Episode #5 // Haleigh Cummings

Often dubbed the "other Caylee Anthony", Haleigh Cummings was 5 years old when she went missing from her Floridian home in 2009. But her case would be so much more complicated, and she had never been found. The last person to see her alive, her 17-year-old babysitter, would tell many different versions of the story, and go on to marry Haleigh's dad a month after Haleigh disappeared. What version of the story is the truth, or has the truth even been told?

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

This episode was researched, written, recorded and edited by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.