Podchaser Logo
Home
Living Without Hope

Living Without Hope

Released Thursday, 20th April 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Living Without Hope

Living Without Hope

Living Without Hope

Living Without Hope

Thursday, 20th April 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Hub and Spoke.

0:03

Audio Collective.

0:13

Hi, I'm Willow Belden

0:15

and you're listening to Out There,

0:18

the podcast that explores big questions

0:21

through intimate stories outdoors.

0:25

This

0:25

season, we're exploring the theme

0:28

Secrets of the Earth. Each

0:31

episode, we're harnessing the power

0:33

of nature to uncover new

0:35

truths and help us understand our

0:37

own humanity.

0:40

But before we get to that, I want to introduce

0:42

you to someone. My

0:45

name is Denis Bulichenko.

0:47

Everything started in 2015 when I moved to Italy and I

0:49

moved from

0:52

a relatively flat area.

0:55

So the mountains were like a really, really

0:58

exciting thing for me. And

1:01

I started to go hiking

1:04

really, really often. And

1:06

also, I have a daughter. She

1:09

was small back then, but she

1:12

also was kind of really curious,

1:14

asking me all the time, what's the name of that

1:17

mountain?

1:18

I think a lot of us have been in this situation.

1:21

You're out in the mountains, you see a peak

1:24

off in the distance. It looks tantalizing,

1:27

but

1:27

you can't figure out what it is. So what

1:30

do you do? Well, if you're

1:33

Denis, you create a new app.

1:36

The app he made is called Peak Visor,

1:39

and they are the presenting sponsor

1:41

for this season of Out There. Peak

1:43

Visor is on a mission to help you make the most

1:46

of your time in the mountains. Check it out

1:48

in the App Store. You just might love it.

1:56

Jacob Erickson is a wilderness

1:58

guide in western North Carolina. He

2:01

takes people out in nature to do healing work,

2:03

dealing with grief and that sort of thing. It's

2:06

a process he's been going through himself for

2:08

years.

2:12

Jacob's been facing up to his own mortality

2:14

since he was around 16.

2:17

But the life-threatening situation he's reckoning

2:20

with isn't what you might think. He

2:23

hasn't been diagnosed with cancer. He's

2:26

not suffering from organ failure. He's

2:29

not actually sick with anything.

2:33

I'm going to let Heather Kitching pick up the story

2:35

from here. And, trigger warning,

2:38

this piece discusses depression and suicidal

2:40

ideation.

2:43

To be honest, Jacob didn't really grow

2:46

up around nature. He's originally

2:48

from Phoenix. It's like a concrete

2:50

jungle built on a desert. And

2:52

the small strip of lawn in his yard?

2:55

Well, lawn was

2:57

a generous word for it. It was more

2:59

like a patch of dried up grass

3:01

and dirt. He wasn't even allowed to

3:03

touch the bushes near the street because

3:05

they were oleander.

3:07

They were toxic.

3:14

Jacob was what you might call a sensitive kid,

3:16

highly attuned to the world around him.

3:19

He was like a sponge for information.

3:21

I remember being present

3:23

watching the 2000 election

3:26

between Bush

3:29

and Al Gore and asking

3:32

my parents, why

3:35

didn't Al Gore win because he won

3:38

the popular vote? And then they're like, Jacob,

3:40

you're like seven. This

3:43

is too big of a question

3:46

for you.

3:47

Notwithstanding Jacob's rather unusual

3:50

fascination with grown-up topics, he

3:52

had a pretty typical childhood in a lot of ways.

3:55

He had

3:55

a sandbox in his yard, got

3:57

into video games and space aliens.

4:00

played on a soccer team for a while. For

4:03

Jacob,

4:04

the first clue that something was wrong came when he was eight.

