Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Hey. And
0:07
when you download the Kroger Ap, you'll enjoy
0:09
over five hundred dollars in savings every week
0:11
with digital coupons. And don't forget few points
0:13
to help you save up to one dollar
0:15
per gallon at the pump. Wanna. Save
0:17
even more with a boost membership you'll
0:19
get double few points and free delivery.
0:21
So shop and save big at Kroger today! Kroger,
0:24
fresh for everyone! Savings may vary
0:26
by state. Restrictions apply. Seasight for
0:28
details. Have. You ever
0:30
noticed how a com mind can really set
0:32
the stage for a good night's sleep? That's.
0:35
The idea behind our new podcast,
0:37
Good Sleep. Greg. Our
0:39
host from Optimal Relationships Daily is
0:42
here to help ease you into
0:44
a peaceful night's rest with some
0:46
positive affirmations. And. These affirmations
0:48
aren't just comforting. They. Can
0:50
help ease anxiety and nurture positive
0:52
thoughts setting you up for true
0:55
good sleep. So. Press play
0:57
on good sleep tonight. Because.
0:59
A good tomorrow starts with a good
1:01
night's sleep. Just. Search for
1:03
good sleep in your podcast app and
1:05
be sure to pick the one from
1:07
Optimal Living Daily. This
1:10
is Optimal Finance Daily, episode 2691. Is
1:14
it ever okay to borrow from your 401k? By
1:17
Mark Dennis of financialfinesse.com. And
1:20
I'm your host and personal finance enthusiast,
1:23
Diana Merriam. Welcome. Back
1:25
to Optimal Finance Daily where every day I
1:27
read an offer commentary on some of the
1:29
best personal finance bugs on the web and
1:31
about ten minutes or less. So.
1:34
With that, let's get right to it as we
1:36
optimize your life. Is.
1:41
It ever okay to borrow from your four o
1:43
one k. By. Mark Dennis of
1:46
Financial Fun as.com. Ideally
1:49
never. Or at least rarely.
1:52
Plundering. Our retirement piggy banks can
1:54
be tempting when a financial emergency arises.
1:56
or perhaps when we're looking for cash to
1:58
finance a home purchase or pay off
2:01
some high interest credit cards. Although
2:03
the IRS rules do allow for
2:05
retirement plan loans, the maximum loan
2:07
size is either one, the
2:10
greater of $10,000 or half of your vested 401k balance, or
2:15
two, $50,000, whichever is smaller. While
2:19
borrowing from yourself in this way can be
2:21
convenient and seem relatively harmless, this
2:24
type of short-term fix may have
2:26
some long-term consequences that are more
2:28
expensive than we realize. 401k
2:31
loans seem attractive, at first.
2:34
On the one hand, borrowing from our company
2:37
retirement plans is tempting for several reasons. No
2:40
credit check is required and consequently, it'll not
2:42
affect your credit score. The
2:45
interest rate is potentially lower than that of
2:47
a traditional loan. You
2:49
pay back the loan conveniently through
2:51
payroll deduction and
2:53
you're borrowing your own money and paying
2:55
yourself back with interest. Where's the
2:57
harm, right? Then things
2:59
can get ugly. A
3:01
closer examination of exactly how all of
3:03
the moving parts work as well as
3:05
some of the things that could potentially
3:08
go wrong might lead you to conclude
3:10
that getting a bank loan, borrowing against
3:12
home equity, selling other assets, or even
3:14
borrowing from family might be better for
3:16
you in the long run. Here
3:18
are some of the reasons to think twice before taking
3:21
out a 401k loan. Number
3:23
one, you'll pay taxes on the
3:26
same money twice. It's
3:28
true that you pay yourself back with
3:30
some interest, but you also use after-tax
3:32
dollars to make those interest payments. In
3:35
the future, when you spend your pre-tax 401k money
3:38
in retirement, those future interest distributions
3:40
will be taxable as ordinary income,
3:42
meaning you actually pay taxes twice
3:45
on that money. Number
3:48
two, lost growth and compounding.
