Charity Tessener was another one of the 3 persons of interest that the Walker County Sheriff's Office was looking for shortly after Hayden disappeared. In this episode, she shares what details she knows about that night and why the sheriff's o

Tommy

Jul 30th, 2020 25m 34s

Hayden was planning for his friend, Tommy, to pick him up the night he disappeared. Tommy tells us about that night and another person surprised us with some new information.

Pine Drive

Jul 16th, 2020 31m 12s

6 weeks after Hayden Mayberry walked out of the back door of his home on Pine Drive, his body was discovered just off the road on...Pine Drive.

The Mysterious Disappearance & Death of Hayden Mayberry

Jul 2nd, 2020 32m 55s

26 year old Hayden Mayberry went missing on November 19, 2019. He reportedly walked into the woods in the Boldo area of Walker County, AL from a home he was staying at on Pine Dr. His remains were found on February 2, 2020 under some unusual ci

Intimidation & Abuses of Power

Apr 16th, 2020 32m 14s

Tobbie's had some unnerving and downright alarming experiences since Eric & Gypsy were murdered.

Injustices

Mar 26th, 2020 40m 4s

It seems that the offices of the Walker County District Attorney, the Walker County Coroner's Office, the Walker County Sheriff's Office and the Alabama State Fire Marshal's Office all had just a fraction of Eric Cates' autopsy for almost 5 yea

The Autopsy

Mar 12th, 2020 41m 30s

Eric's mom Tobbie has been adamant that the autopsy she was recently allowed to see was not a complete autopsy. In this episode, you'll hear a shocking update.

The Struggle Is Real

Feb 27th, 2020 58m 6s

Tobbie reveals that her struggle to get Eric's case investigated is an ongoing battle.

The Suspicious Death of Randy Hicks

Feb 13th, 2020 41m 36s

Randy Hicks was one of the most commonly rumored to have been responsible for the murders of Eric & Gypsy. In July 2016, Randy Hicks went missing and then was found deceased in the woods under very mysterious circumstances. What really happen

Meetings

Jan 30th, 2020 28m 34s

Numerous items were missing from Eric's truck. What happened to them? As Eric's family continued to get tips, there were numerous meetings with informants who provided information.

The Letter

Jan 16th, 2020 41m 41s

Eric's dad was given a letter shortly after Eric and Gypsy were murdered. The letter details what the author says happened to Eric and names people who were allegedly involved. Huge thanks to Podcorn for sponsoring this episode. Explore spon

The Lost Footage

Jan 2nd, 2020 43m 29s

We were given the surveillance footage from the Blue Store for Eric's last day. The Blue Store was the last reported sighting of Eric and Michael made a very significant discovery as he poured over this video. Be sure to visit our Facebook pa

Working Theories

Dec 19th, 2019 33m 19s

We continue to investigate the most common theories in Eric and Gypsy's murders and we go through the timeline of Eric's last day. Huge thanks to Podcorn for sponsoring this episode. Explore sponsorship opportunities and start monetizing your

The Drive By Shooting

Dec 5th, 2019 36m 51s

So many tips came in the day Eric & Gypsy were found murdered. In this episode you'll hear directly from a man who was the subject of one of these tips. The murder of Eric & Gypsy and the events that followed set off a chain reaction that has

The House Fire

Nov 21st, 2019 30m 33s

Eric's family began to receive tips about what happened to Eric and Gypsy the same day their remains were found. One of the first and most interesting tips is about a house where a BBQ was held. Join us as we explore this lead and more.

Empire School

Nov 7th, 2019 40m 14s

After Eric & Gypsy's bodies were found at the school, Eric's family is given access to the crime scene and are shocked at what they found.

The Eric Cates & Gypsy Story

Oct 24th, 2019 38m 28s

On March 21, 2015, 32 year old Eric Cates and his beloved dog, Gypsy, were found murdered behind the old Empire School in the tiny Walker County town of Empire, AL. Hunters found their bodies burned in the cab of Eric’s truck. Their murders rem

Season 2 - Eric Cates & Gypsy

Oct 16th, 2019 5m 39s

On March 21, 2015, 32 year old Eric Cates and his beloved dog, Gypsy, were found murdered behind the old Empire School in the tiny Walker County town of Empire, AL. Their murders remain unsolved even though the crime is rumored to have been wit

The Quarry

Sep 5th, 2019 27m 52s

Podcast listener tips led us to an infamous Elmore County location. Our searches here were filled with surprises.

Leave No Stone Unturned

Aug 22nd, 2019 25m 53s

Thanks to the many tips from podcast listeners, the searches for Susan and Evan continue. Amid triple-digit temperatures, the search teams worked at 4 of our top places of interest. You'll hear the details of our most recent searches and hear

The No-Body Guy

Aug 8th, 2019 31m 52s

The foremost expert on no-body prosecutions, Tad DiBiase, talks about what it takes to successfully prosecute a no-body murder case.

No Body Homicides

Jul 25th, 2019 26m 57s

This is the 1st of 2 episodes discussing no-boy homicides and why Jerry is still free.

Echo 7 Foxtrot

Jul 11th, 2019 46m 7s

The private investigator investigating Susan and Evan's disappearance describes areas of interest in the search for them.

A Devious Plan?

Jun 20th, 2019 21m 10s

Was the disappearance of Susan and Evan planned? Also, new information has become available on the Starr Mulder disappearance.

Birmingham

Jun 6th, 2019 32m 17s

Susan and Evan aren't the only missing people from Elmore County. Starr Mulder has been missing since June 11, 2016. Hear the never released before details the investigator assigned to her case shared with me and I'll explain the odd connecti