk about other aspects of mental health, it's

19:04

in terms of diagnoses. And it's gotten

19:06

to the point where we've, we've, we've confused

19:09

depression, the emotion with depression,

19:11

the disorder and anxiety, the emotion

19:14

with anxiety, the disorder. And

19:16

we use the terms interchangeably. So

19:19

I think that that and then you've got they're all

19:21

over social media. They're, you

19:23

know, they're people are self-diagnosing on social

19:25

media. We have TikTok therapists. And then

19:27

as you said, celebrities come out. And

19:31

one scholar wrote about essentially

19:33

how young people will look at a

19:35

celebrity, you know, who's talking about a

19:38

mental health diagnosis and say, Oh, if they

19:40

have it, maybe I have it too, in

19:42

this kind of idolizing way. So

19:44

there's there's there can be backfired

19:46

there as well. It's tricky. We

19:49

can talk about is awareness of a

19:51

diagnosis a good thing or is it

19:54

actually making us identify with them?

19:57

And then, you know, it has been reported that people

19:59

are asking for. diagnoses and that never

20:01

happened. But what's interesting is I

20:03

was in the 19th century, people

20:05

didn't know their diagnoses. And

20:08

this was true actually pre 1960s. So

20:11

it was just for doctors. Actually the DSM

20:13

was simply for doctors to communicate with each

20:15

other. It was never meant. These diagnoses were

20:17

never meant for us, ever. And

20:21

so for us to be identifying with them,

20:24

that's not what they were for. So

20:27

my doctor has my diagnosis and he can

20:29

communicate with anyone. And so I'm just living

20:31

in the 19th century and everyone else can

20:34

live here. I

20:36

don't know. Yeah, and

20:38

don't you also think that

20:40

maybe the prospect of getting

20:42

a diagnosis and a label

20:45

may prevent some people from

20:47

actually seeking help because they don't

20:49

wanna be called of

20:52

whatever it might be that they

20:54

have a negative association with. That's

20:57

such a good point. And what's interesting about

20:59

that is I read, part of

21:01

my research was that you would think

21:03

the biological explanation for mental health diagnoses,

21:05

which by the way, I didn't know.

21:08

No one told me that that's never

21:10

been proven. There is no

21:12

such thing as a chemical imbalance. That

21:14

was debunked 20 years ago. Wow. I

21:16

had no idea. I mean, I

21:18

had. Nobody, what are you talking about? Yeah.

21:21

So those aspects of this that are not being talked about

21:27

but what they found as well is

21:29

that they thought, oh, the biological explanation

21:31

is good. It may not be proven

21:33

yet, but it's going to be is what

21:35

they promised for 20 years, but it hasn't been.

21:39

But the biological

21:41

explanation prevents people from

21:44

self-stigmatizing, right? That's the idea. Because

21:46

if you think, well, it's not a character flaw.

21:48

It's not something wrong with me. But

21:50

what they found is actually it leads to more self

21:52

stigma because then it's in

21:54

you. It's you. It's like

21:56

your biology instead of something you

21:58

could possibly turn into. transcend or heal

22:00

from or move past. What

22:04

advice do you have for somebody who

22:06

has recently been diagnosed with

22:09

a mental health disorder and feels

22:11

really shattered and a sense of

22:13

shame because of it? I

22:17

understand that. I think the most

22:19

shame I felt was with bipolar

22:21

disorder, certainly. So I understand that.

22:23

And I was shocked to get

22:25

that diagnosis. I didn't think, I mean, it

22:27

shouldn't have come as a shock because I

22:29

received it while I was in crisis, but

22:32

it really did. And I didn't want it.

22:35

But then what happened to me was I clung

22:37

to it. So it was almost

22:39

like, oh, this has to be the answer.

22:41

This has to be where I'm gonna find

22:43

the key to my mental health. So

22:46

I would just say to be, it

22:48

can be great to identify with a

22:50

diagnosis. So a good example of this

22:52

is autism. That community,

22:54

I mean, they just rally. They rally

22:57

around each other. They get services for

22:59

themselves. They get funding. I mean, they're

23:01

amazing. That's a very positive diagnosis and

23:03

where I see diagnosis working really well.

23:05

I mean, there are some issues with

23:08

it, but for the most part, it's

23:10

a good example of that. The issue

23:12

with me was identified with all the negatives.

23:15

So I was really holding myself back. And

23:17

that's what I encourage people not to do.