3:51
The money you borrow from your 401k is
3:54
temporarily removed from the underlying
3:56
investments, missing out on any
3:58
market growth, interest, dividends, The
4:01
double whammy comes from the missed
4:03
opportunity for this growth to be
4:05
reinvested and earn even more through
4:07
compounding, which is the financial superpower
4:09
that comes from investing and staying
4:12
invested over time. Number
4:14
3. Treating Your 401k Like
4:16
an ATM Once
4:18
you dip into your retirement stash and use it
4:21
to relieve some type of financial pain, you
4:23
can begin to slide down a slippery
4:26
financial behavior slope. Having
4:28
rewarded yourself once with a relatively easy
4:30
source of cash, you run the risk
4:33
of training your brain to think of
4:35
this strategy as a reasonable substitute for
4:37
creating and maintaining better financial habits, such
4:40
as regularly saving cash in an emergency
4:42
fund, sticking with a budget, or
4:45
increasing your retirement plan contribution rate.
4:48
Staying faithful to healthier financial
4:50
priorities helps you avoid disturbing
4:52
your retirement plan's progress by
4:55
treating it like an ATM machine
4:57
and dipping into it multiple times.
5:00
Number 4. Less Take Home Pay While
5:04
you're repaying your loan, your paycheck will be
5:06
reduced by the amount of the loan repayment.
5:09
If your cash flow is tight before rating
5:11
your retirement fund, you may soon discover that
5:13
it becomes even more challenging with a reduced
5:16
paycheck. And number 5. Severe
5:19
Taxes and Penalties If
5:21
you leave your employer for any reason, whether
5:23
it's your idea or if your employer fires
5:26
you, you might have to repay the entire
5:28
remaining loan balance within as little as 60
5:30
to 90 days. This
5:33
requirement varies from plan to plan. Some
5:35
company retirement plans allow you to continue
5:37
making the scheduled loan payments without having
5:39
to pay it all back early. However,
5:42
your payments obviously will no longer come
5:44
from payroll deduction once your job ends.
5:47
If your period of unemployment is lengthy,
5:49
you might not be able to keep
5:51
up with the required repayment schedule. Once
5:54
You default on a 401k loan, the
5:56
IRS then treats any remaining balance as
5:59
a taxable. To be seen. If
6:01
you're under age fifty nine and a
6:03
half at that time, there may be
6:05
an additional ten percent tax penalty for taking
6:08
an early withdrawal from your retirement plan.
6:10
What? Was once a temporary financial
6:12
six could quickly become an expensive
6:15
pox bomb. It
6:17
might be okay to borrow once is.
6:20
Number one, you have a high interest
6:22
rates think double digit death and he
6:24
had exhausted all other options to resign.
6:26
He have already do a lower. Interest
6:28
rates. Be. Ongoing challenge
6:30
will be to reduce any temptation
6:32
to begin using the same high
6:35
interest credit cards or loan sources
6:37
again and recreate the problem. Once.
6:39
You pay back the four o one
6:42
K loan, take that monthly loan payment
6:44
you were making and redirected to a
6:46
savings account, your bank, building up an
6:48
emergency funds you can use for future
6:50
financial emergencies rather than reading your retirement
6:52
plan like a parrot. Number
6:54
till you owe the Iris back
6:57
taxes. With. Interest and
6:59
penalties stacking up on overdue taxes.
7:01
this financial burden can become very
7:03
serious over to him. In.
7:05
This case of four one k loan might be
7:07
you're saving grace. However, you
7:09
may qualify for release under the
7:11
iris guidelines for alternate payment plans
7:13
and hardship. Number. Three,
7:16
You're in real danger of defaulting on
7:18
a student loan. In most cases,
7:20
bankruptcy is not an option for these.
7:23
Or. Number for you're. Facing eminent
7:25
bankruptcy or a vixen from your
7:27
home, Talk. To
7:29
a nonprofit consumer credit
7:32
counselor at nfcc.org about
7:34
alternatives to bankruptcy. Of.