4:14

I remember my dad waking

4:16

me up in the morning and he

4:18

tells me, Jacob, this

4:20

is a day that will change your life

4:23

for the rest of your life. And

4:25

I was just like, oh my gosh, mom's

4:29

dead. And I asked him,

4:31

is mom dead? And he was

4:33

like, no, someone flew

4:36

a plane into the Twin Towers. And

4:38

I was like, where's the Twin Towers? I had

4:40

like no idea. He's like, it's New York City.

4:43

And I was just like, where's

4:45

New York City? Like it was just

4:47

totally beyond my eight-year-old brain.

4:51

Jacob gets out of bed, goes

4:54

into the living room. His mom

4:56

and two sisters are watching TV. He

4:59

starts watching with them. And

5:02

he sees those images that we've all seen a million

5:04

times now. The North

5:07

Tower with a giant gash near the top, smoke

5:10

billowing into the air.

5:12

I do remember this

5:16

sense

5:18

of like a shock wave hitting

5:23

me. Mixed

5:27

with the feeling like the floor just dropped out

5:30

underneath you. It

5:34

was just this like sense of that

5:40

things aren't really safe. This

5:46

is the day that Jacob starts to notice

5:48

the symptoms of a disease

5:51

that's not in his body,

5:53

but in society. In

5:55

his case, though, that disease

5:58

will just about kill him. before

6:00

he discovers what you might call a natural

6:03

remedy.

6:09

After 9-11, Jacob

6:11

wants to learn more about this sickness

6:14

that he perceives in the world. He

6:16

watches Mississippi Burning, reads

6:18

about the Civil Rights Movement, and

6:21

when he's 15, he goes to this leadership

6:23

camp. It teaches young people about

6:25

things like race riots, genocide

6:27

against indigenous peoples, the Holocaust,

6:30

Rwanda, and Darfur. He

6:33

says it gives him a language for what ails

6:35

the world,

6:36

a diagnosis,

6:38

several actually, colonialism,

6:41

xenophobia,

6:42

white supremacy,

6:44

anti-Semitism, and

6:46

it motivates him to start fighting them.

6:49

He joins his high school social justice

6:51

club, gets involved in activism,

6:54

and then something happens that makes

6:57

Jacob realize that the sickness is even

6:59

worse than he imagined.

7:04

He goes to Australia on this student

7:06

ambassador program called People to

7:08

People. He gets a chance

7:10

to go snorkeling on the Great Barrier Reef,

7:13

and what he sees shocks him.

7:16

There's

7:21

nothing but miles and miles of pale

7:24

white coral against a blue ocean.

7:27

He sees like one fish, a

7:30

big flat thing about four feet

7:32

long, and a couple of sea cucumbers.

7:35

And that's it.

7:36

I

7:45

thought I was going to see like clownfish and starfish,

7:48

and

7:51

what I got was like Haiti's

7:53

underworld.

7:56

Jacob is totally taken back by this.

10:01

When he gets to university, he starts

10:03

looking up climate science in academic

10:05

journals. He grows concerned

10:07

that climate change could cross a threshold

10:10

where feedback loops feed into

10:12

each other and then collapse the entire

10:15

ecosystem, killing us all

10:17

in the process. Or that the fallouts

10:19

from climate change like food shortages

10:22

and mass migration could lead to

10:24

social unrest and war as

10:26

humans destroy each other trying

10:28

to compete for scarce resources.

10:31

And remember,

10:32

Jacob lives in Arizona.

10:34

He goes jogging on a dried up riverbed.

10:37

It's not hard for him to believe that life

10:40

as we know it is on its last legs. He

10:43

says he started to become like Chicken Little,

10:46

telling anyone who would listen that the sky

10:48

was falling.

11:03

This

11:13

is like we all need to learn this.

11:17

So it's possible that you're listening

11:19

to all of this and thinking it

11:22

all sounds a bit extreme. But

11:24

I think it's important to point out here that

11:26

what Jacob fears is not

11:29

out of the realm of possibility. Just

11:31

lately, scientists have been calling for more

11:33

discussion about this. The Center

11:36

for the Study of Existential Risk at

11:38

Cambridge University published a

11:40

paper last summer in the Proceedings of the

11:42

National Academy of Sciences saying

11:45

we need more research on a possible

11:47

climate endgame.

