Because everyone loves a Halloween episode, your hosts Jimmy and Dustin deep dive into a disturbing Reddit fan theory that suggests "One Week" is about a GRISLY MURDER. PLUS: Jimmy goads Dustin into talking about The Watchmen but they end up talking about Alan Moore being into sex magik. PLUS: the twentieth anniversary of Halloween H20 (spoiler: not about water). PLUS: stick around till the end or you'll miss Dustin hate review a Halloween/Barenaked Ladies referencing episode of How I Met Your Mother.