7:36
A Four O One K loan can buy
7:39
you some valuable time while you restructure your
7:41
cash flow and other investments to support a
7:43
sustainable strategy and repay your Four O One
7:45
K loan. This. Might be
7:47
inappropriate Financial move. The.
7:50
important things to keep in mind regarding
7:52
loans from your retirement plan is to
7:54
make sure you address the underlying me
7:56
for cause rather than simply assuming the
7:58
four o one k alone will solve
8:00
the a me problem. Otherwise you could
8:02
find yourself on an unhealthy financial
8:04
treadmill where you repeatedly borrow from
8:06
your 401k and begin to seriously
8:08
jeopardize your ability to retire on
8:10
time, comfortably, or both.
8:14
A good way to see just how
8:16
damaging and expensive a retirement plan loan
8:18
can be to your financial future is
8:20
to use the National Center for Policy
8:22
Analysis 401k borrowing
8:24
calculator. This calculator
8:27
shows how much less money you may
8:29
have for retirement if you borrow from
8:31
your retirement plan versus not taking a
8:33
401k loan. Bottom
8:35
line, make sure you have carefully
8:37
considered all other alternatives before you
8:39
undo much of the hard work you've
8:42
already invested in growing your retirement nest
8:44
egg. You
8:49
just listened to the post titled, Is it
8:51
ever okay to borrow from your 401k? by
8:55
Mark Dennis of financialfinesse.com and
8:57
I'll be right back with
8:59
my commentary. Have you been using
9:01
Mint to manage your finances? First,
9:03
the bad news. Mint is shutting down.
9:05
And now, the good news. There's
9:08
a better alternative. Our sponsor, Monarch
9:10
Money. Mint users are turning
9:12
to Monarch Money and loving it. Maybe
9:14
you're saving for a down payment, a
9:16
wedding, a dream vacation, your kids college.
9:19
I found that Monarch makes it easy to help you
9:21
reach your financial goals, whatever they are. I definitely
9:24
wouldn't be able to allocate my finances
9:26
or plan as clearly without help from
9:28
Monarch. In fact, Monarch
9:30
is the top-rated all-in-one personal finance
9:33
app. It gives you a
9:35
comprehensive view of all of your accounts, investments,
9:37
transactions, and more. Create custom
9:39
budgets, set goals, and collaborate with your
9:41
partner. And now, get
9:44
an extended 30-day free trial
9:46
when you go to monarchmoney.com/OFD.
9:49
After trying out Monarch for myself, I
9:51
understand why it's a top-rated personal finance
9:53
app. And right now, get
9:55
an extended 30-day free trial when
9:58
you go to monarchmoney.com/OFD. While
10:01
I'm sure there are
10:03
probably situations where a
10:06
401k loan is a good idea, I personally
10:16
cannot think of even one. For
10:19
me, taking on a 401k loan
10:21
would require some pretty dire circumstances,
10:23
where I needed money immediately for
10:25
some life-threatening emergency. I had
10:28
no other reserves, no options for
10:30
increasing my income, I didn't qualify for any
10:32
other type of low-interest debt, and no one
10:34
on the planet was willing to lend me
10:37
some money. I can't imagine
10:39
why I would need a loan so bad
10:41
that I would risk my retirement savings and
10:43
that I'd be willing to interrupt my money
10:45
earning more money. I
10:47
mostly hear of people taking a 401k loan
10:49
to fund a down payment on a house,
10:52
do home impresence or consolidate
10:54
debt. That sounds ludicrous
10:56
to me. When I invest my
10:58
money, I do it for the long term, and I'm
11:00
so firm in my commitment to not touch the money
11:02
I have invested, I actually think of it
11:05
as a tax I've paid to my future self. That
11:07
money is gone, I have no claim to it, because
11:10
it's not my money. It's future
11:12
Diana's money, and she says no anytime I
11:14
ask for some. That
11:16
should do it for today, have a happy rest of
11:18
your day, and I'll see you on the Monday show
11:20
tomorrow, where your optimal life awaits.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More