11:48

Dr. Kristi E. By

11:50

is a co-author of that paper. She's

11:52

a professor at the Center for Health and the Global

11:54

Environment at the University of Washington.

11:58

There is a possibility of a climate catastrophe.

12:05

According to E. Bye and her co-authors,

12:08

we could cross thresholds this century

12:10

that led to mass extinction events

12:12

in the past. They say climate

12:14

change could trigger other catastrophes,

12:17

like international conflict, or

12:19

exacerbate the spread of infectious diseases,

12:22

or trigger system failures that unravel

12:25

societies. And that

12:27

could all happen at even moderate levels

12:29

of warming.

12:32

Jacob is not the only person

12:34

who is consumed by fear over

12:36

this. A study in the Lancet

12:39

found that 59% of young

12:41

people worldwide were either very

12:44

or extremely worried about climate

12:46

change, and 45% of

12:48

them said it is affecting their

12:50

daily life and functioning.

12:53

It was Dr. Derek Seabree Jr.

12:55

who told me about that study. He's

12:57

a core faculty member and the master's program

13:00

director at the Michigan School of Psychology.

13:03

He's registered with the Climate Psychology Alliance

13:06

as a climate-aware therapist. And

13:08

he says climate grief can

13:11

cause people to give up on life.

13:13

I mean, it's a form of fatalism. Like the idea

13:16

of, like, well, why would I go to university?

13:19

The university I want to go to is in a place like

13:21

California where they might not be here

13:23

by then. So why would I even try to go

13:25

there?

13:27

You can see these fears reflected in online

13:29

forums, too. There's a massive

13:32

community on Reddit for people who are concerned

13:34

about social and ecological collapse.

13:37

It's the kind of place where people post questions

13:40

like, should I even bother saving

13:42

for retirement?

13:44

Nearly half a million people

13:46

take part in these forums. And

13:49

Jacob was just like them. Reddit started

13:51

asking himself,

13:53

what was the point in even living

13:55

if everyone was just going to die?

13:58

I kept thinking.

14:00

Am I going to bear witness to this? Am I going

14:02

to watch the cascade

14:05

of climate change, you

14:09

know, like extinguish

14:11

millions of species and people?

14:17

At this point, Jacob is sympathizing

14:19

with climate radicals. His

14:22

friend Quincy, who's black, starts

14:24

calling him the White Malcolm X. He

14:27

draws a picture in his journal of a polar

14:29

bear with a rocket propelled grenade blowing

14:31

up a gas pump. He's

14:33

become cynical of the climate movement.

14:36

He thinks the game's already over.

14:38

I was like, oh

14:40

my God, there's no saving this.

14:43

Like I can't save anything. None

14:45

of this. Yeah,

14:48

like that was rock bottom.

14:51

Flash forward to July of 2013. Jacob's

14:56

back in Phoenix for the summer after his first

14:58

year of university in Flagstaff.

15:01

He's staying with his sister in

15:03

the family home they grew up in. He's

15:06

by himself one night

15:07

sitting on the sofa. He's

15:09

got a bottle of sailor Jerry Rum in his

15:11

hand and his mind

15:13

is filled with images of death

15:16

and destruction. I mean,

15:18

birds flying out of the sky, putrefied

15:22

rivers and seeing,

15:24

you know.

15:27

Trans

15:27

women's skulls bashed

15:30

in. I'm seeing black

15:32

boys murdered. I'm

15:34

seeing like exploded

15:40

bombs and just like nuclear

15:44

war. Like it was just like a cascade of

15:46

imagery of just like the bleak

15:49

darkness of,

15:52

you know, reality, honestly. And

15:55

I'm just like, man, this is so bad.