23:20

If it offers some sort of relief

23:22

to diagnosis, that's great. That's wonderful. And

23:25

I have very close friends for whom

23:27

that's true. And I support them 100%. Definitely

23:30

don't wanna take anyone's diagnosis away. I'm

23:33

not medically trained to do that for one

23:35

thing, but. So yeah,

23:37

to just not necessary, not to

23:39

take on all the negatives as

23:42

being a part of you. I

23:44

mean, there are other things that worked well for me,

23:46

but that's not really advice that I could give anyone

23:48

else. But the one thing of course is if

23:50

you get a diagnosis from a GP,

23:53

please ask for a second opinion. What

23:56

are some of the concerns that you have

23:58

in terms of people? and

24:00

the pandemic and the mental health issues

24:03

that they may be feeling as a result

24:05

of the pandemic that may not

24:07

be a specific mental illness. Yeah,

24:11

I mean, where I see that, and this

24:14

is all over the media, and I'm sure you've seen

24:16

it too, is mental health crisis

24:18

among teens. And I think

24:20

that what's being a little bit left

24:22

out, first of all, what people are doing is trying to

24:24

find the reason, and I feel like we were

24:26

in a global pandemic and they were in their

24:28

rooms for two years. There

24:31

you go. I hope

24:33

they, I mean, if they were feeling anxiety

24:35

and depression, we'd worry about that. We'd call

24:37

them sociopaths. So

24:39

it's kind of, I mean, I think

24:41

that that, it's not to say that there isn't

24:44

something wrong. Like just like with me, there

24:46

was something wrong. What I worry about is

24:48

someone who is in a similar position to

24:50

what I was in. When you receive a diagnosis

24:52

at 12 and you

24:54

identify with that diagnosis and you start to

24:56

see, I mean, what happened to me was, I

24:59

was, as I said, 12 and my parents were

25:01

divorcing and I was going to a new high

25:03

school. I was terribly sad and

25:05

I was terrified. And I had a stomach

25:07

ache and I wasn't eating. And it was

25:10

extreme, I was not eating, but I wasn't

25:12

counting calories and I wasn't weighing myself and

25:14

I didn't think I was fat, which are

25:17

kind of the cornerstones of the

25:19

anorexia diagnosis. But we went to

25:22

my pediatrician and he said,

25:25

you have anorexia. And so

25:27

I from then on associated stomach

25:29

ache, sadness, terror with a

25:31

diagnosis. So I started to

25:33

associate my emotions and my thoughts and

25:36

my behaviors with a diagnosis instead of

25:39

just letting them be there as

25:41

part of my life and as

25:43

everything in my life. So I

25:45

worry about during the pandemic, so

25:48

many young people receiving diagnoses

25:51

without being told that these

25:54

diagnoses are approximations and

25:56

may or may not be

25:59

totally. what we think they are. And

26:02

since the medical field has such

26:04

focus on these diagnoses, it

26:06

makes me nervous that you might have

26:08

people kind of doing the opposite of

26:10

saying they have the symptoms that make

26:14

up the disorder that they think they

26:16

have. And they may just say, Oh my

26:18

God, I don't want to be bipolar. I don't

26:20

want to be psychotic or

26:22

something like that. And maybe

26:25

don't say

26:27

what they're actually feeling because they don't

26:29

want to have that disorder. And they

26:31

know the questions that the doctors would

26:33

ask to test that. What

26:36

gets where this gets also really confusing

26:38

is there are now

26:41

acceptable diagnoses and unacceptable ones,

26:44

even cool diagnoses and

26:46

uncool. So the accepted

26:48

ones are ADHD and depression and

26:50

anxiety and phobias. Those

26:52

are okay. But a polar, no.

26:54

Borderline personality disorder, no. And schizophrenia,

26:57

no. So you've got this kind

27:00

of subculture of diagnosis where what

27:03

if you had a child who's suffering

27:05

from schizophrenia, but that's not a cool

27:07

diagnosis. I mean, it's really kind

27:10

of getting into a place where, yeah, it's

27:13

confusing. What are some of

27:15

the things that worked for you, some of the

27:17

things that you were able to do on

27:20

your own without medication that

27:23

that helps you feel better mentally?

27:26

There are a lot of the things I'm about to

27:28

say are going to feel like, really, that's kind

27:30

of dorky. And it is they are. I

27:33

just want to preface that. One

27:35

thing that I do is every morning, and

27:38

this was something I started once

27:40

I stopped identifying with the diagnosis

27:42

is I just write

27:44

down all my thoughts. So

27:47

just one after another in a list, just

27:49

one after another. They are

27:51

incredibly negative. I'm soundingly negative.

27:53

My favorite one is everything's

27:55

wrong. Like, what is that? I don't know how

27:57

to deal with that. I got to confront it.

28:00

But after a while, and I started reading

28:02

a lot about evolutionary psychiatry,

28:04

and I came to understand that our brains

28:06

are designed to keep us alive. That's it.