15:58

And I was just... Yeah,

16:00

trying to wash

16:04

the images away. Drink

16:07

by drink. And it

16:09

would hold for like five seconds. And

16:13

then I would take another drink. And the images

16:15

came back

16:19

worse and worse and worse. And

16:20

for whatever

16:22

reason, I don't know how my 38 revolver was on the table.

16:28

And I remember the way the lamp light was reflected off the end of the

16:32

barrel. And

16:35

it was a matte black, uh, black,

16:37

uh, black, uh,

16:39

black, uh, black, uh, black, uh, black,

16:42

lamp light was reflected off the end

16:44

of the barrel. And

16:46

it was a matte black, uh,

16:50

revolver, snub nose revolver.

16:53

And I'm looking at the, the

16:56

end of the barrel and, and there's this glint

16:58

of light. And I just

17:01

remember thinking, that's

17:03

my out. This

17:05

is how I get rid of these screens. And

17:08

I think I remember like, might as well just finish

17:12

the bottle first. And

17:26

I remember having

17:28

the bottle on one hand and the gun on the other hand, holding it.

17:41

And I remember

17:44

taking a swig from the bottle

17:48

and then I, everything kind

17:50

of fades to black.

19:59

all darkness and gloom in his head. But

20:03

his dog Jack needs to go outside. So

20:06

Jacob takes him out for a walk. It's

20:08

a cool day. It's like a nice 75

20:10

degree sunny day.

20:18

Slight breeze in the air.

20:20

They walk through the neighborhood and

20:22

then up a hill.

20:24

And it's this mesa where

20:28

it's flat on top. And

20:31

I just go to go sit with my back up to a ponderosa pine. And

20:45

I can smell their butterscotch

20:48

vanilla aroma. And

20:52

I can feel the sun on my skin

20:55

and the warmth. And

20:58

I just feel like the well

21:00

and that pressure of coming up from my lungs,

21:03

coming up from my chest into

21:09

my throat, feeling that throat

21:11

quiver of tears. And

21:17

I'm on my knees weeping. And

21:27

it was the weirdest thing of like this sense

21:41

and feeling of serenity, the

21:43

sense and feeling that like everything

21:46

is gonna be okay. Like it's like I was being held. And

21:51

my grief

21:53

started to disappear.

21:55

It started to loosen its grip

21:58

and... I just

22:01

felt like everything

22:03

was going to be okay. That

22:09

the Earth that I loved so deeply was

22:15

going to be alright. So,

22:23

just to be clear, it's not that Jacob

22:26

suddenly concluded that climate change

22:28

isn't happening. Or that violence

22:31

and inequality aren't serious

22:33

problems. That's not what

22:35

he meant by the Earth being alright.

22:38

It was more that he saw himself as

22:40

part of a much larger picture, in

22:42

which life and death are part of a natural

22:45

cycle.

22:46

He is going to die, but

22:49

his body will nourish new life by

22:51

becoming food for bacteria and

22:53

insects, who will in turn feed

22:56

other animals and plants.

22:58

And this whole cycle, all

23:00

of humanity, is just a blip

23:03

in the Earth's history. And the

23:05

Earth itself

23:06

is just a blip

23:08

in a much larger universe.

23:09

When I reach out and go big,

23:12

it's not as existential of a crisis

23:15

as I once interpreted it to

23:17

be.

23:19

Scientists have discovered like 100 million

23:21

galaxies. And

23:24

inside each galaxy is another 100

23:26

billion stars. And

23:30

around each star is an untold

23:33

number of planets. And then

23:35

here we are, and our one planet, and

23:37

our one star. And

23:41

that smallness in

23:44

the grand scheme of the universe

23:48

is quite helpful.

23:52

Jacob spends the day kind of basking

23:55

in the afterglow of this planet. moment.

24:01

And then the next morning,

24:02

a part of him is like,

24:04

did that even happen? Was

24:06

that even real?

24:09

Call

24:09

it what you want, but it changes

24:11

Jacob's life completely.

24:16

He goes out and buys a backpack, starts

24:18

spending all his free time in the outdoors.

24:21

He's backpacking or mountain biking every

24:23

weekend in every spare moment he can

24:25

get.

24:26

But he says, it's not like he just

24:29

stops being depressed. He

24:31

just stops running from it. He

24:33

turns toward it and he lets

24:36

nature comfort him. He

24:38

says he probably still wakes up with a dark

24:40

cloud over his head between four and

24:42

six days a week. But the first

24:44

thing he'll do is go outside

24:47

and listen for the birds singing.

24:48

I often tell people now that

24:51

like going outside is my church.

24:53

Like going outside, backpacking

24:56

is my like devotion. As

25:03

time goes on, Jacob's focus starts

25:06

to shift away from death

25:09

to questions of how he wants to live for

25:11

whatever time we have left on this planet.

25:14

Because he's still not convinced that

25:16

he has that long.

25:19

He's basically going through a process like one

25:21

that Dr. Seabree described to me, a

25:24

process of learning how to live without

25:26

hope.

25:27

If you knew that tomorrow wasn't promised to you,

25:30

would you still go to work?

25:31

Like what would you do with that day knowing that tomorrow

25:35

might be the last? For

25:38

Jacob, finding the answer to that question

25:41

means going to grad school, studying

25:43

sustainable communities, even

25:45

going on a vision fast. And

25:48

he eventually becomes a full-time

25:50

wilderness guide.

25:52

Two years ago, he and his partner

25:54

finally left the desert of Arizona for

25:57

a place with an abundance of water.

25:59

North Carolina.

26:02

They set up a company with some friends that

26:04

takes people out on the land to do healing

26:06

work

26:07

and they call it Remembering Earth.

26:13

A couple of years back, Jacob was guiding

26:16

a day hike in the Smoky Mountains for

26:18

a young guy in his 20s. Suddenly,

26:21

out of the blue, the sky asked Jacob,

26:24

if you knew you only had a year to live,

26:26

how would you live your life?

26:28

I just chuckled to myself. I

26:30

just laughed because it was a question

26:34

that I, in one

26:36

way or another, ask myself, most

26:39

days I wake up, is this

26:41

my last day on Earth? Or I

26:43

would just tell myself today was my last day

26:45

and how would I live that day?

26:48

So how does Jacob answer that question

26:50

now?

26:51

Last year, he told a version of

26:53

his story to the Collapse Support Forum

26:55

on Reddit. That's the forum I mentioned

26:58

earlier for people who are struggling with

27:00

climate anxiety. This

27:02

is part of what he wrote,

27:04

quote, if I only had one

27:06

year, I would still float rivers,

27:09

hunt, garden, play music,

27:11

write poetry,

27:13

wrap my arms around my lover,

27:15

laugh with friends and family, but

27:18

most of all, I would want to be rekindling

27:20

the fire of life within others.

27:23

I

27:29

have such a vivacious

27:31

desire to live and

27:34

like know

27:36

that when I do die, oh my gosh, I'm

27:38

going to just be so sad

27:41

to leave this place because even

27:43

with all the horrors happening, I

27:47

know

27:47

it will be difficult and you know, it's

27:49

like, I know I will lose everything that I love

27:51

and

27:55

it's a price that I'm willing

27:58

to pay again and again and again. to

28:01

steep myself in the beauty with

28:04

other people no matter how dark and

28:06

bleak it is. You

28:13

know, I was drawn to Jacob's story

28:16

because it made me think of people that I've known

28:18

or read about who've been diagnosed with

28:20

terminal illnesses. The

28:23

intense grief and depression, the

28:25

learning to live without hope, but

28:28

also, for some, that kind

28:30

of spiritual journey. Finding

28:33

comfort in natural beauty and human

28:36

connections, trying to

28:38

find meaning in the life they have left.