28:08

Not to make us happy, not to make

28:11

us calm. They are just there to keep

28:13

us alive. And the way they do that

28:15

often is to alert us of danger everywhere

28:17

all the time. And I think people

28:19

like me, I mean, my, I still have,

28:21

you know, deep ways of depression

28:23

and crippling anxiety. So it's not

28:25

as if things have changed that

28:27

that much. In the

28:30

sense of I mean, it has changed. But those

28:33

emotions are still there. Those experiences are

28:35

still there. But knowing that

28:38

my brain is really negative because

28:40

it's trying to protect me has really

28:42

changed everything. I hope that doesn't sound

28:44

too meta or like weird. No, no,

28:46

no, no, no, but these negative thoughts

28:48

that I have, I get them out, I put them on

28:50

a piece of paper, and I throw them away.

28:53

Like that's just okay, we're done with them. And

28:55

now we're gonna go about our day. And

28:57

so I don't even look back at them. It's just a

28:59

way to get it out. And this will sound,

29:02

you know, a little bit woo woo or spooky, but

29:04

I feel like, okay, my brain needs to be heard.

29:06

I'm alerting you to all the danger. I'm letting

29:09

it be heard. And now we're moving on. So

29:11

that's been I mean, it sounds and I'll do it. So I'll

29:13

do it in the middle of the day too, if I if

29:15

I noticed that my anxiety is at a pitch or

29:17

something like that. So that's been incredibly helpful.

29:19

And then a weird thing,

29:21

I never thought of the physical aspects

29:23

of mental health in the sense of

29:26

when I am struggling. So let's say

29:29

I'm suddenly feeling overcome with sadness, drink

29:31

a glass of water or 60% water like

29:34

that's contributing. That's like taking one for the

29:36

you know, like giving back to the team

29:38

guy. And so I

29:40

just drink a glass of water

29:42

and sometimes it helps amazingly well. I

29:45

mean, it doesn't solve any problems,

29:47

but it's weird how those two things

29:49

are have become a kind of

29:51

cornerstone of my life. I think those

29:53

are really great pieces of advice.

29:55

I think that yeah, anybody could try and

29:57

use those and those aren't really talked about.

30:00

but they make so much fun. And

30:02

they're very inexpensive. Yeah. Very. They're free.

30:04

And we both offer them the water.

30:06

Yeah, I love that. At

30:09

the end of each show, we always ask

30:11

our guests, what is your Nobody Told Me

30:14

lesson? So what do you wish that someone

30:16

had told you prior to embarking on

30:18

your own mental health journey that

30:21

you had to learn the hard way? And

30:23

you'd like to pass on to someone else

30:25

who's maybe about to

30:27

start seeking help for their own

30:29

mental health? The

30:32

one thing that I would wish

30:34

I'd known and that I would love to give to

30:36

everyone as a gift is that recovery

30:38

is possible. And mental illness has

30:40

not been proven to be chronic. That

30:44

would have changed a lot for me is to know.

30:46

I mean, I was told all of my diagnoses were

30:48

chronic. I was told I'd have them for the rest

30:50

of my life. And I

30:52

just wish someone had said, no, you could

30:55

recover from this. And here's what we're going to do

30:57

and maybe take you off medication or maybe

30:59

not or whatever it is. And I

31:01

just wish I'd had that option and

31:03

that in mind. And

31:05

Sarah, how can people connect with you on

31:08

social media and on the internet and learn

31:10

more about your work? So

31:13

I'm at serafay.org,

31:15

s-a-r-a-h-f-a-y.org. And

31:17

I'm serafay author, all

31:19

one word, S-A-R-A-H-F-A-Y author

31:22

at serafay author on

31:24

all socials. Great, great. Well,

31:27

Sarah, this has been just so eye

31:29

opening and fun, too, to talk with

31:31

you. I mean, you're so open and

31:33

honest. You never think with mental health

31:35

that that would be a positive

31:38

show. But my god, I feel really

31:40

hopeful. I was going to say, I

31:42

feel better. I

31:45

feel better for the world. Good,

31:47

because I do, too. I mean, I can't tell

31:49

you how hopeful. I'm writing

31:51

a sequel to Pathological. And I just

31:54

feel so hopeful, especially about that, and

31:56

giving that to people. We

31:58

were all in this together. just are.

32:01

Right. Yeah. Well

32:05

again our thanks to Sarah Faye whose

32:07

new book is called Pathological, the true

32:10

story of six misdiagnoses. And again her

32:12

website is sarahfaye.org. I'm

32:14

Jan Black. And I'm Laura Owen. You're

32:16

listening to Nobody Told Me. Thank you so

32:18

much for joining us.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features