28:41

And I think to myself, this is what

28:43

we're doing to young people with all

28:45

our inaction on climate change. This

28:48

is what happens when we scream at

28:50

our politicians to do something about

28:53

gas prices, but not about

28:55

our climate targets. This

28:57

is what happens when we egg on the culture

29:00

wars on Twitter and Facebook,

29:02

instead of fighting to end social

29:04

inequality.

29:06

It's older generations like

29:08

mine, who are the ones who should

29:10

have had the maturity and the resilience

29:13

to face up to what's happening to our planet.

29:16

We are the ones who should be demanding

29:18

real solutions and welcoming

29:21

real sacrifices,

29:23

but instead we've left it to teenagers

29:26

to make peace with the possibility

29:29

of dying young.

29:36

That was Heather Kitching. She's

29:38

a freelance radio producer based in

29:40

Thunder Bay, Canada. If

29:43

you want to check out Jacob's company, it's

29:45

called Remembering Earth. If

29:49

you liked this story,

29:51

please share the link with a friend.

29:53

We are always eager for new listeners

29:56

and your recommendation is our best form

29:58

of advertising.

30:07

Coming up next time on Out There. Thoughts

30:10

started crowding my mind. This can't be happening.

30:12

I should have listened to my gut. I think it was

30:15

okay to go on this hike alone when it was

30:17

getting dark. What if there's a creepy person

30:19

following me this whole time? What if I don't make it back

30:21

to the campground tonight?

30:25

How do you get back on track when you

30:27

lose your way? Out There is

30:29

a proud member of Hub

30:32

and Spoke, a collective of idea-driven, independent

30:34

podcasts.

30:38

One

30:47

of the other Hub and Spoke shows that I think

30:49

you'll love is called Rumble

30:52

Strip. It's based in Vermont

30:54

and the host, Erica Heilman, tells

30:56

these really beautiful, intimate stories

30:59

about everyday people. She invites

31:01

herself into their homes and talks to

31:03

them about what they love, what they hate,

31:06

what they're afraid of,

31:07

and how they're probably a lot

31:10

like you.

31:11

Rumble Strip was named the number

31:13

one podcast of 2022 by The New

31:15

Yorker and it won a Peabody Award

31:18

that year as well. It's also gotten recognition

31:20

from The New York Times and The Atlantic. In

31:23

other words, it's the real deal.

31:25

You can listen to Rumble Strip wherever you get

31:27

your podcasts or at rumblestripvermont.com.

31:33

A big thank you to Peak Visor

31:35

for supporting this season of Out There. As

31:38

I mentioned, Peak Visor is an app

31:40

that helps you make the most of your adventures. You

31:43

can use it to figure out what mountains you're looking

31:45

at and you can take advantage of

31:47

their 3D maps when you're planning a

31:49

trip. Plus, they have a Peak Bagging

31:51

feature so you can keep track of all your accomplishments.

31:55

If you'd like your own personal mountain guide, check

31:57

out Peak Visor in the App Store. You

31:59

just might love it.

31:59

it.

32:06

Today's story was reported, produced, and sound-designed

32:09

by Heather Kitching, story editing

32:11

by me, Willow Belden, OutThere's

32:14

advertising manager is Jessica Taylor,

32:16

our audience growth director is Sheba Joseph,

32:19

our ambassadors are Tiffany Duong, Ashley

32:21

White, and Stacia Bennett, and our theme

32:23

music was written by Jared Arnold. Special

32:26

thanks to all our listeners who are supporting

32:28

OutThere with financial contributions, including

32:31

Adam Milgram, Alana Mugden, Matt

32:33

Perry, Eric Biederman, Phil

32:35

Timm,

32:36

Doug Frick, Tara Jocelyn,

32:38

and Deb and Vince Garcia. It's

32:41

your support that makes this podcast

32:43

possible.

32:44

We'll be back with another episode in two

32:46

weeks. In the meantime, have

32:48

a beautiful day, be bold,

32:51

go outside, and find your

32:53

dreams.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features